Translated from Philip Schaff's History of The Christian Church
第十章 敬拜与礼仪
目录
§ 92. 弥撒
§ 93. 讲道
§ 94. 教会诗歌:希腊圣诗与圣诗作者
§ 95. 拉丁圣诗:文献
§ 96. 拉丁圣诗与圣诗作者
§ 97. 七项圣礼
§ 98. 管风琴与钟
§ 99. 圣徒崇拜
§ 100. 圣像崇拜:文献与不同理论
§ 101. 圣像破坏之争与754年会议
§ 102. 第七次大公会议恢复圣像崇拜,787年
§ 103. 圣像破坏的反扑与圣像崇拜的最终胜利,公元842年
§ 104. 《查理书》与法兰克教会对圣像崇拜的立场
§ 105. 福音派改革者:里昂的阿戈巴尔德与都灵的克劳狄乌斯
参阅第三卷第VII章,以及尼安德 (Neander) 第III卷,第123–140、425–455页(波士顿版)。
§ 92. 弥撒
参阅第三卷§ 96–101及其中所引的礼仪学文献;另参有关基督教的和教会的古制的著作,例如西格尔 (Siegel) 第III卷,第361–411页。
公共敬拜以举行弥撒为中心,视之为基督为世人之罪所献祭的实际重演,虽是不流血的。在这一点上,东方与西方教会直到今日仍完全一致。两者都以神秘象征所具有的一切庄严气氛环绕这一圣礼。彼此的差异仅在细节。
教皇格列高利一世 (Gregory I.) 改进了拉丁礼仪,赋予它一种形式,罗马教会至今基本上仍保留着这一形式。1他深信,圣餐体现了天与地、永恒与时间的和好,并在一种不间断的相通中,为活人和虔诚的死者带来丰盛的属灵益处。当祭司向上帝献上不流血的祭时,诸天敞开,天使临在,可见与不可见的世界联合为一。2
格列高利引入了为死者举行的弥撒,3这与他所发展并普及的炼狱教义相联系。这些弥撒以更古老的为亡者祈祷的习俗为基础,旨在减轻并缩短那些在大公信仰中去世、却仍需洁净残余软弱之人的刑罚痛苦。人们认为,极少有天主教徒已预备好进入天堂;因此,临终者往往预先安排此类弥撒,或由亲友代为筹办。4这些弥撒为祭司带来了可观的收入。东方教会没有明确定义的炼狱教义,但同样认为,亡者能从活人的祈祷中得益,“尤其是那些与献上基督身体和宝血之不流血的祭相联合的祈祷,以及凭信心为纪念他们而行的怜悯之工。”5
对圣礼功效的高度评价,也导致了独祭弥撒 (solitary masses) 的滥用,即祭司在无人参与的情况下举行弥撒。6这破坏了这一礼仪原本作为与救赎主及蒙救赎者相交之筵席的性质。查理曼 (Charlemagne) 时代的数次教会会议曾反对此种做法。813年的美因茨会议 (Synod of Mainz) 规定:“在我们看来,没有一位长老能够独自合宜地唱弥撒;因为身旁若没有人,他怎能说‘sursum corda(举心向上)!’或‘Dominus vobiscum(愿主与你们同在)!’呢?”829年一次旨在改革的巴黎会议 (Synod of Paris) 禁止此类弥撒,称之为一种“应受谴责的做法”,是“部分由于疏忽,部分由于贪婪”而悄然混入教会的。7
随着化质说 (transubstantiation) 信仰的传播,圣餐的神秘性质变成了神迹性的,甚至带有巫术性质。但这一教义在十一世纪获胜以前,曾在两次争论中受到质疑。8
弥撒在东方教会使用希腊语,在西方教会使用拉丁语。对欧洲的蛮族而言,拉丁语是一种不通晓的语言。它在罗马人的后裔中也逐渐不再通用,让位于罗曼诸语言 (Romanic languages)。但教皇的教会牺牲民众的利益以维护祭司阶层,又牺牲理性或属灵的敬拜9以维护外在的统一,直到今日,仍保留拉丁语作为教会的神圣语言,用来举行弥撒。特伦托大公会议 (Council of Trent) 甚至将并非出于默示的拉丁文《武加大译本》(Vulgate),在实际上置于与出于默示的希伯来文和希腊文圣经同等的地位。10
§ 93. 讲道
既然礼拜的主要部分是民众所不能理解的,以本地语言讲道并施行教理问答教导来加以补充,就显得更为重要。但这正是中世纪教会的薄弱之处。11
教皇格列高利一世偶尔也极其恳切地讲道,但很少有教皇效法他的榜样。讲道是主教的职责,他们却常常忽略。747年,为改革弊端而在坎特伯雷大主教卡思伯特 (Cuthbert) 主持下于伦敦 (London) 附近召开的克洛夫绍会议 (Council of Clovesho) 规定:主教应每年巡视各堂区,教导并劝勉修道院院长和修士;所有长老都应能用本地语言向民众解释《使徒信经》、主祷文、弥撒和洗礼仪式。12813年召开的图尔会议 (Synod of Tours),以及847年在拉巴努斯·毛鲁斯 (Rabanus Maurus) 主持下召开的美因茨会议,都规定每位主教应备有一部讲道集,并将其清楚地翻译“in rusticam Romanam linguam aut Theotiscam, i.e. 译成法语(罗曼语)或德语”,“使所有人都能明白”。13
绝大多数祭司过于无知,不能预备讲章,对拉丁文礼仪程式也仅勉强理解。802年的亚琛会议 (Synod of Aix) 规定,他们应学习《亚他那修信经》和《使徒信经》、主祷文及其解释、《圣礼书》(Sacramentarium),即弥撒正典祷文、驱魔程式、临终荐魂祷文(the commendatio animae)、《补赎规程》(Penitential)、教历及罗马圣咏 (Roman cantus);他们应学会理解主日及圣日的讲章,以之为讲道范本,并阅读教皇格列高利的教牧神学。这便是教士学问的全部内容。14研究希腊文新约和希伯来文圣经,根本无从谈起;中世纪的西方主教或教皇,几乎没有一人能用原文研读上帝的圣言。
因此,祭司、执事,甚至大多数主教,所能做的最好之事,就是宣读教父的讲章。奥古斯丁 (Augustin) 曾向不善撰述的人提出这一建议。这在法国 (France) 和英格兰 (England) 成为公认的惯例。因此便有了针对主日和圣日所读福音书与书信而编成的讲道集,称为 Homiliaria。它们大多是教父著作的汇编。比德 (Bede) 的讲道集名为《节期讲道集》(Homilice de Tempore),其中有夏季讲章三十三篇、冬季十五篇、大斋期二十二篇,此外还有圣徒纪念日的讲章。约在公元780年,查理曼 (Charlemagne) 委托执事保罗 (Paulus Diaconus),又名保罗·瓦尔内弗里德 (Paul Warnefrid),编撰一部讲道集(Homiliarium,或 Omiliarius),并推荐法国各教会采用。此人是卡西诺山 (Monte Cassino) 的修士,也是查理曼的随侍教士之一,既是伦巴第人 (Lombards) 的历史学家,也写过歌咏圣徒的诗篇。这部讲道集按主日和节期的次序编排,以《武加大译本》(Vulgate) 的经文为依据,此后数百年间一直或多或少地沿用着。15后来又编成其他集子;即使在爱德华六世 (Edward VI.) 和伊丽莎白女王 (Queen Elizabeth) 治下,经过宗教改革的英格兰教会也认为,有必要为无知的教士提供两部适合宗教改革教义的《讲道集》(Books of Homilies)。
在此,我们必须再次提及那些以诗体重述圣经历史的作品,即诺森布里亚 (Northumbrian) 修士凯德蒙 (Caedmon) 的神圣史诗(680年)、撒克逊语的《救主》("Heliand",Heiland,即救主,约880年),以及奥特弗里德 (Otfrid) 的《基督》,又称《福音合参》(他是拉巴努斯·毛鲁斯的学生,约870年)。这些作品是讲述救赎历史的有效通俗讲道,同时也是条顿语言 (Teutonic language) 中盎格鲁-撒克逊语和古高地德语方言最有价值的遗存。16
然而,直到十六世纪宗教改革,讲道和教导的成分才得到恢复,作为公共敬拜中固定而不可或缺的部分,其尊严和重要性也才得到充分承认。我说的是敬拜,因为阐明上帝的圣言,并虔诚地聆听这样的阐释,无论对讲道者还是听道者,都是或理应是敬拜,正如祈祷和歌唱一样。
§ 94. 教会诗歌:希腊圣诗与圣诗作者
参阅第三卷§ 113(第575页及下页)及§ 114(第578页)所列文献,并增补如下:
皮特拉枢机 (Cardinal Pitra):《希腊教会圣诗学》(Hymnographie de l’église grecque)。罗马 (Rome),1867年。同作者:《为索莱姆文献拾遗编备的神圣文献选集》(Analecta Sacra Spicilegio Solesmensi parata),第I卷。巴黎 (Par.),1876年。
威廉·克里斯特 (Wilhelm Christ) 与M. 帕拉尼卡斯 (M. Paranikas):《希腊基督教诗歌选》(Anthologia Graeca carminum Christianorum)。莱比锡 (Lips.),1871年。CXLIV及268页。希腊文正文,附博学的拉丁文导论。克里斯特得到希腊教会成员帕拉尼卡斯的协助。参阅克里斯特:《拜占庭教会文献研究》(Beiträge zur kirchlichen Literatur der Byzantiner)。慕尼黑 (München),1870年。
[?]. L. 雅可比 ([?]. L. Jacobi,哈勒教会史教授):《希腊教会圣诗史论》(Zur Geschichte der griechischen Kirchenliedes)(对皮特拉《神圣文献选集》〔Analecta〕的评论),载布里格尔 (Brieger) 的《教会史杂志》(Zeitschrift für Kirchengesch.),第V卷,第2期,第177–250页(哥达〔Gotha〕,1881年)。
希腊圣诗原文的小型选集,可参阅丹尼尔 (Daniel) 的《圣诗宝库》(Thesaurus Hymnologicus) 第三卷(1855年),以及贝斯勒 (Bässler) 的《古代基督教诗歌选》(Auswahl altchristlicher Lieder)(1858年),第153–166页。
英译本尤其可参阅J. M. 尼尔 (J. M. Neale):《东方教会圣诗》(Hymns of the Eastern Church)(伦敦〔Lond.〕,1862年;第三版,1866年,159页;新版,1876年,大字体排印,250页);另参沙弗 (Schaff):《诗歌中的基督》(Christ in Song)(1869年),其中收有14首希腊圣诗(以及73首拉丁圣诗)的译文。德译见贝斯勒,前引书,第3–25页。
[叙利亚圣诗学。在第三卷第580页所列文献之外,增补:古斯特·比克尔 (Gust. Bickell):《叙利亚的圣以法莲〈尼西比诗歌〉,附导论及叙利亚语词典补编,校订、翻译并注释》(S. Ephraemi Syri Carmina Nisibena, additis prolegomenis et supplemento lexicorum syriacorum edidit, vertit, explicavit.)。莱比锡 (Lips.),1866年。卡尔·马克 (Carl Macke):《两河流域圣诗:叙利亚的圣以法莲诗作,由叙利亚文原文译为德文》(Hymnen aus dem Zweiströmeland. Dichtungen des heil. Ephrem des Syrers aus dem syr. Urtext in’s Deutsche übertragen),等等。美因茨 (Mainz),1882年。270页。马克是比克尔的学生,并接续青格勒 (Zingerle),从事叙利亚教会诗歌的翻译。]
一般的教会史大多轻忽或忽略圣诗学,而它恰是基督徒生活与敬拜的最佳反映。
希腊教会诗歌的古典时期约从650年延续至820年,几乎与圣像破坏运动的争论 (iconoclastic controversy) 同时。对圣徒和圣像敬拜的热情点燃了诗歌的灵感,而这种敬拜的主要倡导者也正是主要的圣诗作者。17东方教会一直尊崇他们的纪念。他们的作品被收入礼仪书,尤其是《月课经》(Menaea);此书共十二卷,每月一卷,收录每日的敬虔礼文,与拉丁教会的《日课经》(Breviary) 相对应。18许多作品仍未刊行,保存在修道院图书馆中。这些诗歌颂扬神圣的三位一体、道成肉身和各大节期,尤其也颂扬童贞女马利亚、圣徒、殉道者及圣像。
希腊教会诗歌不采用格律与押韵,而是写成供吟唱的有节奏的散文,如同《诗篇》、新约中的颂歌、《至高荣耀颂》(Gloria in Excelsis) 和《赞美颂》(Te Deum) 一样。较早的圣诗作者同时也是曲调作者,亲自谱曲。19诗节称为 troparia;20第一节称为 hirmos,因为它定下曲调,并引领其余各节随之而行。21三个或更多诗节组成一首颂歌(ode);三首小颂歌组成一个三颂组(triodion);九首颂歌或三个三颂组构成一部颂诗组曲(canon)。颂歌通常以荣耀颂(doxa)和一节赞美上帝之母马利亚的诗歌(theotokion)作结。22拥有自己独特曲调的圣诗,称为自调圣诗(idiomelon)。23
据尼尔说,这类诗歌占希腊礼仪书的十分之九以上,或五分之四。西方以往对它知之甚少,也很少欣赏,但如今已能接触到这些作品。24其中有一些真正的基督教圣诗珍品,却埋没在大量单调、浮夸而乏味的赞词之中;这些赞词所颂扬的,是不知名的认信者、殉道者,以及显奇迹的圣像。25
严格说来,希腊教会诗歌始于第三世纪那首作者不详、却获普遍接纳、真正不朽的《至高荣耀颂》(Gloria in Excelsis)。26拿先斯的贵格利 (Gregory of Nazianzus,卒于390年) 和昔兰尼的叙内修斯 (Synesius of Cyrene,约卒于414年) 采用通常的古典格律所写的诗,既不适合公共敬拜,也不是为此而作的。27
拜占庭时期第一位圣诗作者,是君士坦丁堡牧首阿纳托利乌斯 (Anatolius,约卒于458年)。他开创了音韵和谐的散文这一新途径,可与西方的维南提乌斯·福尔图纳图斯 (Venantius Fortunatus) 相提并论。28
我们现在转而论述希腊教会诗歌的古典时期。
在希腊圣诗作者中居于首位的,是大马士革的圣约翰 (St. John Of Damascus),别号 曼苏尔 (Mansur)(约于780年以极高龄去世)。他是东方教会最伟大的系统神学家,也是在伊苏里亚人皇帝利奥 (Leo the Isaurian,717–741年) 和君士坦丁·科普罗尼穆斯 (Constantinus Copronymus,741–775年) 统治期间,抵抗圣像破坏运动、捍卫圣像敬拜的主要斗士。他一生中有一段时间住在马尔萨巴修道院 (Mar Sâba,或称圣萨巴修道院〔St. Sabas〕);该院位于耶路撒冷 (Jerusalem) 与死海 (Dead Sea) 之间荒凉的汲沦谷 (Kedron)。29人们认为,他特别蒙受了这所修道院的主保童贞女马利亚的启迪,将自己的诗才奉献于赞美基督。他撰写了《八调经》(Octoechus) 的很大一部分;此书收录东方教会的主日礼文。他为复活节所作的颂诗组曲,被称为“黄金颂诗组曲”或“颂诗组曲之后”,在复活节前的午夜吟唱,以欢呼“基督复活了”及应答“基督确实复活了”开始。他的纪念日是12月4日。30
仅次于他的是耶路撒冷的圣科斯马斯 (St. Cosmas Of Jerusalem),号称旋律家 (the Melodist);在拜占庭作家看来,若论谱曲,他甚至高于约翰。正如尼尔 (Neale) 所说,他是“希腊诗人中最有学问的一位,是东方的圣维克托的亚当 (Adam of St. Victor)”。科斯马斯与大马士革的约翰是同受一人抚养的兄弟,也是朋友,并同在马尔萨巴修道院为修士,彼此修改对方的作品。耶路撒冷牧首约翰 (John) 不顾科斯马斯本人的意愿,将他祝圣为巴勒斯坦南部迦萨 (Gaza) 附近马尤马 (Maiuma) 的主教。他约卒于760年,纪念日为10月14日。他的传记前所题的诗句 (stichos) 说:
“科斯马斯已往甘美圆满之处,
他的甘美诗歌却长存,仍使教会欢欣。”31
第三位是圣狄奥法尼斯 (St. Theophanes),别号受烙印者 (the Branded),32他是最多产的诗人之一。他参加了第二次尼西亚会议 (second Council of Nicaea,787年)。在利奥·阿尔米尼安 (Leo the Arminian,813年) 统治期间,他因热心敬奉圣像而遭受监禁、放逐及残肢之刑,约于820年去世。他的《编年史》(Chronography) 是研究圣像之争历史的主要史料之一。33
以下节选自亚当哀叹自己堕落的诗篇,颇有意味:
“亚当坐在东门正对面,
悲伤的回忆如阵阵风暴,使他辗转不安:
我真有祸啊!竟被蛇的仇恨毁坏至此!
我真有祸啊!从前何等荣耀,如今何等沦丧!
竟如此疯狂,选择这苦楚的命运!
受了欺哄,失尽所有!
那么,我眼目的喜乐啊——
乐园啊,我岂必须离开你,
如流亡者一般离去?
我岂必须无休止地悲叹,
追念我的上帝曾在晚凉时分,
降临地上,在这里漫步?
慈悲的主啊!我向你呼求:
怜悯人的主啊!求你赦免我的堕落!”
其余在这三位大师之前或之后的拜占庭圣诗作者,列举如下。他们的年代大多不能确定,或尚有争议。
塞尔吉乌斯 (Sergius) 在希拉克略 (Heracleus,610–641年) 统治期间任君士坦丁堡牧首,在基督一志论争论 (Monotheletic controversy) 初起时扮演了重要角色;那位皇帝采用的联合信式,很可能就是他提出的。克里斯特 (Christ) 认为,著名而广受喜爱的《不坐颂》(Akathistos) 出自他的手笔;此诗赞美马利亚解救君士坦丁堡脱离波斯人的围困(630年),但通常被归于皮西迪亚的乔治 (Georgius Pisida)。34
耶路撒冷牧首索弗罗尼乌斯 (Sophronius,629年) 用阿那克里翁格律 (Anacreontic metres) 颂赞基督、使徒与殉道者,并为教会礼拜撰写自调圣诗 (idiomela),配以曲调。35
认信者马克西穆斯 (Maximus The Confessor,580–662年) 是基督一志论争论中正统基督二志论 (dyotheletic doctrine) 的领袖和殉道者,也是东方教会最深邃的神学家与神秘主义者之一;他写过几首圣诗。36
日耳曼努斯 (Germanus,634–734年) 先任基齐库斯 (Cyzicus) 主教,后任君士坦丁堡牧首(715年);他因拒绝服从皇帝伊苏里亚人皇帝利奥(717–741年)破坏圣像的敕令,于730年被废黜,此后退居而终,享年约一百岁。他“被希腊人视为他们最光荣的认信者之一”(尼尔语)。他为数不多的诗作中,有咏柱头修士西面 (Symeon the Stylite)、先知以利亚、施洗约翰被斩首的诗节,以及一部咏埃德萨 (Edessa) 显奇迹圣像的颂诗组曲。37
克里特的安德烈 (Andrew Of Crete,660–732年) 生于大马士革,先在耶路撒冷成为修士,后任君士坦丁堡执事、克里特大主教。他参加了712年的基督一志论会议,但后来回归正统。由于这一转变,加上他拥护圣像,他被列入圣徒之中。他被认为是颂诗组曲的创始人。他的《大颂诗组曲》在大斋期中段那一周的星期四通篇吟唱,这一天也因这首圣诗而得名。这是一篇认罪及祈求上帝怜悯的诗篇,共有不少于二百五十节(尼尔说是三百节)。38
大马士革的约翰缩减了颂诗组曲不合理的篇幅。
另有一位安德烈,称为 Ἀνδρέας Πυρός* 或 Πυρρός*,据说《月课经》(Menaea) 中有八首自调圣诗出自他的手笔;克里斯特从中选出赞美彼得和保罗的一首,认为最为出色。39
萨巴修道院的司提反 (Stephen The Sabaite,725–794年) 是大马士革的约翰的侄子,在马尔萨巴修道院度过了五十九年;该院如鹰巢一般,坐落在汲沦谷的荒野岩石之上。他的纪念日为7月13日。他为尼尔那首精美的慰藉圣诗《你疲倦了吗》奠定了基调;这首诗见于《八调经》的某些版本。与其说他是此诗的作者,不如说他是它的灵感来源;此诗值得收入每一本敬虔诗集。40
罗马努斯 (Romanus) 曾任贝里图斯 (Berytus) 的执事,后任君士坦丁堡的司祭,是较早诗人中最具独创性、也最多产的诗人之一。佩特拉 (Petra) 将二十五首圣诗归于他,认为他生活在阿纳斯塔修斯一世 (Anastasius I.,491–518年) 统治时期;克里斯特则将他置于阿纳斯塔修斯二世 (Anastasius II.,713–719年) 统治时期,而雅科比 (Jacobi) 认为他生活在君士坦丁·波戈纳图斯 (Constantinus Pogonatus,681–685年) 的时代,这一说法更为可信。41
斯图迪乌斯修道院的狄奥多尔 (Theodore Of The Studium;该院是君士坦丁堡附近一所著名的修道院),因在圣像破坏运动的争论中受苦而著称,于826年11月11日在流放中去世。他为大斋期撰写颂诗组曲,也为圣徒节期撰写颂歌。那部在正统信仰主日吟唱、庆祝圣像敬拜于842年最终获胜的激昂颂诗组曲,被归于他的名下;但它必定出自较晚时期,因为他在这一胜利之前便已去世。42
斯图迪乌斯修道院的约瑟 (Joseph Of The Studium) 是狄奥多尔的兄弟,也是该院的修士,后来成为帖撒罗尼迦大主教(因此又称 Thessalonicensis,即“帖撒罗尼迦的”)。他因遭受皇帝狄奥菲卢斯 (Theophilus,829–842年) 下令施加的酷刑而死于狱中。有时人们(甚至尼尔)将他与圣诗作者约瑟 (Joseph Hymnographus) 混为一人;但尼基弗鲁斯 (Nicephorus) 将二人区分开来,他们的纪念日也各不相同。43
斯图迪乌斯修道院的狄奥克提斯图斯 (Theoctistus Of The Studium,约890年) 是《向耶稣恳求的颂诗组曲》的作者;这是我们所知关于他的唯一事迹,却也是希腊教会最甘美的耶稣圣诗。44
约瑟,号称圣诗作者 (Hymnographus,880年),是希腊圣诗作者中最多产、最浮夸、也最冗长乏味的一位。他生于西西里,最后在君士坦丁堡的一所教堂中任圣器总管。他是佛提乌斯 (Photius) 的朋友,并随他一同流亡。《月课经》(Mencaea) 和《八调经》中的大量颂诗组曲,都被归于他。45
君士坦丁堡牧首塔拉修 (Tarasius,784年) 是恢复圣像及召开第二次尼西亚会议(787年)的主要推动者。他于806年2月25日去世。他的圣诗并不重要。46
欧提米乌斯 (EUTHYMIUS),通常称为辛格鲁斯 (Syngelus) 或辛凯卢斯 (Syncellus),约卒于910年,写过一部向童贞女马利亚祈求的悔罪颂诗组曲,在东方备受推崇。47
皮特拉 (Pitra) 研究格罗塔费拉塔 (Grotta Ferrata) 及其他修道院图书馆的藏书,揭示了约761年任耶路撒冷主教的埃利亚斯 (Elias),以及996–1012年任该城主教的奥雷斯特斯 (Orestes),也都是诗人。
此外,还可提到美多迪乌斯 (Methodius,846年)、48君士坦丁堡牧首佛提乌斯(卒于891年)、士每拿的梅特罗法尼斯 (Metrophanes of Smyrna,900年)、因第四次婚姻而使东方教会陷入纷扰的利奥六世 (Leo VI.,又称哲学家,886–917年)、西面·梅塔弗拉斯特斯 (Symeon Metaphrastes,约900年任君士坦丁堡宫廷秘书及掌玺大臣)、卡西阿斯 (Kasias)、尼卢斯·克桑托普卢斯 (Nilus Xanthopulus)、约安尼斯·格奥梅特拉 (Joannes Geometra),以及毛罗普斯 (Mauropus,1060年)。至最后这一位,希腊圣诗创作便几乎终止了。有相当数量的圣诗,无法查明其作者。49
最后,我们列出希腊圣诗中最优秀的几篇范例,采用尼尔博士重新译写并改编以适合现代使用的版本。
今日是复活之日 (Ἀναστάσεως ἡμέρα*。)
大马士革的圣约翰作。
今日是复活之日,
大地啊,四处传扬!
这是欢欣的逾越节,
这是上帝的逾越节!
从死亡进入永生,
从大地升到天上,
我们的基督已领我们渡过,
伴随着得胜的歌唱。
愿我们的心洁净,远离罪恶,
使我们能真切瞻望,
瞻望那位主,置身于
复活永恒的光芒:
并且侧耳聆听他的声音,
听见那平和而清晰的,
他亲口所说的“愿你们平安!”——听见之后,
便高唱得胜的乐章。
如今,愿诸天同在!
愿大地开始歌唱!
愿整个世界欢庆胜利,
连同其中的一切:
愿万物以感恩的欢腾,
将各自的歌声汇成一曲,
因为主基督已经复活,
他是我们无尽的喜乐。
––––––––––
耶稣,你名超乎万名
(至甘甜的耶稣,Ἰησοῦ γλυκύτατε*。)
斯图迪乌斯修道院的圣狄奥克提斯图斯作。
耶稣,你名超乎万名,
耶稣,至善至亲,
耶稣,完全之爱的泉源,
至圣、至柔、至近!
耶稣,完备恩典的源头,
耶稣,至诚;耶稣,至甘,
耶稣,神圣能力的泉源,
使我属你,保守我,印我归你!
耶稣,为我敞开那门,
就是那罪人曾进入的门,
他在临终的最后时刻,
曾将自己完全托付于你。
你的伤痕永远在恳求,
你的受难也在代求,
求你使我脱离苦境,升入
乐园中的家乡!
你曾呼唤浪子;
你曾赦免马利亚:
你的话语永不落空,
你的慈爱永不改变,
主啊,我正处于沦丧之中,
求赐我痛悔——因你能赐下!
你若愿意,就能赦免我一切罪恶:
求你说:“我愿意!”
我有祸了,竟偏离正路,
追随肉体的享乐!
我有祸了,竟从未努力,
寻求天上的财宝!
那财宝安存于天上居所;
不朽坏,永长存!
赢得这财宝所付的代价,
竟是圣子的受难!
耶稣,你为我戴荆棘冠冕,
为我的过犯受鞭打!
你在剧痛之中,
为那美好的认信作了见证;
耶稣,你身披紫袍,
为我的罪恶偿付代价;
愿你一切的忧患痛苦,
愿你在各各他所受的苦,不归徒然!
当我来到死亡的苦海,
波浪愈卷愈高,
风暴愈来愈近,
援助也愈发离我而去:
耶稣,莫任凭我衰残,
无助、绝望、满怀痛楚!
求你对我说:“我实在告诉你,
今日你要同我在一起!”
你疲倦了吗?
(劳苦与疲乏,Κόπον τε καὶ κάματον*。)
萨巴修道院的圣司提反作。
你疲倦了吗,你困乏了吗,
你深陷愁苦了吗?
有一位说:“到我这里来,
来了便得安息!”
若他是我的向导,
他有什么记号,能领我到他那里?
“他的脚上、手上,
还有肋旁,都有伤痕。”
他既为君王,是否有冠冕,
装点他的额头?
“是的,确实有冠冕,
却是荆棘编成!”
若我寻见他,若我跟随他,
他在今世给什么赏赐?
“许多忧伤,许多劳苦,
许多眼泪。”
若我始终紧紧依附他,
他最终有什么赐予?
忧伤已胜过,劳苦已止息,
约旦河已渡过!”
若我求他接纳我,
他会拒绝我吗?
除非大地、除非诸天,
都已废去!”
寻见、跟随、持守、奋斗,
他果真必赐福吗?
天使、殉道者、先知、童贞者,
都回答:是的!”
§ 95. 拉丁圣诗:文献
参见第III卷,第585页及后。以下书目涵盖整个中世纪时期的拉丁圣诗。
I. 拉丁文诗集
《日课经》(Breviaries) 和《弥撒经》(Missals)。克利希托韦乌斯 (Clichtovaeus) 的圣诗集(巴黎,1515年;巴塞尔〔Bas.〕,1517及1519年),卡桑德尔 (Cassander) 的圣诗集(科隆〔Col.〕,1556年),埃林格尔 (Ellinger) 的圣诗集(美因河畔法兰克福〔Frankf. a. M.〕,1578年),格奥尔格·法布里修斯 (Georg Fabricius) 的《古代教会诗人作品集》(Poetarum Veterum ecclesiasticorum Opera,巴塞尔,1564年)。各部《日课经》及这些早期诗集的完整书名,见丹尼尔著作,第I卷,第XIII–XXII页,及第II卷,第VIII–XIV页。
枢机主教约斯·马里亚·托马修斯 (Jos. Maria Thomasius,亦作 Tomasi,1649–1713年,罗马教会礼仪与仪式的主要阐释者之一):《全集》(Opera Omnia)。罗马 (Rom.),1741年及后,7卷。第II卷,第351–403页,载有《全年圣诗集》(Hymnarium de anni circulo) 等;为编成此集,他校勘了梵蒂冈 (Vatican) 及意大利其他地方最古老的圣诗抄本,年代下迄八世纪。同卷还收有《诗篇日课经》(Breviarium Psalterii)。第IV卷(1749年)收有《罗马教会应答咏与对经集》(Responsorialia et antiphonaria Romanae ecclesia),第VI卷(1751年)则收有一部弥撒经汇编。托马修斯的著作至今仍极有价值。丹尼尔称其书为“fons primarius”(首要源泉)。
奥古斯特·雅各布·兰巴赫 (Aug. Jak. Rambach,汉堡〔Hamburg〕的路德宗牧师,1777年生,1851年卒):《基督教会历代圣歌选》(Anthologie christlicher Gesänge aus alien Jahrh. der christl. Kirche)。阿尔托纳 (Altona) 及莱比锡 (Leipzig),1817–1833年,6卷。第I卷收录拉丁圣诗,附德译及注释。其余各卷只收德文圣诗,尤其是宗教改革以来的作品。兰巴赫是圣诗学的先驱。
约布·克赖因 (Job. Kehrein,罗马天主教徒):《中世纪基督教诗人拉丁诗选》(Lat. Anthologie aus den christl. Dichtern des Mittelalters)。美因河畔法兰克福 (Frankfurt a. m.),1840年。其篇幅更大的著作见下文。
[约翰·亨利·纽曼 (John Henry Newman),原属圣公会,1845年加入罗马教会]:《教会圣诗》(Hymni Ecclesiae)。伦敦(麦克米伦〔Macmillan〕),1838年;新版,1865年(401页)。仅收巴黎、罗马及圣公会《日课经》中的圣诗。第一部分序言署名“J. H. N.”,日期为1838年2月21日,但扉页未署作者姓名。约在同一时期,纽曼枢机主教译出了《日课经》圣诗,见下文第III类。
H. A. 丹尼尔 (H. A. Daniel,路德宗信徒,1871年卒):《圣诗宝库》(Thesaurus Hymnologicus)。莱比锡 (Lips.),1841–1856年,5卷。第I、II、IV、V卷收拉丁圣诗,第IV卷收希腊及叙利亚圣诗。这是一部内容丰富的标准诗集,但有待修订。
P. J. 莫内 (P. J. Mone,罗马天主教徒,1871年卒):《中世纪拉丁圣诗》(Lateinische Hymnen des Mittelalters)。布赖斯高的弗赖堡 (Freiburg i. B.),1853–1855年,3卷。依据抄本编成,附有注释。共收1215首圣诗,分为篇幅大致相等的三部分:(1)献给上帝和天使的圣诗(461页);(2)献给童贞女马利亚的圣诗(457页);(3)献给圣徒的圣诗(579页)。
D. 奥扎南 (D. Ozanam):《意大利文学史未刊文献》(Documents inédits pour servir a l’histoire littéraire de l’Italie)。巴黎,1850年。内收一部古代拉丁圣诗集,后重印于米涅 (Migne) 的《拉丁教父集》(Patrol. Lat.),第151卷,第813–824栏。
约瑟夫·斯蒂文森 (Joseph Stevenson):《盎格鲁—撒克逊教会的拉丁圣诗:附行间盎格鲁—撒克逊语释义,据达勒姆图书馆所藏十一世纪抄本》(Latin Hymns of the Anglo-Saxon Church; with an Interlinear Anglo-Saxon Gloss, from a MS. of the eleventh century in Durham Library)。1851年(瑟蒂斯学会〔Surtees Soc.〕)。
J. M. 尼尔 (J. M. Neale,萨克维尔学院〔Sackville College〕院长,圣公会高派人士,1866年卒):《从中世纪德国、英国、法国及其他地方弥撒经中辑录的继抒咏》(Sequentiae ex Missalibus Germanicis, Anglicis, Gallicis, aliisque medii aevi collectae)。伦敦,1852年。284页。收继抒咏125首。
费利克斯·克莱芒 (Felix Clément):《基督教诗人诗选》(Carmina e Poetis Christianis excerpta)。巴黎 (Parisiis),戈姆兄弟 (Gaume Fratres),1854年。564页。收四至十四世纪圣诗的拉丁文本,附法文注释。
R. Ch. 特伦奇 (R. Ch. Trench,都柏林〔Dublin〕大主教):《拉丁圣诗选,以抒情诗为主》(Sacred Latin Poetry, chiefly Lyrical)。伦敦及剑桥 (Cambridge),1849年;第2版,1864年;第3版,经修订改进,1874年(342页)。附有富于教益的导论及注释。
安斯·舒比格尔 (Ans. Schubiger):《八至十二世纪的圣加仑歌唱学校》(Die Sängerschule St. Gallens vom 8ten bis 12ten Jahrh)。艾因西德伦 (Einsiedeln),1858年。收录六十篇歌词,附古代乐谱及摹真本。
P. 加尔·莫雷尔 (P. Gall Morel,罗马天主教徒):《中世纪拉丁圣诗,主要采自瑞士修道院抄本》(Lat. Hymnen des Mittelalters, grösstentheils aus Handschriften schweizerischer Klöster)。艾因西德伦(本齐格〔Benziger〕),1868年(341页)。主要为马利亚颂歌 (Marienlieder) 和圣徒颂歌 (Heiligenlieder)(第30–325页)。是丹尼尔及莫内诗集的补编。
菲尔·瓦克纳格尔 (Phil. Wackernagel,路德宗信徒,1877年卒):《从最早时期至十七世纪初的德国教会圣诗》(Das deutsche Kirchenlied von der ältesten Zeit bis zum Anfang des XVII. Jahrh)。莱比锡 (Leipz.),1864–1877年,5卷(末卷由其二子编辑)。这是规模最大的一部古代德文圣诗巨集;但第I卷收录的却是四至十六世纪的拉丁圣诗及继抒咏。
卡尔·巴尔奇 (Karl Bartsch,罗斯托克〔Rostock〕的德语及罗曼语文学教授):《从音乐和节奏方面论中世纪拉丁继抒咏》(Die lateinischen Sequenzen des Mittelalters in musikalischer und rhythmischer Beziehung dargestellt)。罗斯托克,1868年。
查尔斯·布坎南·皮尔森 (Chs. Buchanan Pierson):《索尔兹伯里弥撒经中的继抒咏》(Sequences from the Sarum Missal)。伦敦,1871年。
约瑟夫·克赖因 (Joseph Kehrein,罗马天主教徒):《据抄本与印本辑成的中世纪拉丁继抒咏》(Lateinische Sequenzen des Mittelalters aus Handschriften und Drucken)。美因茨,1873年(620页)。这是最完备的继抒咏集(八百余首)。他如同莫内划分圣诗一般,按题材划分继抒咏(献给上帝的诗歌、天使颂歌、马利亚颂歌、圣徒颂歌:Lieder an Gott, Engellieder, Marienlieder, Heiligenlieder)。亦参上文所述其早期著作。
弗朗西斯·A. 马奇 (Francis A. March):《拉丁圣诗,附英文注释》(Latin Hymns, with English Notes)。纽约 (N. York),1874年。
W. 麦基尔文 (W. McIlvaine):《爱尔兰神圣诗琴》(Lyra Sacra Hibernica)。贝尔法斯特 (Belfast),1879年。(收有圣帕特里克〔St. Patrick〕、科伦巴〔Columba〕及塞杜利乌斯〔Sedulius〕的圣诗。)
E. 迪姆勒 (E. Dümmler):《加洛林时代拉丁诗人集》(Poëtae Latini Aevi Carolini)。柏林 (Berol.),1880–1884年,2卷。亦收有圣诗,见第II卷,第244–258页。
圣维克托的亚当作品的专门版本:L. 戈蒂耶 (L. Gautier):《圣维克托的亚当诗作集》(La aeuvres poétiques d’ Adam de S. Victor)。巴黎,1858及1859年,2卷。迪格比·S. 朗厄姆 (Digby S. Wrangham,牛津〔Oxford〕圣约翰学院人士):《圣维克托的亚当的礼仪诗歌》(The Liturgical Poetry of Adam of St. Victor)。伦敦,1881年,3卷。(采用戈蒂耶的拉丁文本,附按原诗格律译成的英译及简注。)关于《震怒之日》(Dies Irae),见利斯科 (Lisco) 的专著(柏林〔Berlin〕,1840年)。此诗常有单行本,例如富兰克林·约翰逊 (Franklin Johnson) 所出版本,马萨诸塞州剑桥 (Cambridge, Mass.),1883年。《圣母侍立》(Stabat Mater) 和克吕尼的伯纳德 (Bernard of Cluny) 的圣诗《论轻看世界》(De Contemptu Mundi) 也同样常有单行本(后者为尼尔的新耶路撒冷圣诗提供了思想)。圣伯尔纳 (St. Bernard)、阿伯拉尔 (Abelard)、托马斯·阿奎那 (Thomas Aquinas)、波拿文都拉 (Bonaventura) 的圣诗,均收在各人的全集中。圣伯尔纳的圣诗见米涅《拉丁教父集》(Patrol. Lat.),第184卷,第1307–1330栏;阿伯拉尔的圣诗见第178卷,第1759–1824栏。
II. 历史与批评著作
波利卡普·莱瑟 (Polyc. Leyser):《中世纪诗人与诗作史》(Historia Poëtarum et Poëmatum Medii Aevi)。哈勒 (Halae),1721年。
弗里德里希·明特尔 (Friedr. Münter):《论最早的基督教诗歌》(Ueber die älteste christl. Poesie)。哥本哈根 (Kopenhagen),1806年。
埃德尔斯唐·迪梅里尔 (Edélstand Du Méril):《十二世纪以前的拉丁民间诗歌》(Poésies populaires Latines anterieures au douzième siècle)。巴黎,1843年。《中世纪拉丁民间诗歌》(Poésies populaire’s Latines du moyen âge)。巴黎,1847年。
特伦奇:《拉丁圣诗选》(S. Lat. Poetry) 的《导论》(Introd.)。见上文。
贝尔 (Baehr):《罗马的基督教诗人与历史作家》(Die christl. Dichter und Geschichtschreiber Roms)。卡尔斯鲁厄 (Karlsruhe),1836年;修订第2版,1872年(附书目)。
爱德华·埃米尔·科赫 (Edward Emil Koch):《基督教会,尤其德国福音派教会的圣诗与圣歌史》(Geschichte des Kirchenlieds und Kirchengesangs in der christlichen, insbesondere der deutschen evangel. Kirche)。斯图加特 (Stuttgart),修订增补第3版,1866–1876年,7卷。这部极富教益且有价值的著作,在第I卷第40–153页论及拉丁圣诗学,但论述颇为肤浅。
阿德·埃伯特 (Ad. Ebert):《西方中世纪文学通史》(Allgem. Gesch. der Lit. des Mittelalters im Abendlande),第I卷(莱比锡,1874年)第三编(第516页及后),及第II卷(1880年),后者涵盖查理曼及其继承者的时代。
约翰·凯泽 (Joh. Kayser,罗马天主教徒):《最早期教会圣诗的历史与阐释论集》(Beiträge zur Geschichte und Erklärung der ältesten Kirchenhymnen)。帕德博恩 (Paderborn),第2版,1881年。477页,仅论至六世纪,以福图纳图斯 (Fortunatus) 作结。亦见其论文《〈圣母痛苦侍立〉圣诗的文本》(Der Text des Hymnus Stabat Mater dolorosa),载图宾根 (Tübingen)《神学季刊》(Theol. Quartalschrift),1884年,第I期,第85–103页。
III. 英译本
约翰·钱德勒 (John Chandler,圣公会信徒,1876年7月1日卒):《初期教会圣诗,首次汇集、翻译并编排》(The Hymns of the Primitive Church, now first collected, translated and arranged)。伦敦,1837年。收108首拉丁圣诗,附钱德勒的译文。
理查德·曼特 (Richard Mant,唐与康纳〔Down and Connor〕主教,1848年11月2日卒):《罗马日课经中的古代圣诗》(Ancient Hymns from the Roman Breviary)。1837年。新版,伦敦及牛津 (Oxf.),1871年(272页)。
约翰·亨利·纽曼:《各时各境诗作》(Verses on Various Occasions)。伦敦,1868年(由帕特里克·多纳休〔Patrick Donahue〕在波士顿〔Boston〕重印)。序言日期为1867年12月21日,署名 J. H. N.。本书收有这位枢机主教的原创诗作,以及他所译的《罗马日课经》圣诗和《巴黎日课经》中的两首圣诗;据第186页一则注释,这些译作全作于1836–1838年,即他离开英格兰教会之前八年。
艾萨克·威廉斯 (Isaac Williams,原属牛津三位一体学院,1865年卒):《译自巴黎日课经的圣诗》(Hymns translated from the Parisian Breviary)。伦敦,1839年。
爱德华·卡斯沃尔 (Edward Caswall,原属圣公会,1847年加入罗马天主教会,1878年1月2日卒):《大公诗琴:收录日课经及弥撒经的全部圣诗,并若干其他圣诗》(Lyra Catholica. Containing all the Breviary and Missal Hymns together with some other hymns)。伦敦,1849年(311页)。纽约 (N. Y.),1851年重印。译文极佳。这些译作也收入他的《圣诗与诗作:原创与翻译》(Hymns and Poems, original and translated),伦敦,第2版,1873年。
约翰·戴维·钱伯斯 (John David Chambers,新索尔兹伯里〔New Sarum〕市法官):《锡安当赞美:英格兰及其他教会的古代拉丁圣诗,按对应格律翻译》(Lauda Syon. Ancient Latin Hymns in the English and other Churches, translated into corresponding metres)。伦敦,1857年(116页)。
J. M. 尼尔:《中世纪圣诗与继抒咏》(Mediaeval Hymns and Sequences)。伦敦,1862年;第3版,1867年(224页)。在自由再现拉丁及希腊圣诗方面,尼尔是最伟大的大师。他还将自己所译的新耶路撒冷圣诗另行出版:《克吕尼修士莫尔莱的伯纳德论天上家乡的韵诗》(The Rhythm of Bernard de Morlaix, Monk of Cluny, on the Celestial Country)。伦敦,1858年,第7版,1865年,附所译部分的拉丁文本(48页)。此外还有《美丽的圣母侍立》(Stabat Mater Speciosa, Full of Beauty stood the Mother)(1866年)。
《中世纪教会七大圣诗》(The Seven Great Hymns of the Mediaeval Church)。纽约(A. D. F. Randolph & Co.),1866年;增补第7版,1883年。154页。这部匿名著作(作者为华盛顿〔Washington〕的 C. C. 诺特〔C. C. Nott〕法官)收有多位作者所译的伯纳德《天上家乡》、 《震怒之日》(Dies Irae)、《痛苦之母》(Mater Dolorosa)、《美丽之母》(Mater Speciosa)、《圣灵,请降临》(Veni Sancte Spiritus)、《创造者圣灵,请降临》(Veni Creator Spiritus)、《君王旌旗》(Vexilla Regis),以及戈德斯卡尔库斯 (Godescalcus) 的《哈利路亚继抒咏》。亦附原文。
菲利普·沙弗 (Philip Schaff):《诗歌中的基督》(Christ in Song)。纽约,1868年;伦敦,1869年。收多位作者所译的七十三首拉丁圣诗。
W. H. 奥登海默 (W. H. Odenheimer) 及弗雷德里克·M. 伯德 (Frederic M. Bird):《圣灵之歌》(Songs of the Spirit)。纽约,1871年。收二十三首论圣灵的拉丁圣诗译文,以及数量更多的英文圣诗。伊拉斯塔斯·C. 本尼迪克特 (Erastus C. Benedict,纽约法官,1878年卒):《希尔德贝特的圣诗及其他中世纪圣诗,附译文》(The Hymn of Hildebert and other Mediaeval Hymns, with translations)。纽约,1869年。
亚伯拉罕·科尔斯 (Abraham Coles,医学博士):《拉丁圣诗,附自译本》(Latin Hymns, with Original Translations)。纽约,1868年。收《震怒之日》(Dies Irae) 的13种译文,这些译文也曾于1859年单独出版。
汉密尔顿·M. 麦吉尔 (Hamilton M. Macgill),神学博士(属苏格兰联合长老会〔United Presb. Ch. of Scotland〕):《选自十八个世纪的基督教信仰与生活之歌》(Songs of the Christian Creed and Life selected from Eighteen Centuries)。伦敦及爱丁堡 (Edinb.),1879年。收若干拉丁圣诗及少数希腊圣诗的译文,附原文;亦收英文圣诗的拉丁译文。
《罗马日课经》(The Roman Breviary)。由比尤特侯爵约翰 (John Marquess of Bute),K. T.,从拉丁文译为英文。爱丁堡及伦敦,1879年,2卷。散见本书各处的圣诗译文,以原属圣公会的卡斯沃尔和纽曼枢机主教所译者为最佳。比尤特侯爵本人也是从英格兰教会归入罗马教会的。
D. F. 摩根 (D. F. Morgan):《拉丁教会的圣诗及其他诗歌》(Hymns and other Poetry of the Latin Church)。牛津,1880年。收100首译诗,按圣公会历编排。
爱德华·A. 沃什伯恩 (Edward A. Washburn,纽约各各他教会主任牧师,1881年2月2日卒):《忙碌人生的心声》(Voices from a Busy Life)。纽约,1883年。除原创诗作外,还收有32首拉丁圣诗的精妙译文,其中数首先前曾发表于沙弗的《诗歌中的基督》(Christ in Song)。
塞缪尔·W. 达菲尔德 (Samuel W. Duffield):《拉丁圣诗作者及其圣诗》(The Latin Hymn Writers and their Hymns)(正在编写,拟于1885年在纽约出版。此书将涵盖拉丁圣诗学的全部领域,并收录较著名圣诗的译文)。
- 拉丁圣诗的德译本:(大多附原文)数量极多,例如兰巴赫,1817年及后(见上文);C. 福特拉格 (C. Fortlage)(《基督教古代圣歌》〔Gesänge christl. Vorzeit〕,1844年);卡尔·西姆罗克 (Karl Simrock)(《锡安当赞美》〔Lauda Sion〕,1850年);埃德·考弗尔 (Ed. Kauffer)(《耶稣圣诗:古代教会拉丁圣歌集》〔Jesus-Hymnen, Sammlung altkirchl. lat. Gesänge〕等,莱比锡,1854年,65页);H. 施塔德尔曼 (H. Stadelmann)(《古代基督教圣诗与歌曲》〔Altchristl. Hymnen und Lieder〕,奥格斯堡〔Augsb.〕,1855年);贝斯勒(1858年);J. Fr. H. 施洛瑟 (J. Fr. H. Schlosser)(《诗歌中的教会》〔Die Kirche in ihren Liedern〕,布赖斯高的弗赖堡,1863年,2卷);G. A. 柯尼希斯费尔德 (G. A. Königsfeld)(《拉丁圣诗与圣歌》〔Lat. Hymnen und Gesänge〕,波恩〔Bonn〕,1847年;新编,1865年,两编均附原文及注释)。
§ 96. 拉丁圣诗与圣诗作者
中世纪拉丁教会 (Latin church) 的诗歌远比希腊教会 (Greek church) 的诗歌广为人知,直到今日,在罗马教会 (Roman church) 中,以及凡珍视诗才与宗教热忱之处,仍是敬虔生活的丰富泉源。最优秀的拉丁圣诗已收入《日课经》(Breviary) 和《弥撒经书》(Missal)(有些所谓的改进反而使原作失色),并屡次译成现代语言。然而,真正出于对基督纯洁的爱、能使各宗派基督徒获益的经典圣诗,数量相对不多。拉丁教会的诗歌与希腊教会的诗歌一样,充满了对马利亚和圣徒的崇拜。中世纪人们向我们主那蒙福的母亲倾注了何等侠义而热烈的虔诚,实在令人惊讶。在莫内 (Mone) 的选集中,献给童贞女的圣诗占了整整一卷,共457页;献给圣徒的另占一卷,共579页;而只有461页的第一卷,却由献给上帝与天使的圣诗共同占有。诗人本想借着基督的母亲荣耀基督,然而母亲却遮蔽了孩子,正如圣母像 (Madonna) 中所见的情形。她被立为一切神恩的女中保,几乎取代了基督;人们认为,基督所居的威严宝座太高,罪人若没有他母亲的帮助及其温柔的人间同情,便无法企及。人们用一切赞美的称号称呼她,如 Mater Dei, Dei Genitrix, Mater summi Domini, Mater misericordiae, Mater bonitatis, Mater dolorosa, Mater jucundosa, Mater speciosa, Maris Stella, Mundi domina, Mundi spes, Porta paradisi, Regina coeli, Radix gratiae, Virgo virginum, Virgo regia Dei(上帝之母、诞育上帝者、至高主之母、怜悯之母、良善之母、忧苦之母、欢欣之母、美丽之母、海上之星、世界之主母、世界之希望、乐园之门、天后、恩典之根、童贞女中之童贞女、上帝的王家童贞女)。甚至著名的圣波拿文都拉 (St. Bonaventura) 也把《赞美颂》(Te Deum) 改编为献给她的颂歌,写道:“Te Matrem laudamus, Te Virginem confitemur”(我们赞美你这位母亲,我们承认你这位童贞女)。50
拉丁圣诗作者与希腊圣诗作者一样,几乎全是修士;但其中也有一位皇帝(查理曼〔Charlemagne〕?)和一位国王(法国的罗贝尔〔Robert of France〕),应当享有荣誉的地位。
拉丁教会的圣诗可分为三个时期:1. 教父时期,从希拉里 (Hilary,卒于368年) 和安布罗斯 (Ambrose,卒于397年),到维南提乌斯·福尔图纳图斯 (Venantius Fortunatus,约卒于609年) 和格列高利一世 (Gregory I.,卒于604年);2. 中世纪早期,直到彼得·达米安尼 (Peter Damiani,卒于1072年);3. 经典时期,直到十三世纪。第一时期我们已在前卷讨论过。它留给普世教会最宝贵的遗产,是《赞美颂》(Te Deum laudamus)。一般人把它归于米兰的安布罗斯 (Ambrose of Milan),或认为是安布罗斯与奥古斯丁共同所作;但它现今完整的形式,直到六世纪上半叶才出现,尽管其中一些部分可以追溯到更早的希腊来源。它与《使徒信经》和希腊文《至高荣耀颂》(Gloria in Excelsis) 一样,是教会逐渐孕育而成的成果,而非某一个人的作品。51第三时期包括最伟大的拉丁圣诗作者,如莫尔莱的伯尔纳 (Bernard of Morlaix,约1150年为克吕尼〔Cluny〕修士)、克莱尔沃的伯尔纳 (Bernard of Clairvaux,卒于1153年)、圣维克托的亚当 (Adam of St. Victor,卒于1192年)、波拿文都拉 (Bonaventura,卒于1274年)、托马斯·阿奎那 (Thomas Aquinas,卒于1274年)、切拉诺的托马斯 (Thomas a Celano,约1250年)、雅科波内 (Jacopone,卒于1306年),并产生了最后一批、也是最优秀而永不朽坏的天主教圣诗,如《末后的时辰》(Hora Novisasima)、《耶稣,甘甜的记念》(Jesu dulcis memoria)、《满被血伤的圣首》(Salve caput cruentatum)、《圣母伫立》(Stabat Mater) 和《震怒之日》(Dies Irae)。本卷所论的是第二时期。
普瓦捷 (Poitiers) 的维南提乌斯·福尔图纳图斯 (Venantius Fortunatus),以及与他同时代的教皇格列高利一世 (Gregory I.),构成了从塞杜利乌斯 (Sedulius) 和普鲁登提乌斯 (Prudentius) 的教父时期诗歌,到中世纪经典诗歌的过渡。
福图纳图斯 (Fortunatus,约600年)52是当时风靡一时的诗人。他原籍意大利,移居高卢 (Gaul),游历甚广,与图尔的圣格列高利 (St. Gregory of Tours),以及退隐修道的寡居王后拉德贡德 (Radegund) 交往甚密,去世时任普瓦捷主教。他是第一位精通扬抑格四音步诗体 (trochaic tetrameter) 的诗人,写有三百首诗,其中最重要的是两首著名的受难圣诗:
“Vexilla regis prodeunt”(君王旌旗向前行),
“君王旌旗向前行;”
以及
“Pange, lingua, gloriosi proelium certaminis”(我舌,当歌唱这场荣耀的争战),
“我舌,当歌唱这场荣耀的争战。”
两首都收入了《罗马日课经》(Roman Breviary)。53
格列高利一世 (Gregory I.,卒于604年) 虽然在诗才上远逊于福图纳图斯,却在教会诗歌和教会音乐中都占有显要的地位。他在格律形式、祈祷般的语调及教会精神上,都追随安布罗斯,并以实际使用为写作目的。他创作了约十二首圣诗,其中数首已收入《罗马日课经》。54最优秀的是他的主日圣诗:
“Primo dierum omnium”(在一切日子的第一日),
“在这第一日,天临大地之时,”
或者,按《日课经》中修改后的文字,
“Primo die quo Trinitas”(在三一上帝开始创造的第一日),
“今日,蒙福的三一上帝,
开始创造天地;
今日,得胜者圣子上帝,
从坟墓中复起;
我们也要醒来,尽管
有懒惰困倦,仍要同心合一,
遵诗人的吩咐,在幽暗长夜里,
举目切切等候。”55
尊者比德 (The Venerable Bede,卒于735年) 写过一首优美的升天圣诗:
“Hymnum canamus gloriae”(让我们唱一首荣耀的颂歌),
“让我们唱一首荣耀的颂歌;”
还有一首纪念无辜圣婴 (Holy innocents) 的圣诗:
“Hymnum canentes Martyrum”(唱起殉道者的颂歌),
“高唱得胜殉道者的颂歌。”56
拉巴努斯·毛鲁斯 (Rabanus Maurus) 原籍莱茵河 (Rhine) 畔的美因茨 (Mainz,又称Mayence),是阿尔昆 (Alcuin) 的学生,曾任富尔达 (Fulda) 修道院的修士和院长,847至856年任美因茨大主教。他是加洛林时代 (Carolingian age) 首屈一指的诗人,也是第一位用拉丁文写圣诗的德国人。他的一些圣诗已收入《日课经》。57
他很可能是五旬节圣诗《创造之灵,求你降临》(Veni, Creator Spiritus) 的作者。58这一首胜过他其余所有诗作。它是拉丁圣诗中的经典之作,天主教会至今仍在最庄严的场合使用,如会议开幕、教皇选立和国王加冕。人们还赋予它一种迷信的魔力。它是《日课经》圣诗中唯一进入圣公会礼仪 (Anglican liturgy) 的一首,成为按立祭司和祝圣主教礼仪的一部分。59有人把它归于查理曼,60有人归于大格列高利 (Gregory the Great),61也有人归于阿尔昆,甚至安布罗斯,却都没有充分的理由。它最早出现于898年,见于收有拉巴努斯·毛鲁斯诗作的手抄本,也见于所有古老的德文《日课经》;它很早便被译为德文,而且屡有新译,62其思想和措辞也与他论圣灵的著作十分吻合。63
我们将原文和两种译文列于下文。64
*Veni, Creator Spiritus,
Mentes tuorum visita.
Imple superna gratia
Quo tu creasti pectora.*
创造之灵,求你降临,
眷顾属你之人的心思。
求以天上的恩典,
充满你所创造的心灵。
创造之灵,恩典之主,
求以我们的心为居所,
用你属天的能力扶助
你所创造之人的灵魂。
*Qui Paracletus diceris,
Donum Dei altissimi,
Fons vivus, ignis, charitas,
Et spiritalis unctio.*
你被称为保惠师,
是至高上帝的恩赐,
是活泉、火焰、仁爱,
也是属灵的膏油。
求从天上上帝宝座降临,
保惠师啊,圣洁的鸽子,
求你降临,喜乐之油、洁净之火,
纯洁渴慕的生命泉源。
*Tu septiformis munere,
Dextrae Dei tu digitus,
Tu rite Promissum Patris,
Sermone ditans guttura.*
你赐下七重恩赐,
你是上帝右手的指头,
你正是父所应许的,
使人的口舌满有言语。
上帝圣手的指头啊,
七重恩典的赐予全属于你,
嘴唇蒙你触摸,就宣扬
对上帝至圣之名的一切赞美。
*Accende lumen sensibus,
Infunde amorem cordibus;
Infirma nostri corporis,
Virtute firmans perpetim.*65
求在我们的感官中燃起亮光,
将爱倾注在我们心中;
我们身体的软弱,
求以大能永远坚固。
求将你的光赐给我们的灵魂,
将你的爱赐给每一颗心,
使我们一切软弱化为能力,
你这生命与光明的泉源。
*Hostem repellas longius,
Pacemque dones protinus.
Ductore sic te praevio,
Vitemus omne noxium.*
求将仇敌远远驱逐,
立刻赐下平安。
有你在前引领,
愿我们避开一切灾害。
求保护我们,抵挡来袭的仇敌,
赐下平安,就是爱的果实;
你是我们的力量与向导,蒙你扶持,
我们脚步便不遭灾祸。
*Per te sciamus, da Patrem,
Noscamus atque Filium,
Te utriusque Spiritum,
Credamus omni tempore.*
求使我们借着你认识父,
也认识子,
并永远相信你,
就是父与子二者的灵。
信心之灵,求赐我们
认识圣父与圣子;
也认识你,父与子二者的灵;
永恒的一,永恒的三。
[*Sit laus Patri cum Filio,
Sancto simul Paracleto,
Nobisque mittat Filius
Charisma Sancti Spiritus*.]66
〔愿颂赞归于父与子,
同归于圣保惠师,
愿圣子向我们赐下
圣灵的恩赐。〕
让我们向圣父上帝歌唱,
也向圣子上帝、复活的君王歌唱;
并同样敬拜圣灵,
他是上帝,直到永远。
[*Praesta hoc Pater piissime,
Patrique compar unice,
Cum Spiritu Paracleto,
Regnans per omne saeculum*.] 见上注。
〔至慈的父,求你成全此事,
与父同等的独生子,
同保惠师圣灵,
掌权直到世世代代。〕
圣灵啊,创造者,求你降临!
充满你子民的心思;
求以你超自然的恩典,
充满你所创造的灵魂。
求将我们的感官点燃如火,
使我们的心充满爱,
纵然我们的身体软弱,
仍求你
从天上倾注勇力!
你被称为保惠师,
至高上帝的恩赐——
你是活泉、火焰与爱,
我们心灵纯洁的良伴;
求将我们的仇敌远远驱逐,
立刻赐给我们平安;
使我们有你亲自引导,
就能止息罪恶。
你是一切美善的七重赐予者,
是上帝右手的指头;
你是父所应许的,
满有万邦的言语;
愿我们借着你认识
圣父,
并如此承认圣子;
你是出于二者的圣灵,
我们要赞美你,
直到时光的尽头。
在此我们也提及《圣灵,求你降临》(Veni, Sancte Spiritus),这是中世纪另一首伟大的五旬节圣诗。一般认为它出自法国的罗贝尔国王 (King Robert of France,970—1031年),他是于格·卡佩 (Hugh Capet) 的儿子和继承人。67他以敬虔和仁爱著称,正如他那位更著名的继承者圣路易九世 (St. Louis IX.) 一样;比起王位,他更适合修道院的生活。他因与一位远房表亲结婚而受到教皇的惩戒(998年),便以离婚表示服从。他喜爱音乐与诗歌,创立修道院和教堂,并供养三百名穷人。他的这首圣诗以简洁而富于音乐性的语言,显明他对圣灵在人心中的恩赐与工作有亲身的认识。这首诗优于与之并称的《创造之灵,求你降临》(Veni, Creator Spiritus)。特伦奇 (Trench) 称它为一切拉丁圣诗中“最可爱的”,但我们宁愿将这赞誉给予圣伯尔纳 (St. Bernard) 的《耶稣,甘甜的记念》(Jesu dulcis memoria,“耶稣,每逢想到你”)。这首圣诗共有十个半节,每半节三行,均以 ium 为叠韵。每行七个音节,以双音节韵或三音节韵结尾;每半节的第三行与下一个半节的第三行押韵。尼尔 (Neale) 在译文中再现了每个第三行的双音节韵尾(如“brilliancy”〔灿烂〕与“radiancy”〔光辉〕)。
*Veni, Sancte Spiritus,
Et emittee coelitus
Lucis tuae radium.*
圣灵,求你降临,
从天上放射
你的光芒。
圣灵,光明的上帝!
求你降临,向我们的心眼
倾注你明亮属天的光辉!
*Veni, Pater pauperum,
Veni, dator munerum,
Veni, lumen cordium.*
穷人之父,求你降临,
恩赐的施予者,求你降临,
心灵之光,求你降临。
卑微者之父,求你降临;
伟大的施予者,求以此为家,
永作我们心中的阳光!
*Consolator optime,
Dulcis hospes animae,
Dulce refrigerium:*
至善的安慰者,
灵魂甘美的宾客,
甘甜的清凉:
至深至善的安慰者!
我们灵魂最亲爱的宾客,
求甘甜地止息灵魂一切干渴;
*In labore requies,
In aestu temperies,
In fletu solatium.*
劳苦中的安息,
炎热中的清凉,
哭泣中的慰藉。
求在劳苦中作我们的歇息处,
在炎热中作我们的荫庇,
降临,擦去我们的眼泪。
*O lux beatissima,
Reple cordis intima,
Tuorum fidelium.*
至福的光啊,
求充满你忠信之人
内心的深处。
你这全然纯洁蒙福的光!
求以喜乐充满这疲惫的胸怀,
使黑暗变为白昼。
*Sine tuo numine
Nihil est in homine
Nihil est innoxium,*
若无你的神圣能力,
人里面就一无所有,
没有一样不受玷污,
因为离了你,我们在人间
找不到纯洁或刚强,
没有一样未曾偏离正路。
*Lava quod est sordidum,
Riga quod est aridum,
Sana quod est saucium.*
求洗净污秽的,
滋润干涸的,
医治受伤的。
求洗去我们罪恶的污痕,
温柔地软化我们整个内心,
医治、扶持受伤的灵魂。
*Flecte quod est rigidum,
Fove quod est languidum,
Rege quod est devium.*
求使刚硬的屈服,
扶养衰弱的,
引导迷途的。
求使刚硬顽梗的屈服,
安慰照料软弱的,
温柔地引领偏离正路的。
*Da tuis fidelibus,
In te confitentibus,
Sacrum septenarium;*
求赐给你忠信的人,
就是承认信靠你的人,
神圣的七重恩赐;
求赐给你忠信的仆人,
就是蒙你教导、信靠而活的人,
从今日起享有七重福分;
*Da virtutis meritum,
Da salutis exitum,
Da perenne gaudium*.68
求赐美德的奖赏,
求赐得救的终局,
求赐永恒的喜乐。
我们祈求,在脱去这必朽尘躯之时,
求使我们的凭据确实无疑;
那时,求赐我们永远的喜乐。489
以下是一位美国神学家的精妙译文。69
圣灵啊,恩典之泉,求你降临!
从你天上的居所,
赐下一线明亮的晨光:
求你降临,贫穷人的父!
求你降临,丰盛恩赐的泉源!
求你降临,照亮心灵的阳光!
啊,三重蒙福的神圣之光!
求你降临,以你圣洁的临在,
充满心灵最深处的圣所;
若失去你覆庇的慈爱,
绝望的人便一无所有;
除了罪恶,再无别物。
人类最美善的保惠师!
你接纳忧伤的灵魂为宾客;
在我们恐惧中赐下甘甜的苏息,
在劳苦中作我们的安歇之所,
在炎热中作清凉的荫蔽,
在我们落泪时赐下安慰。
求你洗净一切属世的污点,
再次流过这干渴的荒原,
医治良心痛楚的创伤,
约束内心顽梗的意志,
融化罪恶冰冷的锁链,
引导我们,使我们不再迷失。
求你赐给信你的人,
就是在你的圣洁盼望中生活的人,
赐下你七重慈爱的全部恩惠;
赐下信心确实的奖赏,
赐下胜过死亡的爱,
赐下天上永不止息的喜乐。
诺特克 (Notker),别称年长者 (Older),或巴尔布卢斯 (Balbulus,意为“小口吃者”,因他说话略有口齿不清),约于850年生于瑞士 (Switzerland) 的一个贵族家庭,在爱尔兰传教士所建的圣加仑修道院 (St. Gall) 受教育,并在那里终身作一名谦卑的修士。他约于912年去世,1512年被封为圣徒。70
他以被认为是继抒咏 (Sequences, Sequentiae) 的作者而闻名。这是一类有节奏的散文赞美诗,因此也称为散文咏 (Proses, Prosae)。它们源于一种习俗:在书信与福音的宣读之间,唱升阶咏 (Gradual) 的 Allelu-ia 时,将最后一个音节延长;这时执事正从祭坛登上十字架楼廊(管风琴楼廊),以便在那里吟唱福音。这种拖长的唱法,因其欢欣的声调而称为 jubilatio、jubilus 或 laudes(欢呼、赞美),有时也称为 sequentia(希腊文 ἀκολουθία*),因为它接在书信宣读或哈利路亚之后。神秘主义的解释者把这种单纯声音的无意义延长,说成是天上欢欣音乐的回声。进一步的发展,是给这些音符配上有节奏的散文,供人吟唱。于是,继抒咏这一名称便用于歌词,在更广的意义上,也用于格律整齐、押韵的赞美诗。汇集继抒咏的书称为《继抒咏集》(Sequentiale)。71
诺特克标志着继抒咏从无意义的音乐形式向文学或诗歌形式的过渡。有三十余首诗署他的名字。他最初的尝试以下面这一行开始:
“Laudes Deo concinat orbis ubique totus. ”
“愿普天下各处齐向上帝歌颂。”
流传更广的是他的圣灵继抒咏:
“Sancti Spiritus adsit nobis gratia. ”
“愿圣灵的恩典与我们同在。”
“愿圣灵的恩典与我们同在。”72
他全部作品中最出色的是《论死亡的对经》(Antiphona de morte),一篇关于死亡的默想;据说,其灵感来自他看见工匠在马丁斯托贝 (Martinstobe) 的深渊上架桥的情景:
“Media vita in morte sumus:
我们虽在生命之中,却已身处死亡;
Quem quaerimus adiutorem nisi te, Domine,
主啊,除你以外,我们还能求谁帮助?
Qui pro peccatis nostris juste irasceris?
你因我们的罪,公义地向我们发怒。
Sancte Deus, sancte fortis,
圣洁的上帝,圣洁的大能者,
Sancte et misericors Salvator:
圣洁而慈悲的救主,
Amarae morti ne tradas nos. ”73
求你不要将我们交付苦痛的死亡。
这篇庄严的祷文被收入许多安葬礼仪。《公祷书》(Book of Common Prayer) 将它扩充如下:
“我们虽在生命之中,却已身处死亡:
除你以外,我们还能求谁救助,
主啊,你因我们的罪,公义地发怒?
然而,至圣的主上帝啊,至能的主啊,
圣洁而至慈悲的救主啊,
求你不要将我们交付永死的苦痛。
主啊,你知道我们心中的隐秘。
求你不要向我们的祷告闭起慈悲的眼目:
至圣的主啊,求你怜恤我们,
至能的上帝啊,
圣洁而慈悲的救主啊,
你这至配得尊崇的永恒审判者,
求你不要容我们在临终之时,
因任何死亡的痛苦,
而离弃你。”74
彼得·达米安尼 (Peter Damiani,卒于1072年) 是希尔德布兰德 (Hildebrand) 的朋友,也是其教阶制度改革的推动者;他写过一首论死亡之日的庄严赞美诗:
“Gravi me terrore pulsas vitae dies ultima, ”75
“你以何等沉重的恐惧击打我!”
那首较为著名、描写乐园荣耀与欢愉的诗,通常归于圣奥古斯丁 (St. Augustin),或许也是他所作:
“Ad perennis vitae fontem mens sitivit arida,
干渴的心灵渴慕永生的泉源,
Claustra carnis praesto frangi clausa quaerit anima:
被囚的灵魂求肉身的牢笼速速破裂:
Gliscit, ambit, eluctatur exsul frui patria. ”76
流亡者热望、追求、奋力挣脱,要享受故乡的福乐。
本时期次要的赞美诗作者如下:77
塞维利亚的伊西多尔 (Isidor of Seville,Isidoris Hispalensis,560—636年)。有一首咏圣阿加莎 (St. Agatha) 的赞美诗:“Festum insigne prodiit”(“盛大的节期已经来临”)。
西班牙的西克西拉 (Cyxilla of Spain)。《咏圣图尔苏斯及其同伴的赞美诗》(Hymnus de S. Thurso et sociis):“Exulta nimium turba fidelium”(“众信徒啊,尽情欢欣”)。
托莱多的欧根尼乌斯 (Eugenius of Toledo)。《托莱多主教圣欧根尼乌斯的祷文》(Oratio S. Eugenii Toletani Episcopi):“Rex Deus”(“君王上帝”)。
蒙特卡西诺 (Monte Casino) 的执事保罗 (Paulus Diaconus,720—800年),查理曼 (Charlemagne) 的随侍司铎、伦巴第人 (Lombards) 的历史家,也是一部著名讲道集的作者。他写过咏施洗约翰的诗(“Ut queant laxis”,意为“使他们能舒声歌唱”),78以及咏圣本笃 (St. Benedict) 神迹的诗(Fratres alacri pectore,意为“弟兄们,怀着欢欣的心”)。
克吕尼的奥多 (Odo of Cluny,卒于941年)。有一首为圣抹大拉的马利亚节所作的赞美诗:“Lauda, Mater Ecclesiae”(“教会之母啊,赞美吧”),尼尔 (Neale) 将其译为:“教会之母啊,今日当颂扬,你的主基督的慈悲。”这首诗被收入《约克日课经》(York Breviary)。
戈德斯卡尔库斯 (Godescalcus,又名戈特沙尔克 Gottschalk,约卒于950年,不可与九世纪那位同名的预定论者混淆),是仅次于诺特克 (Notker) 的继抒咏或散文咏作者,作品如《基督啊,赞美归于你》(Laus Tibi, Christe) 及《诸天述说荣耀》(Coeli enarrant),两首均由尼尔 (Neale) 译出。
沙特尔的富尔贝尔 (Fulbert Of Chartres,约卒于1029年) 写过一首被数种日课经采用的复活节赞美诗:“Chorus novae Jerusalem”(“新耶路撒冷的众诗班啊”),由尼尔译出。
本时期从六世纪到十二世纪的若干最优秀的赞美诗,作者姓名不详。79其中包括:
“Hymnum dicat turba fratrum”(“愿众弟兄同唱赞美诗”)。这是一首晨祷诗,比德 (Bede) 曾提及它,视之为扬抑格四音步诗体的佳作。
“Sancti venite”(“圣徒们,来吧”)。这是一首圣餐赞美诗。
“Urbs beata Jerusalem”(“蒙福的耶路撒冷城”)。80这首诗出自八世纪,属于那些感人至深的新耶路撒冷赞美诗;它们从圣约翰《启示录》的末章汲取灵感,表达基督徒对天家思乡般的眷恋。以下是第一节(附尼尔译文):
“Urbs beata Jerusalem,
Dicta pacis visio,
蒙福的耶路撒冷城,
被称为和平的异象,
Quae construitur in coelo
Vivis ex lapidibus,
你在天上建造,
以活石砌成,
Et angelis coronata
Ut sponsata comite.”
众天使环绕,
如新妇有随从相伴。”
蒙福之城,天上的撒冷,
和平与慈爱的可亲异象,
你以活石建成,
是天上的喜乐,
天使的众军环绕着你,
你如新妇降临人间!”
“Apparebit repentina”(“必忽然显现”)。这是一首论审判之日、依字母次序排列的离合诗,以《马太福音》25:31—36为依据,出自七世纪;最早由比德提及,此后长期湮没。它是《震怒之日》(Dies Irae) 的先驱,叙事多于抒情,崇高与震慑之力稍逊,却同样庄严。以下是尼尔精彩译文的开头数行:81
“那震怒而可畏的大日,
那灾祸与审判的末日,
必如半夜到来的贼,
临到世人的身上;
那时历代的骄傲与荣华,
都已消逝净尽,
他们站在痛苦之中,承认
末日终于已经来临;
号角响亮的轰鸣,
传遍大地四方,
声音越来越响,
要召集活人与死人:
天上荣耀的君王,
要登上高处的宝座,
他天使的众军,
要在天空侍立身旁:
日头要变为麻布般的黑色,
月亮要红如鲜血,
众星要从天上坠落,
淹没在毁灭的洪流之中。
烈焰、大火与荒凉,
要行在审判者的脚前:
大地、海洋及一切深渊,
都要晓得他大能的判决。”
“Ave, Maris Stella”(“万福,海洋之星”)。这是中世纪最受喜爱的马利亚赞美诗,在大量敬拜“天后”的诗歌中,或许也是最好的一首;这种敬拜深深融入了东西方大公教会的虔敬与礼拜生活。因此,这里将全诗连同爱德华·卡斯沃尔 (Edward Caswall) 的译文一并列出。82
"Ave, Maris Stella,83
*Dei Mater alma
Atque semper Virgo,
Felix coeli porta*.
*“万福,海洋之星,
慈爱的上帝之母,
永远的童贞女,
蒙福的天国之门*。
万福,你这海洋之星,
天庭的门户,
至高主的母亲,
永远的童贞女!
*Sumens illud Ave
Gabrielis ore,
Funda nos in pace,
Mutans nomen Evae*.84
你领受了那声万福,
从加百列口中发出;
求使我们稳居平安,
将夏娃之名倒转。
啊,藉加百列久远以前
所说的万福(Ave),
将夏娃(Eva)之名倒转,
在世间建立平安!
*Solve vincla reis
Profer lumen coecis,
Mala nostra pelle,
Bona cuncta posce*.
解开罪人的锁链,
将光明带给瞎眼的人,
驱除我们的灾患,
为我们祈求一切美善。
打断被掳者的锁链,
将光明倾注给瞎眼的人,
驱尽我们一切灾患,
为我们求得种种福乐。
Monstra te esse matrem,85
*Sumat per te precem,
Qui pro nobis natus
Tulit esse tuus.*
显明你是母亲,
愿他藉你垂听祈祷,
他为我们降生,
甘愿作你的儿子。
显明你的母亲之情,
将我们的叹息呈献给他;
他为我们道成肉身,
并不曾轻看你。
*Virgo singularis,
Inter omnes mitis,
Nos culpis solutos
Mites facet castos.*
无比的童贞女,
万人中最温柔者,
求使我们脱离罪愆,
成为温柔贞洁的人。
众童贞女之上的童贞女!
求你收容我们,赐下庇护——
温柔者中最温柔的!
求使我们贞洁而温柔。
*Vitam praesta puram
Iter para tutum,
Ut videntes Iesum
Semper collaetemur.*
求赐纯洁的生命,
预备平安的道路,
使我们得见耶稣,
永远一同欢欣。
在我们前行的路上,
求不断扶助我们软弱的努力,
直到我们与你和耶稣,
永远一同欢喜。
*Sit laus Deo Patri,
Summo Christo decus,
Spiritui Sancto
Honor trinus et unus.*
愿赞美归于父上帝,
尊荣归于至高的基督,
荣耀归于圣灵,
三位一体,同受尊崇。
愿至高诸天,
将同一的荣耀,
归于全能的三位,
就是父、子、圣灵。
拉丁赞美诗只供司铎、修士以及少数懂得拉丁文的人使用。民众像听弥撒一样聆听,以 Kyrie eleison, Christe eleison(主啊,怜悯;基督啊,怜悯)回应;这句祷词从希腊教会传入西方教会的连祷文。随着欧洲 (Europe) 的现代语言从拉丁语及条顿语中发展出来,十三、十四世纪兴起了通俗诗歌,后来又从宗教改革获得强大的推动力。自那时起,新教各教会,尤其德国 (Germany) 和英格兰的教会,创作了最丰富的赞美诗,以民众熟悉的本国语言向他们的心灵说话;这些诗歌仅次于《诗篇》,成为滋养公共与个人敬虔生活的主要源泉。在这批福音派赞美诗中,最优秀的希腊和拉丁赞美诗以各种译作、再创作和改作的形式,占据着受尊崇的地位,并在敬拜同一位上帝和救主的事上,成为联结古今的纽带。
§ 97. 七项圣礼
中世纪基督教具有极其浓厚的圣礼、祭司及教阶制度色彩。祭司、祭物与祭坛的观念紧密相连。圣礼被视为一切恩典的渠道和灵魂的主要食粮。它们伴随人的一生,从摇篮直到坟墓。婴孩以洗礼受迎接进入这个世界;老人则领受临终圣餐 (viaticum),踏上前往另一个世界的旅程。
主要的圣礼是洗礼与圣餐。洗礼被视为重生的圣礼,开启天国之门;圣餐则被视为成圣的圣礼,维持并滋养新的生命。
除这两项圣礼外,其他几种仪式也获尊称为圣礼,但在经院哲学时期以前,其数目尚无定论。拉丁文 sacramentum 与希腊文的 mystery 一样(《武加大译本》以它翻译后者),长期以来都以宽泛而不确定的意义,用来指神圣奥秘的教义和仪式。拉巴努斯·毛鲁斯 (Rabanus Maurus) 与帕斯卡修斯·拉德贝尔图斯 (Paschasius Radbertus) 列出四项圣礼,亚略巴古的狄奥尼修斯 (Dionysius Areopagita) 列出六项,达米安尼则列出多达十二项。主要凭借伦巴德的彼得 (Peter the Lombard) 和托马斯·阿奎那 (Thomas Aquinas) 的权威,最后才确定为七这一神圣数目,并以德行的数目、罪的数目及人生需要等种种类比来论证其合理性。86
然而,远在教会对数目达成共识以前,七项圣礼就已作为神圣仪式而存在。我们发现,它们不仅存在于拉丁人中间,也独立存在于希腊人中间,称为“奥秘”,彼此只有细微差别。除洗礼与圣餐(既是圣礼,也是献祭)之外,其余各项是:坚振礼、补赎礼(告解与赦罪)、婚礼、按立礼和临终傅油礼。
坚振礼与洗礼密切相连,仿佛是洗礼的一种补充。对于已受洗的婴孩,坚振礼便具有较为独立的性质,在日后施行。在希腊教会,任何祭司都可以施行此礼;在拉丁教会,则唯有主教才能施行。87
补赎礼被认为是为洗礼以后所犯的罪而必需的。88
按立礼是教阶制度的圣礼,为教会的治理所不可或缺。
婚姻是教会与国家中家庭及社会的基础;教会对它施以最严密、最警觉的维护,反对轻易离婚、异教通婚以及近亲结婚。
伴随祈祷的临终傅油礼(850年的帕维亚会议及达米安尼首次将它列入圣礼)是人离世前往另一个世界的临终圣餐 (viaticum),依据的是《雅各书》5:14、15的指示(参《马可福音》6:13;16:18)。起初,它用于各种疾病,平信徒和祭司都可施行,既作为医治的方法,也用来取代护身符和各种咒语;但拉丁教会后来将其限定于病情极其危急之时。
圣礼的功效以经院术语“事效性” (ex opere operato) 来界定,意即圣礼凭其设立及内在能力,产生其预定的果效,不取决于祭司及领受者的道德品格,只须按规定的方式、怀着适当的意向施行,且领受者不从中设置障碍。89
其中三项圣礼,即洗礼、坚振礼和按立礼,还具有赋予不可磨灭之印记的功效。90一经受洗,就永远是受过洗的人,尽管可能永远丧失其益处;一经按立,就永远是受过按立的人,尽管祭司可能被革职并逐出教会。
§ 98. 管风琴与钟
管风琴与钟也加入了礼拜的外在辅助设施之列。
管风琴91作为一种特定乐器的名称(此用法始于圣奥古斯丁时代),是由绪任克斯笛 (Syrinx),即潘神排箫 (Pandean pipe) 发展而来的。其最早的形制是一个小箱子,顶部排列着一列管子,演奏者从一端的吹管用口向内吹气。随着时间推移,它经历了相当大的改进。在教堂中使用管风琴,据说始于教皇维塔利安 (Vitalian,657–672年)。767年,君士坦丁·科普罗尼穆斯 (Constantine Copronymos) 将一架管风琴连同其他礼物赠给法国国王丕平 (Pepin)。查理曼也收到哈里发哈伦·拉希德 (Haroun al Rashid) 赠送的一架管风琴,并将它安置在亚琛 (Aix-la-Chapelle) 的主教座堂。管风琴制造技艺主要在德国得到发展。教皇约翰八世 (John VIII.,872–882年) 曾请求弗赖辛 (Freising) 的主教安诺 (Anno) 为他送来一架管风琴和一位管风琴师。
各教会对管风琴的态度不一。它在某种程度上与圣像有着相同的命运,只是它从未成为崇拜的对象。一个富有诗意的传说,将它的发明归于圣乐的主保圣徒圣塞西莉亚 (St. Cecilia);拉斐尔 (Raphael) 的一幅杰作使这个传说流传不朽。希腊教会不赞成使用管风琴。拉丁教会相当普遍地采用了它,却也不乏杰出人物的抗议,以致甚至在特伦托大公会议上,也有人提出至少在弥撒中禁用管风琴的动议,尽管未获通过。路德宗教会保留了管风琴,加尔文宗各教会则拒绝使用,尤其在瑞士和苏格兰 (Scotland);但近来这种反对已大体消退。92
据说,钟是诺拉的保利努斯 (Paulinus of Nola,卒于431年) 在坎帕尼亚 (Campania) 发明的;93但他在描述教堂时从未提及此物。自君士坦丁大帝 (Constantine the Great) 时代起,人们便使用各种能发声的器具,宣告公共礼拜开始。图尔的格列高利提到一种召集修士祈祷的“信号器” (signum)。爱尔兰人自圣帕特里克时代起,主要使用手铃;他本人也曾大量分发手铃。据传,圣科伦巴在午夜钟响时(pulsante campana)前往教堂。比德提到葬礼上召集祈祷的钟。富尔达的圣施图尔姆 (St. Sturm) 在临终时命人敲响修道院所有的钟(779年)。查理曼在位时,钟在帝国境内已普遍使用。他鼓励铸钟技艺,并在宫廷款待铸钟匠。圣加仑修道院的一位修士坦科 (Tancho),为亚琛主教座堂铸了一口精美的钟,重四百至五百磅。在东方,直到九世纪末才有教堂用钟的记载。
钟与其他教会器物一样,藉礼仪性的祝福仪式祝圣,供神圣用途。有时甚至给钟施洗;但查理曼在789年的一道敕令中禁止了这种滥用。94当时,司钟人的职分95备受尊崇,甚至修道院院长和主教都渴望担任。民间迷信认为,钟具有平息风暴和驱除瘟疫的神奇效力。人们还为钟专建高塔。96许多钟上镌刻着下列古老诗句,表达教堂之钟的用途:
“Lauda Deum verum, plebem voco, congrego clerum, 赞美真神,我召唤百姓,聚集教士;
Defunctos ploro, pestem fugo, festaque honoro. 我哀悼亡者,驱逐瘟疫,尊荣节期。”97
§ 99. 圣徒崇拜
参第III卷,§§ 81–87(第409–460页)。
从尼西亚时代 (Nicene age) 流传下来的圣徒崇拜,是基督教用以取代异教偶像崇拜和英雄崇拜的事物,很适合蛮族各民族的趣味及其既有习俗,但在有教养的希腊人中间也同样流行。经院学者将崇拜分为三个等级:1)敬拜(λατρεία*),唯独归于上帝;2)尊崇(δουλεία*),当归于圣徒,因为他们是上帝亲自尊荣、并在天上与他一同作王的人;3)特殊尊崇(ὑπερδουλεία*),当归于童贞女马利亚,因为她是救主之母,也是众圣徒的女王。但百姓并不总是留意这种区别,而祭司反倒助长圣徒崇拜的过度行为。人们毫无拘束地向圣徒祈祷,虽然并非视他们为所求福分的赐予者,而是视他们为代求者和辩护者。因此有了“为我们祈祷”(Ora pro nobis)这一形式。
圣徒及其节日的数目增长极快。每个民族、国家、行省或城市都选择自己的主保圣徒,例如罗马的彼得与保罗,米兰的圣安布罗斯,法国的圣马丁、圣德尼 (St. Denys,即狄奥尼修斯 Dionysius) 与圣日耳曼 (St. Germain),英格兰的圣乔治 (St. George),爱尔兰 (Ireland) 的圣帕特里克,德国的圣卜尼法斯 (St. Boniface),尤其是童贞女马利亚 (Virgin Mary),无数地方和教堂都在她的照料与保护之下。起初,一人是否为圣徒,由民众的呼声决定,这呼声被当作上帝的声音而服从。那些生活散发圣洁馨香,并以传教士、殉道者、主教、修士或修女的身份,为宗教事业作出卓越贡献的伟大而良善的男女,死后受到人们感恩的追念;他们成了自己劳苦受难之国家或行省的主保圣徒,对他们的崇拜逐渐传遍全教会。他们的遗物被视为圣物;朝圣者前往瞻仰他们的坟墓。直到公元1153年,各教省内有关圣徒资格的主张,通常由都主教裁定。98但为遏制其数目的增长并防止错误,自公元1170年亚历山大三世 (Alexander III.) 起,教皇便宣称独享判定圣徒身份、并规定整个(拉丁)大公教会崇拜该圣徒的权利。99这由一种称为封圣 (canonization) 的庄严行动来完成。后来又将宣福 (beatification) 与此区分开来:宣福仅宣布某位已故的天主教基督徒在天上是有福者,即贝阿图斯 (beatus),并在一定范围内准许(却不规定)对他的尊崇。100
已知最早由教皇封圣的事例,是约翰十五世 (John XV.) 为奥格斯堡 (Augsburg) 主教乌尔里希 (Ulrich,卒于973年) 封圣。993年,在一次由十九位显要组成的拉特兰会议 (Lateran synod) 上,约翰应乌尔里希在奥格斯堡主教座上的继任者吕托尔夫 (Luitolph,又作Leuthold) 的请求,亲自听取他关于乌尔里希生平及神迹的报告之后,宣布乌尔里希为圣徒。他的主要功绩,是解救德国南部,使之免受野蛮的马扎尔人 (Magyars) 侵袭,以及对其广大教区事务的尽心。他惯常乘牛车巡访,四周簇拥着一群乞丐和残疾人。他两次前往罗马朝圣,第二次是在八十一岁时;临终时,他如一个谦卑的悔罪者,躺在光秃的地板上。该诏书以圣徒崇拜能增进基督的荣耀为其根据,因为基督将自己与他的圣徒视为一体;但它并未明确区分崇拜的不同等级。它威胁说,凡不遵守此项法令的人,都将受到使徒教座的咒诅。101
对教皇封圣特权的一种温和解释,将其仅仅视为宣布一项事实,而事先须在礼仪部 (Congregation of Rites) 对该案的功德作仔细审查。然而,若非藉着神圣启示,必死的人绝无从得知这样的事实。审查按照正规的法律程序进行,其中一人担任魔鬼的辩护人 (Advocatus Diaboli),即封圣候选人的控告者,另一人则担任上帝的辩护人 (Advocatus Dei)。能否成功,取决于是否证明候选人必曾具有最高的圣洁,以及行神迹的能力——无论是在生前,或藉其死后的骸骨,或藉人求告他的援助而施行神迹。有句谚语说,要证明一个神迹,也需要一个神迹。然而,教皇仍凭罗马天主教信徒所满意的证据,以法令完成此事。102
圣徒和童贞女马利亚,若未被赋予无所不知、无所不在的神性属性,怎能听见那么多不同地方同时向他们发出的成千上万的祈祷?这个问题并未动摇百姓的信仰。经院神学家通常试图以如下假定来解决:圣徒在上帝无所不知的心智中读到这些祈祷。那么,何不直接向上帝祈祷呢?
除了个别圣徒的纪念日之外,又设立了两个节日,以纪念所有已故之人。
诸圣节 (Festival of All Saints)103由教皇卜尼法斯四世 (Boniface IV.) 在为罗马万神殿 (Pantheon) 举行奉献礼时引入西方。万神殿原由阿格里帕 (Agrippa) 为纪念奥古斯都 (Augustus) 在亚克兴 (Actium) 的胜利而建,奉献给复仇者朱庇特 (Jupiter Vindex);它在古代异教庙宇消亡之后仍保存下来,并于公元607年由皇帝福卡斯 (Phocas) 赠给教皇;于是它被洁净、修复,并以永贞女马利亚和所有殉道者之名奉献,供敬奉上帝之用。巴罗尼乌斯 (Baronius) 告诉我们,5月13日举行奉献礼时,人们以庄严的行列,用二十八辆车,将各墓地的殉道者遗骨运至这座教堂。104九世纪期间,这个节日从罗马传遍西方;835年,格列高利四世 (Gregory IV.) 促使虔诚者路易 (Lewis the Pious) 将它推广至全帝国。庆祝的日期定在11月1日,为的是便利百姓,因为收获之后,他们有了闲暇,也乐于为上帝的一切恩惠献上感谢。
万灵节 (Festival of All Souls)105可说是诸圣节的一种补充,在翌日(11月2日)庆祝。其创立可追溯至十世纪克吕尼修道院院长奥迪洛 (Odilo)。它无需特别命令便很快传播开来,契合了那个时代的人对炼狱中灵魂所受痛苦的同情。礼拜者身着丧服;亡者弥撒中唱诵“震怒之日,那一日”(Dies irae, Dies illa),并反复唱诵“主啊,求你赐他们永远的安息”(Requiem aeternam dona eis, Domine)。有些地方(例如慕尼黑 (Munich))盛行在这一天用当季最后的鲜花覆盖坟墓的习俗。
天使长米迦勒 (Michael the Archangel)106是天军的统帅,他的节日定于9月29日107,专为敬拜天使而设。108这个节日既无教义依据,也无事实根据,只建立在神迹传说的沙土根基上。109我们最先在东方见到它。君士坦丁堡 (Constantinople) 城内及附近有几座教堂奉献给圣米迦勒,查士丁尼 (Justinian) 重建了其中两座已经破败的教堂。在西方,813年的美因茨会议 (Council of Mentz) 首次提到这个节日,将“圣米迦勒奉献节”(dedicatio S. Michaelis)列为应当遵守的节日之一;此后,尽管使徒曾警告人不可崇拜天使(《歌罗西书》2:18;《启示录》19:10;22:8、9),这个节日仍传遍了全教会。110
§ 100. 圣像崇拜:文献与不同理论
参较第II卷,第vi章(第266页及后)和第vii章(第285页);第III卷,§§109–111(第560页及后)。
(I.)大马士革的约翰 (John of Damascus,约750年,圣像崇拜的主要辩护者):《为圣像辩护》〔Λόγοι ἀπολογητικοὶ πρὸς τοὺς διαβάλλοντας τὰς ἁγίας εἰκόνας*,勒基安 (Le Quien) 编,第I卷,第305页〕。尼基弗鲁斯 (Nicephorus,君士坦丁堡牧首,卒于828年):《历史简编》 (Breviarium Hist.,记事至公元769年),佩塔维乌斯 (Petavius) 编,巴黎 (Paris),1616年。狄奥法尼斯 (Theophanes,圣像崇拜的宣信者,几乎为此殉道,约卒于820年):《编年史,附戈阿尔与孔贝菲斯注》 (Chronographia, cum notis Goari et Combefisii),巴黎 (Par.),1655年;威尼斯 (Ven.),1729年;又收入1839年波恩 (Bonn) 版《拜占庭史家集》第I卷(重印于米涅 (Migne)《希腊教父集》“Patrol. Graeca”,第108卷)。后来的拜占庭史家凡论及这场争论,主要都取材于狄奥法尼斯;阿纳斯塔修斯 (Anastasius) 的《教会史》 (Historia Eccles.) 和执事保罗 (Paulus Diaconus) 的《杂史》与《伦巴第人史》 (Historia miscella and Hist. Longobardorum) 也是如此。
教皇书信及各次会议的议事录,尤其是第二次《尼西亚会议议事录》 (Acta Concilii Nicaeni II,公元787年),见曼西 (Mansi),第XIII卷;阿尔杜安 (Harduin),第IV卷。
M. H. 戈尔达斯特 (M. H. Goldast):《两帝国颁布的有关圣像崇拜的帝国敕令》 (Imperialia Decreta de Cultu Imaginum in utroque imperio promulgata)。法兰克福 (Frankf.),1608年。
史料几乎全都出自正统一方。第七次大公会议(787年)在第五次会议上命令销毁一切反对圣像的书籍。
(II.)J. 达勒乌斯 (J. Dalleus,加尔文派):《论圣像》 (De Imaginibus)。莱顿 (Lugd. Bat.),1642年。
L. 曼堡 (L. Maimbourg,耶稣会士):《破坏圣像派异端史》 (Histoire de l’hérésie des iconoclastes)。巴黎,1679年及1683年,2卷。(赫费勒 (Hefele),第III卷,第371页,称此书“nicht ganz zuverlässig”,即不甚可靠。)
Fr. 施潘海姆 (Fr. Spanheim,加尔文派):《重建的圣像史》 (Historia Imaginum restituta)。莱顿 (Lugd. Bat.),1686年(收入《著作集》 Opera,第II卷,第707页)。
Chr. W. Fr. 瓦尔希 (Chr. W. Fr. Walch,路德宗):《异端史》 (Ketzerhistorie)。莱比锡 (Leipz.),1762年起陆续出版,第X卷(1782年),第65–828页,以及第XI卷全卷(施皮特勒 (Spittler) 编,1785年)。极为详尽、公允,却也冗长乏味。
F. Ch. 施洛瑟 (F. Ch. Schlosser):《东罗马帝国破坏圣像诸帝史》 (Geschichte der bilderstürmenden Kaiser des oströmischen Reichs)。美因河畔法兰克福 (Frankf. a. M.),1812年。
J. 马克斯 (J. Marx,罗马天主教徒):《拜占庭皇帝的圣像争论》 (Der Bilderstreit der Byzant. Kaiser)。特里尔 (Trier),1839年。
赫费勒主教:《教会会议史》 (Conciliengesch.),第III卷,第366–490、694–716页(修订版,布赖斯高的弗赖堡 (Freib. i. B.),1877年)。
R. 申克 (R. Schenk):《皇帝利奥三世:圣像争论史论稿》 (Kaiser Leo III. Ein Beitrag zur Geschichte des Bilderstreites)。哈勒 (Halle),1880年。
教会通史:1)罗马天主教方面:巴罗尼乌斯 (Baronius)、帕吉 (Pagi)、纳塔利斯·亚历山大 (Natalis Alexander)、阿尔措格 (Alzog)、赫尔根勒特 (Hergenröther,第I卷,第121–143、152–168页)。2)新教方面:巴斯纳日 (Basnage)、吉本 (Gibbon,第49章)、施勒克 (Schröckh,第XX卷)、尼安德 (Neander,第III卷,第197–243、532–553页,波士顿版;详尽而公允);吉泽勒 (Gieseler,第II卷,第13–19页,过于简略)。
关于圣像争论的文献,深受作者教义立场的影响。吉本以冷漠的哲学态度来处理这场争论,主要着眼于它对拜占庭帝国政治命运的影响。
与圣徒崇拜密切相连的,是一种从属的崇拜,即对圣徒像和遗物的崇拜。后者是前者顺理成章的应用。然而,中世纪东西方教会除了少数反对的声音之外,虽都赞同圣徒崇拜,却在圣像问题上发生了激烈的争论,使东方教会动荡了一个多世纪(公元724–842年),并加速了拜占庭帝国的衰落。
使用圣像这一抽象问题,与艺术和敬拜之关系这一总的课题相连。基督教自称是完美而普世的宗教;它以面酵般的力量,渗透人的一切官能和生活的一切领域。凡上帝所造的,没有一样与它无关。它与一切真、美、善相和谐。它善待哲学、科学和艺术,并使之为己所用。诗歌、音乐和建筑作为宗教的婢女,实现了各自最高的使命,并从圣经汲取灵感,创作出最崇高的作品。那么,绘画、雕刻或其他任何出于上帝的艺术,为何应被排斥,不供教会使用呢?圣经历史为何不能像其他一切历史那样,以绘画和雕刻来表现,使爱好美的儿童和成人从中得到教益与享受呢?凡出于上帝的,都必须归于上帝,并彰显他的荣耀。
然而,从使用图像作装饰、教导和欣赏,到崇拜图像,其间有极大的距离;经验也证明,前者可以存在,而不带有丝毫后者的痕迹。但在中世纪,由于圣徒崇拜盛行,二者却不可分割。图画被引入教堂,并非作为艺术品,而是作为虔敬的辅助和对象。因此,圣像争论纯粹是一个实际的敬拜问题,而非哲学或艺术问题。对于粗陋的想象力来说,一幅丑恶可憎的图画,甚至比一幅优美雅致的图画更能达到虔敬的目的。直到中世纪末期,基督教绘画艺术才开始产生卓越的作品。此外,圣像争论还牵涉十诫的第二诫;这一诫命即便未禁止一切以形象表现神的做法,也至少明确而明智地禁止了对图像的一切偶像崇拜式和迷信式使用。这场争论还面临一个难题:我们并没有基督、圣母像 (Madonna)、使徒或任何其他圣经人物的可靠画像。
我们在前几卷中,已经追溯了从罗马地下墓窟 (Roman Catacombs) 到六世纪末圣像逐渐被引入的过程。起初,使用象征和图画全然无害,后来随着圣徒崇拜的发展而不知不觉地流传开来。东方承袭了古希腊人对艺术的爱好,主要热衷于圣像;西方那些不能欣赏艺术作品的蛮族,则更看重遗物。
我们可以区分出三种理论,其中两种发生了公开冲突,彼此争夺阵地,直到842年。
- 圣像崇拜的理论。这是正统的理论,被反对者斥为偶像崇拜的一种,111却得到民众、修士、诗人、妇女,以及伊琳娜 (Irene) 和狄奥多拉 (Theodora) 两位女皇的有力支持,并获第七次大公会议(787年)和诸位教皇(格列高利二世、格列高利三世及哈德良一世 (Hadrian I))认可。它主张使用和崇拜基督、童贞女及圣徒的圣像,既是权利,也是义务;却愤然否认偶像崇拜的指控,并区分了应当给予图像的有限崇敬112与惟独上帝当受的严格意义上的敬拜113(这种区分在实际中往往遭到忽视)。圣像是一部图画圣经,它向眼睛说话,甚至比言语向耳朵说话更有说服力。对于不能阅读圣经的平民,它们尤其有价值。原属天上那些活着的原型的尊荣,逐渐转移到了他们在地上的木制图像上;人们恭敬地亲吻这些图像,并在其周围举行跪拜、点灯、焚香等异教仪式;又认为在它们面前所作的祈祷更为有效。对图像的热情与圣徒崇拜携手并进,几乎不可分割。这种热情激发了诗歌灵感,丰富了希腊教会的礼仪书。主要的圣诗作者,如大马士革的约翰、耶路撒冷的科斯马斯 (Cosmas of Jerusalem)、日耳曼努斯 (Germanus)、狄奥法尼斯、斯图迪乌斯修道院的狄奥多尔,都是圣像的支持者;其中有些人因其热忱而遭罢黜、监禁和残害肢体;毁像派却没有产生一个诗人。114
反对这一理论的主要论据,是第二诫。对此,人们提出了各种答辩:有人认为,这项禁令只是暂时的,直到基督显现为止;有人认为,它只适用于雕刻的偶像;又有人认为,它只禁止为偶像崇拜的目的制造图像。
另一方面,人们援引约柜上方的基路伯和旷野中的铜蛇,作为摩西礼拜中使用可见象征的例证。上帝之子道成肉身,为绘制基督像提供了神圣的依据。既然基督以人的形体显现,以这一形体来表现他便不可能是罪。福音书对他的容貌保持了意味深长的沉默,人们便用托名出于圣路加 (St. Luke)、圣韦罗妮卡 (St. Veronica) 的虚构画像,以及埃德萨 (Edessa) 的画像,来填补这一空白。迷信的幻想甚至编造了能行神迹的画像故事,声称它们能移动、说话和行动。
还应补充一点:东方教会将圣像限定为平面上的彩色图像和镶嵌画,却不准以浮雕和雕像作为崇拜对象。罗马教会则没有这种限制。
- 破坏圣像的理论处于相反的极端。它的拥护者被称为圣像破坏者。115精力充沛的希腊皇帝利奥三世 (Leo III.) 及其子君士坦丁 (Constantine) 支持这一理论;他们抵御撒拉逊人 (Saracens) 的入侵,挽救了摇摇欲坠的帝国。这一理论在军队中广受欢迎,并获754年君士坦丁堡会议 (Constantinopolitan Synod) 认可。它始终诉诸十诫的第二诫,严格按照犹太人和原始基督徒的理解来解释。穆罕默德教徒的胜利大大增强了这一理论的力量;他们像犹太人一样,指控基督徒犯了偶像崇拜的大罪,并征服了叙利亚、巴勒斯坦和埃及的诸城,尽管这些城市依赖圣像的保护和神奇干预。754年反对圣像的会议谴责圣像崇拜是重新堕入异教的偶像崇拜,是魔鬼偷偷带进教会的,用以取代以心灵和诚实惟独敬拜上帝。
然而,破坏圣像派并不一贯;因为他们仍坚持圣徒崇拜,而这正是圣像崇拜的根源;他们也没有扫除一切宗教象征,反倒保留了十字架的记号及其一切迷信用途,并援引圣经中论十字架功效的经文来为这一例外辩护,尽管这些经文所指的是十字架上的献祭,而非十字架的记号。
破坏圣像运动的主要缺陷及其失败的原因,在于它的消极性质。它没有提供任何东西来取代圣像崇拜,只留下空荡荡的墙壁,无法满足希腊民族的宗教需要。这与福音派宗教改革中的破坏圣像运动大不相同;后者用来自上帝圣言的、更丰富的理性与属灵教导,取代了圣像。
- 温和理论在圣像崇拜与憎恶圣像之间寻求一条中间道路(via media),区分记号与其所指之物、使用与滥用。它容许描绘基督和圣徒的形像,借着使人记起眼前所呈现的人物与事实,辅助敬虔。教皇格列高利一世 (Gregory I.) 应一位隐士的请求,赠给他一幅绘有基督、马利亚、圣彼得和圣保罗的图画,并附上一封信,赞同人希望借可见之物记起自己所敬爱之对象的自然愿望,同时又告诫他不可作迷信的使用。他说:“我们并非把图画当作神明而跪拜;我们所敬拜的,乃是图画使我们记起其降生、受难或坐在威严宝座上的那一位。”这位教皇也称赞马赛 (Marseilles) 主教塞雷努斯 (Serenus) 反对崇拜图画的热忱,却不赞同他在这方面走得过远,并提醒他:对于那些刚脱离异教野蛮状态、不能自行从圣经领受教导的人,这些辅助之物自有其用处。八、九世纪的法兰克教会 (Frankish church) 更坚决地反对这种滥用,却没有走到东方毁像派那样的地步。
随着时间推移,拉丁教会在实际的圣像崇拜上,即使没有超过第七次大公会议以后的东方教会,也已经走得同样远。格列高利二世 (Gregory II.) 坚决抵制利奥皇帝的圣像破坏敕令,并利用这场争论来争取教皇宝座的独立。格列高利三世 (Gregory III.) 步其后尘,哈德良 (Hadrian) 则批准了第二次尼西亚会议的法令。若不放弃圣徒崇拜,就不能一贯地反对圣像崇拜。
同样的理论与派别在宗教改革时代再度出现:罗马教会与希腊教会都坚持圣像崇拜,只偶尔对其中的弊端提出微弱的抗议,并鼓励美术的发展,尤其在意大利 (Italy);激进的改革者(卡尔施塔特 (Carlstadt)、茨温利 (Zwingli)、加尔文 (Calvin)、诺克斯 (Knox))重申圣像破坏理论,认为图画助长了一种精致的偶像崇拜,妨碍属灵的敬拜,因而有秩序地将它们从教堂中移除;路德宗教会则效法路德和他的朋友卢卡斯·克拉纳赫 (Lucas Kranach),保留旧有图画,或以更好的新作取代,但除去了从前的迷信。近代艺术的进步,以及复制图画的机械技术日益便利,使新教国家发生了变化。主日学书籍及其他供老少阅读的著作,充满取材于圣经历史的教学插图;宗教绘画大师的杰作也成了家居装饰,却决不会再成为崇拜的对象,因为崇拜惟独归于上帝。
附注
特伦托大公会议 (Council of Trent) 于1563年12月举行的第XXV次会议,在批准圣徒及圣物崇拜的同时,也以下列措辞批准了“圣像的合法使用”:“此外,基督、上帝之母童贞女及其他圣徒的圣像,应当置备并保留,尤其是在圣堂之中;应当给予它们适当的尊敬与敬礼。这并不是相信其中具有任何神性或能力,因而应当加以崇拜;也不是要向它们求什么;或像古时那些寄望于偶像的外邦人一样,把信赖寄托在圣像上;而是因为给予圣像的尊敬,乃是归于这些圣像所代表的原型。因此,借着我们所亲吻、在其前脱帽俯伏的圣像,我们敬拜基督,敬礼那些圣像所描绘的圣徒;正如历次会议,尤其第二次尼西亚会议的法令,为反对圣像的敌人所作的界定。”《特伦托信仰宣认》 (Profession of the Tridentine Faith) 第IX条也作同样的教导。(见沙弗 (Schaff),《信经》 (Creeds),II,第201、209页。)
东方教会的近代信仰准则重申了第七次大公会议的决定。耶路撒冷会议 (Synod of Jerusalem),或《多西修斯信条》 (Confession of Dositheus),将基督、上帝之母、圣徒,以及曾向一些族长和先知显现的圣天使的图像,还有以鸽子形状象征圣灵的图像,都列入崇拜的对象(προσκυνοῦμεν καὶ τιμῶμεν καὶ ἀσπαζόμεθα*)。见沙弗,前引书 (l.c.),II,第436页。《俄国大教理问答》 (The Longer Russian Catechism) 在解释第二诫时(沙弗,II,第527页),这样论到这个问题:
“什么是圣像 (icon)(εἰκών*)?
“这个词来自希腊文,意思是形像或表象。在正教会 (Orthodox Church) 中,这个名称指我们的主耶稣基督——道成肉身的上帝——以及他无玷污的母亲和他的圣徒的神圣图像。
“使用圣像是否符合第二诫?
只有当人把圣像当作神明时,才是不符合的;但把圣像尊为神圣的图像,并用它们来虔诚地记念上帝的作为和他的圣徒,却丝毫不违背这条诫命;因为圣像如此使用时,就是书籍,不过是用人物和事物的形状,而非用字母写成的〔原文 writen,原书如此〕。(见伟大者格列高利,Greg. Magn. lib. ix. Ep. 9, ad Seren. Epis.,第ix卷,第9封信,致塞雷努斯主教。)
“我们敬礼圣像时,应当怀着怎样的心态?
“当我们用眼睛观看它们时,应当在心中仰望它们所描绘的上帝和圣徒。”
§ 101. 圣像破坏之争与754年会议
圣像争论的历史包括三个时期:1)反对圣像的争战,以及君士坦丁堡会议 (Council of Constantinople) 废除圣像崇拜,公元726—754年。2)拥护圣像崇拜的反动,以及第二次尼西亚会议对它的庄严认可,公元754—787年。3)两派冲突再起,以及圣像崇拜于公元842年取得最后胜利。
圣像崇拜随圣徒崇拜一同传播,成了东方教会民众的普遍习惯,程度之深,以致基督教护教者面对不断向他们提出的偶像崇拜指控,很难站稳脚跟。这些指控不仅来自犹太人,也来自伊斯兰教 (Islam) 的信徒;后者还可以援引自己迅速取得的胜利,支持他们对一切偶像崇拜的憎恶。教堂与教会书籍、宫殿与私人住宅、衣服与家具,都饰有宗教图画。在富于艺术天赋的希腊人中,这些图画占据了圣物在粗野的西方各民族中所占的地位。人们甚至让圣像以其所代表的圣徒之名充当洗礼保人。关于圣像施行奇迹之能力的荒诞故事四处流传,人们也轻易相信。这种种过度的行为,自然激起了反动。
利奥三世 (Leo III.),号称伊苏里亚人 (the Isaurian,716—741年),是一位头脑冷静、精力充沛,却不通文墨、专横独断的皇帝。他凭军事才干与战功,从伊苏里亚 (Isauria) 山区的一个农民登上恺撒的宝座,又借新发明的“希腊火 (Greek fire)”使臣民摆脱了对阿拉伯人 (Arabs) 的恐惧。他自觉蒙召,要作第二个约西亚,用自己的权柄铲除偶像崇拜。拜占庭皇帝毫不顾忌地干预教会内部事务,并为此运用专制权力。利奥受到弗吕家 (Phrygia) 纳科利亚 (Nakolia) 的一位主教君士坦丁努斯 (Constantinus)116 的影响,也希望削弱穆罕默德教徒对基督徒的指控。在位第六年,他下令强迫犹太人和孟他努派 (Montanists)(或摩尼派 (Manichaeans))受洗;前者假意顺从,暗中嘲弄这仪式;后者宁可放火焚烧自己的聚会场所,葬身火海。此后,在位第十年(726年),117他开始向圣像开战。起初,他只禁止崇拜圣像,并面对日益高涨的反对声浪宣称,他要把圣像移至人手摸不到、嘴亲不到的地方,以保护它们不受亵渎。但在第二道敕令(730年)中,他下令移除或毁坏一切圣像。绘有图画的墙壁都要刷白。他用一个朴素的十字架,取代皇宫大门上方那幅华美的基督画像。他罢免了年迈的君士坦丁堡牧首日耳曼努斯 (Germanus),以主张圣像破坏的阿纳斯塔修斯 (Anastasius) 取代他。
这些敕令激起了教士、修士和民众的激烈反对;他们认为这是对宗教本身的攻击。从皇宫大门上取下画像的仆役,被暴民杀死。我们先前已知的圣诗作者大马士革的约翰 (John of Damascus) 和日耳曼努斯,是主要的反对者。前者不在利奥势力所及之处,写了三篇雄辩的论说,为圣像崇拜辩护:一篇写于日耳曼努斯被迫辞职之前,两篇写于其后,将这一论题的论据发挥殆尽。118群岛 (Archipelago) 的居民在修士控制之下,公开起兵反叛,拥立了一位皇位觊觎者;但他们遭到击败,首领被处死。利奥在东方帝国疆域内强迫人们服从,但对撒拉逊人统治下的基督徒臣民,却无能为力;在罗马和拉文纳 (Ravenna),他的权威也受到公开蔑视。教皇格列高利二世在一封侮辱性的信中(约729年)告诉他:若他公开自称是圣像的毁坏者,文法学校的孩子们便会把写字板掷向他的头;他不肯向智慧人学习的事,无知的人倒要教给他。119七十年后,西方建立了自己的帝国,与罗马主教密切联合。
君士坦丁五世 (Constantine V.),绰号科普罗尼摩斯 (Copronymos),120在长达三十四年的统治期间(741—775年),以卓越的才干、旺盛的精力和残酷的手段,顶住民众的喧嚷、叛乱与阴谋,继续推行父亲的政策。各作者因教义立场不同,对他的品格评价也迥然相异。他的敌人指控他恶行骇人、持异端见解,并施行邪术;毁像派却盛赞他的美德,甚至在他死后四十年,仍在他的墓前祈祷。他的行政和军事才干,以及对撒拉逊人、保加利亚人 (Bulgarians) 和其他敌人所取得的胜利,正如他的专横与残酷(这也是其他拜占庭皇帝所共有的)一样,都是无可争辩的。
754年,他在君士坦丁堡召开了一次主张圣像破坏的会议,原拟作为第七次大公会议,后来却被斥为异端的伪会议。会议由以弗所大主教狄奥多西 (Theodosius of Ephesus,一位前任皇帝之子) 主持,有三百三十名唯命是从的主教出席,历时六个月(2月10日至8月27日);但耶路撒冷、安提阿 (Antioch) 和亚历山大里亚 (Alexandria) 的牧首因身处穆斯林统治之下,无法出席,君士坦丁堡的主教座位当时空缺,教皇司提反三世 (Stephen III.) 则不理会皇帝的召集。会议援引第二条诫命及其他谴责偶像崇拜的经文(罗1:23、25;约4:24),以及教父的意见(伊皮法纽、尤西比乌斯 (Eusebius)、拿先斯的贵格利、金口约翰等),谴责并禁止在公共场合及私下崇拜圣像,违者处以革职及逐出教会;但与此同时,它又前后不一地下令,任何人不得损毁或擅动饰有人像的圣器或圣衣,并正式声明赞同前六次大公会议,承认祈求蒙福童贞女及圣徒的合法性。会议斥责一切由画家或雕刻家制作的宗教形象为僭妄、异教化和偶像崇拜。救主既是神,也是人,二者在同一不可分割的位格中;因此,凡为他画像的,若不是把不可测度的神性限制在受造肉身的范围之内,就是像欧迪奇 (Eutyches) 那样混淆他的二性,或像聂斯托利 (Nestorius) 那样将二性分开,或像阿里乌那样否认他的神性;凡崇拜这种画像的,也犯了同样的异端和亵渎之罪。惟有圣餐才是基督的恰当形象。会议向圣像崇拜的拥护者宣告三重咒诅,甚至伟大的大马士革的约翰也未能幸免;他被冠以曼苏尔之名,被称为基督的叛徒、帝国的仇敌、不敬虔的教师和曲解圣经的人。会议记录已被销毁,仅存决议(ὅρος*)及一篇简短引言,二者都收录在第二次尼西亚会议的记录中,并受到谴责。121
皇帝在其权力所及之处,极其严厉地执行这项法令。圣像遭到无情毁坏,取而代之的是粉刷一白的墙面,或树木、飞鸟和走兽的图画。主教和教士都顺服了;但制作画像的修士却斥皇帝为第二个穆罕默德和异端魁首,又斥一切毁像派为异端、无神论者和亵渎者,因而遭受监禁、鞭打、残害肢体和种种凌辱,甚至被处死。这一朝代中(761—775年),为圣像殉难的主要人物有彼得鲁斯·卡拉比特斯 (Petrus Kalabites,即住在茅舍〔καλύβη*〕中的人)、莫纳格里亚修道院院长约翰内斯 (Johannes, Abbot of Monagria),以及君士坦丁堡对岸奥克森提乌斯修道院院长司提反努斯 (Stephanus, Abbot of Auxentius,被称为“新司提反努斯”,以区别于第一位殉道者)。皇帝甚至企图废除修道院。122
§ 102. 第七次大公会议恢复圣像崇拜,787年
利奥四世 (Leo IV.),号称哈扎鲁斯 (Chazarus,775—780年),继续维持反对圣像的法律,只是执行得较为温和。但他的妻子、雅典的伊琳娜 (Irene of Athens),以美貌、才干、野心和权谋著称,内心笃信圣像崇拜;在他死后、其子紫衣贵胄君士坦丁六世 (Constantine VI. Porphyrogenitus) 尚未成年期间,她以精明和毅力致力于恢复圣像崇拜(780—802年)。起初,她宣布对双方一律宽容,后来却不再宽容毁像派。她把受迫害的修士擢升到最高职位,又在教皇哈德良 (Hadrian) 同意之下,将自己的秘书塔拉修 (Tarasius) 提上君士坦丁堡牧首的宝座;教皇预期他将为正统信仰效力,便愿意不计较突然选立一位平信徒这种不合规制的做法。她撤换了主张圣像破坏的御林军,代之以赞同她见解的卫队。
但最重要的举措,是召开一次大公会议,因为惟有大公会议才能废除754年圣像破坏会议的权威。786年,她首次尝试在君士坦丁堡召开这样的会议,结果彻底失败。第二次尝试由于筹备更为周密,终于成功。
伊琳娜 (Irene) 于787年在尼西亚 (Nicaea) 召开第七次大公会议;那里比君士坦丁堡较少受到圣像破坏骚乱的威胁,却又便于宫廷往来,并以第一届、也是最重要的大公会议的会址而闻名。约有三百五十位主教出席,123由塔拉修 (Tarasius) 主持,自9月24日至10月23日,只举行了八次会议,最后一次在君士坦丁堡皇宫举行。教皇哈德良一世 (Hadrian I.) 派遣了两名都叫彼得的司铎,他们的名字在会议记录中列于首位。三位东方牧首身处撒拉逊人的专制统治之下,无法安全地离开自己的住处;但两名东方修士约翰 (John) 和托马斯 (Thomas),自称是其中两位牧首的同住辅佐 (syncelli),并确知埃及和叙利亚通行的正统信仰,便获准代替这些显贵列席并投票,尽管他们并未得到牧首授权,只是由若干同道修士派遣前来。124
尼西亚会议废除了君士坦丁堡圣像破坏会议的法令,并郑重批准对圣像施行有限度的崇拜(proskynesis)。125
所谓圣像,包括十字架的标记,以及基督、童贞女马利亚、天使和圣徒的画像。这些可以用彩色绘制,或用镶嵌工艺及其他合宜材料制成,安置在教堂、住宅和街道上,或制作在墙壁、板面、圣器及圣衣上。人可以用亲吻、鞠躬、焚香、点灯和在像前祷告来表达敬意;这种尊敬应当是献给圣像所代表的、在天上活着的对象。福音书和殉道者的圣物也被列在敬奉的对象之中。
这项法令以几处论及基路伯的经文(出25:17—22;结41:1、15、19;来9:1—5)、大量真伪混杂的教父证言,以及据称由圣像施行的奇迹,作为支持。126一位长老作证说,一幅基督画像治好了他的重病。主教们一个接一个地放弃了圣像破坏的见解,连那些曾参加754年会议的人也不例外;许多人一同呼喊:“我们都犯了罪,我们都错了,我们都恳求赦免。”有些人表示良心上有所顾虑,但会议议定,违背违反上帝律法的誓言不算背誓,他们的疑虑便消除了。应一位罗马代表的请求,一幅圣像被带进会场,众人都恭敬地亲吻它。结束时,与会主教齐声呼喊:“我们如此相信。这是使徒的教义。凡不持守这教义、不向圣像致敬、称圣像为偶像、并指控基督徒拜偶像的,都当受咒诅。愿皇帝万岁!愿新的君士坦丁和新的海伦娜 (Helena) 永受纪念!愿上帝保守他们的统治!愿一切异端都受咒诅!尤其愿以弗所的伪主教狄奥多西,以及西辛尼乌斯 (Sisinnius) 和巴西尔,都受咒诅!圣三位一体已经弃绝了他们的教义。”接着又咒诅其他著名的毁像派,以及一切不承认基督的人性具有可限定的形体、不向圣像致敬、拒绝教会成文或不成文传统的人;同时宣告,愿圣像崇拜的主要捍卫者、真理的宣告者——君士坦丁堡的日耳曼努斯 (Germanus of Constantinople)、大马士革的约翰和塞浦路斯的乔治 (George of Cyprus)——永受纪念。127
会议的法令在君士坦丁堡举行的第八次会议中公开宣读,伊琳娜与其子在场,并签署了这些法令;随后,主教们与民众和士兵照惯例高呼:“正统的摄政女皇万岁!”女皇厚赠礼物,送主教们返乡。
第二次尼西亚会议在道德尊严和教义重要性上都远逊于第一次,在七次大公会议中居于最末;但它决定了东方教会此后历代敬拜的性质,其意义正在于此。它的决议也约束罗马教会;罗马教会曾派两位教皇使节参与会议,后来教皇哈德良又致信查理曼,答复《查理书》(Libri Carolini),为会议辩护。新教各教会不承认这次会议,因为它们谴责圣像崇拜是偶像崇拜的一种精致形式,也是滋生迷信的丰沃土壤;第二条诫命的明白含义、早期基督徒的观点,都支持这一看法,而伴随圣像崇拜历史的种种迷信,直到十九世纪那些施行奇迹的圣母像,也从反面印证了这一点。同时,我们也不难承认,尼西亚的法令扶助并安慰了那种需要可见支撑的低下而粗陋的虔诚,并促进了基督教艺术的发展。圣像破坏本会扼杀这种艺术。然而,一个值得注意的事实是,天主教徒拉斐尔 (Raphael) 和米开朗琪罗 (Michael Angelo),以及新教徒卢卡斯·克拉纳赫 (Lucas Kranach) 和阿尔布雷希特·丢勒 (Albrecht Dürer),都与宗教改革者同时;绘画艺术达到最高境界的时期,正是基督教世界很大一部分地区以单单敬拜上帝的属灵敬拜取代圣像崇拜的时期。
尼西亚会议结束几个月后,伊琳娜解除了其子君士坦丁皇帝与查理曼之女罗特鲁德 (Rotrude) 的婚约——这婚约原是她亲自促成的——又强迫他娶了一位亚美尼亚女子,后来他将这女子休弃,送进修道院。128她与君士坦丁的决裂始于此时。她野心勃勃地追求专制权力,纵容他的恶习,使他遭人憎恶,最后又使他无法再居王位:她趁他睡着时命人剜去他的双眼,下手极其凶狠,以致他因此而死(797年)。令人羞愧的是,第一次尼西亚会议的召集者君士坦丁大帝,以及第二次、也是最后一次尼西亚会议的召集者伊琳娜,都沾染了自己子女的鲜血,却仍在东方教会被尊为圣徒;在东方教会的衡量中,正统信仰遮盖了许多的罪。129她享受了五年以违背天性的残酷手段加害独子所得的果实。她经过君士坦丁堡街道时,四位贵族步行在她的金车前,牵着四匹乳白骏马的缰绳。但这些贵族密谋反对他们的女皇,拥立财政大臣尼基弗鲁斯登上皇位,由那位可被收买的牧首在圣索菲亚教堂 (St. Sophia) 为他加冕。伊琳娜被流放到莱斯博斯岛 (Isle of Lesbos),不得不靠纺纱糊口,正如她年轻时还是雅典少女的日子一样。803年,她忧伤而死。伊苏里亚王朝随她一同灭亡。在拜占庭帝国的君主和牧首中,这种惊人的命运逆转并不罕见。
§ 103. 圣像破坏的反扑与圣像崇拜的最终胜利,公元842年
瓦尔希 (Walch),第X卷,第592—828页。赫费勒 (Hefele),第IV卷,第1—6、38—47、104—109页。
伊琳娜之后的五朝,共三十八年间,圣像之争仍在继续,双方互有胜负。士兵大多主张圣像破坏,修士和民众则拥护圣像崇拜。在后者之中,斯图迪乌斯修道院的狄奥多尔 (Theodore of the Studium),因无畏的辩护和在亚美尼亚人利奥五世 (Leo V., the Armenian,813—820年) 治下所遭受的残酷迫害而著称;这位皇帝后来被杀于祭坛脚下。狄奥菲卢斯 (Theophilus,829—842年) 是最后一位、也是最残酷的圣像破坏派皇帝。他以监禁、肉刑和残害肢体来迫害修士。130
但他的遗孀狄奥多拉 (Theodora),这位没有伊琳娜恶行的第二个伊琳娜,131在酗酒者米迦勒 (Michael the Drunkard) 未成年期间摄政的第十三年,以审慎而果断的措施,使圣像崇拜取得了最终而持久的胜利。她虽曾答应丈夫不作任何改变,却虚构了他临终悔改的说法,为亡夫取得了赦免。主张圣像破坏的牧首、文法学家约翰 (John the Grammarian) 被放逐,并被判鞭打二百下;立场相反的修士美多迪乌斯 (Methodius,被尊为认信者和圣徒) 接替了他的位置;主教们战战兢兢,或改变立场,或遭到罢黜;修士和民众则欢欣鼓舞。君士坦丁堡的一次会议(会议记录已佚)重新颁行七次大公会议的法令,恢复圣像崇拜,宣布咒诅一切毁像派,并决定此后每逢大斋期的第一个主日,以庄严的游行和再次宣布咒诅毁像派异端来纪念这一事件。
842年2月19日,圣像再次被迎入君士坦丁堡的各教堂。这是第一次庆祝“正统信仰主日”,132后来这一节日的意义扩大,成为庆祝战胜一切异端的节日。它是东方教会最具特色的节日之一。古代大公会议的情景以戏剧形式重现,并三次宣布咒诅各类异端:无神论者、反三位一体论者,否认马利亚在基督降生之前或之后仍为童贞的人,否认圣经的默示或灵魂不朽的人,拒绝奥秘(圣礼)、传统和会议的人,否认正统君主奉神任命而统治、并在受膏时领受圣灵的人,以及一切毁像派。这番咒诅之后,便怀着感恩的心纪念正统信仰的认信者,以及“一切以言语、著述、教导、受苦和敬虔的榜样为正统信仰争战的人,并基督教会的一切保护者和捍卫者”。最后,主教、修道院长和司祭亲吻圣像。133
§ 104. 《查理书》与法兰克教会对圣像崇拜的立场
I. 《查理书》(Libri Carolini),由埃利亚斯·菲利拉 (Elias Philyra)(即让·迪蒂耶,Jean du Tillet,或称蒂利乌斯,Tilius;他曾被怀疑信奉加尔文主义,后来却成为莫城主教)据一部法国(巴黎)抄本首次刊行,巴黎,1549年;随后,梅尔希奥尔·戈尔达斯特 (Melchior Goldast) 将其收入所编关于圣像争论的帝国敕令集,法兰克福 (Francof.),1608年(第67页及后),又收入其《帝国宪令集》(Constitutiones imperiales) 第I卷,并补入蒂利乌斯所遗漏的最后一章(第IV卷,第29章);最佳版本为Ch. A. 霍伊曼 (Ch. A. Heumann) 所编,汉诺威 (Hanover),1731年,题为《对第二次尼西亚会议的庄严审断,即查理大帝论不虔敬的圣像崇拜四书》(Augusta Concilii Nicaeni II. Censura, h. e., Caroli Magni de impio imaginum cultu libri IV.),附导论和注释。米涅 (Migne) 神父收入其《拉丁教父集》(Patrol. Lat.) 第98卷,第990—1248栏(《查理大帝著作集》,Opera Caroli M.,第II卷)的版本,是蒂利乌斯版的重印,不及霍伊曼版。(赫费勒在第III卷第696页说:“Es ist zu bedauern, dass Migne, statt Besseres, entschieden Geringeres geboten hat, als man bisher schon besass”,即“令人遗憾的是,米涅没有提供更好的东西,反而提供了明显逊于人们原已拥有的东西。”)
- 瓦尔希将第十一卷的大部分篇幅用于叙述自丕平至虔诚者路易 (Louis the Pious) 期间法兰克教会圣像崇拜的历史。尼安德,第III卷,第233—243页;吉泽勒,第II卷,第66—73页;赫费勒,第III卷,第694—716页;赫尔根勒特,第I卷,第553—557页。弗洛斯 (Floss):《论〈查理书〉的真伪疑问》(De suspecta librorum Carolinorum fide)。波恩,1860年。赖弗沙伊德 (Reifferscheid):《梵蒂冈〈查理书〉抄本述略》(Narratio de Vaticano librorum Carolinorum Codice)。布雷斯劳 (Breslau),1873年。
罗马教会在教皇的领导下,接受并支持第七次大公会议,最终甚至比东方教会走得更远,不仅容许崇拜绘制的圣像,也容许崇拜雕刻的圣像。但查理曼帝国境内的教会,却在圣像崇拜与圣像破坏之间采取了居中的立场;查理曼与伊琳娜女皇的关系并不融洽。
法国首次讨论圣像问题,是在丕平治下于767年在巴黎附近让蒂伊 (Gentilly) 举行的一次会议上,但结果如何,我们并不知道。134教皇哈德良将尼西亚会议记录的拉丁文译本送给查理曼;然而这译本错误百出,晦涩难懂,以致数十年后,罗马图书馆馆长阿纳斯塔修斯指责译者既不懂希腊文,也不懂拉丁文,并用一个较好的译本取代了它。
尼西亚会议三年后,查理曼在宫廷教士、尤其是阿尔昆的协助下,编写并出版了一部论圣像崇拜的重要著作,题为《查理四书》(Quatuor Libri Carolini,790年)。135他既不赞同754年的圣像破坏派会议,也不赞同787年的反圣像破坏派会议,但对后者尤为反对,措辞极不恭敬。136他断然拒绝圣像崇拜,却容许使用圣像作为装饰和虔敬之助,并以圣经经文和教父引文支持自己的见解。这部书的精神与宗旨几乎是新教式的。其主要思想如下:惟独神是敬拜和崇拜的对象(colondus et adorandus)。圣徒只应受到尊敬(venerandi)。圣像在任何意义上都不应受到敬拜。在圣像前鞠躬或下跪,向它们致敬或亲吻它们,在它们面前焚香点烛,都是拜偶像和迷信的行为。远不如查考圣经,因为圣经全然不知有这些做法。关于圣像施行神迹的传说,都是想象的产物,或邪灵的欺骗。另一方面,毁像派出于反对偶像崇拜的真诚热忱,却因全然排斥圣像而走得过远。圣像合法而适当的用途,是装饰教堂,使其所表现的人物和事件长存于人们的记忆之中,并广为人知。然而,即使这也不是必需的;因为基督徒应当能够不借助感官的媒介,就提升自己,默想圣徒的美德,上达永恒之光的源头。人是照着神的形象造的,因此能够将基督接入自己的灵魂。神应当永远临在于我们心中,受我们崇拜。唉,何等可悲的记忆,竟只能凭借用感官可见的色彩绘成的图画,才能体认基督的临在!尼西亚会议定罪那些不崇拜圣像的人,犯下了大错。
然而,《查理书》的作者却与东方毁像派一样陷入自相矛盾,因为他为十字架记号和圣徒遗骸作了例外。十字架被称为使仇敌逃跑的旗帜;尊崇圣徒遗骸则被宣称是促进敬虔的重要手段,因为圣徒在天上与基督一同作王,他们的骸骨也将复起而得荣耀;圣像却是人手所造,终将归于尘土。
公元794年在法兰克福 (Frankfort) 举行的一次会议,是查理曼在位期间最重要的会议,代表法国和德国的教会,并有两位教皇使节——狄奥菲拉克图斯 (Theophylactus) 和斯特凡努斯 (Stephanus)——在场。会议赞同《查理书》(Libri Carolini) 的教导,一致谴责任何形式的圣像崇拜,并拒绝承认第七次大公会议。137按照一个古老的传说,英国教会也赞同这一决定。138
查理曼经由女婿安吉尔贝特 (Angilbert),将其著作的一份副本,或更可能是其中的摘录(85条,Capitula,或称《论圣像条款》,Capitulare de Imaginibus),送给他的朋友教皇哈德良。哈德良作了长篇答复,试图在对其西方保护者保持应有敬意的同时,为尼西亚所代表的东方正统信仰辩护,却未能使法兰克教会满意,不久便去世了(795年12月25日)。139
825年,在查理曼之子及继承者虔诚者路易治下举行的巴黎会议,为答复皇帝口吃者米迦勒 (Michael Balbus) 派来的使团,重申了法兰克福会议反对圣像崇拜和第二次尼西亚会议权威的抗议,并对教皇稍加责备。140
附注
《查理书》即使不是查理曼亲笔所写,无论如何也是以他的名义颁行的;因为作者屡次称丕平为自己的父亲,并说是在其领地内教士的同意之下(conniventia sacerdotum in regno a Deo nobis concesso,即在神赐给我们的国度内,得到教士的赞同)着手此项工作的。九世纪兰斯的欣克马尔 (Hincmar of Rheims) 最先提及这部书,称它是针对“希腊人的伪会议”(pseudo-Synodus Graecorum,即第二次尼西亚会议)而写,并从他在王宫见到的一部抄本中引录了一段。第二次提及并引述此书的是教皇图书馆馆长奥古斯丁·斯托伊库斯 (Augustin Steuchus,卒于1550年),他依据的是帕拉丁图书馆 (Bibliotheca Palatina) 的一部十分古老的抄本。此书一经刊印,弗拉维乌斯 (Flavius) 和其他新教论战家就用它来反对罗马。巴罗尼乌斯、贝拉明 (Bellarmin) 和其他罗马天主教人士否认其真实性,将此书归于查理曼时代某些异端之手,说他们将它送到罗马,以便受到定罪;有些人甚至宣称,它是激进改革家卡尔施塔特的伪作!但西尔蒙 (Sirmond) 和纳塔利斯·亚历山大令人信服地证明了它的真实性。近来,波恩的弗洛斯 (Floss) 博士(罗马天主教徒)于1860年再度提出疑问;然而,自赖弗沙伊德 (Reifferscheid) 教授于1866年在梵蒂冈图书馆发现一部新的十世纪抄本之后,这些疑问便永久消除了。这部抄本不同于斯托伊库斯所用的那部,很可能抄写于威斯特法伦 (Westphalia) 马林费尔德 (Marienfeld) 的熙笃会 (Cistercian) 修道院。因此,赫费勒主教在1877年写道(第III卷,第698页):“此后,《查理书》(Libri Carolini) 的真实性不容再质疑(nicht mehr zu beanstanden)。”
§ 105. 福音派改革者:里昂的阿戈巴尔德与都灵的克劳狄乌斯
I. 阿戈巴尔德 (Agobardus):《驳那些认为应以敬拜之礼尊奉圣徒图画和圣像者的迷信》(Contra eorum superstitionem qui picturis et imaginibus SS. adorationis obsequium deferendum putant)。《著作集》(Opera),巴卢齐乌斯 (Baluzius) 编,巴黎 (Par.),1666年,2卷;又载米涅《拉丁教父集》(Patrol. Lat.),第104卷,第29—351栏。《法国文学史》(Histoire litter. de la France),第IV卷,第567页及后。C. B. 洪德斯哈根 (C. B. Hundeshagen):《论阿戈巴尔德的生平与著作》(De Agobardi vita et scriptis),第I部,吉森 (Giessae),1831年;又参其发表于赫尔措格 (Herzog) 百科全书第2版第I卷第212页及下页的文章。贝尔 (Bähr):《加洛林时代的罗马文学史》(Gesch. der röm. Lit. in Karoliny. Zeitalter),第383—393页。布吕格尔 (Bluegel):《论里昂大主教阿戈巴尔德的生平与著作》(De Agobardi archiep. Lugd. vita et scriptis)。哈雷 (Hal.),1865年。西姆松 (Simson):《虔诚者路易治下的法兰克帝国编年史》(Jahrbücher des fränkischen Reichs unter Ludwig dem Frommen)。莱比锡 (Leipz.),1874及1876年。C. 迪兹 (C. Deedes),载史密斯 (Smith) 与韦斯 (Wace) 所编著作,第I卷,第63—64页。利希滕贝格尔 (Lichtenberger),第I卷,第119页。
克劳狄乌斯 (Claudius):《著作集》(Opera),载米涅《拉丁教父集》(Patrol. Lat.),第104卷,第609—927栏。包括《列王纪》《加拉太书》《以弗所书》等书注释,以及《奥古斯丁颂》(Eulogium Augustini) 和《护教书》(Apologeticum)。他的部分著作仍未刊行。鲁德尔巴赫 (Rudelbach):《都灵主教克劳狄乌斯未刊著作选篇,前附论其教义与著述之论文》(Claudii Tur. Ep. ineditorum operum specimina, praemissa de ejus doctrina scriptisque dissert.)。哥本哈根 (Havniae),1824年。C. 施密特 (C. Schmidt):《都灵的克劳狄乌斯》(Claudius v. Turin),载伊尔根 (Illgen) 的《历史神学杂志》(Zeitschrift f. die Hist. Theol.),1843年,第II册,第39页;又参其发表于赫尔措格百科全书第2版第III卷第243—245页的文章。
尼安德,第III卷,第428—439页(论克劳狄乌斯极为详尽,且富于辨析);吉泽勒,第II卷,第69—73页(附有选取精当的摘录);罗伊特 (Reuter):《中世纪启蒙史》(Geschichte der Aufklärung im Mittelalter),第I卷(柏林,1875年),第16—20及24—41页。
九世纪期间,法兰克教会继续反对圣像崇拜和其他迷信习俗。
两位杰出的主教带头倡导一种更为属灵、更合乎福音的宗教形态。在这一点上,他们不同于东方那些理性主义的、破坏性的毁像派。他们受到保罗和奥古斯丁著作的影响;这两位乃是教会历史上一切福音运动的启发者。不过,两者有所不同:保罗远超各党派和学派之上;奥古斯丁虽持守一切反伯拉纠主义原则,却仍大力拥护大公教会关于教会及其秩序的理论。
阿戈巴尔德 (Agobard;里昂方言称 Agobaud 或 Aguebaud) 生于西班牙,父母却是高卢人,曾任里昂大主教(816—841年);在虔诚者路易 (Louis the Pious) 统治时期法国的政治史和教会史上,他占有显著地位。我们此前已知道,他反对神判法、司法决斗以及其他异教习俗。141 他的性格呈现出奇特的对照。他是一位严厉的教士和祭司权威论者,在教义上完全正统(只是他否认圣经的逐字默示);但另一方面,他又是一切迷信的死敌,并在敬拜事务上倡导开明的见解。142 833年,他参加了洛泰尔 (Lothaire) 反叛其父路易的行动,因此失去主教职位,品格也留下了严重的污点;但后来他与路易和解,恢复了主教职位。他反对嗣子论 (Adoptionism),视之为聂斯托利异端的一种较温和的形式。他抨击大批涌入里昂的犹太人,指控他们对基督徒态度傲慢。在这一点上,他与他那个时代一样不宽容。然而,另一方面,他写了一部反对圣像崇拜的书。143 他追溯到这一难题的根源,即圣徒崇拜。他找不到任何支持这种崇拜的权威根据。圣徒自己也拒绝接受这种崇拜。这是撒但的诡计,借尊敬圣徒之名,将异教的偶像崇拜暗中带入教会。他就这样引人离开属灵的敬拜,转向感官的敬拜。唯独上帝应当受崇拜;我们必须单单向他献上忧伤痛悔之心的祭。对于得胜加冠、以代祷帮助我们的天使和圣徒,可以爱戴、尊敬,却不可敬拜。“倚靠人的,那人有祸了”(耶利米书17:5)。我们可以愉快地观赏他们的画像,但最好只以十字架这个简单的象征为满足(仿佛这就不会遭到同样的滥用)。阿戈巴尔德赞同埃尔维拉 (Elvira) 完全禁止圣像的教规。他最后说:“既然除我们的救主耶稣以外,没有人在本质上是上帝,那么,我们就当遵照圣经的命令,单单向他的名屈膝,免得将这尊荣给予别人,以致与上帝疏远,任凭自己随从内心的倾向,追随人的教训和传统。”144
阿戈巴尔德的职位未受扰动,死后甚至在里昂被尊为圣徒,虽然他的圣徒身份仍有争议。145 他的著作曾经失传,直到帕皮里乌斯·马松 (Papirius Masson) 在里昂发现一部抄本,将它从一位装订匠手中抢救出来(1605年)。
都灵主教克劳狄乌斯 (Claudius,814—839年在任) 生于西班牙,曾在虔诚者路易的宫廷中担任三年随侍司铎,随后奉派前往都灵教区。他应皇帝的要求,为教育教士,几乎为圣经的每一卷书都写了实用性的注释。这些注释大多摘录自奥古斯丁、哲罗姆 (Jerome) 及其他拉丁教父的著作,如今只剩片段。他极其推崇奥古斯丁,却缺乏后者的智慧和节制。146
他发现意大利各教会充满画像和敬拜画像的人。有人告诉他,百姓并非要敬拜圣像,而是要敬拜圣徒。他回答说,异教徒也以同样的理由为自己的偶像崇拜辩护;如此说来,他们只须更换名称,就可以成为基督徒了。他将圣像崇拜和圣徒崇拜 (saint-worship) 追溯到一种伯拉纠主义 (Pelagian) 的倾向,并以奥古斯丁关于神恩典之主权的观点加以反驳。他说,保罗推翻人的功德——如今修士们最为夸耀的正是这些功德——而高举上帝的恩典。我们得救是靠恩典,不是靠行为。我们必须敬拜创造主,而非受造之物。“凡向天上或地上任何受造之物寻求那本应单单向上帝寻求的救恩的人,就是拜偶像者。”已故的圣徒自己并不愿受我们敬拜,也不能帮助我们。我们活着的时候,可以藉祷告彼此帮助,死后却不能。他也抨击迷信地使用十字圣号 (sign of the cross),在这一点上比查理曼 (Charlemagne) 和阿戈巴尔德 (Agobard) 走得更远。他将辩护者的论点推至荒谬的结论,以此加以反驳。他说,若因基督曾在十字架上受苦,我们就敬拜十字架,那么,我们也可以因他由童贞女所生而敬拜每一个童贞女,因他曾卧在马槽里而敬拜每一个马槽,因他曾在船上教训人而敬拜每一条船,甚至因他曾骑驴进入耶路撒冷而敬拜每一头驴。我们应当背负十字架,而不是崇拜十字架。他把画像、十字架和苦像 (crucifixes) 逐出教堂,认为这是根除迷信的唯一办法。他也强烈反对朝圣。他对宗教象征毫无欣赏之心,在清教徒式的热忱中走向狂热的极端。
克劳狄乌斯的主教职位未受扰动;但据他自己说,他得不到百姓的同情,反倒成了“邻舍讥诮的对象”;他们指着他,称他为“可怕的幽灵”。他受到教皇帕斯卡尔一世 (Paschalis I.,817—824年) 的谴责,也受到几个人的反对:他的老友、尼姆 (Nismes) 教区的修院院长狄奥德米尔 (Theodemir),他曾将现已失传的《利未记注释》题献给此人(823年);邓加尔 (Dungal,来自苏格兰或爱尔兰,约827年);以及奥尔良的约纳斯 (Jonas of Orleans,840年),后者不公正地指控他持有嗣子论,甚至阿里乌异端。有些作者试图将他与年代晚得多的皮埃蒙特 (Piedmont) 瓦勒度派 (Waldenses) 联系起来,却没有证据。147
奥尔良的约纳斯 (Jonas of Orleans)、兰斯的欣克马尔 (Hincmar of Rheims) 和瓦拉弗里德·斯特拉博 (Wallafrid Strabo),基本上仍然维持《加洛林书》在毁像与圣像崇拜两个极端之间所采取的温和立场。然而,教皇无所不能的影响、这个时代偏重感官而又轻信的倾向、教士的无知,以及百姓更为粗陋的无知,共同促成了圣像崇拜最终甚至在法国也取得胜利。加洛林时代的旭日,被十世纪的黑暗遮蔽了。
Original Text
CHAPTER X. WORSHIP AND CEREMONIES.
Comp. vol. III. ch. VII., and Neander III. 123–140; 425–455 (Boston ed.).
§ 92. The Mass.
Comp. vol. III. § 96–101 and the liturgical Lit. there quoted; also the works on Christian and Ecclesiastical Antiquities, e.g. Siegel III. 361–411.
The public worship centered in the celebration of the mass as an actual, though unbloody, repetition of the sacrifice of Christ for the sins of the world. In this respect the Eastern and Western churches are fully agreed to this day. They surround this ordinance with all the solemnity of a mysterious symbolism. They differ only in minor details.
Pope Gregory I. improved the Latin liturgy, and gave it that shape which it substantially retains in the Roman church.(1) He was filled with the idea that the eucharist embodies the reconciliation of heaven and earth, of eternity and time, and is fraught with spiritual benefit for the living and the pious dead in one unbroken communion. When the priest offers the unbloody sacrifice to God, the heavens are opened, the angel are present, and the visible and invisible worlds united.(2)
Gregory introduced masses for the dead,(3) in connection with the doctrine of purgatory which he developed and popularized. They were based upon the older custom of praying for the departed, and were intended to alleviate and abridge the penal sufferings of those who died in the Catholic faith, but in need of purification from remaining infirmities. Very few Catholics are supposed to be prepared for heaven; and hence such masses were often ordered beforehand by the dying, or provided by friends.(4) They furnished a large income to priests. The Oriental church has no clearly defined doctrine of purgatory, but likewise holds that the departed are benefited by prayers of the living, "especially such as are offered in union with the oblation of the bloodless sacrifice of the body and blood of Christ, and by works of mercy done in faith for their memory."(5)
The high estimate of the efficacy of the sacrament led also to the abuse of solitary masses, where the priest celebrates without attendants.(6) This destroys the original character of the institution as a feast of communion with the Redeemer and the redeemed. Several synods in the age of Charlemagne protested against the practice. The Synod of Mainz in 813 decreed: "No presbyter, as it seems to us, can sing masses alone rightly, for how will he say sursum corda! or Dominus vobiscum! when there is no one with him?" A reformatory Synod of Paris, 829, prohibits these masses, and calls them a "reprehensible practice," which has crept in "partly through neglect, partly through avarice."(7)
The mysterious character of the eucharist was changed into the miraculous and even the magical with the spread of the belief in the doctrine of transubstantiation. But the doctrine was contested in two controversies before it triumphed in the eleventh century.(8)
The language of the mass was Greek in the Eastern, Latin in the Western church. The Latin was an unknown tongue to the barbarian races of Europe. It gradually went out of use among the descendants of the Romans, and gave place to the Romanic languages. But the papal church, sacrificing the interests of the people to the priesthood, and rational or spiritual worship(9) to external unity, retained the Latin language in the celebration of the mass to this day, as the sacred language of the church. The Council of Trent went so far as to put even the uninspired Latin Vulgate practically on an equality with the inspired Hebrew and Greek Scriptures.(10)
§ 93. The Sermon.
As the chief part of divine service was unintelligible to the people, it was all the more important to supplement it by preaching and catechetical instruction in the vernacular tongues. But this is the weak spot in the church of the middle ages.(11)
Pope Gregory I. preached occasionally with great earnestness, but few popes followed his example. It was the duty of bishops to preach, but they often neglected it. The Council of Clovesho, near London, which met in 747 under Cuthbert, archbishop of Canterbury, for the reformation of abuses, decreed that the bishops should annually visit their parishes, instruct and exhort the abbots and monks, and that all presbyters should be able to explain the Apostles’ Creed, the Lord’s Prayer, the mass, and the office of baptism to the people in the vernacular.(12) A Synod of Tours, held in the year 813, and a Synod of Mainz, held under Rabanus Maurus in 847, decreed that every bishop should have a collection of homilies and translate them clearly "in rusticam Romanam linguam aut Theotiscam, i.e. into French (Romance) or German," "in order that all may understand them."(13)
The great majority of priests were too ignorant to prepare a sermon, and barely understood the Latin liturgical forms. A Synod of Aix, 802, prescribed that they should learn the Athanasian and Apostles’ Creed, the Lord’s Prayer with exposition, the Sacramentarium or canon of the mass, the formula of exorcism, the commendatio animae, the Penitential, the Calendar and the Roman cantus; they should learn to understand the homilies for Sundays and holy days as models of preaching, and read the pastoral theology of Pope Gregory. This was the sum and substance of clerical learning.(14) The study of the Greek Testament and the Hebrew Scriptures was out of the question, and there was hardly a Western bishop or pope in the middle ages who was able to study the divine oracles in the original.
The best, therefore, that the priests and deacons, and even most of the bishops could do was to read the sermons of the fathers. Augustin had given this advice to those who were not skilled in composition. It became a recognized practice in France and England. Hence the collection of homilies, called Homiliaria, for the Gospels and Epistles of Sundays and holy days. They are mostly patristic compilations. Bede’s collection, called Homilice de Tempore, contains thirty-three homilies for the summer, fifteen for the winter, twenty-two for Lent, besides sermons on saints’ days. Charlemagne commissioned Paulus Diaconus or Paul Warnefrid (a monk of Monte Cassino and one of his chaplains, the historian of the Lombards, and writer of poems on saints) to prepare a Homiliarium (or Omiliarius) about a.d. 780, and recommended it for adoption in the churches of France. It follows the order of Sundays and festivals, is based on the text of the Vulgate, and continued in use more or less for several centuries.(15) Other collections were made in later times, and even the Reformed church of England under Edward VI. and Queen Elizabeth found it necessary to provide ignorant clergymen with two Books of Homilies adapted to the doctrines of the Reformation.
In this connection we must allude again to the poetic reproductions of the Bible history, namely, the divine epos of Caedmon, the Northumbrian monk (680), the Saxon Heliand" (Heiland, i.e. Saviour, about 880), and the "Christ" or Gospel Harmony of Otfrid (a pupil of Rabanus Maurus, about 870). These works were effective popular sermons on the history of redemption, and are at the same time the most valuable remains of the Anglo-Saxon and old high German dialects of the Teutonic language.(16)
It was, however, not till the Reformation of the sixteenth century that the sermon and the didactic element were restored and fully recognized in their dignity and importance as regular and essential parts of public worship. I say, worship, for to expound the oracles of God, and devoutly to listen to such exposition is or ought to be worship both on the part of the preacher and on the part of the hearer, as well as praying and singing.
§ 94. Church Poetry. Greek Hymns and Hymnists.
See the Lit. in vol. III. § 113 (p. 575 sq.) and § 114 (p. 578), and add the following:
Cardinal Pitra: Hymnographie de l’église grecque. Rome 1867. By the same: Analecta Sacra Spicilegio Solesmensi parata, T. I. Par. 1876.
Wilhelm Christ et M. Paranikas: Anthologia Graeca carminum Christianorum. Lips. 1871. CXLIV and 268 pages. The Greek text with learned Prolegomena in Latin. Christ was aided by Paranikas, a member of the Greek church. Comp. Christ: Beiträge zur kirchlichen Literatur der Byzantiner. München 1870.
[?]. L. Jacobi (Prof. of Church Hist. in Halle): Zur Geschichte der griechischen Kirchenliedes (a review of Pitra’s Analecta), in Brieger’s "Zeitschrift für Kirchengesch., "vol. V. Heft 2, p. 177–250 (Gotha 1881).
For a small selection of Greek hymns in the original see the third volume of Daniel’s Thesaurus Hymnologicus (1855), and Bässler’s Auswahl altchristlicher Lieder (1858), p. 153–166.
For English versions see especially J. M. Neale: Hymns of the Eastern Church (Lond. 1862, third ed. 1866, 159 pages; new ed. 1876, in larger print 250 pages); also Schaff: Christ in Song (1869), which gives versions of 14 Greek (and 73 Latin) hymns. German translations in Bässler, l.c. p. 3–25.
[Syrian Hymnology. To the lit. mentioned vol. III. 580 add: Gust. Bickell: S. Ephraemi Syri Carmina Nisibena, additis prolegomenis et supplemento lexicorum syriacorum edidit, vertit, explicavit. Lips.] 1866. Carl Macke: Hymnen aus dem Zweiströmeland. Dichtungen des heil. Ephrem des Syrers aus dem syr. Urtext in’s Deutsche übertragen, etc. Mainz 1882. 270 pages. Macke is a pupil of Bickell and a successor of Zingerle as translator of Syrian church poetry.]
The general church histories mostly neglect or ignore hymnology, which is the best reflection of Christian life and worship.
The classical period of Greek church poetry extends from about 650 to 820, and nearly coincides with the iconoclastic controversy. The enthusiasm for the worship of saints and images kindled a poetic inspiration, and the chief advocates of that worship were also the chief hymnists.(17) Their memory is kept sacred in the Eastern church. Their works are incorporated in the ritual books, especially the Menaea, which contain in twelve volumes (one for each month) the daily devotions and correspond to the Latin Breviary.(18) Many are still unpublished and preserved in convent libraries. They celebrate the holy Trinity and the Incarnation, the great festivals, and especially also the Virgin Mary, the saints and martyrs, and sacred icons.
The Greek church poetry is not metrical and rhymed, but written in rhythmical prose for chanting, like the Psalms, the hymns of the New Testament, the Gloria in Excelsis and the Te Deum. The older hymnists were also melodists and composed the music.(19) The stanzas are called troparia;(20) the first troparion is named hirmos, because it strikes the tune and draws the others after it.(21) Three or more stanzas form an ode; three little odes are a triodion; nine odes or three triodia form a canon. The odes usually end with a doxology (doxa) and a stanza in praise of Mary the Mother of God (theotokion).(22) A hymn with a tune of its own is called an idiomelon.(23)
This poetry fills, according to Neale, more than nine tenths or four fifths of the Greek service books. It has been heretofore very little known and appreciated in the West, but is now made accessible.(24) It contains some precious gems of genuine Christian hymns, buried in a vast mass of monotonous, bombastic and tasteless laudations of unknown confessors and martyrs, and wonder-working images.(25)
The Greek church poetry begins properly with the anonymous but universally accepted and truly immortal Gloria in Excelsis of the third century.(26) The poems of Gregory of Nazianzus (d. 390), and Synesius of Cyrene (d. about 414), who used the ordinary classical measures, are not adapted and were not intended for public worship.(27)
The first hymnist of the Byzantine period, is Anatolius patriarch of Constantinople (d. about 458). He struck out the new path of harmonious prose, and may be compared to Venantius Fortunatus in the West.(28)
We now proceed to the classical period of Greek church poetry.
In the front rank of Greek hymnists stands St. John Of Damascus, surnamed Mansur (d. in extreme old age about 780). He is the greatest systematic theologian of the Eastern church and chief champion of image-worship against iconoclasm under the reigns of Leo the Isaurian (717–741), and Constantinus Copronymus (741–775). He spent a part of his life in the convent of Mar Sâba (or St. Sabas) in the desolate valley of the Kedron, between Jerusalem and the Dead Sea.(29) He was thought to have been especially inspired by the Virgin Mary, the patron of that Convent, to consecrate his muse to the praise of Christ. He wrote a great part of the Octoechus, which contains the Sunday services of the Eastern church. His canon for Easter Day is called "the golden Canon" or "the queen of Canons," and is sung at midnight before Easter, beginning with the shout of joy, "Christ is risen," and the response, "Christ is risen indeed." His memory is celebrated December 4.(30)
Next to him, and as melodist even above him in the estimation of the Byzantine writers, is St. Cosmas Of Jerusalem, called the Melodist. He is, as Neale says, "the most learned of the Greek poets, and the Oriental Adam of St. Victor." Cosmas and John of Damascus were foster-brothers, friends and fellow-monks at Mar Sâba, and corrected each other’s compositions. Cosmas was against his will consecrated bishop of Maiuma near Gaza in Southern Palestine, by John, patriarch of Jerusalem. He died about 760 and is commemorated on the 14th of October. The stichos prefixed to his life says:
"Where perfect sweetness dwells, is Cosmas gone;
But his sweet lays to cheer the church live on."(31)
The third rank is occupied by St. Theophanes, surnamed the Branded,(32) one of the most fruitful poets. He attended the second Council of Nicaea (787). During the reign of Leo the Arminian (813) he suffered imprisonment, banishment and mutilation for his devotion to the Icons, and died about 820. His "Chronography" is one of the chief sources for the history of the image-controversy.(33)
The following specimen from Adam’s lament of his fall is interesting:
"Adam sat right against the Eastern gate,
By many a storm of sad remembrance tost:
O me! so ruined by the serpent’s hate!
O me! so glorious once, and now so lost!
So mad that bitter lot to choose!
Beguil’d of all I had to lose!
Must I then, gladness of my eyes, —
Must I then leave thee, Paradise,
And as an exile go?
And must I never cease to grieve
How once my God, at cool of eve,
Came down to walk below?
O Merciful! on Thee I call:
O Pitiful! forgive my fall!"
The other Byzantine hymnists who preceded or succeeded those three masters, are the following. Their chronology is mostly uncertain or disputed.
Sergius, patriarch of Constantinople in the reign of Heracleus (610–641), figures in the beginning of the Monotheletic controversy, and probably suggested the union formula to that emperor. He is supposed by Christ to be the author of a famous and favorite hymn Akathistos, in praise of Mary as the deliverer of Constantinople from the siege of the Persians (630), but it is usually ascribed to Georgius Pisida.(34)
Sophronius, patriarch of Jerusalem (629), celebrated in Anacreontic metres the praises of Christ, the apostles, and martyrs, and wrote idiomela with music for the church service (35)
Maximus The Confessor (580–662), the leader and martyr of the orthodox dyotheletic doctrine in the Monotheletic controversy, one of the profoundest divines and mystics of the Eastern Church, wrote a few hymns.(36)
Germanus (634–734), bishop of Cyzicus, then patriarch of Constantinople (715), was deposed, 730, for refusing to comply with the iconoclastic edicts of the Emperor Leo the Isaurian (717–741), and died in private life, aged about one hundred years. He is "regarded by the Greeks as one of their most glorious Confessors" (Neale). Among his few poetical compositions are stanzas on Symeon the Stylite, on the prophet Elijah, on the Decollation of John the Baptist, and a canon on the wonder-working Image in Edessa.(37)
Andrew Of Crete (660–732) was born at Damascus, became monk at Jerusalem, deacon at Constantinople, archbishop of Crete, took part in the Monotheletic Synod of 712, but afterwards returned to orthodoxy. In view of this change and his advocacy of the images, he was numbered among the saints. He is regarded as the inventor of the Canons. His "Great Canon" is sung right through on the Thursday of Mid-Lent week, which is called from that hymn. It is a confession of sin and an invocation of divine mercy. It contains no less than two hundred and fifty (Neale says, three hundred) stanzas.(38)
John of Damascus reduced the unreasonable length of the canons.
Another Andrew, called jAndreva" Purov" or Purrov", is credited with eight idiomela in the Menaea, from which Christ has selected the praise of Peter and Paul as the best.(39)
Stephen The Sabaite (725–794) was a nephew of John of Damascus, and spent fifty-nine years in the convent of Mar Sâba, which is pitched, like an eagle’s nest, on the wild rocks of the Kedron valley. He is commemorated on the 13th of July. He struck the key-note of Neale’s exquisite hymn of comfort, "Art thou weary," which is found in some editions of the Octoechus. He is the inspirer rather than the author of that hymn, which is worthy of a place in every book of devotional poetry.(40)
Romanus, deacon in Berytus, afterwards priest in Constantinople, is one of the most original and fruitful among the older poets. Petra ascribes to him twenty-five hymns. He assigned him to the reign of Anastasius I. (491–518), but Christ to the reign of Anastasius II. (713–719), and Jacobi with greater probability to the time of Constantinus Pogonatus (681–685).(41)
Theodore Of The Studium (a celebrated convent near Constantinople) is distinguished for his sufferings in the iconoclastic controversy, and died in exile, 826, on the eleventh of November. He wrote canons for Lent and odes for the festivals of saints. The spirited canon on Sunday of Orthodoxy in celebration of the final triumph of image-worship in 842, is ascribed to him, but must be of later date as he died before that victory.(42)
Joseph Of The Studium, a brother of Theodore, and monk of that convent, afterwards Archbishop of Thessalonica (hence also called Thessalonicensis), died in prison in consequence of tortures inflicted on him by order of the Emperor Theophilus (829–842). He is sometimes confounded (even by Neale) with Joseph Hymnographus; but they are distinguished by Nicephorus and commemorated on different days.(43)
Theoctistus Of The Studium (about 890) is the author of a "Suppliant Canon to Jesus," the only thing known of him, but the sweetest Jesus-hymn of the Greek Church.(44)
Joseph, called Hymnographus (880), is the most prolific, most bombastic, and most tedious of Greek hymn-writers. He was a Sicilian by birth, at last superintendent of sacred vessels in a church at Constantinople. He was a friend of Photius, and followed him into exile. He is credited with a very large number of canons in the Mencaea and the Octoechus.(45)
Tarasius, patriarch of Constantinople (784), was the chief mover in the restoration of Icons and the second Council of Nicaea (787). He died Feb. 25, 806. His hymns are Unimportant.(46)
EUTHYMIUS, usually known as Syngelus or Syncellus (died about 910), is the author of a penitential canon to the Virgin Mary, which is much esteemed in the East.(47)
Elias, bishop of Jerusalem about 761, and Orestes, bishop of the same city, 996–1012, have been brought to light as poets by the researches of Pitra from the libraries of Grotta Ferrata, and other convents.
In addition to these may be mentioned Methodius (846)(48) Photius, Patriarch of Constantinople (d. 891), Metrophanes of Smyrna (900), Leo VI., or the Philosopher, who troubled the Eastern Church by a fourth marriage (886–917), Symeon Metaphrastes (Secretary and Chancellor of the Imperial Court at Constantinople, about 900), Kasias, Nilus Xanthopulus, Joannes Geometra, and Mauropus (1060). With the last the Greek hymnody well nigh ceased. A considerable number of hymns cannot be traced to a known author.(49)
We give in conclusion the best specimens of Greek hymnody as reproduced and adapted to modern use by Dr. Neale.
’Tis the Day of Resurrection. ( jAnastavsew" hJmevra.)
By St. John of Damascus.
’Tis the Day of Resurrection,
Earth, tell it out abroad!
The Passover of gladness,
The Passover of God!
From death to life eternal,
From earth unto the sky,
Our Christ hath brought us over,
With hymns of victory.
Our hearts be pure from evil,
That we may see aright
The Lord in rays eternal
Of resurrection light:
And, listening to His accents,
May hear, so calm and plain,
His own "All hail!"—and hearing,
May raise the victor strain.
Now let the heavens be!
Let earth her song begin!
Let the round world keep triumph,
And all that is therein:
In grateful exultation
Their notes let all things blend,
For Christ the Lord hath risen,
Our joy that hath no end.
––––––––––
Jesu, name all names above.
(!Ihsou' glukuvtate.)
By St. Theoctistus of the Studium.
Jesu, name all names above,
Jesu, best and dearest,
Jesu, Fount of perfect love,
Holiest, tenderest, nearest!
Jesu, source of grace completest,
Jesu truest, Jesu sweetest,
Jesu, Well of power divine,
Make me, keep me, seal me Thine!
Jesu, open me the gate
Which the sinner entered,
Who in his last dying state
Wholly on Thee ventured.
Thou whose wounds are ever pleading,
And Thy passion interceding,
From my misery let me rise
To a home in Paradise!
Thou didst call the prodigal;
Thou didst pardon Mary:
Thou whose words can never fall
Love can never vary,
Lord, amidst my lost condition
Give—for Thou canst give—contrition!
Thou canst pardon all mine ill
If Thou wilt: O say, "I will!"
Woe, that I have turned aside
After fleshly pleasure!
Woe, that I have never tried
For the heavenly treasure!
Treasure, safe in homes supernal;
Incorruptible, eternal!
Treasure no less price hath won
Than the Passion of the Son!
Jesu, crowned with thorns for me,
Scourged for my transgression!
Witnessing, through agony,
That Thy good confession;
Jesu, clad in purple raiment,
For my evils making payment;
Let not all thy woe and pain,
Let not Calvary be in vain!
When I reach Death’s bitter sea,
And its waves roll higher,
Help the more forsaking me,
As the storm draws nigher:
Jesu, leave me not to languish,
Helpless, hopeless, full of anguish!
Tell me,—"Verily, I say,
Thou shalt be with me to-day!"
Art thou weary?
(Kovpon te kai; kavmaton.)
By St. Stephen The Sabaite.
Art thou weary, art thou languid,
Art thou sore distrest?
"Come to me"—saith One—"and coming
Be at rest!"
Hath He marks to lead me to Him,
If He be my Guide?
"In His feet and hands are wound-prints,
And His side."
Is there diadem, as Monarch,
That His brow adorns?
"Yea, a crown in very surety,
But of thorns!"
If I find Him, if I follow,
What His guerdon here?
"Many a sorrow, many a labor,
Many a tear."
If I still hold closely to Him,
What hath He at last?
Sorrow vanquished, labor ended,
Jordan past!"
If I ask Him to receive me,
Will He say me nay?
Not till earth, and not till heaven
Pass away!"
Finding, following, keeping, struggling
Is He sure to bless?
Angels, martyrs, prophets, virgins,
Answer, Yes!"
§ 95. Latin Hymnody. Literature.
See vol. III. 585 sqq. The following list covers the whole mediaeval period of Latin hymnody.
I. Latin Collections.
The Breviaries and Missals. The hymnological collections of Clichtovaeus (Paris 1515, Bas. 1517 and 1519.), Cassander (Col. 1556), Ellinger (Frankf. a. M. 1578), Georg Fabricius (Poetarum Veterum ecclesiasticorum Opera, Bas. 1564). See the full titles of Breviaries and these older collections in Daniel, vol. I. XIII-XXII. and vol. II. VIII-XIV.
Cardinal Jos. Maria Thomasius (Tomasi, 1649–1713, one of the chief expounders of the liturgy and ceremonies of the Roman church): Opera Omnia. Rom. 1741 sqq., 7 vols. The second volume, p. 351–403, contains the Hymnarium de anni circulo, etc., for which he compared the oldest Vatican and other Italian MSS. of hymns down to the eighth century. The same vol. includes the Breviarium Psalterii. The fourth (1749) contains the Responsorialia et antiphonaria Romanae ecclesia, and the sixth vol. (1751) a collection of Missals. Thomasius is still very valuable. Daniel calls his book "fons primarius."
Aug. Jak. Rambach (Luth. Pastor in Hamburg, b. 1777, d. 1851): Anthologie christlicher Gesänge aus alien Jahrh. der christl. Kirche. Altona and Leipzig 1817–1833, 6 vols. The first vol. contains Latin hymns with German translations and notes. The other volumes contain only German hymns, especially since the Reformation. Rambach was a pioneer in hymnology.
Job. Kehrein (R.C.): Lat. Anthologie aus den christl. Dichtern des Mittelalters. Frankfurt a. m. 1840. See his larger work below.
[John Henry Newman, Anglican, joined the Rom. Ch. 1845]: Hymni Ecclesiae. Lond. (Macmillan) 1838; new ed. 1865 (401 pages). Contains only hymns from the Paris, Roman, and Anglican Breviaries. The preface to the first part is signed "J. H. N." and dated Febr. 21, 1838, but no name appears on the title page. About the same time Card. N. made his translations of Breviary hymns, which are noticed below, sub. III.
H. A. Daniel (Lutheran, d. 1871): Thesaurus Hymnologicus. Lips. 1841–1856, 5 Tomi. The first, second, fourth and fifth vols. contain Lat. hymns, the fourth Greek and Syrian h. A rich standard collection, but in need of revision
P. J. Mone (R. Cath. d. 1871): Lateinische Hymnen des Mittelalters. Freiburg i. B. 1853–’55, 3 vols. From MSS with notes. Contains in all 1215 hymns divided into three divisions of almost equal size; (1) Hymns to God and the angels (461 pages); (2) Hymns to the Virgin Mary, (457 pages); (3) Hymns to saints (579 pages).
D. Ozanam: Documents inédits pour servir a l’histoire littéraire de l’Italie. Paris 1850. Contains a collection of old Latin hymns, reprinted in Migne’s "Patrol. Lat." vol. 151, fol. 813–824.
Joseph Stevenson: Latin Hymns of the Anglo-Saxon Church; with an Interlinear Anglo-Saxon Gloss, from a MS. of the eleventh century in Durham Library. 1851 (Surtees Soc.).
J. M. Neale (Warden of Sackville College, high Anglican, d. 1866): Sequentiae ex Missalibus Germanicis, Anglicis, Gallicis, aliisque medii aevi collectae. Lond. 1852. 284 pages. Contains 125 sequences.
Felix Clément: Carmina e Poetis Christianis excerpta. Parisiis (Gaume Fratres) 1854. 564 pages. The Latin texts of hymns from the 4th to the 14th century, with French notes.
R. Ch. Trench (Archbishop of Dublin): Sacred Latin Poetry, chiefly Lyrical. Lond. and Cambridge, 1849; 2d ed. 1864; 3rd ed. revised and improved, 1874. (342 pages). With an instructive Introduction and notes.
Ans. Schubiger: Die Sängerschule St. Gallens vom 8ten bis 12ten Jahrh. Einsiedeln 1858. Gives sixty texts with the old music and facsimiles.
P. Gall Morel (R.C.): Lat. Hymnen des Mittelalters, grösstentheils aus Handschriften schweizerischer Klöster. Einsiedeln (Benziger) 1868 (341 pages). Mostly Marienlieder and Heiligenlieder (p. 30–325). Supplementary to Daniel and Mone.
Phil. Wackernagel (Luth., d. 1877): Das deutsche Kirchenlied von der ältesten Zeit bis zum Anfang des XVII. Jahrh. Leipz. 1864–1877, 5 vols. (the last vol. ed. by his two sons). This is the largest monumental collection of older German hymns; but the first vol. contains Latin hymns and sequences from the fourth to the sixteenth century.
Karl Bartsch (Prof of Germ. and Romanic philology in Rostock): Die lateinischen Sequenzen des Mittelalters in musikalischer und rhythmischer Beziehung dargestellt. Rostock 1868.
Chs. Buchanan Pierson: Sequences from the Sarum Missal. London 1871.
Joseph Kehrein (R.C.): Lateinische Sequenzen des Mittelalters aus Handschriften und Drucken. Mainz 1873 (620 pages). The most complete collection of Sequences (over 800). He divides the sequences, like Mone the hymns, according to the subject (Lieder an Gott, Engellieder, Marienlieder, Heiligenlieder). Comp. also his earlier work noticed above.
Francis A. March: Latin Hymns, with English Notes. N. York, 1874.
W. McIlvaine: Lyra Sacra Hibernica. Belfast, 1879. (Contains hymns of St. Patrick, Columba, and Sedulius).
E. Dümmler: Poëtae Latini Aevi Carolini. Berol. 1880–’84, 2 vols. Contains also hymns, II. p. 244–258.
Special editions of Adam of St. Victor: L. Gautier: La aeuvres poétiques d’ Adam de S. Victor. Par. 1858 and 1859, 2 vols. Digby S. Wrangham (of St. John’s College, Oxford): The Liturgical Poetry of Adam of St. Victor. Lond. 1881, 3 vols. (The Latin text of Gautier with E. Version in the original metres and with short notes). On the Dies Irae see the monograph of Lisco (Berlin 1840). It has often been separately published, e.g. by Franklin Johnson, Cambridge, Mass. 1883. So also the Stabat Mater, and the hymn of Bernard of Cluny De Contemptu Mundi (which furnished the thoughts for Neale’s New Jerusalem hymns). The hymns of St. Bernard, Abelard, Thomas Aquinas, Bonaventura, are in the complete editions of their works. For St. Bernard see Migne’s "Patrol. Lat." vol. 184, fol. 1307–1330; for Abelard, vol. 178, fol. 1759–1824.
II. Historical and Critical.
Polyc. Leyser: Historia Poëtarum et Poëmatum Medii Aevi. Halae 1721.
Friedr. Münter: Ueber die älteste christl. Poesie. Kopenhagen 1806.
Edélstand Du Méril: Poésies populaires Latines anterieures au douzième siècle. Paris 1843. Poésies populaire’s Latines du moyen âge. Paris 1847.
Trench: Introd. to his S. Lat. Poetry. See above.
Baehr: Die christl. Dichter und Geschichtschreiber Roms. Karlsruhe 1836 , 2nd ed., revised, 1872 (with bibliography).
Edward Emil Koch: Geschichte des Kirchenlieds und Kirchengesangs in der christlichen, insbesondere der deutschen evangel. Kirche. Stuttgart, third ed. rev. and enlarged 1866–1876, 7 vols. This very instructive and valuable work treats of Latin hymnology, but rather superficially, in vol. I. 40–153.
Ad. Ebert: Allgem. Gesch. der Lit. des Mittelalters im Abendlande, vol. I. (Leipz. 1874), the third book (p. 516 sqq.), and vol. II. (1880) which embraces the age of Charlemagne and his successors.
Joh. Kayser (R.C.): Beiträge zur Geschichte und Erklärung der ältesten Kirchenhymnen. Paderborn, 2d ed. 1881. 477 pages, comes down only to the sixth century and closes with Fortunatus. See also his article Der Text des Hymnus Stabat Mater dolorosa, in the Tübingen "Theol. Quartalschrift" for 1884, No. I. p. 85–103.
III. English translations.
John Chandler (Anglican, d. July 1, 1876): The Hymns of the Primitive Church, now first collected, translated and arranged. London 1837. Contains 108 Latin hymns with Chandler’s translations.
Richard Mant (Lord Bishop of Down and Connor, d. Nov. 2, 1848): Ancient Hymns from the Roman Breviary. 1837. New ed. Lond. and Oxf. 1871. (272 pages)
John Henry Newman:] Verses on Various Occasions. London 1868 (reprinted in Boston, by Patrick Donahue). The Preface is dated Dec. 21, 1867, and signed J. H. N. The book contains the original poems of the Cardinal, and his translations of the Roman Breviary Hymns and two from the Parisian Breviary, which, as stated in a note on p. 186, were all made in 1836–38, i.e. eight years before he left the Church of England.
Isaac Williams (formerly of Trinity College, Oxford, d. 1865): Hymns translated from the Parisian Breviary. London 1839.
Edward Caswall (Anglican, joined the R.C. Church 1847, d. Jan. 2, 1878): Lyra Catholica. Containing all the Breviary and Missal Hymns together with some other hymns. Lond. 1849. (311 pages). Reprinted N. Y. 1851. Admirable translations. They are also included in his Hymns and Poems, original and translated. London 2d ed. 1873.
John David Chambers (Recorder of New Sarum): Lauda Syon. Ancient Latin Hymns in the English and other Churches, translated into corresponding metres. Lond. 1857 (116 pages.)
J. M. Neale: Mediaeval Hymns and Sequences. Lond. 1862; 3d ed. 1867. (224 pages). Neale is the greatest master of free reproduction of Latin as well as Greek hymns. He published also separately his translation of the new Jerusalem hymns: The Rhythm of Bernard de Morlaix, Monk of Cluny, on the Celestial Country. Lond. 1858, 7th ed. 1865, with the Latin text as far as translated (48 pages). Also Stabat Mater Speciosa, Full of Beauty stood the Mother (1866).
The Seven Great Hymns of the Mediaeval Church. N. York (A. D. F. Randolph & Co.) 1866; seventh ed. enlarged, 1883. 154 pages. This anonymous work (by Judge C. C. Nott, Washington) contains translations by various authors of Bernard’s Celestial Country, the Dies Irae, the Mater Dolorosa, the Mater Speciosa, the Veni Sancte Spiritus, the Veni Creator Spiritus, the Vexilla Regis, and the Alleluiatic Sequence of Godescalcus. The originals are also given.
Philip Schaff: Christ in Song. N. Y. 1868; Lond. 1869. Contains translations of seventy-three Latin hymns by various authors.
W. H. Odenheimer and Frederic M. Bird: Songs of the Spirit. N. York 1871. Contains translations of twenty-three Latin hymns on the Holy Spirit, with a much larger number of English hymns. Erastus C. Benedict (Judge in N. Y., d. 1878): The Hymn of Hildebert and other Mediaeval Hymns, with translations. N. York 1869.
Abraham Coles (M. D.): Latin Hymns, with Original Translations. N. York 1868. Contains 13 translations of the Dies Irae, which were also separately published in 1859.
Hamilton M. Macgill, D. D. (of the United Presb. Ch. of Scotland): Songs of the Christian Creed and Life selected from Eighteen Centuries. Lond. and Edinb. 1879. Contains translations of a number of Latin and a few Greek hymns with the originals, also translations of English hymns into Latin.
The Roman Breviary. Transl. out of Latin into English by John Marquess of Bute, K. T. Edinb. and Lond. 1879, 2 vols. The best translations of the hymns scattered through this book are by the ex-Anglicans Caswall and Cardinal Newman. The Marquess of Bute is himself a convert to Rome from the Church of England.
D. F. Morgan: Hymns and other Poetry of the Latin Church. Oxf. 1880. 100 versions arranged according to the Anglican Calendar.
Edward A. Washburn (Rector of Calvary Church, N. Y. d. Feb. 2, 1881): Voices from a Busy Life. N. York 1883. Contains, besides original poems, felicitous versions of 32 Latin hymns, several of which had appeared before in Schaff’s Christ in Song.
Samuel W. Duffield: The Latin Hymn Writers and their Hymns (in course of preparation and to be published, New York 1885. This work will cover the entire range of Latin hymnology, and include translations of the more celebrated hymns).
- German translations of Latin hymns: (Mostly accompanied by the original text) are very numerous, e.g. by Rambach, 1817 sqq. (see above); C. Fortlage (Gesänge christl. Vorzeit, 1844); Karl Simrock (Lauda Sion, 1850); Ed. Kauffer (Jesus-Hymnen, Sammlung altkirchl. lat. Gesänge, etc. Leipz. 1854, 65 pages); H. Stadelmann (Altchristl. Hymnen und Lieder. Augsb. 1855); Bässler (1858); J. Fr. H. Schlosser (Die Kirche in ihren Liedern, Freiburg i. B. 1863, 2 vols); G. A. Königsfeld (Lat. Hymnen und Gesänge, Bonn 1847, new series, 1865, both with the original and notes).
§ 96. Latin Hymns and Hymnists.
The Latin church poetry of the middle ages is much better known than the Greek, and remains to this day a rich source of devotion in the Roman church and as far as poetic genius and religious fervor are appreciated. The best Latin hymns have passed into the Breviary and Missal (some with misimprovements), and have been often reproduced in modern languages. The number of truly classical hymns, however, which were inspired by pure love to Christ and can be used with profit by Christians of every name, is comparatively small. The poetry of the Latin church is as full of Mariolatry and hagiolatry as the poetry of the Greek church. It is astonishing what an amount of chivalrous and enthusiastic devotion the blessed Mother of our Lord absorbed in the middle ages. In Mone’s collection the hymns to the Virgin fill a whole volume of 457 pages, the hymns to saints another volume of 579 pages, while the first volume of only 461 pages is divided between hymns to God and to the angels. The poets intended to glorify Christ through his mother, but the mother overshadows the child, as in the pictures of the Madonna. She was made the mediatrix of all divine grace, and was almost substituted for Christ, who was thought to occupy a throne of majesty too high for sinful man to reach without the aid of his mother and her tender human sympathies. She is addressed with every epithet of praise, as Mater Dei, Dei Genitrix, Mater summi Domini, Mater misericordiae, Mater bonitatis, Mater dolorosa, Mater jucundosa, Mater speciosa, Maris Stella, Mundi domina, Mundi spes, Porta paradisi, Regina coeli, Radix gratiae, Virgo virginum, Virgo regia Dei. Even the Te Deum was adapted to her by the distinguished St. Bonaventura so as to read "Te Matrem laudamus, Te Virginem confitemur."(50)
The Latin, as the Greek, hymnists were nearly all monks; but an emperor (Charlemagne?) and a king (Robert of France) claim a place of honor among them.
The sacred poetry of the Latin church may be divided into three periods: 1, The patristic period from Hilary (d. 368) and Ambrose (d. 397) to Venantius Fortunatus (d. about 609) and Gregory I. (d. 604); 2, the early mediaeval period to Peter Damiani (d. 1072); 3, the classical period to the thirteenth century. The first period we have considered in a previous volume. Its most precious legacy to the church universal is the Te Deum laudamus. It is popularly ascribed to Ambrose of Milan (or Ambrose and Augustin jointly), but in its present completed form does not appear before the first half of the sixth century, although portions of it may be traced to earlier Greek origin; it is, like the Apostles’ Creed, and the Greek Gloria in Excelsis, a gradual growth of the church rather than the production of any individual.(51) The third period embraces the greatest Latin hymnists, as Bernard of Morlaix (monk of Cluny about 1150), Bernard of Clairvaux (d. 1153), Adam of St. Victor (d. 1192), Bonaventura (d. 1274), Thomas Aquinas (d. 1274), Thomas a Celano (about 1250), Jacopone (d. 1306), and produced the last and the best Catholic hymns which can never die, as Hora Novisasima; Jesu dulcis memoria; Salve caput cruentatum; Stabat Mater; and Dies Irae. In this volume we are concerned with the second period.
Venantius Fortunatus, of Poitiers, and his cotemporary, Pope Gregory I., form the transition from the patristic poetry of Sedulius and Prudentius to the classic poetry of the middle ages.
Fortunatus (about 600)(52) was the fashionable poet of his day. A native Italian, he emigrated to Gaul, travelled extensively, became intimate with St. Gregory of Tours, and the widowed queen Radegund when she lived in ascetic retirement, and died as bishop of Poitiers. He was the first master of the trochaic tetrameter, and author of three hundred poems, chief among which are the two famous passion hymns:
"Vexilla regis prodeunt,"
"The Royal Banners forward go;"
and
"Pange, lingua, gloriosi proelium certaminis,"
"Sing, my tongue, the glorious battle."
Both have a place in the Roman Breviary.(53)
Gregory I. (d. 604), though far inferior to Fortunatus in poetic genius, occupies a prominent rank both in church poetry and church music. He followed Ambrose in the metrical form, the prayer-like tone, and the churchly spirit, and wrote for practical use. He composed about a dozen hymns, several of which have found a place in the Roman Breviary.(54) The best is his Sunday hymn:
"Primo dierum omnium,"
"On this first day when heaven on earth,"
or, as it has been changed in the Breviary,
"Primo die quo Trinitas,"
"To-day the Blessed Three in One
Began the earth and skies;
To-day a Conqueror, God the Son,
Did from the grave arise;
We too will wake, and, in despite
Of sloth and languor, all unite,
As Psalmists bid, through the dim night
Waiting with wistful eyes."(55)
The Venerable Bede (d. 735) wrote a beautiful ascension hymn
"Hymnum canamus gloriae,"
"A hymn of glory let us sing;"
and a hymn for the Holy innocents,
"Hymnum canentes Martyrum,"
"The hymn of conquering martyrs raise."(56)
Rabanus Maurus, a native of Mainz (Mayence) on the Rhine, a pupil of Alcuin, monk and abbot in the convent of Fulda, archbishop of Mainz from 847 to 856, was the chief Poet of the Carolingian age, and the first German who wrote Latin hymns. Some of them have passed into the Breviary.(57)
He is probably the author of the pentecostal Veni, Creator Spiritus.(58) It outweighs all his other poems. It is one of the classical Latin hymns, and still used in the Catholic church on the most solemn occasions, as the opening of Synods, the creating of popes and the crowning of kings. It was invested with a superstitious charm. It is the only Breviary hymn which passed into the Anglican liturgy as part of the office for ordaining priests and consecrating bishops.(59) The authorship has been variously ascribed to Charlemagne,(60) to Gregory the Great,(61) also to Alcuin, and even to Ambrose, without any good reason. It appears first in 898, is found in the MS. containing the Poems of Rabanus Maurus, and in all the old German Breviaries; it was early and repeatedly translated into German(62) and agrees very well in thought and expression with his treatise on the Holy Spirit.(63)
We give the original with two translations.(64)
*Veni, Creator Spiritus,
Mentes tuorum visita.
Imple superna gratia
Quo tu creasti pectora.*
Creator, Spirit, Lord of Grace,
O make our hearts Thy dwelling-place,
And with Thy might celestial aid
The souls of those whom Thou hast made.
*Qui Paracletus diceris,
Donum Dei altissimi,
Fons vivus, ignis, charitas,
Et spiritalis unctio.*
Come from the throne of God above,
O Paraclete, O Holy Dove,
Come, Oil of gladness, cleansing Fire,
And Living Spring of pure desire.
*Tu septiformis munere,
Dextrae Dei tu digitus,
Tu rite Promissum Patris,
Sermone ditans guttura.*
O Finger of the Hand Divine,
The sevenfold gifts of Grace are Thine,
And touched by Thee the lips proclaim
All praise to God’s most holy Name.
*Accende lumen sensibus,
Infunde amorem cordibus;
Infirma nostri corporis,
Virtute firmans perpetim.*(65)
Then to our souls Thy light impart,
And give Thy Love to every heart
Turn all our weakness into might,
O Thou, the Source of Life and Light.
*Hostem repellas longius,
Pacemque dones protinus.
Ductore sic te praevio,
Vitemus omne noxium.*
Protect us from the assailing foe,
And Peace, the fruit of Love, bestow;
Upheld by Thee, our Strength and Guide,
No evil can our steps betide.
*Per te sciamus, da Patrem,
Noscamus atque Filium,
Te utriusque Spiritum,
Credamus omni tempore.*
Spirit of Faith, on us bestow
The Father and the Son to know;
And, of the Twain, the Spirit, Thee;
Eternal One, Eternal Three.
[*Sit laus Patri cum Filio,
Sancto simul Paracleto,
Nobisque mittat Filius
Charisma Sancti Spiritus*.](66)
To God the Father let us sing;
To God the Son, our risen King;
And equally with These adore
The Spirit, God for evermore.
[*Praesta hoc Pater piissime,
Patrique compar unice,
Cum Spiritu Paracleto,
Regnans per omne saeculum*.] See note above.
O Holy Ghost, Creator come!
Thy people's minds pervade;
And fill, with Thy supernatural grace,
The souls which Thou hast made.
Kindle our senses to a flame,
And fill our hearts with love,
And, through our bdies' weakness,
still
Pour valor from above!
Thou who art called the Paraclete,
The gift of God most high–
Thou living fount, and fire and love,
Our spirit's pure ally;
Drive further off our enemy,
And straightway give us peace;
That with Thyself as such a guide,
We may from evil cease.
Thou sevenfold giver of all good;
Finger of God's right hand;
Thou promise of the Father, rich
In words for every land;
Through Thee may we the Father
know,
And thus confess the Son;
For Thee, from both the Holy
Ghost,
We praise while time shall run.
In this connection we mention the Veni, Sancte Spiritus, the other great pentecostal hymn of the middle ages. It is generally ascribed to King Robert of France (970–1031), the son and success or of Hugh Capet.(67) He was distinguished for piety and charity, like his more famous successor, St. Louis IX., and better fitted for the cloister than the throne. He was disciplined by the pope (998) for marrying a distant cousin, and obeyed by effecting a divorce. He loved music and poetry, founded convents and churches, and supported three hundred paupers. His hymn reveals in terse and musical language an experimental knowledge of the gifts and operations of the Holy Spirit upon the heart. It is superior to the companion hymn, Veni, Creator Spiritus. Trench calls it "the loveliest" of all the Latin hymns, but we would give this praise rather to St. Bernard’s Jesu dulcis memoria ("Jesus, the very thought of Thee"). The hymn contains ten half-stanzas of three lines each with a refrain in ium. Each line has seven syllables, and ends with a double or triple rhyme; the third line rhymes with the third line of the following half-stanza. Neale has reproduced the double ending of each third line (as "brilliancy"—"radiancy").
*Veni, Sancte Spiritus,
Et emittee coelitus
Lucis tuae radium.*
Holy Spirit, God of light!
Come, and on our inner sight
Pour Thy bright and heavenly ray!
*Veni, Pater pauperum,
Veni, dator munerum,
Veni, lumen cordium.*
Father of the lowly! come;
Here, Great Giver! be Thy home,
Sunshine of our hearts, for aye!
*Consolator optime,
Dulcis hospes animae,
Dulce refrigerium:*
Inmost Comforter and best!
Of our souls the dearest Guest,
Sweetly all their thirst allay;
*In labore requies,
In aestu temperies,
In fletu solatium.*
In our toils be our retreat,
Be our shadow in the heat,
Come and wipe our tears away.
*O lux beatissima,
Reple cordis intima,
Tuorum fidelium.*
O Thou Light, all pure and blest!
Fill with joy this weary breast,
Turning darkness into day.
*Sine tuo numine
Nihil est in homine
Nihil est innoxium,*
For without Thee nought we find,
Pure or strong in human kind,
Nought that has not gone astray.
*Lava quod est sordidum,
Riga quod est aridum,
Sana quod est saucium.*
Wash us from the stains of sin,
Gently soften all within,
Wounded spirits heal and stay.
*Flecte quod est rigidum,
Fove quod est languidum,
Rege quod est devium.*
What is hard and stubborn bend,
What is feeble soothe and tend,
What is erring gently sway.
*Da tuis fidelibus,
In te confitentibus,
Sacrum septenarium;*
To Thy faithful servants give,
Taught by Thee to trust and live,
Sevenfold blessing from this day;
*Da virtutis meritum,
Da salutis exitum,
Da perenne gaudium*.(68)
Make our title clear, we pray,
When we drop this mortal clay;
Then,—O give us joy for aye.489
The following is a felicitous version by an American divine.(69)
Come, O Spirit! Fount of grace!
From thy heavenly dwelling-place
One bright morning beam impart:
Come, O Father of the poor;
Come, O Source of bounties sure;
Come, O Sunshine of the heart!
O! thrice blessed light divine!
Come, the spirit’s inmost shrine
With Thy holy presence fill;
Of Thy brooding love bereft,
Naught to hopeless man is left;
Naught is his but evil still.
Comforter of man the best!
Making the sad soul thy guest;
Sweet refreshing in our fears,
In our labor a retreat,
Cooling shadow in the heat,
Solace in our falling tears.
Wash away each earthly stain,
Flow o’er this parched waste again,
Real the wounds of conscience sore,
Bind the stubborn will within,
Thaw the icy chains of sin,
Guide us, that we stray no more.
Give to Thy believers, give,
In Thy holy hope who live,
All Thy sevenfold dower of love;
Give the sure reward of faith,
Give the love that conquers death,
Give unfailing joy above.
Notker, surnamed the Older, or Balbulus ("the little Stammerer, "from a slight lisp in his speech), was born about 850 of a noble family in Switzerland, educated in the convent of St. Gall, founded by Irish missionaries, and lived there as an humble monk. He died about 912, and was canonized in 1512.(70)
He is famous as the reputed author of the Sequences (Sequentiae), a class of hymns in rythmical prose, hence also called Proses (Prosae). They arose from the custom of prolonging the last syllable in singing the Allelu-ia of the Gradual, between the Epistle and the Gospel, while the deacon was ascending from the altar to the rood-loft (organ-loft), that he might thence sing the Gospel. This prolongation was called jubilatio or jubilus, or laudes, on account of its jubilant tone, and sometimes sequentia (Greek ajkolouqiva), because it followed the reading of the Epistle or the Alleluia. Mystical interpreters made this unmeaning prolongation of a mere sound the echo of the jubilant music of heaven. A further development was to set words to these notes in rythmical prose for chanting. The name sequence was then applied to the text and in a wider sense also to regular metrical and rhymed hymns. The book in which Sequences were collected was called Sequentiale.(71)
Notker marks the transition from the unmeaning musical sequence to the literary or poetic sequence. Over thirty poems bear his name. His first, attempt begins with the line
"Laudes Deo concinat orbis ubique totus."
More widely circulated is his Sequence of the Holy Spirit:
"Sancti Spiritus adsit nobis gratia."
"The grace of the Holy Spirit be present with us."(72)
The best of all his compositions, which is said to have been inspired by the sight of the builders of a bridge over an abyss in the Martinstobe, is a meditation on death (Antiphona de morte):
"Media vita in morte sumus:
Quem quaerimus adiutorem nisi te, Domine,
Qui pro peccatis nostris juste irasceris?
Sancte Deus, sancte fortis,
Sancte et misericors Salvator:
Amarae morti ne tradas nos."(73)
This solemn prayer is incorporated in many burial services. In the Book of Common Prayer it is thus enlarged:
"In the midst of life we be in death:
Of whom may we seek for succour, but of Thee,
O Lord, which for our sins justly art moved?
Yet, O Lord God most holy, O Lord most mighty,
O holy and most merciful Saviour,
Deliver us not into the bitter pains of eternal death.
Thou knowest, Lord, the secrets of our hearts.
Shut not up thy merciful eyes to our prayers:
But spare us, Lord most holy,
O God most mighty,
O holy and merciful Saviour,
Thou most worthy Judge eternal,
Suffer us not, at our last hour,
For any pains of death,
To fall from Thee."(74)
Peter Damiani (d. 1072), a friend of Hildebrand and promoter of his hierarchical refrms, wrote a solemn hymn on the day of death:
"Gravi me terrore pulsas vitae dies ultima,"(75)
"With what heavy fear thou smitest."
He is perhaps also the author of the better known descriptive poem on the Glory and Delights of Paradise, which is usually assigned to St. Augustin:
"Ad perennis vitae fontem mens sitivit arida,
Claustra carnis praesto frangi clausa quaerit anima:
Gliscit, ambit, eluctatur exsul frui patria."(76)
The subordinate hymn-writers of our period are the following:(77)
Isidor of Seville (Isidoris Hispalensis, 560–636). A hymn on St. Agatha: "Festum insigne prodiit."
Cyxilla of Spain. Hymnus de S. Thurso et sociis: Exulta nimium turba fidelium."
Eugenius of Toledo. Oratio S. Eugenii Toletani Episcopi: "Rex Deus."
Paulus Diaconus (720–800), of Monte Casino, chaplain of Charlemagne, historian of the Lombards, and author of a famous collection of homilies. On John the Baptist ("Ut queant laxis),(78) and on the Miracles of St. Benedict (Fratres alacri pectore).
Odo of Cluny (d. 941). A hymn on St. Mary Magdalene day, "Lauda, Mater Ecclesiae," translated by Neale: "Exalt, O mother Church, to-day, The clemency of Christ, thy Lord." It found its way into the York Breviary.
Godescalcus (Gottschalk, d. about 950, not to be confounded with his predestinarian namesake, who lived in the ninth century), is next to Notker, the best writer of sequences or proses, as "Laus Tibi, Christe" ("Praise be to Thee, O Christ"), and Coeli enarrant ("The heavens declare the glory"), both translated by Neale.
Fulbert Of Chartres (died about 1029) wrote a paschal hymn adopted in several Breviaries: "Chorus novae Jerusalem" ("Ye choirs of New Jerusalem"), translated by Neale.
A few of the choicest hymns of our period, from the sixth to the twelfth century are anonymous.(79) To these belong:
"Hymnum dicat turba fratrum." A morning hymn mentioned by Bede as a fine specimen of the trochaic tetrameter.
"Sancti venite." A communion hymn.
"Urbs beata Jerusalem."(80) It is from the eighth century, and one of those touching New Jerusalem hymns which take their inspiration from the last chapter of St. John’s Apocalypse, and express the Christian’s home-sickness after heaven. The following is the first stanza (with Neale’s translation):
"Urbs beata Jerusalem,
Dicta pacis visio,
Quae construitur in coelo
Vivis ex lapidibus,
Et angelis coronata
Ut sponsata comite."
Blessed City, Heavenly Salem,
Vision dear of Peace and Love,
Who, of living stones upbuilded,
Art the joy of Heav'n above,
And, with angel cohorts circled,
As a bride to earth dost move!"
"Apparebit repentina." An alphabetic and acrostic poem on the Day of Judgment, based on Matt. 25:31–36; from the seventh century; first mentioned by Bede, then long lost sight of; the forerunner of the Dies Irae, more narrative than lyrical, less sublime and terrific, but equally solemn. The following are the first lines in Neale’s admirable translation:(81)
"That great Day of wrath and terror,
That last Day of woe and doom,
Like a thief that comes at midnight,
On the sons of men shall come;
When the pride and pomp of ages
All shall utterly have passed,
And they stand in anguish, owning
That the end is here at last;
And the trumpet’s pealing clangor,
Through the earth’s four quarters spread,
Waxing loud and ever louder,
Shall convoke the quick and dead:
And the King of heavenly glory
Shall assume His throne on high,
And the cohorts of His angels
Shall be near Him in the sky:
And the sun shall turn to sackcloth,
And the moon be red as blood,
And the stars shall fall from heaven,
Whelm’d beneath destruction’s flood.
Flame and fire, and desolation
At the Judge’s feet shall go:
Earth and sea, and all abysses
Shall His mighty sentence know."
"Ave, Maris Stella." This is the favorite mediaeval Mary hymn, and perhaps the very best of the large number devoted to the worship of the "Queen of heaven," which entered so deeply into the piety and devotion of the Catholic church both in the East and the West. It is therefore given here in full with the version of Edward Caswall.(82)
"Ave, Maris Stella,(83)
*Dei Mater alma
Atque semper Virgo,
Felix coeli porta*.
Hail, thou Star-of-Ocean,
Portal of the sky,
Ever-Virgin Mother
Of the Lord Most High!
*Sumens illud Ave
Gabrielis ore,
Funda nos in pace,
Mutans nomen Evae*.(84)
Oh, by Gabriel’s Ave
Uttered long ago
Eva’s name reversing,
’Stablish peace below!
*Solve vincla reis
Profer lumen coecis,
Mala nostra pelle,
Bona cuncta posce*.
Break the captive’s fetters,
Light on blindness pour,
All our ills expelling,
Every bliss implore.
Monstra te esse matrem,(85)
*Sumat per te precem,
Qui pro nobis natus
Tulit esse tuus.*
Show thyself a mother,
Offer Him our sighs,
Who, for us Incarnate,
Did not thee despise.
*Virgo singularis,
Inter omnes mitis,
Nos culpis solutos
Mites facet castos.*
Virgin of all virgins!
To thy shelter take us—
Gentlest of the gentle!
Chaste and gentle make us.
*Vitam praesta puram
Iter para tutum,
Ut videntes Iesum
Semper collaetemur.*
Still as on we journey,
Help our weak endeavor,
Till with thee and Jesus,
We rejoice for ever.
*Sit laus Deo Patri,
Summo Christo decus,
Spiritui Sancto
Honor trinus et unus.*
Through the highest heaven
To the Almighty Three,
Father, Son, and Spirit,
One same glory be.
The Latin hymnody was only, for priests and monks, and those few who understood the Latin language. The people listened to it as they do to the mass, and responded with the Kyrie eleison, Christe eleison, which passed from the Greek church into the Western litanies. As the modern languages of Europe developed themselves out of the Latin, and out of the Teutonic, a popular poetry arose during the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries, and afterwards received a powerful impulse from the Reformation. Since that time the Protestant churches, especially in Germany and England, have produced the richest hymnody, which speaks to the heart of the people in their own familiar tongue, and is, next to the Psalter, the chief feeder of public and private devotion. In this body of evangelical hymns the choicest Greek and Latin hymns in various translations, reproductions, and transformations occupy an honored place and serve as connecting links between past and modern times in the worship of the same God and Saviour.
§ 97. The Seven Sacraments.
Mediaeval Christianity was intensely sacramental, sacerdotal and hierarchical. The ideas of priest, sacrifice, and altar are closely connected. The sacraments were regarded as the channels of all grace and the chief food of the soul. They accompanied human life from the cradle to the grave. The child was saluted into this world by the sacrament of baptism; the old man was provided with the viaticum on his journey to the other world.
The chief sacraments were baptism and the eucharist. Baptism was regarded as the sacrament of the new birth which opens the door to the kingdom of heaven the eucharist as the sacrament of sanctification which maintains and nourishes the new life.
Beyond these two sacraments several other rites were dignified with that name, but there was no agreement as to the number before the scholastic period. The Latin sacramentum, like the Greek mystery (of which it is the translation in the Vulgate), was long used in a loose and indefinite way for sacred and mysterious doctrines and rites. Rabanus Maurus and Paschasius Radbertus count four sacraments, Dionysius Areopagita, six; Damiani, as many as twelve. By the authority chiefly of Peter the Lombard and Thomas Aquinas the sacred number seven was at last determined upon, and justified by various analogies with the number of virtues, and the number of sins, and the necessities of human life.(86)
But seven sacraments existed as sacred rites long before the church was agreed on the number. We find them with only slight variations independently among the Greeks under the name of "mysteries" as well as among the Latins. They are, besides baptism and the eucharist (which is a sacrifice as well as a sacrament): confirmation, penance (confession and absolution), marriage, ordination, and extreme unction.
Confirmation was closely connected with baptism as a sort of supplement. It assumed a more independent character in the case of baptized infants and took place later. It may be performed in the Greek church by any priest, in the Latin only by the bishop.(87)
Penance was deemed necessary for sins after baptism.(88)
Ordination is the sacrament of the hierarchy and indispensable for the government of the church.
Marriage lies at the basis of the family and society in church and state, and was most closely and jealously guarded by the church against facility of divorce, against mixed marriages, and marriages between near relatives.
Extreme unction with prayer (first mentioned among the sacraments by a synod of Pavia in 850, and by Damiani) was the viaticum for the departure into the other world, and based on the direction of St. James 5:14, 15 (Comp. Mark 6:13; 16:18). At first it was applied in every sickness, by layman as well as priest, as a medical cure and as a substitute for amulets and forms of incantation; but the Latin church afterwards confined it to of extreme danger.
The efficacy of the sacrament was defined by the scholastic term ex opere operato, that is, the sacrament has its intended effect by virtue of its institution and inherent power, independently of the moral character of the priest and of the recipient, provided only that it be performed in the prescribed manner and with the proper intention and provided that the recipient throw no obstacle in the way.(89)
Three of the Sacraments, namely baptism, confirmation, and ordination, have in addition the effect of conferring an indelible character.(90) Once baptized always baptized, though the benefit may be forfeited for ever; once ordained always ordained, though a priest may be deposed and excommunicated.
§ 98. The Organ and the Bell.
To the external auxiliaries of worship were added the organ and the bell.
The Organ,(91) in the sense of a particular instrument (which dates from the time of St. Augustin), is a development of the Syrinx or Pandean pipe, and in its earliest form consisted of a small box with a row of pipes in the top, which were inflated by the performer with the mouth through means of a tube at one end. It has in the course of time undergone considerable improvements. The use of organs in churches is ascribed to Pope Vitalian (657–672). Constantine Copronymos sent an organ with other presents to King Pepin of France in 767. Charlemagne received one as a present from the Caliph Haroun al Rashid, and had it put up in the cathedral of Aix-la-Chapelle. The art of organ-building was cultivated chiefly in Germany. Pope John VIII. (872–882) requested Bishop Anno of Freising to send him an organ and an organist.
The attitude of the churches towards the organ varies. It shared to some extent the fate of images, except that it never was an object of worship. The poetic legend which Raphael has immortalized by one of his master-pieces, ascribes its invention to St. Cecilia, the patron of sacred music. The Greek church disapproves the use of organs. The Latin church introduced it pretty generally, but not without the protest of eminent men, so that even in the Council of Trent a motion was made, though not carried, to prohibit the organ at least in the mass. The Lutheran church retained, the Calvinistic churches rejected it, especially in Switzerland and Scotland; but in recent times the opposition has largely ceased.(92)
The Bell is said to have been invented by Paulinus of Nola (d. 431) in Campania;(93) but he never mentions it in his description of churches. Various sonorous instruments were used since the time of Constantine the Great for announcing the commencement of public worship. Gregory of Tours mentions a "signum" for calling monks to prayer. The Irish used chiefly hand-bells from the time of St. Patrick, who himself distributed them freely. St. Columba is reported to have gone to church when the bell rang (pulsante campana) at midnight. Bede mentions the bell for prayer at funerals. St. Sturm of Fulda ordered in his dying hours all the bells of the convent to be rung (779). In the reign of Charlemagne the use of bells was common in the empire. He encouraged the art of bel-founding, and entertained bell-founders at his court. Tancho, a monk of St. Gall, cast a fine bell, weighing from four hundred to five hundred pounds, for the cathedral at Aix-la-Chapelle. In the East, church bells are not mentioned before the end of the ninth century.
Bells, like other church-furniture, were consecrated for sacred use by liturgical forms of benediction. They were sometimes even baptized; but Charlemagne, in a capitulary of 789, forbids this abuse.(94) The office of bell-ringers(95) was so highly esteemed in that age that even abbots and bishops coveted it. Popular superstition ascribed to bells a magical effect in quieting storms and expelling pestilence. Special towers were built for them.(96) The use of church bells is expressed in the old lines which are inscribed in many of them:
"Lauda Deum verum, plebem voco, congrego clerum,
Defunctos ploro, pestem fugo, festaque honoro."(97)
§ 99. The Worship of Saints.
Comp. vol. III. §§ 81–87 (p. 409–460).
The Worship of Saints, handed down from the Nicene age, was a Christian substitute for heathen idolatry and hero-worship, and well suited to the taste and antecedents of the barbarian races, but was equally popular among the cultivated Greeks. The scholastics made a distinction between three grades of worship: 1) adoration (latreiva), which belongs to God alone; 2) veneration (douleiva), which is due to the saints as those whom God himself has honored, and who reign with him in heaven; 3) special veneration (uJperdouleiva), which is due to the Virgin Mary as the mother of the Saviour and the queen of all saints. But the people did not always mind this distinction, and the priests rather encouraged the excesses of saint-worship. Prayers were freely addressed to the saints, though not as the givers of the blessings desired, but as intercessors and advocates. Hence the form "Pray for us" (Ora pro nobis).
The number of saints and their festivals multiplied very rapidly. Each nation, country, province or city chose its patron saint, as Peter and Paul in Rome, St. Ambrose in Milan, St. Martin, St. Denys (Dionysius) and St. Germain in France, St. George in England, St. Patrick in Ireland, St. Boniface in Germany, and especially the Virgin Mary, who has innumerable localities and churches under her care and protection. The fact of saintship was at first decided by the voice of the people, which was obeyed as the voice of God. Great and good men and women who lived in the odor of sanctity and did eminent service to the cause of religion as missionaries or martyrs or bishops or monks or nuns, were gratefully remembered after their death; they became patron saints of the country or province of their labors and sufferings, and their worship spread gradually over the entire church. Their relics were held sacred; their tombs were visited by pilgrims. The metropolitans usually decided on the claims of saintship for their province down to a.d. 1153.(98) But to check the increase and to prevent mistakes, the popes, since Alexander III. a.d. 1170, claimed the exclusive right of declaring the fact, and prescribing the worship of a saint throughout the whole (Latin) Catholic church.(99) This was done by a solemn act called canonization. From this was afterwards distinguished the act of beatification, which simply declares that a departed Catholic Christian is blessed (beatus) in heaven, and which within certain limits permits (but does not prescribe) his veneration.(100)
The first known example of a papal canonization is the canonization of Ulrich, bishop of Augsburg (d. 973), by John XV. who, at a Lateran synod composed of nineteen dignitaries, in 993, declared him a saint at the request of Luitolph (Leuthold), his successor in the see of Augsburg, after hearing his report in person on the life and miracles of Ulrich. His chief merit was the deliverance of Southern Germany from the invasion of the barbarous Magyars, and his devotion to the interests of his large diocese. He used to make tours of visitation on an ox-cart, surrounded by a crowd of beggars and cripples. He made two pilgrimages to Rome, the second in his eighty-first year, and died as an humble penitent on the bare floor. The bull puts the worship of the saints on the ground that it redounds to the glory of Christ who identifies himself with his saints, but it makes no clear distinction between the different degrees of worship. It threatens all who disregard this decree with the anathema of the apostolic see.(101)
A mild interpretation of the papal prerogative of canonization reduces it to a mere declaration of a fact preceded by a careful examination of the merits of a case before the Congregation of Rites. But nothing short of a divine revelation can make such a fact known to mortal man. The examination is conducted by a regular process of law in which one acts as Advocatus Diaboli or accuser of the candidate for canonization, and another as Advocatus Dei. Success depends on the proof that the candidate must have possessed the highest sanctity and the power of working miracles either during his life, or through his dead bones, or through invocation of his aid. A proverb says that it requires a miracle to prove a miracle. Nevertheless it is done by papal decree on such evidence as is satisfactory to Roman Catholic believers.(102)
The question, how the saints and the Virgin Mary can hear so many thousands of prayers addressed to them simultaneously in so many different places, without being clothed with the divine attributes of omniscience and omnipresence, did not disturb the faith of the people. The scholastic divines usually tried to solve it by the assumption that the saints read those prayers in the omniscient mind of God. Then why not address God directly?
In addition to the commemoration days of particular saints, two festivals were instituted for the commemoration of all the departed.
The Festival of All Saints(103) was introduced in the West by Pope Boniface IV. on occasion of the dedication of the Pantheon in Rome, which was originally built by Agrippa in honor of the victory of Augustus at Actium, and dedicated to Jupiter Vindex; it survived the old heathen temples, and was presented to the pope by the Emperor Phocas, a.d. 607; whereupon it was cleansed, restored and dedicated to the service of God in the name of the ever-Virgin Mary and all martyrs. Baronius tells us that at the time of dedication on May 13 the bones of martyrs from the various cemeteries were in solemn procession transferred to the church in twenty-eight carriages.(104) From Rome the festival spread during the ninth century over the West, and Gregory IV. induced Lewis the Pious in 835 to make it general in the Empire. The celebration was fixed on the first of November for the convenience of the people who after harvest had a time of leisure, and were disposed to give thanks to God for all his mercies.
The Festival of All Souls(105) is a kind of supplement to that of All Saints, and is celebrated on the day following (Nov. 2). Its introduction is traced to Odilo, Abbot of Cluny, in the tenth century. It spread very soon without a special order, and appealed to the sympathies of that age for the sufferings of the souls in purgatory. The worshippers appear in mourning; the mass for the dead is celebrated with the "Dies irae, Dies illa," and the oft-repeated "Requiem aeternam dona eis, Domine." In some places (e.g. in Munich) the custom prevails of covering the graves on that day with the last flowers of the season.
The festival of Michael the Archangel,(106) the leader of the angelic host, was dedicated to the worship of angels,(107) on the 29th of September.(108) It rests on no doctrine and no fact, but on the sandy foundation of miraculous legends.(109) We find it first in the East. Several churches in and near Constantinople were dedicated to St. Michael, and Justinian rebuilt two which had become dilapidated. In the West it is first mentioned by a Council of Mentz in 813, as the "dedicatio S. Michaelis," among the festivals to be observed; and from that time it spread throughout the Church in spite of the apostolic warning against angelolatry (Col. 2:18; Rev. 19:10; 22:8, 9).(110)
§ 100. The Worship of Images. Literature. Different Theories.
Comp. Vol. II., chs. vi. (p.266 sqq.) and vii. (p. 285); Vol. III. §§109–111 (p. 560 sqq.).
(I.) John of Damascus (chief defender of image-worship, about 750): Lovgoi ajpologhtikoi; pro;" tou;" diabavllonta" ta;" aJgiva" eijkovna" (ed. Le Quien I. 305). Nicephorus (Patriarch of Constantinople, d. 828): Breviarium Hist. (to a.d. 769), ed. Petavius, Paris, 1616. Theophanes (Confessor and almost martyr of image-worship, d. c. 820): Chronographia, cum notis Goari et Combefisii, Par., 1655, Ven. 1729, and in the Bonn ed. of the Byzant. historians, 1839, Tom. I. (reprinted in Migne’s "Patrol. Graeca," Tom. 108). The later Byzantine historians, who notice the controversy, draw chiefly from Theophanes; so also Anastasius (Historia Eccles.) and Paulus Diaconus (Historia miscella and Hist. Longobardorum).
The letters of the popes, and the acts of synods, especially the Acta Concilii Nicaeni II. (a.d. 787) in Mansi, Tom. XIII., and Harduin, Tom. IV.
M. H. Goldast: Imperialia Decreta de Cultu Imaginum in utroque imperio promulgata. Frankf., 1608.
The sources are nearly all on the orthodox side. The seventh oecumenical council (787) ordered in the fifth session that all the books against images should be destroyed.
(II.) J. Dalleus (Calvinist): De Imaginibus. Lugd. Bat., 1642.
L. Maimbourg (Jesuit): Histoire de l’hérésie des iconoclastes. Paris, 1679 and 1683, 2 vols. (Hefele, III. 371, calls this work "nicht ganz zuverlässig," not quite reliable).
Fr. Spanheim (Calvinist): Historia Imaginum restituta. Lugd. Bat. 1686 (in Opera, II. 707).
Chr. W. Fr. Walch (Lutheran): Ketzerhistorie. Leipz., 1762 sqq., vol. X. (1782) p. 65–828, and the whole of vol. XI. (ed. by Spittler, 1785). Very thorough, impartial, and tedious.
F. Ch. Schlosser: Geschichte der bilderstürmenden Kaiser des oströmischen Reichs. Frankf. a. M., 1812.
J. Marx (R.C.): Der Bilderstreit der Byzant. Kaiser. Trier, 1839.
Bishop Hefele: Conciliengesch. vol III. 366–490; 694–716 (revised ed., Freib. i. B. 1877).
R. Schenk: Kaiser Leo III. Ein Beitrag zur Geschichte des Bilderstreites. Halle, 1880.
General Church Histories: 1) R. Cath.: Baronius, Pagi, Natalis Alexander, Alzog, Hergenröther (I. 121–143; 152–168). 2) Protest.: Basnage, Gibbon (ch. 49), Schröckh (vol. XX.), Neander (III. 197–243; 532–553, Bost. ed.; fall and fair); Gieseler (II. 13–19, too short).
The literature on the image-controversy is much colored by the doctrinal stand-point of the writers. Gibbon treats it with cold philosophical indifference, and chiefly in its bearing on the political fortunes of the Byzantine empire.
With the worship of saints is closely, connected a subordinate worship of their images and relics. The latter is the legitimate application of the former. But while the mediaeval churches of the East and West—with the exception of a few protesting voices—were agreed on the worship of saints, there was a violent controversy about the images which kept the Eastern church in commotion for more than a century (a.d. 724–842), and hastened the decline of the Byzantine empire.
The abstract question of the use of images is connected with the general subject of the relation of art to worship. Christianity claims to be the perfect and universal religion; it pervades with its leavening power all the faculties of man and all departments of life. It is foreign to nothing which God has made. It is in harmony with all that is true, and beautiful, and good. It is friendly to philosophy, science, and art, and takes them into its service. Poetry, music, and architecture achieve their highest mission as handmaids of religion, and have derived the inspiration for their noblest works from the Bible. Why then should painting or sculpture or any other art which comes from God, be excluded from the use of the Church? Why should not Bible history as well as all other history admit of pictorial and sculptured representation for the instruction and enjoyment of children and adults who have a taste for beauty? Whatever proceeds from God must return to God and spread his glory.
But from the use of images for ornament, instruction and enjoyment there is a vast step to the worship of images, and experience proves that the former can exist without a trace of the latter. In the middle ages, however, owing to the prevailing saint-worship, the two were inseparable. The pictures were introduced into churches not as works of art, but as aids and objects of devotion. The image-controversy was therefore a, purely practical question of worship, and not a philosophical or artistic question. To a rude imagination an ugly and revolting picture served the devotional purpose even better than one of beauty and grace. It was only towards the close of the middle ages that the art of Christian painting began to produce works of high merit. Moreover the image-controversy was complicated with the second commandment of the decalogue which clearly and wisely forbids, if not all kinds of figurative representations of the Deity, at all events every idolatrous and superstitious use of pictures. It was also beset by the difficulty that we have no authentic pictures of Christ, the Madonna and the Apostles or any other biblical character.
We have traced in previous volumes the gradual introduction of sacred images from the Roman Catacombs to the close of the sixth century. The use of symbols and pictures was at first quite innocent and spread imperceptibly with the growth of the worship of saints. The East which inherited a love for art from the old Greeks, was chiefly devoted to images, the Western barbarians who could not appreciate works of art, cared more for relics.
We may distinguish three theories, of which two came into open conflict and disputed the ground till the year 842.
- The theory of Image-Worship. It is the orthodox theory, denounced by the opponents as a species of idolatry,(111) but strongly supported by the people, the monks, the poets, the women, the Empresses Irene and Theodora, sanctioned by the seventh oecumenical Council (787) and by the popes (Gregory II., Gregory III. and Hadrian I). It maintained the right and duty of using and worshipping images of Christ, the Virgin, and the saints, but indignantly rejected the charge of idolatry, and made a distinction (often disregarded in practice) between a limited worship due to pictures,(112) and adoration proper due to God alone.(113) Images are a pictorial Bible, and speak to the eye even more eloquently than the word speaks to the ear. They are of special value to the common people who cannot read the Holy Scriptures. The honors of the living originals in heaven were gradually transferred to their wooden pictures on earth; the pictures were reverently kissed and surrounded by the pagan rites of genuflexion, luminaries, and incense; and prayers were thought to be more effective if said before them. Enthusiasm for pictures went hand in hand with the worship of saints, and was almost inseparable from it. It kindled a poetic inspiration which enriched the service books of the Greek church. The chief hymnists, John of Damascus, Cosmas of Jerusalem, Germanus, Theophanes, Theodore of the Studium, were all patrons of images, and some of them suffered deposition, imprisonment, and mutilation for their zeal; but the Iconoclasts did not furnish a single poet.(114)
The chief argument against this theory was the second commandment. It was answered in various ways. The prohibition was understood to be merely temporary till the appearance of Christ, or to apply only to graven images, or to the making of images for idolatrous purposes.
On the other hand, the cherubim over the ark, and the brazen serpent in the wilderness were appealed to as examples of visible symbols in the Mosaic worship. The incarnation of the Son of God furnished the divine warrant for pictures of Christ. Since Christ revealed himself in human form it can be no sin to represent him in that form. The significant silence of the Gospels concerning his personal appearance was supplied by fictitious pictures ascribed to St. Luke, and St. Veronica, and that of Edessa. A superstitious fancy even invented stories of wonder-working pictures, and ascribed to them motion, speech, and action.
It should be added that the Eastern church confines images to colored representations on a plane surface, and mosaics, but excludes sculptures and statues from objects of worship. The Roman church makes no such restriction.
- The Iconoclastic theory occupies the opposite extreme. Its advocates were called image-breakers.(115) It was maintained by the energetic Greek emperors, Leo III. and his son Constantine, who saved the tottering empire against the invasion of the Saracens; it was popular in the army, and received the sanction of the Constantinopolitan Synod of 754. It appealed first and last to the second commandment in the decalogue in its strict sense as understood by the Jews and the primitive Christians. It was considerably strengthened by the successes of the Mohammedans who, like the Jews, charged the Christians with the great sin of idolatry, and conquered the cities of Syria, Palestine, and Egypt in spite of the sacred images which were relied on for protection and miraculous interposition. The iconoclastic Synod of 754 denounced image-worship as a relapse into heathen idolatry, which the devil had smuggled into the church in the place of the worship of God alone in spirit and in truth.
The iconoclastic party, however, was not consistent; for it adhered to saint-worship which is the root of image-worship, and instead of sweeping away all religious symbols, it retained the sign of the cross with all its superstitious uses, and justified this exception by the Scripture passages on the efficacy of the cross, though these refer to the sacrifice of the cross, and not to the sign.
The chief defect of iconoclasm and the cause of its failure was its negative character. It furnished no substitute for image-worship, and left nothing but empty walls which could not satisfy the religious wants of the Greek race. It was very different from the iconoclasm of the evangelical Reformation, which put in the place of images the richer intellectual and spiritual instruction from the Word of God.
- The Moderate theory sought a via media between image-worship and image-hatred, by distinguishing between the sign and the thing, the use and the abuse. It allowed the representation of Christ and the saints as aids to devotion by calling to remembrance the persons and facts set forth to the eye. Pope Gregory I. presented to a hermit at his wish a picture of Christ, of Mary, and of St. Peter and St. Paul, with a letter in which he approves of the natural desire to have a visible reminder of an object of reverence and love, but at the same time warned him against superstitious use. "We do not," he says, "kneel down before the picture as a divinity, but we adore Him whose birth or passion or sitting on the throne of majesty is brought to our remembrance by the picture." The same pope commended Serenus, bishop of Marseilles, for his zeal against the adoration of pictures, but disapproved of his excess in that direction, and reminded him of the usefulness of such aids for the people who had just emerged from pagan barbarism and could not instruct themselves out of the Holy Scriptures. The Frankish church in the eighth and ninth centuries took a more decided stand against the abuse, without, however, going to the extent of the iconoclasts in the East.
In the course of time the Latin church went just as far if not further in practical image-worship as the Eastern church after the seventh oecumenical council. Gregory II. stoutly resisted the iconoclastic decrees of the Emperor Leo, and made capital out of the controversy for the independence of the papal throne. Gregory III. followed in the same steps, and Hadrian sanctioned the decree of the second council of Nicaea. Image-worship cannot be consistently opposed without surrendering the worship of saints.
The same theories and parties reappeared again in the age of the Reformation: the Roman as well as the Greek church adhered to image-worship with an occasional feeble protest against its abuses, and encouraged the development of fine arts, especially in Italy; the radical Reformers (Carlstadt, Zwingli, Calvin, Knox) renewed the iconoclastic theory and removed, in an orderly way, the pictures from the churches, as favoring a refined species of idolatry and hindering a spiritual worship; the Lutheran church (after the example set by Luther and his friend Lucas Kranach), retained the old pictures, or replaced them by new and better ones, but freed from former superstition. The modern progress of art, and the increased mechanical facilities for the multiplication of pictures have produced a change in Protestant countries. Sunday School books and other works for old and young abound in pictorial illustrations from Bible history for instruction; and the masterpieces of the great religious painters have become household ornaments, but will never be again objects of worship, which is due to God alone.
Notes.
The Council of Trent, Sess. XXV. held Dec. 1563, sanctions, together with the worship of saints and relics, also the "legitimate use of images" in the following terms: "Moreover, that the images of Christ, of the Virgin Mother of God, and of the other saints, are to be had and retained particularly in temples, and that due honor and veneration are to be given them; not that any divinity, or virtue, is believed to be in them, on account of which they are to be worshiped; or that anything is to be asked of them; or that trust is to be reposed in images, as was of old done by the Gentiles, who placed their hope in idols; but because the honor which is shown them is referred to the prototypes which those images represent; in such wise that by the images which we kiss, and before which we uncover the head, and prostrate ourselves, we adore Christ, and we venerate the saints, whose similitude they bear: as, by the decrees of Councils, and especially of the second Synod of Nicaea, has been defined against the opponents of images." The Profession of the Tridentine Faith teaches the same in art. IX. (See Schaff, Creeds, II. p. 201, 209).
The modern standards of the Eastern Church reiterate the decision of the seventh (Ecumenical Council. The Synod of Jerusalem, or the Confession of Dositheus, includes pictures of Christ, the mother of God, the saints and the holy angels who appeared to some of the patriarchs and prophets, also the symbolic representation of the Holy Spirit under the form of a dove, among the objects of worship (proskunou'men kai; timw'men kai; ajspazovmeqa). See Schaff, l.c. II. 436. The Longer Russian Catechism, in the exposition of the second commandment (Schaff, II. 527), thus speaks of this subject:
"What is an icon (eijkwvn)?
"The word is Greek, and means an image or representation. In the Orthodox Church this name designates sacred representations of our Lord Jesus Christ, God incarnate, his immaculate Mother, and his saints.
"Is the use of holy icons agreeable to the second commandment?
It would then, and then only, be otherwise, if any one were to make gods of them; but it is not in the least contrary to this commandment to honor icons as sacred representations, and to use them for the religious remembrance of God’s works and of his saints; for when thus used icons are books, writen(sic) with the forms of persons and things instead of letters. (See Greg. Magn. lib. ix. Ep. 9, ad Seren. Epis.).
"What disposition of mind should we have when we reverence icons?
"While we look on them with our eyes, we should mentally look to God and to the saints, who are represented on them."
§ 101. The Iconoclastic War, and the Synod of 754.
The history of the image-controversy embraces three periods: 1) The war upon images and the abolition of image-worship by the Council of Constantinople, a.d. 726–754. 2) The reaction in favor of image-worship, and its solemn sanction by the second Council of Nicaea, a.d. 754–787. 3) The renewed conflict of the two parties and the final triumph of image-worship, a.d. 842.
Image-worship had spread with the worship of saints, and become a general habit among the people in the Eastern church to such an extent that the Christian apologists had great difficulty to maintain their ground against the charge of idolatry constantly raised against them, not only by the Jews, but also by the followers of Islam, who could point to their rapid successes in support of their abhorrence of every species of idolatry. Churches and church-books, palaces and private houses, dresses and articles of furniture were adorned with religious pictures. They took among the artistic Greeks the place of the relics among the rude Western nations. Images were made to do service as sponsors in the name of the saints whom they represented. Fabulous stories of their wonder-working power were circulated and readily believed. Such excesses naturally called forth a reaction.
Leo III., called the Isaurian (716–741), a sober and energetic, but illiterate and despotic emperor, who by his military talents and successes had risen from the condition of a peasant in the mountains of Isauria to the throne of the Caesars, and delivered his subjects from the fear of the Arabs by the new invention of the "Greek fire," felt himself called, as a second Josiah, to use his authority for the destruction of idolatry. The Byzantine emperors did not scruple to interfere with the internal affairs of the church, and to use their despotic power for the purpose. Leo was influenced by a certain bishop Constantinus(116) of Nakolia in Phrygia, and by a desire to break the force of the Mohammedan charge against the Christians. In the sixth year of his reign he ordered the forcible baptism of Jews and Montanists (or Manichaeans); the former submitted hypocritically and mocked at the ceremony; the latter preferred to set fire to their meeting-houses and to perish in the flames. Then, in the tenth year (726),(117) he began his war upon the images. At first he only prohibited their worship, and declared in the face of the rising opposition that he intended to protect the images against profanation by removing them beyond the reach of touch and kiss. But in a second edict (730), he commanded the removal or destruction of all the images. The pictured walls were to be whitewashed. He replaced the magnificent picture of Christ over the gate of the imperial palace by a plain cross. He removed the aged Germanus, patriarch of Constantinople, and put the iconoclastic Anastasius in his place.
These edicts roused the violent opposition of the clergy, the monks, and the people, who saw in it an attack upon religion itself. The servants who took down the picture from the palace gate were killed by the mob. John of Damascus and Germanus, already known to us as hymnists, were the chief opponents. The former was beyond the reach of Leo, and wrote three eloquent orations, one before, two after the forced resignation of Germanus, in defence of image-worship, and exhausted the argument.(118) The islanders of the Archipelago under the control of monks rose in open rebellion, and set up a pretender to the throne; but they were defeated, and their leaders put to death. Leo enforced obedience within the limits of the Eastern empire, but had no power among the Christian subjects of the Saracens, nor in Rome and Ravenna, where his authority was openly set at defiance. Pope Gregory II. told him, in an insulting letter (about 729), that the children of the grammar-school would throw their tablets at his head if he avowed himself a destroyer of images, and the unwise would teach him what he refused to learn from the wise(119). Seventy years afterwards the West set up an empire of its own in close connection with the bishop of Rome.
Constantine V., surnamed Copronymos,(120) during his long reign of thirty-four years (741–775), kept up his father’s policy with great ability, vigor and cruelty, against popular clamor, sedition and conspiracy. His character is very differently judged according to the doctrinal views of the writers. His enemies charge him with monstrous vices, heretical opinions, and the practice of magical arts; while the iconoclasts praise him highly for his virtues, and forty years after his death still prayed at his tomb. His administrative and military talents and successes against the Saracens, Bulgarians, and other enemies, as well as his despotism and cruelty (which he shares with other Byzantine emperors) are beyond dispute.
He called an iconoclastic council in Constantinople in 754, which was to be the seventh oecumenical, but was afterwards disowned as a pseudo-synod of heretics. It numbered three hundred and thirty subservient bishops under the presidency of Archbishop Theodosius of Ephesus (the son of a former emperor), and lasted six months (from Feb. 10th to Aug. 27th); but the patriarchs of Jerusalem, Antioch, and Alexandria, being under Moslem rule, could not attend, the see of Constantinople was vacant, and Pope Stephen III. disregarded the imperial summons. The council, appealing to the second commandment and other Scripture passages denouncing idolatry (Rom. 1:23, 25; John 4:24), and opinions of the Fathers (Epiphanius, Eusebius, Gregory Nazianzen, Chrysostom, etc.), condemned and forbade the public and private worship of sacred images on pain of deposition and excommunication, but (inconsistently) ordered at the same time that no one should deface or meddle with sacred vessels or vestments ornamented with figures, and formally declared its agreement with the six oecumenical councils, and the lawfulness of invoking the blessed Virgin and saints. It denounced all religious representations by painter or sculptor as presumptuous, pagan and idolatrous. Those who make pictures of the Saviour, who is God as well as man in one inseparable person, either limit the incomprehensible Godhead to the bounds of created flesh, or confound his two natures, like Eutyches, or separate them, like Nestorius, or deny his Godhead, like Arius; and those who worship such a picture are guilty of the same heresy and blasphemy. The eucharist alone is the proper image of Christ. A three-fold anathema was pronounced on the advocates of image-worship, even the great John of Damascus under the name of Mansur, who is called a traitor of Christ, an enemy of the empire, a teacher of impiety, and a perverter of the Scriptures. The acts of the Synod were destroyed except the decision (o{ro") and a brief introduction, which are embodied and condemned in the acts of the second Nicene Council.(121)
The emperor carried out the decree with great rigor as far as his power extended. The sacred images were ruthlessly destroyed and replaced by white-wash or pictures of trees, birds, and animals. The bishops and clergy submitted; but the monks who manufactured the pictures, denounced the emperor as a second Mohammed and heresiarch, and all the iconoclasts as heretics, atheists and blasphemers, and were subjected to imprisonment, flagellation, mutilation, and all sorts of indignities, even death. The principal martyrs of images during this reign (from 761–775) are Petrus Kalabites (i.e. the inhabitant of a hut, kaluvbh), Johannes, Abbot of Monagria, and Stephanus, Abbot of Auxentius, opposite Constantinople (called "the new Stephanus," to distinguish him from the proto-martyr). The emperor made even an attempt to abolish the convents.(122)
§ 102. The Restoration of Image-Worship by the Seventh Oecumenical Council, 787.
Leo IV., called Chazarus (775–780), kept up the laws against images, though with more moderation. But his wife Irene of Athens distinguished for beauty, talent, ambition and intrigue, was at heart devoted to image-worship, and after his death and during the minority of her son Constantine VI. Porphyrogenitus, labored with shrewdness and perseverance for its restoration (780–802). At first she proclaimed toleration to both parties, which she afterwards denied to the iconoclasts. She raised the persecuted monks to the highest dignities, and her secretary, Tarasius, to the patriarchal throne of Constantinople, with the consent of Pope Hadrian, who was willing to overlook the irregularity of the sudden election of a layman in prospect of his services to orthodoxy. She removed the iconoclastic imperial guard, and replaced it by one friendly to her views.
But the crowning measure was an oecumenical council, which alone could set aside the authority of the iconoclastic council of 754. Her first attempt to hold such a council at Constantinople in 786 completely failed. The second attempt, owing to more careful preparations, succeeded.
Irene convened the seventh oecumenical council in the year 787, at Nicaea, which was less liable to iconoclastic disturbances than Constantinople, yet within easy reach of the court, and famous as the seat of the first and weightiest oecumenical council. It was attended by about three hundred and fifty bishops,(123) under the presidency of Tarasius, and held only eight sessions from September 24 to October 23, the last in the imperial palace of Constantinople. Pope Hadrian I. sent two priests, both called Peter, whose names stand first in the Acts. The three Eastern patriarchs, who were subject to the despotic rule of the Saracens, could not safely leave their homes; but two Eastern monks, John, and Thomas, who professed to be syncelli of two of these patriarchs and to have an accurate knowledge of the prevailing orthodoxy of Egypt and Syria, were allowed to sit and vote in the place of those dignitaries, although they had no authority from them, and were sent simply by a number of their fellow-monks.(124)
The Nicene Council nullified the decrees of the iconoclastic Synod of Constantinople, and solemnly sanctioned a limited worship (proskynesis) of images.(125)
Under images were understood the sign of the cross, and pictures of Christ, of the Virgin Mary, of angels and saints. They may be drawn in color or composed of Mosaic or formed of other suitable materials, and placed in churches, in houses, and in the street, or made on walls and tables, sacred vessels and vestments. Homage may be paid to them by kissing, bowing, strewing of incense, burning of lights, saying prayers before them; such honor to be intended for the living objects in heaven which the images represented. The Gospel book and the relics of martyrs were also mentioned among the objects of veneration.
The decree was fortified by a few Scripture passages about the Cherubim (Ex. 25:17–22; Ezek. 41:1, 15, 19; Heb. 9:1–5), and a large number of patristic testimonies, genuine and forged, and alleged miracles performed by images.(126) A presbyter testified that he was cured from a severe sickness by a picture of Christ. Bishop after bishop, even those who had been members of the Synod of 754, renounced his iconoclastic opinions, and large numbers exclaimed together: "We all have sinned, we all have erred, we all beg forgiveness." Some professed conscientious scruples, but were quieted when the Synod resolved that the violation of an oath which was contrary to the law of God, was no perjury. At the request of one of the Roman delegates, an image was brought into the assembly, and reverently kissed by all. At the conclusion, the assembled bishops exclaimed unanimously: "Thus we believe. This is the doctrine of the apostles. Anathema upon all who do not adhere to it, who do not salute the images, who call them idols, and who charge the Christians with idolatry. Long life to the emperors! Eternal memory to the new Constantine and the new Helena! God protect their reign! Anathema upon all heretics! Anathema especially upon Theodosius, the false bishop of Ephesus, as also upon Sisinnius and Basilius! The Holy Trinity has rejected their doctrines." Then follows an anathema upon other distinguished iconoclasts, and all who do not confess that Christ’s humanity has a circumscribed form, who do not greet the images, who reject the ecclesiastical traditions, written or unwritten; while eternal memory is given to the chief champions of image-worship, Germanus of Constantinople, John of Damascus, and George of Cyprus, the heralds of truth. (127)
The decrees of the Synod were publicly proclaimed in an eighth session at Constantinople in the presence of Irene and her son, and, signed by them; whereupon the bishops, with the people and soldiers, shouted in the usual form: "Long live the Orthodox queen-regent." The empress sent the bishops home with rich presents.
The second Council of Nicaea stands far below the first in moral dignity and doctrinal importance, and occupies the lowest grade among the seven oecumenical synods; but it determined the character of worship in the oriental church for all time to come, and herein lies its significance. Its decision is binding also upon the Roman church, which took part in it by two papal legates, and defended it by a letter of Pope Hadrian to Charlemagne in answer to the Libri Carolini. Protestant churches disregard the council because they condemn image-worship as a refined form of idolatry and as a fruitful source of superstition; and this theory is supported by the plain sense of the second commandment, the views of the primitive Christians, and, negatively, by the superstitions which have accompanied the history of image-worship down to the miracle-working Madonnas of the nineteenth century. At the same time it may be readily conceded that the decree of Nicaea has furnished aid and comfort to a low and crude order of piety which needs visible supports, and has stimulated the development of Christian art. Iconoclasm would have killed it. It is, however, a remarkable fact that the Catholic Raphael and Michael Angelo, and the Protestant Lucas Kranach and Albrecht Dürer, were contemporaries of the Reformers, and that the art of painting reached its highest perfection at the period when image-worship for a great part of Christendom was superseded by the spiritual worship of God alone.
A few months after the Nicene Council, Irene dissolved the betrothal of her son, the Emperor Constantine, to Rotrude, a daughter of Charlemagne, which she herself had brought about, and forced him to marry an Armenian lady whom he afterward cast off and sent to a convent.(128) From this time dates her rupture with Constantine. In her ambition for despotic power, she rendered him odious by encouraging his bad habits, and at last incapable of the throne by causing his eyes to be plucked out, while he was asleep, with such violence that he died of it (797). It is a humiliating fact that Constantine the Great, the convener of the first Nicene Council, and Irene, the convener of the second and last, are alike stained with the blood of their own offspring, and yet honored as saints in the Eastern church, in whose estimate orthodoxy covers a multitude of sins.(129) She enjoyed for five years the fruit of unnatural cruelty to her only child. As she passed through the streets of Constantinople, four patricians marched on foot before her golden chariot, holding the reins of four milk-white steeds. But these patricians conspired against their queen and raised the treasurer Nicephorus to the throne, who was crowned at St. Sophia by the venal patriarch. Irene was sent into exile on the Isle of Lesbos, and had to earn her bread by the labors of her distaff as she had done in the days of her youth as an Athenian virgin. She died of grief in 803. With her perished the Isaurian dynasty. Startling changes of fortune were not uncommon among princes and patriarchs of the Byzantine empire.
§ 103. Iconoclastic Reaction, and Final Triumph of Image-Worship, a.d. 842.
Walch, X. 592–828. Hefele, IV. 1–6; 38–47; 104–109.
During the five reigns which succeeded that of Irene, a period of thirty-eight years, the image-war was continued with varying fortunes. The soldiers were largely iconoclastic, the monks and the people in favor of image-worship. Among these Theodore of the Studium was distinguished by his fearless advocacy and cruel sufferings under Leo V., the Armenian (813–820), who was slain at the foot of the altar. Theophilus (829–842) was the last and the most cruel of the iconoclastic emperors. He persecuted the monks by imprisonment, corporal punishment, and mutilation.(130)
But his widow, Theodora, a second Irene, without her vices,(131) in the thirteenth year of her regency during the minority of Michael the Drunkard, achieved by prudent and decisive measures the final and permanent victory of image-worship. She secured absolution for her deceased husband by the fiction of a death-bed repentance, although she had promised him to make no change. The iconoclastic patriarch, John the Grammarian, was banished and condemned to two hundred lashes; the monk Methodius of opposite tendency (honored as a confessor and saint) was put in his place; the bishops trembled and changed or were deposed; the monks and the people were delighted. A Synod at Constantinople (the acts of it are lost) reënacted the decrees of the seven oecumenical Councils, restored the worship of images, pronounced the anathema upon all iconoclasts, and decided that the event should be hereafter commemorated on the first Sunday in Lent by a solemn procession and a renewal of the anathema on the iconoclastic heretics.
On the 19th of February, 842, the images were again introduced into the churches of Constantinople. It was the first celebration of the "Sunday of Orthodoxy,"(132) which afterwards assumed a wider meaning, as a celebration of victory over all heresies. It is one of the most characteristic festivals of the Eastern church. The old oecumenical Councils are dramatically represented, and a threefold anathema is pronounced upon all sorts of heretics such as atheists, antitrinitarians, upon those who deny the virginity of Mary before or after the birth of Christ, the inspiration of the Scriptures, or the immortality of the soul, who reject the mysteries (sacraments), the traditions and councils, who deny that orthodox princes rule by divine appointment and receive at their unction the Holy Ghost, and upon all iconoclasts. After this anathema follows the grateful commemoration of the orthodox confessors and "all who have fought for the orthodox faith by their words, writings, teaching, sufferings, and godly example, as also of all the protectors and defenders of the Church of Christ." In conclusion the bishops, archimandrites and priests kiss the sacred icons.(133)
§ 104. The Caroline Books and the Frankish Church on Image-Worship.
I. Libri Carolini, first ed. by Elias Philyra (i.e., Jean du Tillet, or Tilius, who was suspected of Calvinism, but afterwards became bishop of Meaux), from a French (Paris) MS., Paris, 1549; then by Melchior Goldast in his collection of imperial decrees on the image-controversy, Francof., 1608 (67 sqq.), and in the first vol. of his Collection of Constitutiones imperiales, with the addition of the last ch. (lib. IV., c. 29), which was omitted by Tilius; best ed. by Ch. A. Heumann, Hanover, 1731, under the title: Augusta Concilii Nicaeni II. Censura, h. e., Caroli Magni de impio imaginum cultu libri IV., with prolegomena and notes. The ed. of Abbé Migne, in his "Patrol. Lat.," Tom. 98, f. 990–1248 (in vol. II. of Opera Caroli M.), is a reprint of the ed. of Tilius, and inferior to Heumann’s ed. ("Es ist zu bedauern," says Hefele, III. 696, "dass Migne, statt Besseres, entschieden Geringeres geboten hat, als man bisher schon besass".)
- Walch devotes the greater part of the eleventh vol. to the history of image-worship in the Frankish Church from Pepin to Louis the Pious. Neander, III. 233–243; Gieseler, II. 66–73; Hefele, III 694–716; Hergenröther, I. 553–557. Floss: De suspecta librorum Carolinorum fide. Bonn, 1860. Reifferscheid: Narratio de Vaticano librorum Carolinorum Codice. Breslau, 1873.
The church of Rome, under the lead of the popes, accepted and supported the seventh oecumenical council, and ultimately even went further than the Eastern church in allowing the worship of graven as well as painted images. But the church in the empire of Charlemagne, who was not on good terms with the Empress Irene, took a position between image-worship and iconoclasm.
The question of images was first discussed in France under Pepin in a synod at Gentilly near Paris, 767, but we do not know with what result.(134) Pope Hadrian sent to Charlemagne a Latin version of the acts of the Nicene Council; but it was so incorrect and unintelligible that a few decades later the Roman librarian Anastasius charged the translator with ignorance of both Greek and Latin, and superseded it by a better one.
Charlemagne, with the aid of his chaplains, especially Alcuin, prepared and published, three years after the Nicene Council, an important work on image-worship under the title Quatuor Libri Carolini (790).(135) He dissents both from the iconoclastic synod of 754 and the anti-iconoclastic synod of 787, but more from the latter, which he treats very disrespectfully.(136) He decidedly rejects image-worship, but allows the use of images for ornament and devotion, and supports his view with Scripture passages and patristic quotations. The spirit and aim of the book is almost Protestant. The chief thoughts are these: God alone is the object of worship and adoration (colondus et adorandus). Saints are only to be revered (venerandi). Images can in no sense be worshipped. To bow or kneel before them, to salute or kiss them, to strew incense and to light candles before them, is idolatrous and superstitious. It is far better to search the Scriptures, which know nothing of such practices. The tales of miracles wrought by images are inventions of the imagination, or deceptions of the evil spirit. On the other hand, the iconoclasts, in their honest zeal against idolatry, went too far in rejecting the images altogether. The legitimate and proper use of images is to adorn the churches and to perpetuate and popularize the memory of the persons and events which they represent. Yet even this is not necessary; for a Christian should be able without sensual means to rise to the contemplation of the virtues of the saints and to ascend to the fountain of eternal light. Man is made in the image of God, and hence capable of receiving Christ into his soul. God should ever be present and adored in our hearts. O unfortunate memory, which can realize the presence of Christ only by means of a picture drawn in sensuous colors. The Council of Nicaea committed a great wrong in condemning those who do not worship images.
The author of the Caroline books, however, falls into the same inconsistency as the Eastern iconoclasts, by making an exception in favor of the sign of the cross and the relics of saints. The cross is called a banner which puts the enemy to flight, and the honoring of the relics is declared to be a great means of promoting piety, since the saints reign with Christ in heaven, and their bones will be raised to glory; while images are made by men’s hands and return to dust.
A Synod in Frankfort, a.d. 794, the most important held during the reign of Charlemagne, and representing the churches of France and Germany, in the presence of two papal legates (Theophylactus and Stephanus), endorsed the doctrine of the Libri Carolini, unanimously condemned the worship of images in any form, and rejected the seventh oecumenical council.(137) According to an old tradition, the English church agreed with this decision.(138)
Charlemagne sent a copy of his book, or more probably an extract from it (85 Capitula or Capitulare de Imaginibus) through Angilbert, his son-in-law, to his friend Pope Hadrian, who in a long answer tried to defend the Eastern orthodoxy of Nicaea with due respect for his Western protector, but failed to satisfy the Frankish church, and died soon afterwards (Dec. 25, 795).(139)
A Synod of Paris, held under the reign of Charlemagne’s son and successor, Louis the Pious, in the year 825, renewed the protest of the Frankfort Synod against image-worship and the authority of the second council of Nicaea, in reply to an embassy of the Emperor Michael Balbus, and added a slight rebuke to the pope.(140)
Notes.
The Caroline Books, if not written by Charlemagne, are at all events issued in his name; for the author repeatedly calls Pepin his father, and speaks of having undertaken the work with the consent of the priests in his dominion (conniventia sacerdotum in regno a Deo nobis concesso). The book is first mentioned by Archbishop Hincmar of Rheims in the ninth century as directed against the pseudo-Synodus Graecorum (the second Nicene Council), and he quotes a passage from a copy which he saw in the royal palace. The second mention and quotation was made by the papal librarian Augustin Steuchus (d. 1550) from a very old copy in the Bibliotheca Palatina. As soon as it appeared in print, Flavius and other Protestant polemics used it against Rome. Baronius, Bellarmin, and other Romanists denied the genuineness, and ascribed the book to certain heretics in the age of Charlemagne, who sent it to Rome to be condemned; some declared it even a fabrication of the radical reformer Carlstadt! But Sirmond and Natalis Alexander convincingly proved the genuineness. More recently Dr. Floss (R.C.) of Bonn, revived the doubts (1860), but they are permanently removed since Professor Reifferscheid (1866) discovered a new MS. from the tenth century in the Vatican library which differs from the one of Steuchus, and was probably made in the Cistercian Convent at Marienfeld in Westphalia. "Therefore," writes Bishop Hefele in 1877 (III. 698), "the genuineness of the Libri Carolini is hereafter no longer to be questioned (nicht mehr zu beanstanden)."
§ 105. Evangelical Reformers. Agobardus of Lyons, and Claudius of Turin.
I. Agobardus: Contra eorum superstitionem qui picturis et imaginibus SS. adorationis obsequium deferendum putant. Opera ed. Baluzius Par. 1666, 2 vols., and Migne, "Patrol. Lat." vol. 104, fol. 29–351. Histoire litter. de la France, IV. 567 sqq. C. B. Hundeshagen: De Agobardi vita et scriptis. Pars I. Giessae 1831; and his article in Herzog2 I. 212 sq. Bähr: Gesch. der röm. Lit. in Karoliny. Zeitalter, p. 383–393. Bluegel: De Agobardi archiep. Lugd. vita et scriptis. Hal. 1865. Simson: Jahrbücher des fränkischen Reichs unter Ludwig dem Frommen. Leipz. 1874 and ’76. C. Deedes in Smith and Wace, I. 63–64. Lichtenberger, I. 119.
Claudius: Opera in Migne’s "Patrol. Lat." vol. 104, fol. 609–927. Commentaries on Kings, Gal., Ephes., etc., Eulogium Augustini, and Apologeticum. Some of his works are still unpublished. Rudelbach: Claudii Tur. Ep. ineditorum operum specimina, praemissa de ejus doctrina scriptisque dissert. Havniae 1824. C. Schmidt: Claudius v. Turin in Illgen’s "Zeitschrift f. die Hist. Theol." 1843. II. 39; and his art. in Herzog2, III. 243–245.
Neander, III. 428–439 (very full and discriminating on Claudius); Gieseler, II. 69–73 (with judicious extracts); Reuter: Geschichte der Aufklärung im Mittelalter, vol. I. (Berlin 1875), 16–20 and 24–41.
The opposition to image-worship and other superstitious practices continued in the Frankish church during the ninth century.
Two eminent bishops took the lead in the advocacy of a more spiritual and evangelical type of religion. In this they differed from the rationalistic and destructive iconoclasts of the East. They were influenced by the writings of Paul and Augustin, those inspirers of all evangelical movements in church history; with this difference, however, that Paul stands high above parties and schools, and that Augustin, with all his anti-Pelagian principles, was a strong advocate of the Catholic theory of the church and church-order.
Agobard (in Lyonese dialect Agobaud or Aguebaud), a native of Spain, but of Gallic parents, and archbishop of Lyons (816–841), figures prominently in the political and ecclesiastical history of France during the reign of Louis the Pious. He is known to us already as an opponent of the ordeal, the judicial duel and other heathen customs.(141) His character presents singular contrasts. He was a rigid ecclesiastic and sacerdotalist, and thoroughly orthodox in dogma (except that he denied the verbal inspiration of the Scriptures); but, on the other hand, a sworn enemy of all superstition, and advocate of liberal views in matters of worship.(142) He took part in the rebellion of Lothaire against his father Louis in 833, which deprived him of his bishopric and left a serious stain on his character, but he was afterwards reconciled to Louis and recovered the bishopric. He opposed Adoptionism as a milder form of the Nestorian heresy. He attacked the Jews, who flocked to Lyons in large numbers, and charges them with insolent conduct towards the Christians. In this he shared the intolerance of his age. But, on the other hand, he wrote a book against image-worship.(143) He goes back to the root of the difficulty, the worship of saints. He can find no authority for such worship. The saints themselves decline it. It is a cunning device of Satan to smuggle heathen idolatry, into the church under pretext of showing honor to saints. He thus draws men away from a spiritual to a sensual worship. God alone should be adored; to him alone must we present the sacrifice of a broken and contrite heart. Angels and holy men who are crowned with victory, and help us by their intercessions, may be loved and honored, but not worshiped. "Cursed be the man that trusteth in man" (Jer. 17:5). We may look with pleasure on their pictures, but it is better to be satisfied with the simple symbol of the cross (as if this were not liable to the same abuse). Agobart approves the canon of Elvira, which forbade images altogether. He says in conclusion: "Since no man is essentially God, save Jesus our Saviour, so we, as the Scripture commands, shall bow our knees to his name alone, lest by giving this honor to another we may be estranged from God, and left to follow the doctrines and traditions of men according to the inclinations of our hearts."(144)
Agobard was not disturbed in his position, and even honored as a saint in Lyons after his death, though his saintship is disputed.(145) His works were lost, until Papirius Masson discovered a MS. copy and rescued it from a bookbinder’s hands in Lyons (1605).
Claudius, bishop of Turin (814–839), was a native of Spain, but spent three years as chaplain at the court of Louis the Pious and was sent by him to the diocese of Turin. He wrote practical commentaries on nearly all the books of the Bible, at the request of the emperor, for the education of the clergy. They were mostly extracted from the writings of Augustin, Jerome, and other Latin fathers. Only fragments remain. He was a great admirer of Augustin, but destitute of his wisdom and moderation.(146)
He found the Italian churches full of pictures and picture-worshipers. He was told that the people did not mean to worship the images, but the saints. He replied that the heathen on the same ground defend the worship of their idols, and may become Christians by merely changing the name. He traced image-worship and saint-worship to a Pelagian tendency, and met it with the Augustinian view of the sovereignty of divine grace. Paul, he says, overthrows human merits, in which the monks now most glory, and exalts the grace of God. We are saved by grace, not by works. We must worship the Creator, not the creature. "Whoever seeks from any creature in heaven or on earth the salvation which he should seek from God alone, is an idolater." The departed saints themselves do not wish to be worshipped by us, and cannot help us. While we live, we may aid each other by prayers, but not after death. He attacked also the superstitious use of the sign of the cross, going beyond Charlemagne and Agobard. He met the defence by carrying it to absurd conclusions. If we worship the cross, he says, because Christ suffered on it, we might also worship every virgin because he was born of a virgin, every manger because he was laid in a manger, every ship because he taught from a ship, yea, every ass because he rode on an ass into Jerusalem. We should bear the cross, not adore it. He banished the pictures, crosses and crucifixes from the churches, as the only way to kill superstition. He also strongly opposed the pilgrimages. He had no appreciation of religious symbolism, and went in his Puritanic zeal to a fanatical extreme.
Claudius was not disturbed in his seat; but, as he says himself, he found no sympathy with the people, and became "an object of scorn to his neighbors," who pointed at him as "a frightful spectre." He was censured by Pope Paschalis I. (817–824), and opposed by his old friend, the Abbot Theodemir of the diocese of Nismes, to whom he had dedicated his lost commentary on Leviticus (823), by Dungal (of Scotland or Ireland, about 827), and by Bishop Jonas of Orleans (840), who unjustly charged him with the Adoptionist and even the Arian heresy. Some writers have endeavored, without proof, to trace a connection between him and the Waldenses in Piedmont, who are of much later date.(147)
Jonas of Orleans, Hincmar of Rheims, and Wallafrid Strabo still maintained substantially the moderate attitude of the Caroline books between the extremes of iconoclasm and image-worship. But the all-powerful influence of the popes, the sensuous tendency and credulity of the age, the ignorance of the clergy, and the grosser ignorance of the people combined to secure the ultimate triumph of image-worship even in France. The rising sun of the Carolingian age was obscured by the darkness of the tenth century.
Original Footnotes
(1; original 421): See the Ordo Missae Romanae Gregorianus, compared with the Ordo Gelasianus, Ambrosianus, Gallicanus, Mozarabicus, etc., in Daniel’s Codex Liturg. vol. I. 3-168.
(2; original 422): Dialog. 1. IV. c. 58 (in Migne’s ed. III. 425 sq.): "Quis fidelium habere dubium possit, in ipsa immolationis hora ad sacerdotis vocem coelis aperiri, in illo jesu Christi mysteria angelorum choros adesse, summis ima sociari, terrena coelestibus jungi, unumque ex visibilibus atque invisibilibus fieri?"
(3; original 423): Misae pro Defunctis, Todtenmessen, Seelenmessen. Different from them are the Missae de Sanctis, celebrated on the anniversaries of the saints, and to their honor, though the sacrifice is always offered to God.
(4; original 424): Even popes, though addressed by the title "Holiness," while living, have to pass through purgatory, and need the prayers of the faithful. On the marble sarcophagus of Pius IX., who reigned longer than any of his predecessors, and proclaimed his own infallibility in the Vatican Council (1870), are the words: "Orate pro eo." Prayers and masses are said only for the dead in purgatory, not for the saints in heaven who do not need them, nor for the damned in hell who would not profit by them.
(5; original 425): Quoted from the Longer Catechism of the Eastern Church (Schaff, Creeds II. 504). The Greeks have in their ritual special strophes or antiphones for the departed, called nekrwvsima. Mone, Lat. Hymnen des Mittel alters, II. 400, gives some specimens from John of Damascus and others. He says, that the Greeks have more hymns for the departed than the Latins, but that the Latins have older hymni pro defunctis, beginning with Prudentius.
(6; original 426): Missae solitariae or privatae.
(7; original 427): Can. 48. Mansi XIV. 529 sqq. Hefele IV. 64.
(8; original 428): See the next chapter, on Theological Controversies.
(9; original 429): Comp. logikh; latreiva, Rom. 12:1.
(10; original 430): Sess. IV. (April 8, 1546):"Sacrosancta Synodus … statuit et declarat, ut haec ipsa vetus et vulgata editio, quiae longo tot saeculorum usu in ipsa ecclesia probata est, in publicis lectionibus, disputationibus, praedicationibus et expositionibus pro authentica habeatur;. et ut nemo illam rejicere quovis praetextu audeat vel praesumat!" The Council made provision for an authoritative revision of the Vulgate (April 8, 1546); but when the edition of Pope Sixtus V. appeared in 1589 and was enjoined upon the church "by the fullness of apostolic power," it was found to be so full of errors and blunders that it had to be cancelled, and a new edition prepared under Clement VIII. in 1592, which remains the Roman standard edition to this day.
(11; original 431): As it is to-day in strictly Roman Catholic countries; with this difference, that what was excusable in a period of heathen and semi-heathen ignorance and superstition, is inexcusable in an age of advanced civilization furnished with all kinds of educational institutions and facilities.
(12; original 432): See the acts of this council in Haddan and Stubbs, Councils and Eccles. Doc. 360-376, and the letter of Boniface to Cuthbert, giving an account of a similar council in Germany, and recommending measures of reform in the English church, p. 376-382.
(13; original 433): A similar canon was passed by other councils. See Hefele III. 758, 764, and IV. 89, 111, 126, 197, 513, 582; Mansi XIV. 82 sqq.
(14; original 434): Hefele, III. 745.
(15; original 435): F. Dahn, Des Paulus Diaconus Leben und Schriften, 1876; and Mon. Germ. Scriptores rerum Langobardicarum et Italicarum saec. VI.-IX. 1878, p. 45-187, ed. by L. Bethmann and G. Waitz; Wattenbach, Deutschlands Geschichtsquellen, 4th ed. 1877, I. 134-140.
(16; original 436): See above, p. 41, 105, 106. The paraphrase of Caedmon, the first Christian poet of England, is edited or discussed by Thorpe, Bouterweck, Grein, Wright, Ettmüller, Sandrar, Morley, Ten Brink, etc. (see Lit. in Schaff-Herzog sub Caedmon); the Saxon Heliand and Otfrid’s Krist by Sievers, Rettberg, Vilmar, Lechler, Graff, Kelle, Michelsen, etc. (see Herzog2 IV. 428-435).
(17; original 437): Neale and Pitra point out this connection, and Jacobi (l.c. p. 210 sq.) remarks: "Im Kampfe für die Bilder steigerte sich die Glut der sinnlichen Frömmigkeit, und mit dem Siege der Bilderverehrung im neunten Jahrhundert ist eine innerliche und aeusserliche Zunahme des Heiligenkultus und namentlich ein Wachsthum der Marienvehrung unverkennbar."
(18; original 438): The Mhnai'a (sc. bibliva, Monatsbücher) are published at Venice in the Tipografia Greca (hJ JEllhnikh; tupografiva tou' foivniko"). Each month has its separate title: Mhnai'on tou' !Ianouarivou or Mh;n !Ianouavrio" , etc. January begins with the commemoration of the circumcision of our Lord and the commemoration of St. Basil the Great, and December ends with the mnhvmh th'" oJsiva" Mhtro;" hJmw'n Melavnh" th's JRwmaiva" . The copy before me (from the Harvard University Library) is dated 1852, and printed in beautiful Greek type, with the directions in red ink. On older editions see Mone, Lat. Hymnen, II. p. x. sqq. The other books of the Greek Ritual are the Paracletice (Paraklhtikhv, sc. bivblo") or great Octoechus (jOktwvhco", sc. bivblo"), which contains the Sunday services the Triodion (Triwv/dion, the Lent-volume), and the Pentecostarion (Penthkostavrion, the office for Easter-tide). " On a moderate computation," says Neale, " these volumes comprise 5,000 closely printed quarto pages, in double columns, of which at least 4,000 are poetry." See the large works of Leo Allatius, De libris eccles. Graecorum; Goar, Euchologion sive Rituale Graecorum, and especially the Second volume of Neale’s History of the Holy Eastern Church (1850), p. 819 sqq.
(19; original 439): Hence they were called melwdoiv as well as poihtaiv in distinction from the mere uJmnovgrafoi. The Greek service books are also music books. Christ discusses Byzantine music, and gives some specimens in Prol. p. CXI-CXLII.
(20; original 440): Tropavrion, the diminutive of trovpo", as modulus is of modus, was originally a musical term.
(21; original 441): Eijrmov", tractus, a train, series, was likewise originally a musical term like ajkolouqiva and the Latin jubilatio, sequentia. See § 96.
(22; original 442): Qeotokivon, sc. tropavrion (more rarely, but more correctly, with the accent on the ante-penultima, qeotovkion), from qeotovko", Deipara. The stauro-theotokion celebrates Mary at the cross, and corresponds to the Stabat Mater dolorosa of the Latins.
(23; original 443): !Idiovmelon. There are several other designations of various kinds of poems, as ajkolouqiva (the Latin sequentia), ajnabaqmoiv (tria antiphona), ajntivfwnon, ajpolutivkion (breve troparium sub finem officii vespertini), ajpovstica, auvtomelon, ejxaposteilavrion, ejwqinav, kavqisma, katabasiva, kontavria, makarismoiv, megalunavria, oi, prosovmoia, stichrav, triwv/dia, tetrawv/da, diwv/dia, yalthvrion, tropolovgion. These terms and technical forms are fully discussed by Christ in the Prolegomena. Comp. also the Introduction of Neale
(24; original 444): By Vormbaum (in the third volume of Daniel’s Thesaurus which needs reconstruction), Pitra, and Christ. The Continental writers seem to be ignorant of Dr. Neale, the best English connoisseur of the liturgical and poetic literature of the Greek church. His translations are, indeed, very free reproductions and transfusions, but for this very reason better adapted to Western taste than the originals. The hymn of Clement of Alexandria in praise of the Logos has undergone a similar transformation by Dr. Henry M. Dexter, and has been made useful for public worship. See vol. II. 231.
(25; original 445): Even Neale, with all his admiration for the Greek Church, admits that the Menaea contain a "deluge of worthless compositions: tautology repeated till it becomes almost sickening; the merest commonplace, again and again decked in the tawdry shreds of tragic language, ind twenty or thirty times presenting the same thought in slightly varying terms." (Hymns E.Ch. p. 88 sq., 3d ed.)
(26; original 446): See vol. II. 227, and add to the Lit. there quoted: Christ, p. 38-40, who gives from the Codex Alexandrinus and other MSS. the Greek text of the morning hymn (the expanded Angelic anthem Dovxa ejn uJyivstoi" qew'/) and two evening hymns Aijnei'te, pai'de" . kuvrion, and Fw'" iJlaro;n aJgiva" dovxh") of the Greek church.
(27; original 447): See vol. III. 581 and 921. Christ begins his collection with the hymns of Synesius, p. 3-23, and of Gregory Nazianzen, 23-32.
(28; original 448): See the specimens in vol. III. 583-585. Neale begins his translations with Anatolius. Christ treats of him p. XLI, and gives his stichra; ajnastavsima find three ijdiovmela (hymns with their own melody), 113-117. More than a hundred poems in the Menaea and the Octoechus bear the name of Anatolius, but Christ conjectures that stichra; ajnatolikav is a generic name, like katanuktikav and nekrwvsima.
(29; original 449): See a description of this most curious structure in all Palestine, in my book Through Bible Lands (N. Y. 1879), p. 278 sqq.
(30; original 450): The poetry of John of D. in his Opera ed. Le Quien (Par. 1712), Tom. I. 673-693; Poëtae Graeci veteres (Colon. 1614), Tom. II. 737 sqq.; Christ, Anthol. gr. Prol. XLIV. sqq., p. 117-121, and p. 205-236. Vormbaum, in Daniel, III. 80-97, gives six of his odes in Greek; Bässler, 162-164, two (and two in German, 21, 22); Neale nine English versions. The best of his hymns and canons are Eij" th;n cristou' gevnnhsin (or eij" th;n qeogonivan), Eij" ta; qeofavneia, Eij" th;n kuriakh;n tou' Pavsca, Eij" th;n pentekosthvn, Eij" th;n ajnavlhyin tou' Cristou',Eujchv, jIdiovmela ejn ajkolouqiva tou' ejxodiastikou', Eij" th;n koivmhsin th'" qeotovkou.. The last begins with this stanza (Christ, p. 229):
jAnoivxw to; stovma mou,
kai; plhrwqhvsetai pneuvmato":
kai; lovgou ejpeuvxomai th'/ basilivdi mhtriv:
kai; ojfqhvsomai faidrw'"panhgurivzwn:
kai; a[/sw ghqovmeno" tauvth" ta; qauvmata.
(31; original 451): Gallandi, Bibl. Patrum, XIII. 234 sqq.; Christ, XLIX sq., 161-164. Christ calls him "princeps melodorum graecorum," and gives ten of his canons and several triodia; Daniel (III. 55-79) twelve odes. Among the best are Eij" th;n tou' Cristou' gevnnhsin, Eij" ta; qeofavneia, Eij" th;n penthkosthvn, Pro;" Cristovn, Ei" th;n u{ywsin tou' staurou', Eij" to; mevga savbbaton. Neale has reproduced eight odes of Cosmas and a cento on the Transfiguration. The Nativity hymn begins (Christ p. 165):
Cristo;" genna'tai: dovxasate:
Cristo;" ejx oujranw'n: ajpanthvsate:
Cristo;" ejpi; gh'" : uJywvqhte:
a[/sate tw'/ kurivw/ pa'sa hJ gh',
kai; ejn eujfrosuvnh/
ajnumnhvsate, laoiv,
o{ti dedoxastai.
(32; original 452): @o Graptov", with reference to his sufferings.
(33; original 453): According to Christ (Prol. XLIV), he was after the restoration of the images in the churches of Constantinople, 842, elected metropolitan of Nicaea and died in peace. But according to the Bollandists and other authorities, he died much earlier in exile at Samothrace about 818 or 820, in consequence of his sufferings for the Icons. Neale reports that Theophanes was betrothed in childhood to a lady named Megalis, but persuaded her, on their wedding day, to retire to a convent. Christ gives several of his idiomela and stichera necrosima, p. 121-130. See also Daniel, III. 110-112, and Neale’s translations of the idiomela on Friday of Cheese-Sunday (i.e. Quinquagesima), and the stichera at the first vespers of Cheese-Sunday (90-95). The last is entitled by Neale: "Adam’s Complaint," and he thinks that Milton, "as an universal scholar," must, in Eve’s lamentation, have had in his eye the last stanza which we give in the text. But this is very doubtful. The Chronographia of Theophanes is published in the Bonn. ed. of the Byzantine historians, 1839, and in Migne’s "Patrol. Graeca," Tom. 108 (1861). His biography see in the Acta Sanct. ed. Bolland. in XII. Martii.
(34; original 454): Christ (p. LII sq., p. 140-147) reasons chiefly from chronological considerations. The poem is called ajkavqisto"(sc. u{mno") th'"qeotovkou, because it was chanted while priest and people were standing. During the singing of other hymns they were seated; hence the latter are called kaqivsmata, (from kaqivzesqai). See Christ, Prol. p. LXII and p. 54 sqq. Jacobi says of the Akathistos (l.c. p. 230): " Was Enthusiasmus für die heilige Jungfrau, was Kenntniss biblischer Typen, überhaupt religiöser Gegenstände und Gedanken zu leisten vermochten, was Schmuck der Sprache. Gewandtheit des Ausdrucks, Kunst der Rhythmen und der Reime hinzufügen komnten, das ist hier in unübertroffenem Masse bewirkt."
(35; original 455): Christ, XXVII, XXXV, LIII, 43-47 (ajnakreovntika), and 96 (ijdiovmelatw'nQeofaneivwn). Daniel, III. 20-46, gives thirteen pieces of Sophronius from Pet. Metranga, Spicilegium Romanum, 1840, Tom. IV.
(36; original 456): Poetae Gr. vet. Tom. II. 192 sqq. Daniel, III. 97-103, gives three hymns, among them a beautiful u{mno"iJkethvrio"ei"Cristovn Christ omits Maximus.
(37; original 457): See his Opera in Migne’s "Patrol. Graeca" Tom. 98 (1865); and his poems in Christ, XLIII. 98 (ijdiovmelon on the Nativity); Daniel, III. 79, a hymn in praise of Mary, beginning Salpivswmen ejn savlpiggi ajsmavtwn, and ending with ascribing to her almighty power of intercession:
Oujden ga;r ajduvnaton th'/ mesiteiva/ sou.
(38; original 458): Fr. Combefisius first edited the works of Andreas Cretensis, Par. 1644. Christ, 147-161, gives the first part of "the great canon" (about one-fourth), and a new canon in praise of Peter. The last is not in the Menaea but has been brought to light from Paris and Vatican MSS. by Card. Pitra. Daniel, III. 47-54, has seven hymns of Andreas, of which the first is on the nativity, beginning:
Eujfraivnesqe divkaioi:
Oujranoi; ajgallia'sqe:
Skirthvsate ta; o{rh,
Tou' Cristou' gennhqevnto"./
Neale translated four: Stichera for Great Thursday; Troparia for Palm Sunday; a portion of the Great Canon; Stichera for the Second Week of the Great Fast. His Opera in Migne’s " Patrol. Gr." T. 97(1860), p. 1306sqq.
(39; original 459): Christ, p. xlii. sq. and 83, aujtovmelonei"tou;"ajpost. Pevtronkai;Pau'lon. See Men., June 29.
(40; original 460): Christ and Daniel ignore Stephen. Neale calls the one and only hymn which he translated, "Idiomela in the Week of the First Oblique Tone," and adds: "These stanzas, which strike me as very sweet, are not in all the editions of the Octoechus." He ascribes to him also a poetical composition on the Martyrs of the monastery of Mar Sâba (March 20), and one on the Circumcision. "His style," he says, "seems formed on that of S. Cosmas, rather than on that of his own uncle. He is not deficient in elegance and richness of typology, but exhibits something of sameness, and is occasionally guilty of very hard metaphors."
(41; original 461): Christ, 131-140, gives his "Psalm of the Holy Apostles," and a Nativity hymn. Comp. p. li. sq. Jacobi (p. 203 sq.) discusses the data and traces in Romanus allusions to the Monotheletic controversy, which began about a.d. 630. He gives a German version in part of the beautiful description of the benefits of redemption, p. 221 sq.
(42; original 462): Christ, p. 101 sq.; Daniel, III. 101-109. Neale has translated four odes of Theodorus Studita, one on the judgment-day (oJkuvrio"e[rcetai). Pitra has brought to light from MSS. eighteen of his poems on saints. See his Opera in Migne " Patr. Gr." 99.
(43; original 463): Christ, p. xlvii.: "Nicephorus duos Iosephos hymnorum scriptores recenset, quorum alterum Studiorum monasterii socium, alterum peregrinum dicit. Priorem intelligo Iosephum fratrem minorem Theodori, Studiorum antistitis, cuius memoriae dies XIV. mensis Iulii consecratus est. Is ob morum integritatem et doctrina laudem Thessalonicensis ecclesiae archiepiscopus electus a Theophilo rege (829-842), qui in cultores imaginum saeviebat, in vincula coniectus et omni tormentorum genere adeo vexatus est, ut in carcere mortem occumberet. Alterius losephi, qui proprie uJmnovgrafo"audit, memoriam die III. mensis Aprilis ecclesia graeca concelebrat. Is peregrinus (xevno") ab Nicephoro dictus esse dicitur, quod ex Sicilia insula oriundus erat et patria ab Arabibus capta et vastata cum matre et fratribus primum in Peloponnesum, deinde Thessalonicem confugit, qua in urbe monarchorum disciplnae severissimae sese addixit."
(44; original 464): English translation by Neale. See below, p. 473.
(45; original 465): Christ, 242-253; Daniel, III. 112-114; Neale, p. 120-151; Bässler, p. 23, 165; Schaff, p. 240 sq. Joseph is also the author of hymns formerly ascribed to Sophronius, Patriarch of Jerusalem, during the Monotheletic controversy, as Paranikas has shown (Christ, Prol., p. liii.).
(46; original 466): Neale notices him, but thinks it not worth while to translate his poetry.
(47; original 467): Kanw;neij"th;nuJperagivanqeotovkon. See Daniel, III. 17-20.
(48; original 468): Not to be confounded with Methodius Eubulius, of Patara, the martyr (d. 311), who is also counted among the poets for his psalm of the Virgins in praise of chastity (parqevnion); see vol. II. 811, and Christ, p. 33-37. Bässler (p.4 sq.) gives a German version of it by Fortlage.
(49; original 469): Pitra concludes his collection with eighty-three anonymous hymns, thirty-two of which he assigns to the poets of the Studium. See also Daniel, III. 110-138, and the last hymns in Neale’s translations.
(50; original 470): See the Marianic Te Deum in Daniel, II. 293; and in Mone, II. 229 sq.
(51; original 471): A curious mediaeval legend makes the Te Deum the joint product of St. Ambrose and St. Augustin, which was alternately uttered by both, as by inspiration, while Augustin ascended from the baptismal font; Ambrose beginning: Te Deum laudamus, Augustin responding; "Te Dominum confitemur." But neither the writings of one or the other contain the slightest trace of the hymn and its origin. The first historic testimony of its existence and use is the eleventh rule of St. Benedict of Nursia, a.d. 529, which prescribes to the monks of Monte Casino: "Post guartum autem responsorium incipiat Abbas hymnum Te Deum laudamus." But five or eight lines of the hymn are found in Greek as a part of the Gloria in Excelsis (DoxaejnuJyivstoi", etc. ) in the Alexandrian Codex of the Bible which dates from the fifth century. See Daniel, II 289 sqq.;Christ p. 39 (from kaqjhJmevranto eij"tou;"aijw'na"), and Kayser, 437 sqq. Daniel traces the whole Te Deum to a lost Greek original (of which the lines in the Cod. Alex. are a fragment), Kayser to an unknown Latin author in the second half of the fifth century, i.e. about one hundred years after the death of St. Ambrose.
(52; original 472): The dates of his birth and death are quite uncertain, and variously stated from 530 or 550 to 600 or 609.
(53; original 473): See two Latin texts with critical notes in Daniel, I. 160 sqq., rhymed English Versions by Mant, Caswall, and Neale. The originals are not rhymed, but very melodious. See vol. III. 597. The Opera of Fortunatus were edited by Luchi, Rom. 1786, and Migne in "Patrol. Lat." vol. 88 (Paris 1850). Comp. Ampère, Hist. littér. II. 275 sqq.; Ebert, l.c. I. 494 sqq. Fortunatus is a very interesting character, and deserves a special monograph. Kayser devotes to him three chapters (p. 386-434).
(54; original 474): Daniel, I. 175-183, gives ten hymns of Gregory, and an additional one (Laudes canamus) in vol. V. 248. Mone adds some more of doubtful authorship, I. 370, 376 sqq.; III. 325 sqq., and includes hymns in praise of Gregory, as "O decus sacerdotum, flosque sanctorum." English translations of his Breviary hymns in Mant, Chambers, Caswall, Newman. On his merits as a poet, see Ebert, I. 827 sqq. Luther, in his Tischreden (which are a strange mixture of truth and fiction), declared the passion *hymn Rex Christe,**factor omnium, to be the best of all hymns ("der allerbeste Hymnus*"), but this extravagant praise is inconsistent with the poetic taste of Luther and the fact that he did not reproduce it in German.
(55; original 475): From Newman’s free reproduction (in Verses on Various Occasions). See the Latin text in both recensions in Daniel, I. 175,
(56; original 476): Daniel, I. 206 sq.; Mone, I.1 ("Primo Deus coeli globum") and 284 (Ave sacer Christi sanguis). The hymn for the infant martyrs at Bethlehem is far inferior to the Salvete flores martyrum of Prudentius. The first of the hymns quoted in the text is translated by Mrs. Charles and by Neale. German versions by Königsfeld (Ihr Siegeshymnen schallet laut, and Unschuld’ger Kinder Martyrschaar), Knapp, and others. Bede composed also a metrical history, of St. Cuthbert, which Newman has translated in part ("Between two comrades dear").
(57; original 477): His carmina were edited from an old MS. found in the convent of Fulda by Christopher Brower, a Jesuit, in 1617 (as an appendix to the poems of Venantius Fortunatus), and reprinted in Migne’s Rab. Mauri Opera (1852) Vol. VI. f. 1583-1682. Comp. Kunstmann, Hrabamus Magnentius Maurus, Mainz 1841; Koch, I. 90-93; Ebert, II. 120-145; Hauck in Herzog2 XII. 459-465. Hauck refers to Dümmler on the MS. tradition of the poem, of R. M.
(58; original 478): So Brower, and quite recently S. W. Duffield, in an article In Schaff’s "Rel. Encycl." III. 2608 sq. Also Clément, Carmina, etc., p. 379.
(59; original 479): In the abridged and not very happy translation of Bishop Cosin (only four stanzas), beginning:
"Come, Holy Ghost, our souls inspire,
And lighten with celestial fire.
Thou the anointing Spirit art,
Who dost thy sevenfold gift, impart. "
It was introduced into the Prayer Book after the Restoration, 1662. The alternate ordination hymn, "Come, Holy Ghost, eternal God," appeared in 1549, and was altered in 1662.
(60; original 480): By Tomasi (I. 375) and even Daniel (I. 213, sq.; IV. 125), apparently also by Trench (p. 167). Tomasi based his view on an impossible tradition reported by the Bollandists (Acta SS. Apr. 1, 587), that Notker sent to Charlemagne (who died a hundred years before) his sequence Sancti Spiritus adsit nobis gratia, and received in response the Veni, Creator Spiritus from the emperor (whose Latin scholarship was not sufficient for poetic composition). The author of the article "Hymns" in the 9th ed. of the "Encycl. Brit." revives the legend, but removes the anachronism by substituting for Charlemagne his nephew, Charles the Bald (who was still less competent for the task).
(61; original 481): By Mone (I. 242, note), Koch, Wackernagel. Mone’s reasons are "the classical metre with partial rhymes, and the prayer-like treatment."
(62; original 482): In the twelfth and thirteenth century (Komm, Schöpfer, heiliger Geist), as also by Luther (Komm, Gott Schöpfer, heiliger Geist), by Königsfeld (Komm, Schöpfer, heil’ger Geist, erfreu), and others. The oldest German translator (as reported by Daniel, I. 214), says that he who recites this hymn by day or by night, is secure against all enemies visible or invisible.
(63; original 483): As contained in his work De Universo 1. I. c.3 (in Migne’s edition of the Opera, V. 23-26). Here he calls the Holy Spirit digitus Dei (as in the hymn), and teaches the double procession which had come to be the prevailing doctrine in the West since the adoption of the Filioque at the Synod of Aix in Creed. The scanning of Paraclêtus with a long penultimate differs from that 809, though under protest of Leo III. against its insertion into the Nicene of other Latin poets (Paraecletos).
(64; original 484): The Latin text is from Brower, as reprinted in Migne (VI. 1657), with the addition of the first doxology. The first translation is by Robert Campbell, 1850, the second by Rev. S. W. Duffield, made for this work, Feb. 1884. Other English versions by Wither (1623), Drummond (1616), Cosin (1627), Tate (1703), Dryden (1700), Isaac Williams (1839), Bishop Williams (1845), Mant ("Come, Holy Ghost, Creator blest"), Benedict ("Spirit, heavenly life bestowing"), MacGill ("Creator Holy Spirit! come"), Morgan ("Creator Spirit, come in love"), in the Marquess of Bute’s Breviary ("Come, Holy Ghost, Creator come"). See nine of these translations in Odenheimer and Bird, Songs of the Spirit, N. Y. 1871, p. 167-180. German versions are almost as numerous. Comp. Daniel, I. 213; IV. 124; Mone, I. 242; Koch, 1. 74 sq.
(65; original 485): Perpetim, adv., perpetually, constantly. Some copies read perpeti (from perpes).
(66; original 486): The concluding conventional benediction in both forms is a later addition. The first is given by Daniel (I. 214), and Mone (I. 242), the second in the text of Rabanus Maurus. The scanning of Paraecletos differs in both from that in the second stanza.
(67; original 487): A few writers claim it for Pope Innocent III.
(68; original 488): See the Latin text in Daniel II. 35; V. 69; Mone, I. 244. In ver. 8 line 2 Daniel reads frigidum for languidum.
(69; original 490): Dr. E. A. Washburn, late rector of Calvary Church, New York, a highly accomplished scholar (d. 1881). The version was made in 1860 and published in "Voices from a Busy Life," N. Y. 1883, p. 142.
(70; original 491): Comp. on Notker the biography of Ekkehard; Daniel V. 37 sqq.; Koch I. 94 sqq.; Meyer von Knonau,Lebensbild des heil. Notker von St. Gallen, and his article in Herzog2 X. 648 sqq. (abridged in Schaff-Herzog II. 1668); and Ans. Schubiger, Die Sängerschule St. Gallens vom 8ten his 12ten Jahrh. (Einsiedlen, 1858). Daniel II. 3-31 gives thirty-five pieces under the title Notker et Notkeriana. Neale (p. 32) gives a translation of one sequence: Sancti Spiritus adsit nobis gratia.
(71; original 492): For further information on Sequences see especially Neale’s Epistola Critica de Sequentiis at the beginning of the fifth vol. of Daniel’s Thes. (p. 3-36), followed by literary notices of Daniel; also the works of Bartsch and Kehrein (who gives the largest collection), and Duffield in Schaff’s Rel. Encyl. III. 161. Neale defines a sequentia: "prolongatio syllabae tou' Alleluia."
(72; original 493): Translated by Neale, p. 32.
(73; original 494): Daniel, II. 329; Mone, I. 397. Several German versions, one by Luther (1524): "Mitten wir im Leben sind mit dem Tod umfangen." This version is considerably enlarged and has been translated into English by Miss Winkworth in "Lyra Germanica" : "In the midst of life behold Death has girt us round. See notes in Schaff’s Deutsches Gesangbuch, No. 446.
(74; original 495): The text is taken from The First Book of Edward VI., 1549 (as republished by Dr. Morgan Dix, N. Y. 1881, p. 268). In the revision of the Prayer Book the third line was thus improved:
O Lord, who for our sins art justly displeased (irasceris)."
(75; original 496): Daniel, I. 224. English Versions by Neale, Benedict, and Washburn (l. c. p. 145). German translation by Königsfeld: "Wie du mich mit Schrecken schüttelst." Neale (p. 52) calls this "an awful hymn, the Dies Irae of individual life." His version begins:
"O what terror in thy forethought, Ending scene in mortal life!"
(76; original 497): Daniel, I. 116-118 (Rhythmus de gloria et gaudiis Paradisi), under the name of St. Augustin. So also Clément, Carmina, p. 162-166, who says that it is, attributed to Augustin "per les melleurs critiques," and that it is "un reflet de la Cité de Dieu." But the great African father put his poetry into prose, and only furnished inspiring thoughts to poets. German translation by Königsfeld (who gives it likewise under the name of St. Augustin) "Nach des ew’gen Lebens Quellen."
(77; original 498): See their hymns in Daniel, I. 183 sqq., and partly in Mone, and Clément.
(78; original 499): From this poem (see Daniel I. 209 sq. ) Guido of Arezzo got names for the six notes Ut, Re, Mi, Fa, Sol, La:
"Ut queant laxis Re-sonare fibris
Mi-ra gestorum Fa-muli tuorum,
Sol ve polluti La-bii reatum,
Sancte Joannes."
(79; original 500): See Daniel, Hymni adespotoi circa sec. VI-IX. conscripti, I. 191 sqq. Mone gives a larger number.
(80; original 501): In the Roman Breviary: "Coelestis urbs Jerusalem." Neale thinks that the changes in the revised Breviary of Urban VIII. have deprived "this grand hymn of half of its beauty."
(81; original 502): See the original in Daniel, I. 194. Other English translations by Mrs. Charles, and E. C. Benedict. In German by Königsfeld: "Plötzlich wird der Tag erscheinen."
(82; original 503): Daniel (I. 204) says of this hymn: "Hic hymnus Marianus, quem Catholica semper ingenti cum favore prosecuta est, in omnibus breviarriis, quae inspiciendi unquam mihi occasio data est, ad honorem beatissimae virginis cantandus praescribitur, inprimis in Annunciatione; apud permultos tamen aliis quoque diebus Festis Marianis adscriptus est. Quae hymni reverentia ad recentiora usque tempora permansit." It is one of the few hymns which Urban VIII. did not alter in his revision of the Breviary. Mone (II. 216, 218, 220, 228) gives four variations of Ave Maris Stella, which is used as the text.
(83; original 504): This designation of Mary is supposed to be meant for a translation of the name; maria being taken for the plural of mare: see Gen. I: 10 (Vulgate) "congregationes aquarum appellavit maria. Et vidit Deus, quod esset bonum." (See the note in Daniel, I. 205). Surely a most extraordinary exposition, not to say imposition, yet not too far-fetched for the middle ages, when Greek and Hebrew were unknown, when the Scriptures were supposed to have four senses, and allegorical and mystical fancies took the place of grammatical and historical exegesis.
(84; original 505): The comparison of Mary with Eve—the mother of obedience contrasted with the mother of disobedience, the first Eve bringing in guilt and ruin, the second, redemption and bliss—is as old as Irenaeus (about 180) and is the fruitful germ of Mariolatry. The mystical change of Eva and Ave is mediaeval—a sort of pious conundrum.
(85; original 506): The words of our Lord to John: "Behold thy mother" (John 19:27), were supposed to be spoken to all Christians.
(86; original 507): Otto, bishop of Bamberg (between 1139 and 1189), is usually reported to have introduced the seven sacraments among the Pomeranians whom he had converted to Christianity, but the discourse on which this tradition rests is of doubtful genuineness. The scholastic number seven was confirmed by the Council of Florence (the Greek delegates assenting), and by the Council of Trent which anathematizes all who teach more or less, Sess. VII. can. I. The Protestant churches admit only two sacraments, baptism and the Lord’s Supper, because these alone are especially commanded by Christ to be observed. Yet ordination and marriage, and in some churches confirmation also, are retained as solemn religious ceremonies.
(87; original 508): The Lutheran church retains confirmation by the minister, the Anglican church by the bishop.
(88; original 509): See above, § 87.
(89; original 510): Here, too, the Protestant (at least the Reformed) confessions differ from the Roman Catholic by requiring faith in active exercise as a condition of receiving the benefit of the sacrament. In the case of infant baptism the faith of the parents or responsible guardians is taken into account. Without such faith the sacrament would be wasted and profaned.
(90; original 511): Character indelebilis
(91; original 512): Organum from the Greek o[rganon, which is used in the Septuagint for several musical terms in Hebrew, as cheli, chinor (cithara), nephel (nablium), yugab. See the passages in Trommius, Concord. Gr. V. LXX, II. 144.
(92; original 513): See Hopkins and Rimbault: The Organ, its History and Construction, 1855; E. de Coussemakee: Histoire, des instruments de musique au moyen-age, Paris 1859; Heinrich Otte: Handbuch der Kirchl. Kunstarchäologie, Leipz. 4th ed. 1866, p. 225 sqq. O. Wangermann: Gesch. der Orgel und der Orgelbaukunst, second ed. 1881. Comp. also Bingham, Augusti, Binterim, Siegel, Alt, and the art. Organ in Smith and Cheetham, Wetzer and Welte, and in Herzog.
(93; original 514): Hence the names campanum, or campana, nola (continued in the Italian language), but it is more probable that the name is derived from Campanian brass (aes campanum), which in early times furnished the material for bells. In later Latin it is called cloqua, cloccum, clocca, cloca, also tintinnabulum, English: clock; German: Glocke; French: cloche; Irish: clog (comp. the Latin clangere and the German klopfen).
(94; original 515): "Ut cloccae non baptizentur." According to Baronius, Annal. ad a. 968, Pope John XIII. baptized the great bell of the Lateran church, and called it John. The reformers of the. sixteenth century renewed the protest of Charlemagne, and abolished the baptism of bells as a profanation of the sacrament, See Siegel, Handbuch der christl. kirchlichen Alterthümer, II. 243.
(95; original 516): Campanarii, campanatores.
(96; original 517): Called Campanile. The one on place of San Marco at Venice is especially celebrated.
(97; original 518): The literature on bells is given by Siegel, II. 239, and Otte, p.2 and 102. We mention Nic. Eggers: de Origine et Nomine Campanarum, Jen., 1684; by the same: De Campanarum Materia et Forma 1685; Waller: De Campanis et praecipuis earum Usibus, Holm., 1694; Eschenwecker: Circa Campanas, Hal. ) 1708; J. B. Thiers. Traité des Cloches, Par., 1719; Montanus: Hist. Nachricht von den Glocken, etc., Chemnitz, 1726; Chrysander: Hist. Nachricht von Kirchen-Glocken, Rinteln, 1755; Heinrich Otte: Glockenkunde, Leipz., 1858; Comp. also his Handbuch der kirchlichen Kunst-Archäologie des deutschen Mittelalters, Leipz., 1868, 4th ed., p. 245-248 (with illustrations); and the articles Bells, Glocken, in the archaeological works of Smith and Cheetham, Wetzer and Welte, and Herzog. Schiller has made the bell the subject of his greatest lyric poem, which ends with this beautiful description of its symbolic meaning:
"Und diess sei fortan ihr Beruf,
Wozu der Meister sie erschuf:
Hoch über’m niedern Erdenleben
Soll sie im blauen Himmelszelt,
Die Nachbarin des Donners, schweben
Und gränzen an die Sternenwelt;
Soll eine Stimme sein von oben,
Wie der Gestirne helle Shaar,
Die ihren Schöpfer wandelnd loben
Und führen das bekränzte Jahr.
Nur ewigen und ersten Dingen
Sei ihr metall’ner Mund geweiht,
Und stündlich mit den schnellen Schwinger
Berühr’ im Fluge sie die Zeit.
Dem Schicksal leihe sie die Zunge;
Selbst herzlos, ohne Mitgefühl,
Begleite sie mit ihrem Schwunge
Des Lebens wechselvolles Spiel.
Und wie der Klang im Ohr vergehet,
Der mächtig tönend ihr entschallt,
So lehre sie, dass nichts bestehet,
Dass alles Irdische verhallt."
(98; original 519): Sometimes also bishops, synods, and, in cases of political importance, kings and emperors. The last case of a metropolitan canonization is ascribed to the archbishop of Rouen, a.d. 1153, in favor of St. Gaucher, or Gaultier, abbot of Pontoise (d. April 9, 1130). But Labbe and Alban Butler state that he was canonized by Celestine III. in 1194. It seems that even at a later date some bishops exercised a limited canonization; hence the prohibition of this practice as improper by Urban VIII. in 1625 and 1634.
(99; original 520): The occasion of the papal decision in 1170 was the fact that the monks of a convent in the diocese of Lisieux worshiped as a saint their prefect, who had been killed in the refectory by two of their number in a state of intoxication.
(100; original 521): Comp. on this subject Benedict XIV. (Lambertini): De Servorum Dei Beatificatione et Beatorum Canonisatione. Bononisae 1734-’38; ed. II. Venet. et Patav. 1743, 4 vol. fol. Ferraris: Bibliotheca Canonica, a. v. "Veneratio Sanctorum." Canonization includes seven privileges: 1) recognition as saint by the whole (Roman) church; 2) invocation in public and private prayers; 3) erection of churches and altars to the honor of the saints; 4) invocation at the celebration of the mass; 5) appointment of special days of commemoration; 6) exhibition of their images with a crown on their head; 7) exhibition of their bones and relics for veneration. The question whether the papal bulls of canonization are infallible and de fide, or only sententia communis et certa, seems to be still disputed among Roman Catholics.
(101; original 522): See Mansi, XIX. f. 169-179. The bull is signed by, the pope, five bishops, nine cardinal priests, an archdeacon and four deacons. It decrees that the memory of Saint Udalricus be venerated "affectu piisimo et devotione fidelissima," and be dedicated to divine worship ("divino cultui dicata"). It justifies it by the reason "quoniam sic adoramus (!) et colimus reliquius m et confessorum, ut eum, Cuius martyres et confessores sunt, adoremus Honaramus servos ut honor redundet in Dominum, qui dixit: Qui vos recipit me recipit’: ac proinde nos, qui fiduciam nostrae justitiae non habemus, illorum precibus et meritis apud clementissimum Deum jugiter adiuvemur." The bull mentions many miracles of Ulrich, "quae sive in corpore, sive extra corpus gesta sunt, videlicet Caecos illuminasse, daemones ab obsessis effugasse, paralyticos curasse, et quam plurima alia signa gessisse." On the life of St. Ulrich see the biography by his friend and companion Gerhard (between 983 and 993), best edition by Wirtz in the Monum. G. Scriptores, IV. 377 sqq.; Acta Sanct., Bolland. ad 4 Jul.; Mabillon, Ada Ordinis S. B., V. 415-477; Braun, Gesch. der Bischöfe von Augsburg (Augsb. 1813), vol. I.; Schrödl, in Wetzer and Welte, vol. XI. 370-383, and Vogel in Herzog1 vol. XVI. 624-628. Ulrich cannot be the author of a tract against celibacy which was first published under his name by Flacius in his Catalogus Testium Veritatis, but dates from the year 1059 when Pope Nicolas II. issued a decree enforcing celibacy. See Vogel, l.c. p. 627.
(102; original 523): The most recent acts of canonization occurred in our generation. Pope Pius IX. canonized in 1862 with great solemnity twenty-six Japanese missionaries and converts of the Franciscan order, who died in a persecution in 1597. Leo XIII. canonized, December 8, 1881, four comparatively obscure saints of ascetic habits and self-denying charity, namely, Giovanni Battista de Rossi, Lorenzo di Brindisi, Giuseppe Labre, and Clara di Montefalco. A Roman priest describes "the blessed Labre" as a saint who "never washed, never changed his linen, generally slept under the arches of the Colosseum and prayed for hours together in the Church of the Orphanage where there is a tablet to his memory." St. Labre evidently did not believe that "cleanliness is next to godliness"
(103; original 524): Omnium Sanctorum Natalis, or Festivas, Solemnitas, Allerheiligenfest. The Greek church had long before a similar festival in commemoration of all martyrs on the first Sunday after Pentecost, called Kuriakh;tw'nJAgivwnpavntwn. Chrysostom, in a sermon for that day, says that on the Octave of Pentecost the Christians were surrounded by the host of martyrs. In the West the first Sunday after Pentecost was devoted to the Trinity, and closed the festival part of the church year. See vol. III. 408.
(104; original 525): Martyrologio Romano, May 13 and Nov. 1. The Pantheon or Rotunda, like Westminster Abbey, and St. Paul’s Cathedral in London, contains the ashes of other distinguished men besides saints, and is the resting-place of Raphael, and since 1883 even of Victor Emanuel, the founder of the Kingdom of Italy, whom the pope regards as a robber of the patrimony of Peter.
(105; original 526): Omnium Fidelium defunctorum Memoria orCommemoratio, Allerseelentag.
(106; original 527): Festum S. Michaelis, or Michaelis Archangeli, Michaelmas.
(107; original 528): Hence also called Festum omnium Angelorum, St. Michael and all Angels.
(108; original 529): In the Eastern church on November 8. The origin of the Eastern celebration is obscure.
(109; original 530): Namely, sundry apparitions of Michael, at Chonae, near Colossae, in Monte Gargano in the diocese of Sipontum in Apulia (variously assigned to a.d. 492, 520, and 536), in Monte Tumba in Normandy (about 710), and especially one to Pope Gregory I. in Rome, or his successor, Boniface III. (607-610), after a pestilence over the Moles Hadriani, which ever since has been called the Castello di St. Angelo, and is adorned by the statue of an angel.
(110; original 531): See vol. III. 444 sq. Acta Sanct., Sept. 29; Siegel, Handbuch der christl. Kirchl. Alterthümer, III. 419-425; Smith & Cheetham, II. 1176-1180; also Augusti, Binterim, and the monographs mentioned by Siegel, p. 419. The angel-worship in Colossae was heretical and probably of Essenic origin. See the commentaries in loc., especially Lightfoot, p. 101 sqq. A council of Laodicea near Colossae, about 363, found it necessary strongly to forbid angelolatry as then still prevailing in Phrygia. St. Augustin repeatedly objects to it, De vera Rel. 110; Conf. X. 42; De Civ. D. X. 19, 25.
(111; original 532): Its advocates were called eijkonolavtrai, xulolavtrai, eijdwdolavtrai.
(112; original 533): timhtikh;proskuvnhsi". For this word the Latin has no precise equivalent. The English word " worship" is used in different senses.
(113; original 534): latreiva. adoratio.
(114; original 535): See § 94, p. 403 sqq.
(115; original 536): Eijkonoklavstai (from klavw, to break), eijkonokauvstai, eijkonomavcoi, cristianokathvgoroi.
(116; original 537): Not Theophilus, as Baronius and Schlosser erroneously call him. See Hefele, III. 372. Theophanes mentions also a renegade Beser, who had become a Mohammedan, and then probably returned to Christianity and stood in high honor at the court of Leo.
(117; original 538): There is considerable confusion about the beginning of the conflict and the precise order of events. See Hefele, III. 376 sqq.
(118; original 539): See summaries of his lovgoiajpologhtikoiv in Schrceckh and Neander.
(119; original 540): According to older historians (Baronius), the pope even excommunicated the emperor, withdrew his Italian subjects from their allegiance, and forbade the payment of tribute. But this is an error. On the contrary, in a second letter, Gregory expressly disclaims the power of interfering with the sovereign, while he denies in the strongest terms the right of the emperor to interfere with the Church. See the two letters of Gregory to Leo (between 726 to 731) in Mansi, XII. 959 sqq., and the discussion in Hefele, III. 389-404.
(120; original 541): The surname Koprwvnumo" (from kovpro", dung) was given him by his enemies on account of his having polluted the baptismal gont in hid infancy. Theophanes, Chronogr. ed. Bonn. I. 615 He was also called Cabellinus, from his love of horses.
(121; original 542): Mansi, XIII. 205-363; Gieseler, II. 16; Hefele, III. 410-418.
(122; original 543): On these persecutions see, besides Theophanes, the Acta Sanct. of the Bolland. for Oct., Tom. VIII. 124 sqq. (publ. Brussels, 1853), and Hefele, III. 421-428.
(123; original 544): The accounts vary between 330 and 367. The Acts are signed by 308 bishops and episcopal representatives. Nicephorus, the almost contemporaneous patriarch of Constantinople, in a letter to Leo III., mentions only 150. See Hefele, III. 460.
(124; original 545): Theodore of the Studium, himself a zealous advocate of image-worship, exposes this trick, and intimates that the council was not strictly oecumenical, although he sometimes gives it that name. The question connected with these two irresponsible monks is discussed with his usual minuteness and prolixity by Walch, X. 551-558. See also Neander, III. 228, and Hefele, III. 459.
(125; original 546): The definition ( o]ro") sanctions the ajspasmo;" kai; timhtikh; proskuvnhsi", osculum (or salutatio) et honoraria adoratio, but not ajlhqinh; latreiva hJ prevpei movnh th'/ qeiva/ fuvsei, vera latria, quae solam divinam naturam decet. Mansi, XIII. 378 sq. The term Gr. ajpasmov" embraces salutation and kiss, the proskuvnhsi", bowing the knee, and other demonstrations of reverence, see p. 450.
(126; original 547): Walch (X. 572) says of these proofs from tradition: "Die untergeschobenen Schriften, die in der Hauptsache nichts entscheidenden Stellen und die mit grosser Unwissenheit verdrehten Aussprüche sind so haeufig, dass man sich beides über die Unwissenheit und Unverschämtheit nicht genug verwundern kann, welche in diesen Sammlungen sichtbar sind." Even moderate Roman Catholic historians, as Alexander Natalia and Fleury, admit quietly the errors in some patristic quotations.
(127; original 548): See the acts of the council in the twelfth and thirteenth vols. of Mansi, and a summary in Hefele, III. 460-482. On the different texts and defective Latin versions, see Walch, X. 420-422, and Hefele, III. 486. Gibbon calls the acts "a curious monument of superstition and ignorance, of falsehood and folly." This is too severe, but not without some foundation. The personal character of Irene cuts a deep shadow over the Council, and would have been condemned even by the Byzantine historians, if her devotion to images had not so blinded them and Roman historians, like Baronius and Maimbourg, that they excuse her darkest crimes and overwhelm her with praise.
(128; original 549): Charlemagne afterwards offered Irene his hand with a view to unite the Eastern and Western empires, and she accepted the offer; but her prime-minister, Aëtius, who wished to raise his own brother, Leo, to the throne, prevented the marriage.
(129; original 550): The memory of Irene is celebrated by the Greeks on the 15th of August. Her patriarch, Tarasius (d. 806), is canonized in the Roman as well as the Greek Church.
(130; original 551): Hefele, IV. 105, says that under this reign the famous poets, Theophanes and his brother, Theodore of the Studium, were punished with two hundred lashes and the branding of Greek mock-verses on their forehead, whence they received the name "the Marked" (graptoiv). But, according to the Bollandists, Theophanes died in 820, and Hefele himself, III. 370, puts his death in 818, although in vol. IV. 108 be reports that Theophanes gravpto"was made bishop of Smyrna by Theodora, 842. See on this conflict in chronology above, p. 407.
(131; original 552): The tongue of slander, however, raised the story of her criminal intimacy with the patriarch Methodius, whom she had appointed. The court instituted an investigation during which the patriarch by indecent exposure furnished the proof of the physical impossibility of sexual sin on his part; whereupon the accuser confessed that she had been bribed by his iconoclastic predecessor. Hefele, IV. 109.
(132; original 553): hJkuriakh;th'"ojrqodoxiva".
(133; original 554): See the description of Walch (X. 800-808) from the Byzantine historians and from Allacci, and King (on the Russian church).
(134; original 555): See Walch, XI. 7-36; Hefele, III. 461-463. The sources are silent. Walch carefully gives the different conjectures of Baronius, Pagi, Daillé, Natalis, Alexander, Maimburg, Fleury, Sirmond, Spanheim, Basnage, Semler. Nothing new has been added since. But the preceding iconoclastic zeal of Bishop Serenus of Marseilles, and the succeeding position of Charlemagne and the Frankish church, rather favor the inference of Sirmond and Spanheim, that the synod rejected the worship of images.
(135; original 556): Alcuin’s share in the composition appears from the similarity of thoughts in his Commentary on John, and the old English tradition that he wrote a book against the Council of Nicaea. See Walch, XI. 65 sqq.; Hefele, III. 697.
(136; original 557): He calls it posterior tempore, non tamen posterior crimine, eloquentia, sensuque carens, synodus ineptissima, etc. He distrusted a Council in which the Church of his dominions was not represented. He also objected to a woman assuming the office of teacher in the church, as being contrary to the lex divina and lex naturae (III. 13, ed. Migne, fol. 1136). He had reason to be angry with Irene for dissolving the betrothal of her son with his daughter.
(137; original 558): The Synod is often called universalis, and condemned Adoptionism (see Hefele, III. 678 sqq. ). The decision against images see in Mansi, xiii. 909. The chief passage is: "Sanctissimi Patres nostri omnimodis et adorationem et servitutem eis [sc. imaginibus Sanctorum] renuentes contemserunt atque, consentientes condemnaverunt." Einhard made the following entry in his Annals ad a.d. 794 (in Pertz, Monum. I. 181, and Gieseler II. 67): "Synodus etiam, quae ante paucos annos in Constantinopoli [where the Nicene Synod was closed] sub Herena [Irene,]et Constantino filio ejus congregata, et ab ipsis non solum septima, verum etiam universalis est appellata, ut nec septima nec universalis haberetur dicereturve, quasi supervacua in totum ab omnibus [the bishops assembled at Frankfort] abdicata est." Baronius, Bellarmin, and even Hefele (III. 689), charge this Synod with misrepresenting the Council of Nicaea, which sanctioned the worship (in a wider sense), but not the adoration, of images. But the Latin version, which the pope sent to Charlemagne, rendered proskuvnhsi" uniformly by adoratio, and Anastasius, the papal librarian, did the same in his improved translation, thus giving double sanction to the confusion.
(138; original 559): This rests partly on the probable share which the Anglo-Saxon Alcuin had in the composition of the Caroline Books, partly on the testimony of Simeon of Durham (about 1100). See Twysden’s Hist. Angl. Scriptores decem I, III; Mon. Hist. Brit., p. 667; Wilkin’s Conc. Magn. Brit., I. 73; Gieseler, II. 67, note 6, and Hardwick’s Church Hist. of the Middle Age, p. 78, note 3.
(139; original 560): There is a difference of opinion whether Charlemagne sent to the pope his whole book, or only an abridgement, and whether he sent Angilbert before or after the Frankfort synod to Rome. Hefele (III. 713) decides that the Capitula (85) were an extract of the Libri Carolini (121 chs.), and that Angilbert was twice in Rome, a.d. 792 and 794. Hadrian’s answer must have been written at all events before Dec. 25, 795. It is printed in Mansi, XIII. 759-810, and Migne, Opera Car. M. II. fol. 1247-1292. It is full of glaring blunders. Bishop Hefele (p. 716) divides the responsibility between the (fallible) pope, the emperor, and the copyists.
(140; original 561): Mansi, XIV. 415 sqq.; Walch, XI. 95 sqq.; Gieseler, II. 68; Hefele, IV. 41 sqq. (second ed. 1879). Walch says (p. 98) that the Roman church played comedy with the acts of this Synod. Mansi was the first to publish them, but he did it with an excuse, and added as indispensable the refutation of Bellarmin in the appendix to his tract De Cultu Imaginum. Hefele and Hergenröther represent this synod as being guilty of the same injustice to the Nicene Council as the Synod of Frankfort; but this does not alter the fact.
(141; original 562): See § 79.
(142; original 563): Reuter (I. 24) calls him "the clearest head of the ninth century," and "the systematizer of the Aufklärung" (i.e. of Rationalism in the middle age).
(143; original 564): De Imaginibus Sanctorum, in Migne, vol. 104, fol. 199-228.
(144; original 565): Cap. 35 (in Migne, fol. 227): "Flectamus genu in nomine solius Jesu, quod est super omne nomen; ne si alteri hunc honorem tribuimus, alieni judicemur a Deo, et dimittamur secundum cordis nostri ire in adinventionibus nostris." Gieseler directs attention to the verbal agreement between Agobart and Claudius in several sentences.
(145; original 566): See Acta SS. Jun. II. 748, and the Elogia de S. Agobardo in Migne, fol. 13-16. The Bollandists honor him with a place in their work, because Masson, the first editor, allows him the title saint, and because he is commonly called St. Aguebatud in the church of Lyons, and is included in the local martyrologies. A rite of nine lessons is assigned to him in the Breviarium Lugdunense.
(146; original 567): In his comments on Paul’s Epistles (in Migne, 104 f. 927 sq. ), he eulogizes Augustin as "amantissimus Domini sanctissimus Augustinus. calamus Trinitatis lingua Spiritus Sancti, terrenus homo, sed coelestis angelus, in quaestionibus solvendis acutus, in revincendis haereticis circumspectus, in explicandis Scripturis canonicis cautus." In the same place, he says of Paul that his epistles are wholly given to destroy man’s merits and to exalt God’s grace ("ut merita hominum tollat, unde maxime nunc monachi gloriantur, et gratiam Dei commendet"). On his Augustinianism, see the judicious remarks of Neander. Reuter (I. 20) calls him both a biblical reformer and a critical rationalist.
(147; original 568): C. Schmidt in Herzog2 III. 245 says of this view: "Deise, sehr spaet, in dogmatischem Interesse aufgenommene Ansicht, die sich bei Léger und andern ja selbst noch bei Hahn findet, hat keinen historischen Grund und ist von allen gründlichen Kennern der Waldensergeshichte längst aufgegeben. Dabei soll nicht geleugnet werden, dass die Tendenzen des Claudius sich noch eine zeitlang in Italien erhalten haben; es ist soeben bemerkt worden, dass, nach dem Zeugniss des Jonas von Orléans, man um 840 versuchte, sie von neuen zu verbreiten. Dass sie sich aber bis zum Auftreten des Peter Waldus und speciell in den piemontesischen Thälern fortgepflanzt, davon ist nicht die geringste Spur vorhanden."
脚注
Best guess 对照表
正文及中文脚注中带上标 * 的外文为 best guess,尚未逐项核实;原始字串保留如下。
| 原字串 | Best guess | 语言 | 出现位置 | 说明 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| jAndreva" Purov" | Ἀνδρέας Πυρός | Greek | 正文第 60 段 | 按旧编码还原姓名,保留单ρ拼法。 |
| Purrov" | Πυρρός | Greek | 正文第 60 段 | 按旧编码还原,保留双ρ异读。 |
| jAnastavsew" hJmevra | Ἀναστάσεως ἡμέρα | Greek | 正文第 72 段 | 按旧编码还原复活节圣诗起句。 |
| !Ihsou' glukuvtate | Ἰησοῦ γλυκύτατε | Greek | 正文第 88 段 | 起首符号应为平气号,呼格与上下文相合。 |
| Kovpon te kai; kavmaton | Κόπον τε καὶ κάματον | Greek | 正文第 116 段 | 按字母及重音编码还原。 |
| ajkolouqiva | ἀκολουθία | Greek | 正文第 276 段 | 与sequentia对应,按旧编码还原。 |
| latreiva | λατρεία | Greek | 正文第 385 段 | 按旧编码还原敬拜术语。 |
| douleiva | δουλεία | Greek | 正文第 385 段 | 按原串还原,保留作者ει拼写。 |
| uJperdouleiva | ὑπερδουλεία | Greek | 正文第 385 段 | 还原粗气号及重音,保留ει拼写。 |
| Lovgoi ajpologhtikoi; pro;" tou;" diabavllonta" ta;" aJgiva" eijkovna" | Λόγοι ἀπολογητικοὶ πρὸς τοὺς διαβάλλοντας τὰς ἁγίας εἰκόνας | Greek | 正文第 396 段 | 按旧编码还原圣像辩护著作题名。 |
| proskunou'men kai; timw'men kai; ajspazovmeqa | προσκυνοῦμεν καὶ τιμῶμεν καὶ ἀσπαζόμεθα | Greek | 正文第 427 段 | 按旧编码还原三个并列动词。 |
| eijkwvn | εἰκών | Greek | 正文第 428 段 | 按旧编码还原icon的希腊词。 |
| o{ro" | ὅρος | Greek | 正文第 440 段 | 决议之义与粗气、锐音编码相合。 |
| kaluvbh | καλύβη | Greek | 正文第 441 段 | 按旧编码还原茅舍一词。 |
| nekrwvsima | νεκρώσιμα | Greek | 脚注 5 | 按旧编码还原亡者圣诗术语。 |
| logikh; latreiva | λογικὴ λατρεία | Greek | 脚注 9 | 与罗马书12:1所引词组相合。 |
| Mhnai'a | Μηναῖα | Greek | 脚注 18 | 按旧编码还原礼仪书复数名。 |
| bibliva | βιβλία | Greek | 脚注 18 | 按旧编码还原所省略的复数名词。 |
| hJ JEllhnikh; tupografiva tou' foivniko" | ἡ Ἑλληνικὴ τυπογραφία τοῦ φοίνικος | Greek | 脚注 18 | 按旧编码还原印刷所名称及气号。 |
| Mhnai'on tou' !Ianouarivou | Μηναῖον τοῦ Ἰανουαρίου | Greek | 脚注 18 | 按旧编码还原一月卷题名。 |
| Mh;n !Ianouavrio" | Μὴν Ἰανουάριος | Greek | 脚注 18 | 依原串保留Μὴν的重音,不径改为通行Μήν。 |
| mnhvmh th'" oJsiva" Mhtro;" hJmw'n Melavnh" th's JRwmaiva" | μνήμη τῆς ὁσίας Μητρὸς ἡμῶν Μελάνης τῆς Ῥωμαίας | Greek | 脚注 18 | 按原串还原纪念日题文,保留Μελάνης拼法。 |
| Paraklhtikhv | Παρακλητική | Greek | 脚注 18 | 按旧编码还原礼仪书名。 |
| bivblo" | βίβλος | Greek | 脚注 18 | 按旧编码还原省略的单数名词。 |
| jOktwvhco" | Ὀκτώηχος | Greek | 脚注 18 | 依原串还原,未添原串未标出的下标ι。 |
| bivblo" | βίβλος | Greek | 脚注 18 | 按旧编码还原省略的单数名词。 |
| Triwv/dion | Τριῴδιον | Greek | 脚注 18 | ω后的斜线应为下标ι编码。 |
| Penthkostavrion | Πεντηκοστάριον | Greek | 脚注 18 | 按旧编码还原五旬期礼仪书名。 |
| melwdoiv | μελωδοί | Greek | 脚注 19 | 按旧编码还原复数称谓。 |
| poihtaiv | ποιηταί | Greek | 脚注 19 | 按旧编码还原复数称谓。 |
| uJmnovgrafoi | ὑμνογράφοι | Greek | 脚注 19 | 还原粗气号及重音。 |
| Tropavrion | Τροπάριον | Greek | 脚注 20 | 按旧编码还原音乐术语。 |
| trovpo" | τρόπος | Greek | 脚注 20 | 按旧编码还原词源词。 |
| Eijrmov" | Εἱρμός | Greek | 脚注 21 | 编码ij表示ι上的粗气号。 |
| ajkolouqiva | ἀκολουθία | Greek | 脚注 21 | 按旧编码还原礼仪术语。 |
| Qeotokivon | Θεοτοκίον | Greek | 脚注 22 | 保留原文明确讨论的倒数第二音节重音。 |
| tropavrion | τροπάριον | Greek | 脚注 22 | 按旧编码还原省略的名词。 |
| qeotovkion | θεοτόκιον | Greek | 脚注 22 | 保留原文对照的倒数第三音节重音。 |
| qeotovko" | θεοτόκος | Greek | 脚注 22 | 按旧编码还原词源词。 |
| !Idiovmelon | Ἰδιόμελον | Greek | 脚注 23 | 起首符号应为平气号。 |
| ajkolouqiva | ἀκολουθία | Greek | 脚注 23 | 按旧编码还原。 |
| ajnabaqmoiv | ἀναβαθμοί | Greek | 脚注 23 | 按旧编码还原复数术语。 |
| ajntivfwnon | ἀντίφωνον | Greek | 脚注 23 | 按旧编码还原。 |
| ajpolutivkion | ἀπολυτίκιον | Greek | 脚注 23 | 按旧编码还原晚祷短颂名称。 |
| ajpovstica, auvtomelon, ejxaposteilavrion, ejwqinav, kavqisma, katabasiva, kontavria, makarismoiv, megalunavria, oi\koi, prosovmoia, stichrav, triwv/dia, tetrawv/da, diwv/dia, yalthvrion, tropolovgion | ἀπόστιχα, αὐτόμελον, ἐξαποστειλάριον, ἑωθινά, κάθισμα, καταβασία, κοντάρια, μακαρισμοί, μεγαλυνάρια, οἶκοι, προσόμοια, στιχρά, τριῴδια, τετρῴδα, διῴδια, ψαλτήριον, τροπολόγιον | Greek | 脚注 23 | 逐项还原;αὐτόμελον、ἑωθινά据术语补正气号,保留κοντάρια、στιχρά等原拼法。 |
| Dovxa ejn uJyivstoi" qew'/ | Δόξα ἐν ὑψίστοις θεῷ | Greek | 脚注 26 | 按旧编码还原荣耀颂起句及下标ι。 |
| Aijnei'te, pai'de" . kuvrion | Αἰνεῖτε, παῖδες, κύριον | Greek | 脚注 26 | 按旧编码还原;孤立句点疑为呼语后的逗号讹误。 |
| Fw'" iJlaro;n aJgiva" dovxh" | Φῶς ἱλαρὸν ἁγίας δόξης | Greek | 脚注 26 | 按旧编码还原晚祷圣诗起句。 |
| stichra; ajnastavsima | στιχρὰ ἀναστάσιμα | Greek | 脚注 28 | 按原串还原,保留στιχρά的缺η拼法。 |
| ijdiovmela | ἰδιόμελα | Greek | 脚注 28 | 按旧编码还原复数术语。 |
| stichra; ajnatolikav | στιχρὰ ἀνατολικά | Greek | 脚注 28 | 按原串还原,保留στιχρά拼法。 |
| katanuktikav | κατανυκτικά | Greek | 脚注 28 | 按旧编码还原。 |
| nekrwvsima | νεκρώσιμα | Greek | 脚注 28 | 按旧编码还原。 |
| Eij" th;n cristou' gevnnhsin | Εἰς τὴν χριστοῦ γέννησιν | Greek | 脚注 30 | 按旧编码还原篇名,保留原有小写。 |
| eij" th;n qeogonivan | εἰς τὴν θεογονίαν | Greek | 脚注 30 | 按旧编码还原另一篇名。 |
| Eij" ta; qeofavneia, Eij" th;n kuriakh;n tou' Pavsca, Eij" th;n pentekosthvn, Eij" th;n ajnavlhyin tou' Cristou',Eujchv, jIdiovmela ejn ajkolouqiva tou' ejxodiastikou', Eij" th;n koivmhsin th'" qeotovkou | Εἰς τὰ θεοφάνεια, Εἰς τὴν κυριακὴν τοῦ Πάσχα, Εἰς τὴν πεντεκοστήν, Εἰς τὴν ἀνάληψιν τοῦ Χριστοῦ, Εὐχή, Ἰδιόμελα ἐν ἀκολουθία τοῦ ἐξοδιαστικοῦ, Εἰς τὴν κοίμησιν τῆς θεοτόκου | Greek | 脚注 30 | 逐项还原篇名,保留原串πεντεκοστήν、ἐξοδιαστικοῦ等拼写。 |
| jAnoivxw to; stovma mou, | Ἀνοίξω τὸ στόμα μου, | Greek | 脚注 30 | 按旧编码还原诗句。 |
| kai; plhrwqhvsetai pneuvmato": | καὶ πληρωθήσεται πνεύματος: | Greek | 脚注 30 | 按旧编码还原诗句。 |
| kai; lovgou ejpeuvxomai th'/ basilivdi mhtriv: | καὶ λόγου ἐπεύξομαι τῇ βασιλίδι μητρί: | Greek | 脚注 30 | 按原串还原,保留λόγου等原有读法。 |
| kai; ojfqhvsomai faidrw'"panhgurivzwn: | καὶ ὀφθήσομαι φαιδρῶς πανηγυρίζων: | Greek | 脚注 30 | 按旧编码还原并补词间空格。 |
| kai; a[/sw ghqovmeno" tauvth" ta; qauvmata. | καὶ ᾄσω γηθόμενος ταύτης τὰ θαύματα. | Greek | 脚注 30 | 还原ᾄ的气号、重音及下标ι。 |
| Eij" th;n tou' Cristou' gevnnhsin, Eij" ta; qeofavneia, Eij" th;n penthkosthvn, Pro;" Cristovn, Ei" th;n u{ywsin tou' staurou', Eij" to; mevga savbbaton | Εἰς τὴν τοῦ Χριστοῦ γέννησιν, Εἰς τὰ θεοφάνεια, Εἰς τὴν πεντηκοστήν, Πρὸς Χριστόν, Εἰς τὴν ὕψωσιν τοῦ σταυροῦ, Εἰς τὸ μέγα σάββατον | Greek | 脚注 31 | 逐项还原篇名;第五项据重复词形补平气号。 |
| Cristo;" genna'tai: dovxasate: | Χριστὸς γεννᾶται: δοξάσατε: | Greek | 脚注 31 | 按旧编码还原圣诞圣诗。 |
| Cristo;" ejx oujranw'n: ajpanthvsate: | Χριστὸς ἐξ οὐρανῶν: ἀπαντήσατε: | Greek | 脚注 31 | 按旧编码还原诗句。 |
| Cristo;" ejpi; gh'" : uJywvqhte: | Χριστὸς ἐπὶ γῆς: ὑψώθητε: | Greek | 脚注 31 | 按旧编码还原诗句。 |
| a[/sate tw'/ kurivw/ pa'sa hJ gh', | ᾄσατε τῷ κυρίῳ πᾶσα ἡ γῆ, | Greek | 脚注 31 | 还原气号、重音及下标ι。 |
| kai; ejn eujfrosuvnh/ | καὶ ἐν εὐφροσύνῃ | Greek | 脚注 31 | 按旧编码还原,末尾斜线为下标ι。 |
| ajnumnhvsate, laoiv, | ἀνυμνήσατε, λαοί, | Greek | 脚注 31 | 按原串还原,保留ἀνυμνήσατε读法。 |
| o{ti dedoxastai. | ὅτι δεδόξασται. | Greek | 脚注 31 | 按词形补原串漏标的δεδόξασται重音。 |
| @o Graptov" | ὁ Γραπτός | Greek | 脚注 32 | 起首异常符号应表示冠词粗气号。 |
| ajkavqisto" | ἀκάθιστος | Greek | 脚注 34 | 按旧编码还原不坐颂名称。 |
| u{mno" | ὕμνος | Greek | 脚注 34 | 按旧编码还原省略的名词。 |
| th'"qeotovkou | τῆς θεοτόκου | Greek | 脚注 34 | 按旧编码还原并补词间空格。 |
| kaqivsmata | καθίσματα | Greek | 脚注 34 | 按旧编码还原复数术语。 |
| kaqivzesqai | καθίζεσθαι | Greek | 脚注 34 | 按旧编码还原不定式。 |
| ajnakreovntika | ἀνακρεόντικα | Greek | 脚注 35 | 按旧编码还原诗体名称。 |
| ijdiovmelatw'nQeofaneivwn | ἰδιόμελα τῶν Θεοφανείων | Greek | 脚注 35 | 按旧编码还原并分开连写词。 |
| u{mno"iJkethvrio"ei"Cristovn | ὕμνος ἱκετήριος εἰς Χριστόν | Greek | 脚注 36 | 还原连写词组,按εἰς词形补平气号。 |
| ijdiovmelon | ἰδιόμελον | Greek | 脚注 37 | 按旧编码还原。 |
| Salpivswmen ejn savlpiggi ajsmavtwn | Σαλπίσωμεν ἐν σάλπιγγι ᾀσμάτων | Greek | 脚注 37 | 按诗歌词义推测ἀσμάτων漏下标ι,应为ᾀσμάτων。 |
| Oujden ga;r ajduvnaton th'/ mesiteiva/ sou. | Οὐδὲν γὰρ ἀδύνατον τῇ μεσιτείᾳ σου. | Greek | 脚注 37 | 按旧编码还原,并补Οὐδὲν所缺重音。 |
| Eujfraivnesqe divkaioi: | Εὐφραίνεσθε δίκαιοι: | Greek | 脚注 38 | 按旧编码还原诗句。 |
| Oujranoi; ajgallia'sqe: | Οὐρανοὶ ἀγαλλιᾶσθε: | Greek | 脚注 38 | 按旧编码还原诗句。 |
| Skirthvsate ta; o{rh, | Σκιρτήσατε τὰ ὅρη, | Greek | 脚注 38 | 按旧编码还原诗句。 |
| Tou' Cristou' gennhqevnto"./ | Τοῦ Χριστοῦ γεννηθέντος. | Greek | 脚注 38 | 按旧编码还原;句点后斜线疑为杂入符号。 |
| aujtovmelonei"tou;"ajpost. Pevtronkai;Pau'lon | αὐτόμελον εἰς τοὺς ἀποστ. Πέτρον καὶ Παῦλον | Greek | 脚注 39 | 还原并分词,保留ἀποστ.缩写,补εἰς平气号。 |
| oJkuvrio"e[rcetai | ὁ κύριος ἔρχεται | Greek | 脚注 42 | 按旧编码还原并分词。 |
| uJmnovgrafo" | ὑμνογράφος | Greek | 脚注 43 | 按旧编码还原圣诗作者称谓。 |
| xevno" | ξένος | Greek | 脚注 43 | 按旧编码还原外乡人一词。 |
| Kanw;neij"th;nuJperagivanqeotovkon | Κανὼν εἰς τὴν ὑπεραγίαν θεοτόκον | Greek | 脚注 47 | 按旧编码还原并分词。 |
| parqevnion | παρθένιον | Greek | 脚注 48 | 按旧编码还原童女诗名称。 |
| DoxaejnuJyivstoi" | Δόξα ἐν ὑψίστοις | Greek | 脚注 51 | 分词并据荣耀颂起句补Δόξα重音。 |
| kaqjhJmevran | καθ’ ἡμέραν | Greek | 脚注 51 | 连写串应为省音形式καθ’加ἡμέραν。 |
| eij"tou;"aijw'na" | εἰς τοὺς αἰῶνας | Greek | 脚注 51 | 按旧编码还原并分词。 |
| tou' | τοῦ | Greek | 脚注 71 | 按旧编码还原属格冠词。 |
| o[rganon | ὄργανον | Greek | 脚注 91 | 按旧编码还原乐器一词。 |
| reliquius m | reliquias martyrum | Latin | 脚注 101 | 据colimus宾语及后文et confessorum推测为殉道者遗物,m疑为残损缩写。 |
| Kuriakh;tw'nJAgivwnpavntwn | Κυριακὴ τῶν Ἁγίων πάντων | Greek | 脚注 103 | 按旧编码还原诸圣主日名称。 |
| eijkonolavtrai | εἰκονολάτραι | Greek | 脚注 111 | 按旧编码还原。 |
| xulolavtrai | ξυλολάτραι | Greek | 脚注 111 | 按旧编码还原。 |
| eijdwdolavtrai | εἰδωδολάτραι | Greek | 脚注 111 | 依原串保留多出的δ,疑为εἰδωλολάτραι之讹,未径改。 |
| timhtikh;proskuvnhsi" | τιμητικὴ προσκύνησις | Greek | 脚注 112 | 按旧编码还原并分词。 |
| latreiva | λατρεία | Greek | 脚注 113 | 按旧编码还原。 |
| Eijkonoklavstai | Εἰκονοκλάσται | Greek | 脚注 115 | 按旧编码还原毁像派称谓。 |
| klavw | κλάω | Greek | 脚注 115 | 按旧编码还原词源动词。 |
| eijkonokauvstai | εἰκονοκαῦσται | Greek | 脚注 115 | 按原串保留合音符位置。 |
| eijkonomavcoi | εἰκονομάχοι | Greek | 脚注 115 | 按旧编码还原。 |
| cristianokathvgoroi | χριστιανοκατήγοροι | Greek | 脚注 115 | 按旧编码还原。 |
| lovgoiajpologhtikoiv | λόγοι ἀπολογητικοί | Greek | 脚注 118 | 按旧编码还原并分词。 |
| Koprwvnumo" | Κοπρώνυμος | Greek | 脚注 120 | 按旧编码还原绰号。 |
| kovpro" | κόπρος | Greek | 脚注 120 | 按旧编码还原词源词。 |
| o]ro" | ὅρος | Greek | 脚注 125 | 据决议之义及正文同词,异常右方括号应为粗气锐音。 |
| ajspasmo;" kai; timhtikh; proskuvnhsi" | ἀσπασμὸς καὶ τιμητικὴ προσκύνησις | Greek | 脚注 125 | 按旧编码还原并保留原有主格形式。 |
| ajlhqinh; latreiva hJ prevpei movnh th'/ qeiva/ fuvsei | ἀληθινὴ λατρεία ἣ πρέπει μόνῃ τῇ θείᾳ φύσει | Greek | 脚注 125 | 结合关系句及拉丁对译,推测ἡ、μόνη应为ἣ、μόνῃ。 |
| ajpasmov" | ἀσπασμός | Greek | 脚注 125 | 据本注前文同词及亲吻之义,推测原串漏σ。 |
| proskuvnhsi" | προσκύνησις | Greek | 脚注 125 | 按旧编码还原。 |
| graptoiv | γραπτοί | Greek | 脚注 130 | 按旧编码还原复数称号。 |
| gravpto" | γράπτος | Greek | 脚注 130 | 依原串保留首音节重音,不改作通常的γραπτός。 |
| hJkuriakh;th'"ojrqodoxiva" | ἡ κυριακὴ τῆς ὀρθοδοξίας | Greek | 脚注 132 | 按旧编码还原并分词。 |
| proskuvnhsi" | προσκύνησις | Greek | 脚注 137 | 按旧编码还原敬礼术语。 |
参见丹尼尔的《礼仪文献汇编》(Codex Liturg.) 第I卷,第3—168页,其中将《格列高利罗马弥撒礼规》(Ordo Missae Romanae Gregorianus) 与《格拉修礼规、安布罗修礼规、高卢礼规、莫扎拉布礼规》(Ordo Gelasianus, Ambrosianus, Gallicanus, Mozarabicus) 等作了比较。↩︎
《对话录》(Dialog.),第IV卷,第58章(米涅版,第III卷,第425页及下页):“Quis fidelium habere dubium possit, in ipsa immolationis hora ad sacerdotis vocem coelis aperiri, in illo jesu Christi mysteria angelorum choros adesse, summis ima sociari, terrena coelestibus jungi, unumque ex visibilibus atque invisibilibus fieri?”(有哪一个信徒会怀疑:就在献祭之时,随着祭司的声音,诸天敞开,众天使列班临在耶稣基督的这一奥秘中,至卑之物与至高之物相连,地上的与天上的相接,可见的与不可见的合而为一?)↩︎
亡者弥撒,Misae pro Defunctis, Todtenmessen, Seelenmessen。与此不同的是圣徒弥撒 (Missae de Sanctis),在圣徒的周年纪念日举行,以尊荣他们,虽然祭总是献给上帝的。↩︎
即使教皇,虽然在世时被尊称为“圣座”,也必须经过炼狱,需要信徒的祷告。庇护九世 (Pius IX.) 的在位时间比历任前任都长,又曾在梵蒂冈会议(1870年)宣告自己无谬;他的大理石石棺上却刻着:“Orate pro eo”(请为他祷告)。祷告和弥撒只为炼狱中的亡者而献,不为天上的圣徒,因为他们不需要;也不为地狱中被定罪的人,因为他们不能从中得益。↩︎
引自东方教会的《详本教理问答》(沙弗:《信经》[Creeds],第II卷,第504页)。希腊教会的礼仪中有专为亡者而作的诗节或交替圣歌,称为 νεκρώσιμα*。莫内的《中世纪拉丁圣诗》(Lat. Hymnen des Mittel alters),第II卷,第400页,列有大马士革的约翰及其他人的若干范例。他说,希腊教会为亡者而作的圣诗比拉丁教会更多,但拉丁教会的亡者圣诗 (hymni pro defunctis) 更为古老,始于普鲁登提乌斯。↩︎
独诵弥撒 (Missae solitariae) 或私弥撒 (privatae)。↩︎
教规 (Can.) 第48条。曼西,第XIV卷,第529页及后;赫费勒,第IV卷,第64页。↩︎
参见下一章关于神学争论的论述。↩︎
比较 λογικὴ λατρεία*,罗马书12:1。↩︎
第四会期(1546年4月8日):“Sacrosancta Synodus … statuit et declarat, ut haec ipsa vetus et vulgata editio, quiae longo tot saeculorum usu in ipsa ecclesia probata est, in publicis lectionibus, disputationibus, praedicationibus et expositionibus pro authentica habeatur;. et ut nemo illam rejicere quovis praetextu audeat vel praesumat!”(神圣会议……规定并宣告:这部古老的通行译本,既经教会本身如此多世纪的长期使用而获认可,在公开诵读、辩论、讲道和释经中,就应被视为权威文本;任何人都不得胆敢或擅自以任何借口拒绝它!)会议曾作出安排,要对武加大译本进行权威性的修订(1546年4月8日);然而,教皇西克斯图斯五世 (Sixtus V.) 的版本于1589年问世,并“以使徒权力的全备”强令教会采用之后,却被发现充满错误与疏失,不得不撤销,并于1592年在革利免八世 (Clement VIII.) 主持下另编新本;直到今日,这仍是罗马教会的标准版本。↩︎
正如今日在严格奉行罗马天主教的国家中一样;只是有所不同:在异教和半异教的无知迷信时代尚可原谅的事,在文明发达、具备各种教育机构和设施的时代,就不可原谅了。↩︎
参见哈丹 (Haddan) 与斯塔布斯 (Stubbs) 的《会议与教会文献》(Councils and Eccles. Doc.),第360—376页所载此次会议的议事录;又参卜尼法斯致卡思伯特 (Cuthbert) 的信,其中叙述了德国一次类似的会议,并建议对英格兰教会采取改革措施,第376—382页。↩︎
其他会议也通过了类似的教规。参见赫费勒,第III卷,第758、764页,及第IV卷,第89、111、126、197、513、582页;曼西,第XIV卷,第82页及后。↩︎
赫费勒,第III卷,第745页。↩︎
F. 达恩 (F. Dahn):《执事保罗的生平与著作》(Des Paulus Diaconus Leben und Schriften),1876年;又参《日耳曼史料集·六至九世纪伦巴第与意大利史家》(Mon. Germ. Scriptores rerum Langobardicarum et Italicarum saec. VI.-IX.),1878年,第45—187页,由 L. 贝特曼 (L. Bethmann) 与 G. 怀茨 (G. Waitz) 编辑;瓦滕巴赫 (Wattenbach):《德国史料》(Deutschlands Geschichtsquellen),第4版,1877年,第I卷,第134—140页。↩︎
参见上文第41、105、106页。英格兰第一位基督教诗人凯德蒙的意译诗,曾由索普 (Thorpe)、布特韦克 (Bouterweck)、格赖因 (Grein)、赖特 (Wright)、埃特米勒 (Ettmüller)、桑德拉尔 (Sandrar)、莫利 (Morley)、滕布林克 (Ten Brink) 等人编辑或讨论(参见《沙弗—赫尔措格百科全书》Caedmon 条下的参考文献);撒克逊的《救主》(Heliand) 和奥特弗里德的《基督》(Krist),则由西弗斯 (Sievers)、雷特贝格 (Rettberg)、维尔马尔 (Vilmar)、莱希勒 (Lechler)、格拉夫 (Graff)、凯勒 (Kelle)、米歇尔森 (Michelsen) 等人编辑或讨论(参见赫尔措格百科全书第2版,第IV卷,第428—435页)。↩︎
尼尔和皮特拉指出了这一联系,雅科比(前引书 [l.c.],第210页及下页)评论道:“Im Kampfe für die Bilder steigerte sich die Glut der sinnlichen Frömmigkeit, und mit dem Siege der Bilderverehrung im neunten Jahrhundert ist eine innerliche und aeusserliche Zunahme des Heiligenkultus und namentlich ein Wachsthum der Marienvehrung unverkennbar.”(在维护圣像的斗争中,感官性虔敬的热情愈加炽烈;随着九世纪圣像敬奉的胜利,圣徒崇拜在内在与外在方面的增长,尤其是马利亚敬奉的扩展,都是显而易见的。)↩︎
Μηναῖα*(省略了 βιβλία*,即 Monatsbücher,月课经)由威尼斯 (Venice) 的希腊印刷所 (Tipografia Greca,ἡ Ἑλληνικὴ τυπογραφία τοῦ φοίνικος*) 出版。每个月都有单独的书名:Μηναῖον τοῦ Ἰανουαρίου* 或 Μὴν Ἰανουάριος* 等。一月以纪念我主受割礼和大巴西尔的纪念日开始,十二月则以 μνήμη τῆς ὁσίας Μητρὸς ἡμῶν Μελάνης τῆς Ῥωμαίας* 结束。我面前的这部书(来自哈佛大学图书馆)标明的出版年份为1852年,以优美的希腊字体印刷,礼仪指示用红墨印出。关于较早的版本,参见莫内:《拉丁圣诗》(Lat. Hymnen),第II卷,第x页及后。希腊礼仪的其他书籍包括《祈慰经》(Paracletice,Παρακλητική*,省略了 βίβλος*),又称大《八调经》(Octoechus,Ὀκτώηχος*,省略了 βίβλος*),其中载有主日礼仪;《三颂组》(Triodion,Τριῴδιον*,即大斋期用卷);以及《五旬期经》(Pentecostarion,Πεντηκοστάριον*,即复活节期的日课)。尼尔说:“据保守估计,这些书共有5,000页密排的双栏四开本,其中至少4,000页是诗歌。”参见利奥·阿拉提乌斯 (Leo Allatius) 的大部著作《论希腊人的教会书籍》(De libris eccles. Graecorum);戈阿尔 (Goar) 的《希腊祈祷书或礼典》(Euchologion sive Rituale Graecorum);尤其参见尼尔的《神圣东方教会史》(History of the Holy Eastern Church,1850年),第II卷,第819页及后。↩︎
因此,他们既被称为 μελωδοί*,也被称为 ποιηταί*,以区别于仅仅撰写圣诗的 ὑμνογράφοι*。希腊礼仪书也是乐谱集。克里斯特 (Christ) 在《导论》(Prol.),第CXI—CXLII页,讨论拜占庭音乐,并提供若干范例。↩︎
Τροπάριον* 是 τρόπος* 的指小形式,正如 modulus 是 modus 的指小形式一样;它原是一个音乐术语。↩︎
Εἱρμός*,即 tractus,意为一连串、系列,起初也同 ἀκολουθία* 和拉丁文 jubilatio, sequentia 一样,是音乐术语。参见§ 96。↩︎
Θεοτοκίον*,即 τροπάριον*(较少见、但更正确的形式是将重音置于倒数第三音节的 θεοτόκιον*),源自 θεοτόκος*,即 Deipara(生神者)。stauro-theotokion(十字架生神女颂)颂咏十字架旁的马利亚,与拉丁人的《圣母痛苦侍立》(Stabat Mater dolorosa) 相对应。↩︎
Ἰδιόμελον*。各类诗歌还有若干其他名称,如 ἀκολουθία*(拉丁文 sequentia,继叙咏)、ἀναβαθμοί*(tria antiphona,三首交唱)、ἀντίφωνον*、ἀπολυτίκιον*(breve troparium sub finem officii vespertini,晚祷结束时的短颂)、ἀπόστιχα, αὐτόμελον, ἐξαποστειλάριον, ἑωθινά, κάθισμα, καταβασία, κοντάρια, μακαρισμοί, μεγαλυνάρια, οἶκοι, προσόμοια, στιχρά, τριῴδια, τετρῴδα, διῴδια, ψαλτήριον, τροπολόγιον*。克里斯特 (Christ) 在《导论》(Prolegomena) 中详尽讨论了这些术语和专门形式。亦参尼尔的导言。↩︎
整理者有福尔姆鲍姆 (Vormbaum,载于丹尼尔《宝库》[Thesaurus] 第三卷,该卷需要重新编订)、皮特拉和克里斯特。欧洲大陆的作者似乎不知道尼尔博士;他是英国最精通希腊教会礼仪和诗歌文献的学者。诚然,他的翻译是极为自由的再创作和移植,但也正因如此,比原作更适合西方人的趣味。亚历山大里亚的革利免颂赞逻各斯 (Logos) 的圣诗,经亨利·M. 德克斯特 (Henry M. Dexter) 博士作了类似的改写,得以用于公共崇拜。见第II卷,第231页。↩︎
即使尼尔如此钦佩希腊教会,也承认《月课经》中充斥着“泛滥成灾的无价值作品:同义反复,一再重复,直到几乎令人作呕;最平庸的陈词滥调,一再披上悲剧语言华而不实的碎片,以略有变化的词句,把同一个思想说上二三十遍。”(《东方教会圣诗》[Hymns E.Ch.],第3版,第88页及下页。)↩︎
见第II卷,第227页;并在该处所引文献之外补充:克里斯特,第38—40页;他依据《亚历山大抄本》(Codex Alexandrinus) 及其他抄本,刊出希腊教会晨祷圣诗(扩充的天使颂歌 Δόξα ἐν ὑψίστοις θεῷ*)及两首晚祷圣诗(Αἰνεῖτε, παῖδες, κύριον* 和 Φῶς ἱλαρὸν ἁγίας δόξης*)的希腊文文本。↩︎
见第III卷,第581、921页。克里斯特的诗集以叙内修斯 (Synesius) 的圣诗(第3—23页)和拿先斯的贵格利的圣诗(第23—32页)开篇。↩︎
例诗见第III卷,第583—585页。尼尔的译集以阿纳托利乌斯 (Anatolius) 开篇。克里斯特在第XLI页论及他,并在第113—117页刊出他的 στιχρὰ ἀναστάσιμα* 和三首 ἰδιόμελα*(有自己曲调的圣诗)。《月课经》和《八调经》中有一百多首诗署名为阿纳托利乌斯,但克里斯特推测,στιχρὰ ἀνατολικά* 是一个类别名称,如同 κατανυκτικά* 和 νεκρώσιμα* 一样。↩︎
关于这座全巴勒斯坦最奇特的建筑,见我的《圣经之地游记》(Through Bible Lands,纽约 [N. Y.],1879年),第278页及后。↩︎
大马士革的约翰 (John of D.) 的诗作,见勒基安编《著作集》(Opera,巴黎 [Par.],1712年),第I卷,第673—693页;《古希腊诗人集》(Poëtae Graeci veteres,科隆 [Colon.],1614年),第II卷,第737页及后;克里斯特,《希腊诗选》(Anthol. gr.),《导论》,第XLIV页及后,以及第117—121、205—236页。福尔姆鲍姆在丹尼尔,第III卷,第80—97页,刊出他的六首希腊文颂歌;贝斯勒,第162—164页,刊出两首(另有两首德译,见第21、22页);尼尔有九首英译。他最好的圣诗和颂诗组曲是 Εἰς τὴν χριστοῦ γέννησιν*(或 εἰς τὴν θεογονίαν*)、Εἰς τὰ θεοφάνεια, Εἰς τὴν κυριακὴν τοῦ Πάσχα, Εἰς τὴν πεντεκοστήν, Εἰς τὴν ἀνάληψιν τοῦ Χριστοῦ, Εὐχή, Ἰδιόμελα ἐν ἀκολουθία τοῦ ἐξοδιαστικοῦ, Εἰς τὴν κοίμησιν τῆς θεοτόκου*。最后一首以下列诗节开篇(克里斯特,第229页):
Ἀνοίξω τὸ στόμα μου,*
καὶ πληρωθήσεται πνεύματος:*
καὶ λόγου ἐπεύξομαι τῇ βασιλίδι μητρί:*
καὶ ὀφθήσομαι φαιδρῶς πανηγυρίζων:*
καὶ ᾄσω γηθόμενος ταύτης τὰ θαύματα.*↩︎
加兰迪 (Gallandi),《教父文库》(Bibl. Patrum),第XIII卷,第234页及后;克里斯特,第XLIX页及下页,第161—164页。克里斯特称他为“princeps melodorum graecorum”(希腊圣诗作曲家之首),并刊出他的十首颂诗组曲及数首三颂组;丹尼尔(第III卷,第55—79页)刊出十二首颂歌。其中最好的有 Εἰς τὴν τοῦ Χριστοῦ γέννησιν, Εἰς τὰ θεοφάνεια, Εἰς τὴν πεντηκοστήν, Πρὸς Χριστόν, Εἰς τὴν ὕψωσιν τοῦ σταυροῦ, Εἰς τὸ μέγα σάββατον*。尼尔重译了科斯马斯 (Cosmas) 的八首颂歌,以及一首咏变像的集句诗。圣诞圣诗开篇如下(克里斯特,第165页):
Χριστὸς γεννᾶται: δοξάσατε:*
Χριστὸς ἐξ οὐρανῶν: ἀπαντήσατε:*
Χριστὸς ἐπὶ γῆς: ὑψώθητε:*
ᾄσατε τῷ κυρίῳ πᾶσα ἡ γῆ,*
καὶ ἐν εὐφροσύνῃ*
ἀνυμνήσατε, λαοί,*
ὅτι δεδόξασται.*↩︎
ὁ Γραπτός*,此称号与他所受的苦难有关。↩︎
据克里斯特(《导论》[Prol.],第XLIV页),842年君士坦丁堡各教堂恢复圣像后,他被选为尼西亚都主教,并安然去世。但据博兰派学者 (Bollandists) 及其他权威记载,他早在约818或820年流放于萨莫色雷斯 (Samothrace) 时,便因维护圣像所受的苦难而死。尼尔记述,狄奥法尼斯幼年与一位名叫梅加利斯 (Megalis) 的女子订婚,却在婚礼当天劝她退隐女修道院。克里斯特在第121—130页刊出他的数首自调圣诗及亡者颂 (stichera necrosima)。亦见丹尼尔,第III卷,第110—112页,以及尼尔所译乳酪主日(即大斋前第五十日主日,Quinquagesima)的星期五所用自调圣诗,和乳酪主日第一次晚祷所用的颂诗(第90—95页)。最后一首被尼尔题为《亚当的哀诉》;他认为弥尔顿 (Milton)“身为一位博通的学者”,在写夏娃的哀歌时,必定想到我们在正文中所引的最后一节。然而,这是十分可疑的。狄奥法尼斯的《编年史》(Chronographia) 刊于1839年波恩版拜占庭史家丛书,以及米涅《希腊教父集》(Patrol. Graeca) 第108卷(1861年)。他的传记见博兰派编《圣徒行传》(Acta Sanct.),3月12日条。↩︎
克里斯特(第LII页及下页,第140—147页)主要从年代方面加以论证。这首诗称为 ἀκάθιστος*(即 ὕμνος*)τῆς θεοτόκου*,因为吟唱时,祭司和会众都站着。唱其他圣诗时,他们则坐着;因此,后者称为 καθίσματα*(源自 καθίζεσθαι*)。见克里斯特,《导论》,第LXII页及第54页及后。雅科比论《不坐颂》说(前引书,第230页):“对圣童女的热忱,对圣经预表以及一般宗教题材和思想的认识所能成就的一切,语言的华美、表达的娴熟、节奏与押韵的艺术所能增添的一切,在这里都达到了无与伦比的程度。”↩︎
克里斯特,第XXVII、XXXV、LIII、43—47页(ἀνακρεόντικα*),以及第96页(ἰδιόμελα τῶν Θεοφανείων*)。丹尼尔,第III卷,第20—46页,依据 Pet. 梅特兰加 (Pet. Metranga) 的《罗马辑遗》(Spicilegium Romanum,1840年),第IV卷,刊出索弗罗尼乌斯的十三篇作品。↩︎
《古希腊诗人集》(Poetae Gr. vet.),第II卷,第192页及后。丹尼尔,第III卷,第97—103页,刊出三首圣诗,其中有一首优美的 ὕμνος ἱκετήριος εἰς Χριστόν*。克里斯特未收录马克西穆斯 (Maximus)。↩︎
见他的《著作集》(Opera),载米涅《希腊教父集》(Patrol. Graeca),第98卷(1865年);其诗作见克里斯特,第XLIII、98页(咏圣诞的 ἰδιόμελον*);丹尼尔,第III卷,第79页,有一首颂赞马利亚的圣诗,起首为 Σαλπίσωμεν ἐν σάλπιγγι ᾀσμάτων*,结尾则将无所不能的代求之能归于她:
Οὐδὲν γὰρ ἀδύνατον τῇ μεσιτείᾳ σου.*↩︎
Fr. 孔贝菲修斯 (Fr. Combefisius) 首次编印克里特的安德烈 (Andreas Cretensis) 的著作,巴黎,1644年。克里斯特,第147—161页,刊出“大颂诗组曲”的第一部分(约四分之一),以及一首新发现的颂赞彼得的颂诗组曲。后者未收入《月课经》,而是皮特拉枢机从巴黎和梵蒂冈的抄本中发掘出来的。丹尼尔,第III卷,第47—54页,收录安德烈的七首圣诗,第一首咏圣诞,开篇如下:
Εὐφραίνεσθε δίκαιοι:*
Οὐρανοὶ ἀγαλλιᾶσθε:*
Σκιρτήσατε τὰ ὅρη,*
Τοῦ Χριστοῦ γεννηθέντος.*
尼尔翻译了四篇:大星期四颂诗;棕枝主日短颂;大颂诗组曲的一部分;大斋期第二周颂诗。他的《著作集》(Opera) 见米涅《希腊教父集》(Patrol. Gr.),第97卷(1860年),第1306页及后。↩︎
克里斯特,第xlii页及下页,以及第83页,αὐτόμελον εἰς τοὺς ἀποστ. Πέτρον καὶ Παῦλον*。见《月课经》(Men.),6月29日。↩︎
克里斯特和丹尼尔都未提到司提反 (Stephen)。尼尔将自己所译的唯一一首圣诗称为“第一变调周自调圣诗”,并补充说:“这些诗节在我看来十分甜美,却并非所有版本的《八调经》都有。”他又将一首咏马尔萨巴修道院殉道者(3月20日)的诗作,以及一首咏受割礼的诗作归于司提反。他说:“他的风格似乎是以圣科斯马斯为模范,而不是以他自己的叔父为模范。他不乏优雅与丰富的预表,却显得有些单调,偶尔还使用十分生硬的比喻。”↩︎
克里斯特,第131—140页,刊出他的《圣使徒之诗》和一首圣诞圣诗。参第li页及下页。雅科比(第203页及下页)讨论有关资料,并在罗马努斯 (Romanus) 的作品中辨出对约公元630年开始的基督一志论争论的影射。他在第221页及下页,将其中优美描写救赎恩惠的一部分译成德文。↩︎
克里斯特,第101页及下页;丹尼尔,第III卷,第101—109页。尼尔翻译了斯图迪乌斯的狄奥多鲁斯 (Theodorus Studita) 的四首颂歌,其中一首咏审判日(ὁ κύριος ἔρχεται*)。皮特拉从抄本中发掘了他的十八首咏圣徒的诗。其《著作集》(Opera) 见米涅《希腊教父集》(Patr. Gr.),第99卷。↩︎
克里斯特,第xlvii页:“尼基弗鲁斯列举了两位名叫约瑟的圣诗作者,称其中一人为斯图迪乌斯修道院的成员,另一人为外乡人。我认为前者就是约瑟 (Iosephum),斯图迪乌斯修道院院长狄奥多鲁斯 (Theodori) 的弟弟;7月14日被定为他的纪念日。他因品行端正、学识卓著而被选为帖撒罗尼迦 (Thessalonicensis) 教会的大主教;国王狄奥菲卢斯 (Theophilo,829—842年) 残酷迫害敬奉圣像的人,将他下在监里,以各种刑罚折磨他,以致他死于狱中。希腊教会在4月3日共同纪念另一位约瑟;后者特称为 ὑμνογράφος*。据说尼基弗鲁斯称他为外乡人(ξένος*),因为他原籍西西里岛 (Sicilia),家乡被阿拉伯人攻占、蹂躏后,他与母亲和兄弟先逃往伯罗奔尼撒 (Peloponnesum),继而逃往帖撒罗尼迦;在该城,他投身于极为严厉的修道生活。”↩︎
英译出自尼尔。见下文,第473页。↩︎
克里斯特,第242—253页;丹尼尔,第III卷,第112—114页;尼尔,第120—151页;贝斯勒,第23、165页;沙弗,第240页及下页。帕拉尼卡斯 (Paranikas) 已证明,以前归于基督一志论争论期间耶路撒冷牧首索弗罗尼乌斯的那些圣诗,也是约瑟 (Joseph) 的作品(克里斯特,《导论》[Prol.],第liii页)。↩︎
尼尔提到了他,却认为他的诗不值得翻译。↩︎
Κανὼν εἰς τὴν ὑπεραγίαν θεοτόκον*。见丹尼尔,第III卷,第17—20页。↩︎
不可将他与帕塔拉 (Patara) 的殉道者美多迪乌斯·欧布利乌斯 (Methodius Eubulius,卒于311年) 混淆;后者因所作颂赞贞洁的童女诗(παρθένιον*),也被列入诗人之中;见第II卷,第811页,以及克里斯特,第33—37页。贝斯勒(第4页及下页)刊有福特拉格 (Fortlage) 所作的德译。↩︎
皮特拉以八十三首匿名圣诗结束其诗集,其中三十二首被他归于斯图迪乌斯修道院的诗人。亦见丹尼尔,第III卷,第110—138页,以及尼尔译集末尾的圣诗。↩︎
见丹尼尔,第II卷,第293页,以及莫内,第II卷,第229页及下页,所载颂赞马利亚的《赞美颂》(Te Deum)。↩︎
一个奇特的中世纪传说,称《赞美颂》(Te Deum) 是圣安布罗斯 (St. Ambrose) 与圣奥古斯丁共同创作的;当奥古斯丁从洗礼池中上来时,两人仿佛受了默示,交替吟诵:安布罗斯先唱:Te Deum laudamus(上帝啊,我们赞美你),奥古斯丁回应:“Te Dominum confitemur(我们承认你是主)。”然而,两人的著作中都丝毫没有提及这首圣诗及其起源。关于它的存在和使用,最早的历史见证是努尔西亚 (Nursia) 的圣本笃于公元529年所立的第十一条会规,其中吩咐蒙特卡西诺的修士:“Post guartum autem responsorium incipiat Abbas hymnum Te Deum laudamus(第四首应答咏之后,院长应开始唱《上帝啊,我们赞美你》这首圣诗)。”不过,在成书于第五世纪的圣经《亚历山大抄本》(Alexandrian Codex) 中,这首圣诗有五行或八行以希腊文出现,作为《至高荣耀颂》(Gloria in Excelsis,Δόξα ἐν ὑψίστοις*,等等) 的一部分。见丹尼尔,第II卷,第289页及后;克里斯特 (Christ),第39页(从 καθ’ ἡμέραν* 到 εἰς τοὺς αἰῶνας*);以及凯泽 (Kayser),第437页及后。丹尼尔将整首《赞美颂》追溯至一个已经失传的希腊文原本(《亚历山大抄本》中的诗行便是其残篇);凯泽则认为作者是第五世纪后半叶一位不知名的拉丁作家,亦即圣安布罗斯去世约一百年以后的人。↩︎
他的生卒年代极不确定,各种说法不一:生年为530年或550年,卒年为600年或609年。↩︎
两篇拉丁文文本及校勘注释,见丹尼尔,第I卷,第160页及后;押韵的英译本有曼特 (Mant)、卡斯沃尔 (Caswall) 和尼尔所译者。原文并不押韵,却十分悦耳。见第III卷,第597页。福图纳图斯的《全集》(Opera) 曾由卢基 (Luchi) 编辑出版,罗马 (Rom.),1786年;又由米涅收入《拉丁教父集》(Patrol. Lat.),第88卷(巴黎,1850年)。参较安培 (Ampère),《文学史》(Hist. littér.),第II卷,第275页及后;埃伯特,前引书,第I卷,第494页及后。福图纳图斯是个极有趣的人物,值得为他专写一部研究著作。凯泽用三章论述他(第386—434页)。↩︎
丹尼尔,第I卷,第175—183页,载有格列高利 (Gregory) 的十首圣诗,第V卷,第248页又增收一首(Laudes canamus,意为“让我们歌唱赞美”)。莫内另增收了一些作者归属可疑的作品,见第I卷,第370、376页及后;第III卷,第325页及后,其中还包括颂赞格列高利的圣诗,如“O decus sacerdotum, flosque sanctorum”(啊,祭司的荣耀,圣徒中的花朵)。他那些收入《日课经》的圣诗,英译见曼特、钱伯斯 (Chambers)、卡斯沃尔和纽曼 (Newman) 的著作。关于他作为诗人的成就,见埃伯特,第I卷,第827页及后。路德在《席间谈话》(Tischreden) 中(这部书将事实与虚构奇异地混杂在一起),宣称受难圣诗 Rex Christe, factor omnium(基督君王,万有的创造者)是所有圣诗中最好的一首(“der allerbeste Hymnus”);然而,这种过分的赞誉,既不符合路德的诗歌趣味,也与他并未将此诗译成德文这一事实不符。↩︎
取自纽曼的自由改写(收入《各时所作诗篇》〔Verses on Various Occasions〕)。两个修订本的拉丁文文本,见丹尼尔,第I卷,第175页。↩︎
丹尼尔,第I卷,第206页及下页;莫内,第I卷,第1页(“Primo Deus coeli globum”,意为“起初上帝造了天球”)和第284页(Ave sacer Christi sanguis,意为“敬礼,基督的圣血”)。那首为伯利恒殉道婴孩所作的圣诗,远逊于普鲁登提乌斯的 Salvete flores martyrum(向你们致意,殉道者的花朵)。正文所引的第一首圣诗,有查尔斯夫人 (Mrs. Charles) 和尼尔的译本。德译本有克尼格斯费尔德 (Königsfeld) 所译者(Ihr Siegeshymnen schallet laut,意为“你们凯旋的赞歌,高声响起”;以及 Unschuld’ger Kinder Martyrschaar,意为“无辜婴孩的殉道行列”),另有克纳普 (Knapp) 等人的译本。比德还以韵文写过一部圣卡斯伯特 (St. Cuthbert) 传,纽曼译出了其中一部分(“Between two comrades dear”,意为“在两位亲爱同伴之间”)。↩︎
他的《诗集》(carmina) 由耶稣会士克里斯托弗·布劳尔 (Christopher Brower) 根据富尔达修道院中发现的一部古抄本,于1617年编辑出版(作为维南提乌斯·福尔图纳图斯诗集的附录),后重印于米涅所编《拉巴努斯·毛鲁斯全集》(Rab. Mauri Opera,1852年),第VI卷,第1583—1682栏。参较昆斯特曼 (Kunstmann),《赫拉巴努斯·马格嫩提乌斯·毛鲁斯》(Hrabamus Magnentius Maurus),美因茨,1841年;科赫 (Koch),第I卷,第90—93页;埃伯特,第II卷,第120—145页;豪克 (Hauck),载赫尔措格百科全书第2版,第XII卷,第459—465页。关于R. M.诗作的抄本传承,豪克引证了迪姆勒 (Dümmler) 的研究。↩︎
布劳尔持此说;最近S. W. 达菲尔德 (S. W. Duffield) 在沙弗《宗教百科全书》(Rel. Encycl.),第III卷,第2608页及下页的一篇文章中,也持此说。另见克莱芒 (Clément),《诗集》(Carmina) 等,第379页。↩︎
所用的是科辛主教 (Bishop Cosin) 的节译本,译得并不十分成功(仅有四节),起首为:
“来吧,圣灵,感动我们的心灵,
以天上的火照亮我们。
你是施膏的圣灵,
赐下你那七重的恩赐。”
此诗于万有复归之后的1662年收入《公祷书》(Prayer Book)。另一首供选用的按立礼圣诗“来吧,圣灵,永恒的上帝”,于1549年问世,1662年修订。↩︎
托马西 (Tomasi,第I卷,第375页),甚至丹尼尔(第I卷,第213页及下页;第IV卷,第125页)都持此说,特伦奇(第167页)看来也如此。托马西的观点,依据的是博兰派学者所载的一则不可能属实的传说(Acta SS.,4月,第1卷,第587页):诺特克把自己的继抒咏 Sancti Spiritus adsit nobis gratia(愿圣灵的恩典与我们同在)寄给查理曼(此时他已经去世一百年了),皇帝便以 Veni, Creator Spiritus(来吧,创造者圣灵)作为回赠(其实皇帝的拉丁文学识尚不足以作诗)。《大英百科全书》(Encycl. Brit.) 第9版“圣诗”条目的作者又重述此传说,但以查理曼的侄子秃头查理 (Charles the Bald) 取代查理曼,消除了年代上的矛盾(而秃头查理更没有能力胜任这项工作)。↩︎
莫内(第I卷,第242页,注)、科赫、瓦克纳格尔 (Wackernagel) 持此说。莫内的理由是“古典格律而部分押韵,以及祷告式的处理方式”。↩︎
十二、十三世纪已有德译(Komm, Schöpfer, heiliger Geist,意为“来吧,创造者,圣灵”);此外还有路德的译本(Komm, Gott Schöpfer, heiliger Geist,意为“来吧,创造主上帝,圣灵”)、克尼格斯费尔德的译本(Komm, Schöpfer, heil’ger Geist, erfreu,意为“来吧,创造者,圣灵,使人欢喜”),以及其他译本。最早的德文译者说(据丹尼尔,第I卷,第214页所载),凡在白昼或黑夜诵唱这首圣诗的人,便可安然无惧于一切有形或无形的仇敌。↩︎
见其著作《论宇宙》(De Universo),第I卷,第3章(米涅版《全集》〔Opera〕,第V卷,第23—26页)。他在这里称圣灵为 digitus Dei(上帝的手指,与圣诗中的称呼相同),并教导圣灵双重发出的教义;自809年亚琛会议采纳“和子说”条款 (Filioque) 以来,这已成为西方占主导地位的教义,尽管利奥三世曾反对将此条款插入尼西亚信经。Paraclêtus 一词的倒数第二音节按长音扫描,与其他拉丁诗人所用的读法(Paraecletos)不同。↩︎
拉丁文文本取自布劳尔,依米涅重印本(第VI卷,第1657栏),并加上第一首荣耀颂。第一种译文出自罗伯特·坎贝尔 (Robert Campbell),1850年;第二种出自S. W. 达菲尔德牧师,系1884年2月专为本书所译。其他英译本有威瑟 (Wither,1623年)、德拉蒙德 (Drummond,1616年)、科辛(1627年)、泰特 (Tate,1703年)、德莱顿 (Dryden,1700年)、艾萨克·威廉斯(1839年)、威廉斯主教 (Bishop Williams,1845年)、曼特(“来吧,圣灵,蒙福的创造者”)、本尼迪克特 (Benedict,“圣灵啊,赐下属天的生命”)、麦吉尔 (MacGill,“创造者圣灵啊,来吧”)、摩根 (Morgan,“创造者圣灵,在爱中降临”),以及比特侯爵 (Marquess of Bute)《日课经》中的译本(“来吧,圣灵,创造者,来吧”)。其中九种译文,见奥登海默 (Odenheimer) 与伯德 (Bird),《圣灵之歌》(Songs of the Spirit),纽约 (N. Y.),1871年,第167—180页。德译本也几乎同样多。参较丹尼尔,第I卷,第213页;第IV卷,第124页;莫内,第I卷,第242页;科赫,第I卷,第74页及下页。↩︎
Perpetim,副词,意为永久地、不断地。有些本子作 perpeti(来自 perpes)。↩︎
结尾那种惯用的祝福辞,两种形式都是后来增添的。第一种见于丹尼尔(第I卷,第214页)和莫内(第I卷,第242页),第二种见于拉巴努斯·毛鲁斯的文本。两种形式中 Paraecletos 的格律读法,都与第二节中的不同。↩︎
少数作者认为它出自教皇英诺森三世 (Pope Innocent III)。↩︎
拉丁文文本见丹尼尔,第II卷,第35页;第V卷,第69页;莫内,第I卷,第244页。第8节第2行,丹尼尔作 frigidum(冰冷的),而非 languidum(疲乏的)。↩︎
E. A. 沃什伯恩博士 (Dr. E. A. Washburn),纽约各各他教会已故主任牧师,是一位学养极深的学者(卒于1881年)。此译作于1860年,刊于《繁忙生涯中的声音》(Voices from a Busy Life),纽约 (N. Y.),1883年,第142页。↩︎
关于诺特克,参较埃克哈德 (Ekkehard) 所作的传记;丹尼尔,第V卷,第37页及后;科赫,第I卷,第94页及后;迈耶·冯·克诺瑙 (Meyer von Knonau),《圣加仑的圣诺特克生平》(Lebensbild des heil. Notker von St. Gallen),以及他在赫尔措格百科全书第2版,第X卷,第648页及后所写的条目(节本见《沙弗—赫尔措格百科全书》,第II卷,第1668页);还有安斯·舒比格尔的《八至十二世纪的圣加仑歌唱学校》(Die Sängerschule St. Gallens vom 8ten his 12ten Jahrh.),艾因西德伦 (Einsiedlen),1858年。丹尼尔,第II卷,第3—31页,以“诺特克及诺特克相关作品”(Notker et Notkeriana) 为题,收录了三十五篇作品。尼尔(第32页)译出了一首继抒咏:Sancti Spiritus adsit nobis gratia(愿圣灵的恩典与我们同在)。↩︎
关于继抒咏的进一步资料,尤应参看尼尔的《继抒咏批评论书》(Epistola Critica de Sequentiis),载丹尼尔《宝库》(Thes.) 第五卷卷首(第3—36页),其后附有丹尼尔的文献说明;另见巴尔奇 (Bartsch) 和凯赖因 (Kehrein,所编诗集规模最大) 的著作,以及达菲尔德在沙弗《宗教百科全书》(Rel. Encyl.),第III卷,第161页所写的条目。尼尔对继叙咏 (sequentia) 的定义是:“prolongatio syllabae τοῦ* Alleluia”(Alleluia 音节的延长)。↩︎
由尼尔翻译,见第32页。↩︎
丹尼尔,第II卷,第329页;莫内,第I卷,第397页。德译本有数种,其中一种出自路德(1524年):“Mitten wir im Leben sind mit dem Tod umfangen”(我们正处于生命之中,却被死亡环绕)。这个译本有相当多的增补,后由温克沃思小姐 (Miss Winkworth) 译成英文,收入《德意志诗琴》(Lyra Germanica):“看哪,在生命之中,死亡已将我们团团围住。”见沙弗《德文圣诗集》(Deutsches Gesangbuch),第446首的注释。↩︎
文本取自1549年的《爱德华六世第一祈祷书》(The First Book of Edward VI.),依摩根·迪克斯博士 (Dr. Morgan Dix) 重刊本,纽约 (N. Y.),1881年,第268页。《公祷书》修订时,第三行改进如下:
“主啊,你因我们的罪而公义地发怒(irasceris)。”↩︎
丹尼尔,第I卷,第224页。英译本有尼尔、本尼迪克特和沃什伯恩所译者(前引书,第145页)。克尼格斯费尔德的德译为:“Wie du mich mit Schrecken schüttelst”(你使我何等惊惧战栗)。尼尔(第52页)称它为“一首令人敬畏的圣诗,是个人生命的《震怒之日》(Dies Irae)”。他的译文起首为:
“啊,一想到你,便何等恐惧, 必死人生的终结之景!”↩︎
丹尼尔,第I卷,第116—118页(Rhythmus de gloria et gaudiis Paradisi,即《乐园荣耀与喜乐韵歌》),署名圣奥古斯丁。克莱芒《诗集》(Carmina),第162—166页也如此;他称“最优秀的批评家”(“per les melleurs critiques”)都将此诗归于奥古斯丁,并说它是“《上帝之城》的映照”(“un reflet de la Cité de Dieu”)。然而,这位伟大的非洲教父将自己的诗意写入了散文,只是为诗人提供了激发灵感的思想。克尼格斯费尔德的德译(也同样署名圣奥古斯丁)为“Nach des ew’gen Lebens Quellen”(向着永生的泉源)。↩︎
他们的圣诗见丹尼尔,第I卷,第183页及后,部分亦见莫内和克莱芒的诗集。↩︎
阿雷佐的圭多 (Guido of Arezzo) 从这首诗(见丹尼尔,第I卷,第209页及下页)取得六个音符的名称:Ut、Re、Mi、Fa、Sol、La:
“Ut queant laxis Re-sonare fibris
Mi-ra gestorum Fa-muli tuorum,
Sol ve polluti La-bii reatum,
Sancte Joannes. ”
“圣约翰啊,为使你的仆人能舒展歌喉,歌颂你奇妙的作为,求你除去他们不洁嘴唇的罪污。”↩︎
见丹尼尔,《约作于第VI—IX世纪的佚名圣诗》(Hymni adespotoi circa sec. VI-IX. conscripti),第I卷,第191页及后。莫内收录的数目更多。↩︎
《罗马日课经》中作:“Coelestis urbs Jerusalem”(天上的城耶路撒冷)。尼尔认为,乌尔班八世 (Urban VIII) 修订《日课经》时所作的更改,使“这首宏伟的圣诗失去了一半的美”。↩︎
原文见丹尼尔,第I卷,第194页。其他英译本有查尔斯夫人和E. C. 本尼迪克特 (E. C. Benedict) 所译者。克尼格斯费尔德的德译为:“Plötzlich wird der Tag erscheinen”(那日将忽然显现)。↩︎
丹尼尔(第I卷,第204页)论这首圣诗说:“Hic hymnus Marianus, quem Catholica semper ingenti cum favore prosecuta est, in omnibus breviarriis, quae inspiciendi unquam mihi occasio data est, ad honorem beatissimae virginis cantandus praescribitur, inprimis in Annunciatione; apud permultos tamen aliis quoque diebus Festis Marianis adscriptus est. Quae hymni reverentia ad recentiora usque tempora permansit.”(这首马利亚圣诗,天主教会一向极为喜爱;在我有机会查阅的一切日课经中,都规定应唱此诗,以尊崇至福童贞女,尤其是在圣母领报节;不过,许多日课经也将它列入其他马利亚节日。这种对圣诗的尊重,一直延续到较近的时代。)这是乌尔班八世修订《日课经》时未曾改动的少数圣诗之一。莫内(第II卷,第216、218、220、228页)列出了 Ave Maris Stella(敬礼,海洋之星)的四种变体;本书以此诗为正文。↩︎
马利亚的这一称号,据说意在翻译她的名字;其中把 maria 看作 mare(海)的复数:见《创世记》1:10(武加大译本):“congregationes aquarum appellavit maria. Et vidit Deus, quod esset bonum.”(水的聚处,上帝称为海。上帝看着是好的。)(见丹尼尔,第I卷,第205页的注释。)这即使不能说是强加于经文的解释,也肯定是一种极不寻常的解释;然而,对中世纪而言,它还不算太牵强,因为那时人们不懂希腊文和希伯来文,认为圣经有四重意义,寓意和神秘的幻想取代了语法与历史的释经。↩︎
将马利亚与夏娃相比——以顺服之母对照悖逆之母,第一位夏娃带来罪责与毁灭,第二位则带来救赎与福乐——这种比较,早在爱任纽 (Irenaeus,约180年) 时便已存在,是产生马利亚崇拜 (Mariolatry) 的丰饶胚芽。将 Eva 变为 Ave 的神秘转换,则出自中世纪,是一种虔敬的文字谜。↩︎
我们的主对约翰所说的话:“看,你的母亲!”(《约翰福音》19:27),被认为是对所有基督徒说的。↩︎
通常据传,班贝格主教奥托 (Otto,1139至1189年间) 在他所带领归信基督教的波美拉尼亚人 (Pomeranians) 中引入了七项圣礼,但这一传统所依据的讲论,其真伪尚有疑问。经院所定的七项之数,得到佛罗伦萨大公会议 (Council of Florence,希腊代表亦表示赞同) 及特伦托大公会议的确认;后者宣布,凡教导圣礼多于或少于此数者,均受咒诅,见第VII次会议,第I条教规。新教各教会只承认两项圣礼,即洗礼和主的晚餐,因为只有这两项是基督特别吩咐遵守的。不过,按立礼和婚礼,以及某些教会中的坚振礼,仍被保留为庄严的宗教仪式。↩︎
路德宗教会保留由牧师施行的坚振礼,圣公会 (Anglican church) 则由主教施行。↩︎
见上文,§ 87。↩︎
在这一点上,新教(至少是改革宗)的信条也与罗马天主教不同,要求以实际运用的信心,作为领受圣礼益处的条件。婴儿受洗时,则将父母或负有责任的监护人的信心考虑在内。若无这样的信心,圣礼便归于徒然,并受到亵渎。↩︎
Character indelebilis(不可磨灭的印记)。↩︎
Organum 源于希腊文 ὄργανον*;《七十士译本》用此词译出几个希伯来文音乐术语,如 cheli, chinor(cithara,琴)、nephel(nablium,瑟)、yugab。有关经文,见特罗米乌斯 (Trommius),《希腊文汇编》(Concord. Gr. V. LXX),第II卷,第144页。↩︎
见霍普金斯 (Hopkins) 与林博尔特 (Rimbault):《管风琴:其历史与构造》(The Organ, its History and Construction),1855年;E. 德·库瑟马克 (E. de Coussemakee):《中世纪乐器史》(Histoire, des instruments de musique au moyen-age),巴黎,1859年;海因里希·奥特 (Heinrich Otte):《教会艺术考古学手册》(Handbuch der Kirchl. Kunstarchäologie),莱比锡,第4版,1866年,第225页及后;O. 旺格曼 (O. Wangermann):《管风琴与管风琴制造艺术史》(Gesch. der Orgel und der Orgelbaukunst),第2版,1881年。另参宾厄姆 (Bingham)、奥古斯蒂 (Augusti)、宾特里姆 (Binterim)、西格尔、阿尔特 (Alt) 的著作,以及史密斯 (Smith) 与奇瑟姆 (Cheetham)、韦策尔 (Wetzer) 与韦尔特 (Welte),以及赫尔措格各书中的“管风琴”(Organ) 条。↩︎
由此便有了 campanum、campana、nola 等名称(后者沿用于意大利语中);不过,这名称更可能源于坎帕尼亚铜 (aes campanum),早期的钟就是用这种材料铸成的。在后期拉丁文中,它称为 cloqua, cloccum, clocca, cloca,也称 tintinnabulum;英文为 clock;德文为 Glocke;法文为 cloche;爱尔兰文为 clog(比较拉丁文 clangere,鸣响,以及德文 klopfen,敲击)。↩︎
“Ut cloccae non baptizentur.”(不可给钟施洗。)据巴罗尼乌斯《编年史》(Annal.) 968年条,教皇约翰十三世 (John XIII.) 给拉特兰教堂 (Lateran church) 的大钟施洗,并为它取名约翰。十六世纪的改教家重申查理曼的抗议,废除了给钟施洗的做法,认为这是亵渎圣礼。见西格尔,《基督教会古制手册》(Handbuch der christl. kirchlichen Alterthümer),第II卷,第243页。↩︎
Campanarii, campanatores.(司钟人。)↩︎
称为 Campanile(钟楼)。威尼斯圣马可广场 (place of San Marco) 上的那座尤为著名。↩︎
有关钟的文献,见西格尔,第II卷,第239页,以及奥特 (Otte),第2、102页。这里列举:尼克·埃格斯 (Nic. Eggers):《钟的起源与名称》(de Origine et Nomine Campanarum),Jen.,1684年;同一作者:《钟的材料与形制》(De Campanarum Materia et Forma),1685年;瓦勒 (Waller):《论钟及其主要用途》(De Campanis et praecipuis earum Usibus),Holm.,1694年;埃申韦克尔 (Eschenwecker):《论钟》(Circa Campanas),哈雷 (Hal.),1708年;J. B. 蒂耶尔 (J. B. Thiers):《钟论》(Traité des Cloches),巴黎,1719年;蒙塔努斯 (Montanus):《钟的历史记述》(Hist. Nachricht von den Glocken) 等,开姆尼茨 (Chemnitz),1726年;克里桑德 (Chrysander):《教堂钟的历史记述》(Hist. Nachricht von Kirchen-Glocken),林特尔恩 (Rinteln),1755年;海因里希·奥特 (Heinrich Otte):《钟学》(Glockenkunde),莱比锡,1858年。另参其《德国中世纪教会艺术考古学手册》(Handbuch der kirchlichen Kunst-Archäologie des deutschen Mittelalters),莱比锡,1868年,第4版,第245—248页(附插图);以及史密斯 (Smith) 与奇瑟姆 (Cheetham)、韦策尔 (Wetzer) 与韦尔特 (Welte),以及赫尔措格的考古学著作中的“钟”(Bells, Glocken) 各条。席勒 (Schiller) 以钟为题,写成了他最伟大的抒情诗,结尾以如下优美的诗句描绘钟的象征意义:
“从今以后,这便是它的使命,
也是匠师铸造它的初衷:
高高超越尘世卑微的生活,
它要在蔚蓝的天幕中,
与雷霆为邻,悬于高空,
与群星的世界相接;
它要成为来自上方的声音,
如同那灿烂的群星,
运行不息,颂赞它们的创造主,
引领花冠环绕的年岁。
唯有永恒而首要的事物,
才配承受它金属之口的奉献,
它要时时迅疾摆动,
在飞越中触及时光。
让它作命运的喉舌;
它本无心,也无同情,
却要以自己的摆动,
伴随人生变幻的戏景。
正如它发出的雄浑声响,
终必消逝于耳际,
愿它教人明白:没有什么长存,
一切属世之物终将寂然无声。”↩︎
有时也由主教、宗教会议,以及在具有政治重要性的场合,由国王和皇帝主持。最后一次由都主教封圣,据说是鲁昂 (Rouen) 大主教于公元1153年为蓬图瓦兹 (Pontoise) 修道院院长圣戈谢 (St. Gaucher),又名戈尔蒂耶 (Gaultier,1130年4月9日卒) 举行的。但拉贝 (Labbe) 与阿尔班·巴特勒 (Alban Butler) 说,他是于1194年由塞莱斯廷三世 (Celestine III.) 封圣的。看来,甚至在更晚的时期,有些主教仍行使有限的封圣权;因此,乌尔班八世于1625年和1634年以此举不合宜而加以禁止。↩︎
1170年教皇作出裁决的起因,是利雪 (Lisieux) 教区一所修道院的修士,将他们的主管奉为圣徒加以崇拜;此人是在食堂中被两名醉酒的同院修士杀死的。↩︎
关于这一题目,参本笃十四世 (Benedict XIV.,兰贝尔蒂尼,Lambertini):《上帝仆人的宣福与真福者的封圣》(De Servorum Dei Beatificatione et Beatorum Canonisatione),Bononisae,1734—1738年;第II版,Venet. et Patav.,1743年,4卷,对开本。费拉里斯 (Ferraris):《教会法文库》(Bibliotheca Canonica),“圣徒敬礼”("Veneratio Sanctorum") 条。封圣包括七项特权:1)获整个(罗马)教会承认为圣徒;2)在公开和私下祷告中受人祈求;3)为尊崇圣徒而建造教堂和祭坛;4)在举行弥撒时受人祈求;5)设立特别纪念日;6)陈列其头戴冠冕的像;7)陈列其遗骨和遗物,供人敬礼。教皇的封圣诏书是否无谬、属于 de fide(信仰必须接受的教义),抑或只是 sententia communis et certa(普遍而确定的意见),这一问题似乎在罗马天主教徒中仍有争论。↩︎
见曼西,第XIX卷,第169—179页。诏书由教皇、五位主教、九位枢机司祭、一位总执事及四位执事署名。它规定,应“以最虔敬的情感与最忠诚的热忱”(“affectu piisimo et devotione fidelissima”)尊崇圣乌达尔里库斯 (Saint Udalricus) 的纪念,并将其奉献于神圣的崇拜(“divino cultui dicata”)。它以如下理由为此辩护:“quoniam sic adoramus (!) et colimus reliquias martyrum* et confessorum, ut eum, Cuius martyres et confessores sunt, adoremus Honaramus servos ut honor redundet in Dominum, qui dixit: Qui vos recipit me recipit’: ac proinde nos, qui fiduciam nostrae justitiae non habemus, illorum precibus et meritis apud clementissimum Deum jugiter adiuvemur.”(因为我们如此敬拜〔!〕并尊崇殉道者与认信者的遗物,为的是敬拜他们所归属的那一位。我们尊荣仆人,使尊荣归于主;主曾说:‘接待你们的,就是接待我。’因此,我们这些不倚靠自己义的人,得以藉着他们的祈祷和功德,在至仁慈的上帝面前不断蒙受帮助。)诏书提到乌尔里希 (Ulrich) 的许多神迹:“quae sive in corpore, sive extra corpus gesta sunt, videlicet Caecos illuminasse, daemones ab obsessis effugasse, paralyticos curasse, et quam plurima alia signa gessisse.”(这些神迹,有的是在肉身之内,有的是在肉身之外行的,就是使瞎眼的看见,从被附的人身上赶出鬼,医治瘫痪者,并行了许多其他神迹。)关于圣乌尔里希的生平,见其友人及同伴格尔哈德 (Gerhard) 所写的传记(作于983至993年间),最佳版本为维尔茨 (Wirtz) 编入《德国历史文献·史家集》(Monum. G. Scriptores) 的版本,第IV卷,第377页及后;博兰德学派《圣徒行传》(Acta Sanct.),7月4日条;马比永 (Mabillon),Ada Ordinis S. B.,第V卷,第415—477页;布劳恩 (Braun),《奥格斯堡主教史》(Gesch. der Bischöfe von Augsburg),奥格斯堡,1813年,第I卷;施勒德尔 (Schrödl),载韦策尔 (Wetzer) 与韦尔特 (Welte),第XI卷,第370—383页;以及福格尔 (Vogel),载赫尔措格1,第XVI卷,第624—628页。那篇反对独身制的短论,不可能出自乌尔里希之手;弗拉西乌斯 (Flacius) 最初在其《真理见证人名录》(Catalogus Testium Veritatis) 中以乌尔里希之名刊行此文,但它实际出于1059年,即教皇尼古拉二世 (Nicolas II.) 颁令强制实行独身制之时。见福格尔,前引书,第627页。↩︎
最近的封圣发生在我们这一代。教皇庇护九世于1862年以极隆重的仪式,将二十六位于1597年逼迫中殉难的日本方济各会传教士及归信者封圣。利奥十三世 (Leo XIII.) 于1881年12月8日,将四位较不知名、过着苦修生活并以舍己之爱行善的人封圣,即乔瓦尼·巴蒂斯塔·德·罗西 (Giovanni Battista de Rossi)、洛伦佐·迪·布林迪西 (Lorenzo di Brindisi)、朱塞佩·拉布尔 (Giuseppe Labre) 和克拉拉·迪·蒙特法尔科 (Clara di Montefalco)。一位罗马教士如此描述“真福拉布尔”:这位圣徒“从不洗澡,从不更换内衣,通常睡在斗兽场 (Colosseum) 的拱门下,并在孤儿院教堂 (Church of the Orphanage) 一连祷告数小时,那里有一块纪念他的碑”。圣拉布尔显然不相信“清洁仅次于敬虔”这句话。↩︎
Omnium Sanctorum Natalis,或 Festivas, Solemnitas, Allerheiligenfest(诸圣节)。希腊教会早已有类似的节日,在五旬节后的第一个主日纪念所有殉道者,称为 Κυριακὴ τῶν Ἁγίων πάντων*。金口约翰在为该日所作的一篇讲道中说,在五旬节的第八日,基督徒被众殉道者环绕。在西方,五旬节后的第一个主日用于纪念三位一体,并以此结束教会年历中的节期部分。见第III卷,第408页。↩︎
《罗马殉道录》(Martyrologio Romano),5月13日及11月1日条。万神殿 (Pantheon),又称圆殿 (Rotunda),与威斯敏斯特修道院 (Westminster Abbey) 和伦敦圣保罗大教堂 (St. Paul’s Cathedral) 一样,除圣徒之外,也安放其他杰出人物的遗骸;这里是拉斐尔的安息之所,而自1883年以来,甚至也安葬了意大利王国的缔造者维克托·埃马努埃尔 (Victor Emanuel),教皇却视他为抢夺彼得产业的强盗。↩︎
Omnium Fidelium defunctorum Memoria 或 Commemoratio, Allerseelentag(追思所有已故信徒之日,即追思节)。↩︎
Festum S. Michaelis,或 Michaelis Archangeli, Michaelmas.(圣米迦勒节,或天使长米迦勒节。)↩︎
东方教会在11月8日庆祝。东方这一庆典的起源不详。↩︎
因此也称为 Festum omnium Angelorum(众天使节)、圣米迦勒与众天使节 (St. Michael and all Angels)。↩︎
即米迦勒的数次显现:在歌罗西 (Colossae) 附近的霍奈 (Chonae),在阿普利亚 (Apulia) 西蓬图姆 (Sipontum) 教区的加尔加诺山 (Monte Gargano,年代有公元492年、520年、536年等不同说法),在诺曼底 (Normandy) 的通巴山 (Monte Tumba,约710年);尤其是在一次瘟疫之后,向罗马教皇格列高利一世,或其继任者卜尼法斯三世 (Boniface III.,607—610年),显现在哈德良陵 (Moles Hadriani) 上空。自那以后,此处便称为圣天使堡 (Castello di St. Angelo),并饰以天使雕像。↩︎
见第III卷,第444页及下页;《圣徒行传》(Acta Sanct.),9月29日条;西格尔,《基督教会古制手册》(Handbuch der christl. Kirchl. Alterthümer),第III卷,第419—425页;史密斯 (Smith) 与奇瑟姆 (Cheetham),第II卷,第1176—1180页;另见奥古斯蒂 (Augusti)、宾特里姆 (Binterim),以及西格尔第419页所列的专题著作。歌罗西 (Colossae) 的天使崇拜属于异端,很可能起源于爱色尼派 (Essenic)。见各注释书对有关经文的解释,尤其是莱特福特,第101页及后。约363年,歌罗西附近的老底嘉 (Laodicea) 一次宗教会议认为有必要严禁当时仍盛行于弗吕家的天使崇拜。圣奥古斯丁也屡次反对这种做法,见《论真宗教》(De vera Rel.) 110;《忏悔录》(Conf.) X. 42;《上帝之城》(De Civ. D.) X. 19、25。↩︎
其拥护者被称为 εἰκονολάτραι*、ξυλολάτραι*、εἰδωδολάτραι*。↩︎
τιμητικὴ προσκύνησις*。拉丁文没有与此词精确对应的词。英文“worship”(敬拜、尊敬)一词有不同的含义。↩︎
λατρεία*。adoratio(敬拜)。↩︎
见 § 94,第403页及后。↩︎
Εἰκονοκλάσται*(源于 κλάω*,意为打碎)、εἰκονοκαῦσται*、εἰκονομάχοι*、χριστιανοκατήγοροι*。↩︎
并非狄奥菲卢斯 (Theophilus),巴罗尼乌斯和施洛瑟 (Schlosser) 错将他称为此名。见赫费勒,第III卷,第372页。狄奥法尼斯还提到一个名叫贝塞尔 (Beser) 的叛教者,他曾成为穆罕默德教徒,后来大概又重归基督教,并在利奥 (Leo) 的宫廷中备受尊崇。↩︎
关于冲突的开端以及各事件的确切先后次序,存在相当大的混乱。见赫费勒,第III卷,第376页及后。↩︎
他的 λόγοι ἀπολογητικοί* 的梗概,见施勒克 (Schrceckh) 和尼安德的著作。↩︎
据较早的历史学家(巴罗尼乌斯)所说,教皇甚至将皇帝革除教籍,解除其意大利臣民对他的效忠义务,并禁止缴纳贡赋。但这是错误的。相反,格列高利在第二封信中明确声明,自己无权干预君主,同时又以最强烈的措辞否认皇帝有权干预教会。见格列高利致利奥 (Leo) 的两封信(726至731年间),载曼西,第XII卷,第959页及后;另见赫费勒的讨论,第III卷,第389—404页。↩︎
他的敌人给他起了绰号 Κοπρώνυμος*(源自 κόπρος*,意为“粪便”),因为他在婴儿时期曾污秽洗礼池。见狄奥法尼斯 (Theophanes),《编年史》(Chronogr.),波恩 (Bonn) 版,第I卷,第615页。他又因喜爱马匹而被称为 Cabellinus(爱马者)。↩︎
曼西 (Mansi),第XIII卷,第205—363页;吉泽勒 (Gieseler),第II卷,第16页;赫费勒 (Hefele),第III卷,第410—418页。↩︎
关于这些迫害,除狄奥法尼斯外,见博兰德学派 (Bolland.) 的《圣徒行传》(Acta Sanct.),十月部分,第VIII卷,第124页及后(1853年出版于布鲁塞尔);另见赫费勒,第III卷,第421—428页。↩︎
各项记载的数字在330至367之间。会议录有308位主教及主教代表签署。与此几乎同时代的君士坦丁堡 (Constantinople) 牧首尼基弗鲁斯 (Nicephorus),在致利奥三世 (Leo III.) 的一封信中,只提到150人。见赫费勒,第III卷,第460页。↩︎
斯图迪乌斯修道院的狄奥多尔 (Theodore of the Studium) 本人虽是圣像崇拜的热心倡导者,却揭露了这个诡计,并暗示这次会议并非严格意义上的大公会议,尽管他有时也如此称呼它。瓦尔希 (Walch) 以其惯有的细密与冗长,讨论了与这两个不负责任的修士有关的问题,见第X卷,第551—558页。另见尼安德,第III卷,第228页;赫费勒,第III卷,第459页。↩︎
这项决议(ὅρος*)认可 ἀσπασμὸς καὶ τιμητικὴ προσκύνησις*,即 osculum(或 salutatio)et honoraria adoratio,意为亲吻(或致敬)与尊敬性的敬拜,却不认可 ἀληθινὴ λατρεία ἣ πρέπει μόνῃ τῇ θείᾳ φύσει*,即 vera latria, quae solam divinam naturam decet,意为唯独神性所配受的真正崇拜。曼西,第XIII卷,第378页及下页。希腊文 ἀσπασμός* 一词包括致敬和亲吻;προσκύνησις* 则包括屈膝及其他表示敬意的举动,见第450页。↩︎
瓦尔希(第X卷,第572页)论及这些取自传统的证据时说:“伪托的著作、在主要问题上毫无决定作用的段落,以及因极度无知而遭曲解的言论,如此之多,以至于人们对于这些汇编所显出的无知与无耻,无论怎样惊讶也不为过。”甚至温和的罗马天主教历史学家,如亚历山大·纳塔利亚 (Alexander Natalia) 和弗勒里 (Fleury),也坦然承认某些教父引文存在错误。↩︎
见曼西第XII、XIII卷所载会议录,以及赫费勒第III卷第460—482页的概要。关于不同文本及有缺陷的拉丁文译本,见瓦尔希,第X卷,第420—422页;赫费勒,第III卷,第486页。吉本 (Gibbon) 称这些会议录为“迷信与无知、虚假与愚妄的一座奇特纪念碑”。这一评语过于严厉,却也并非毫无根据。伊琳娜 (Irene) 的个人品格给这次会议蒙上了深重的阴影;若不是她对圣像的虔敬如此蒙蔽了拜占庭历史学家,以及巴罗尼乌斯和曼布尔 (Maimbourg) 这样的罗马教会历史学家,使他们为她最黑暗的罪行开脱,并对她极尽赞颂,那么就连拜占庭历史学家也会谴责她的品格。↩︎
查理曼后来向伊琳娜求婚,意在合并东西两帝国,她也接受了求婚;但她的首相埃提乌斯 (Aëtius) 希望扶立自己的兄弟利奥 (Leo) 登基,因而阻止了这桩婚事。↩︎
希腊人在8月15日纪念伊琳娜 (Irene)。她的牧首塔拉修 (Tarasius,卒于806年),在罗马教会和希腊教会中都被封为圣徒。↩︎
赫费勒,第IV卷,第105页说,在这一朝,著名诗人狄奥法尼斯及其兄弟、斯图迪乌斯修道院的狄奥多尔,受到鞭打二百下的刑罚,额头上还被烙上希腊文讥讽诗句,因此得名“受烙印者”(γραπτοί*)。但据博兰派学者所说,狄奥法尼斯死于820年,赫费勒本人在第III卷第370页也将他的卒年定为818年,尽管他在第IV卷第108页又记载,狄奥法尼斯 γράπτος* 于842年被狄奥多拉 (Theodora) 任命为士每拿 (Smyrna) 主教。关于这一年代矛盾,见上文第407页。↩︎
然而,诽谤之舌却编出了她与自己任命的牧首美多迪乌斯 (Methodius) 有不正当私情的故事。宫廷为此展开调查,调查期间,牧首以有伤风化的裸露,证明自己在生理上不可能犯淫乱之罪;于是,控告他的女子承认,她受了他那位主张圣像破坏的前任的贿赂。赫费勒,第IV卷,第109页。↩︎
ἡ κυριακὴ τῆς ὀρθοδοξίας*.↩︎
见瓦尔希(第X卷,第800—808页)依据拜占庭历史学家、阿拉奇 (Allacci) 以及金 (King,论俄国教会) 所作的描述。↩︎
见瓦尔希,第XI卷,第7—36页;赫费勒,第III卷,第461—463页。史料对此保持沉默。瓦尔希仔细列举了巴罗尼乌斯、帕吉、达耶 (Daillé)、纳塔利斯 (Natalis)、亚历山大 (Alexander)、曼布尔 (Maimburg)、弗勒里、西尔蒙、施潘海姆 (Spanheim)、巴斯纳日和塞姆勒 (Semler) 的不同推测。此后并未增添任何新材料。不过,此前马赛主教塞雷努斯 (Serenus) 破坏圣像的热忱,以及此后查理曼和法兰克教会的立场,倒更支持西尔蒙与施潘海姆的推论,即这次会议拒绝了圣像崇拜。↩︎
阿尔昆参与撰写此书,可以从他《约翰福音注释》中思想的相似性,以及英国古老的传统看出来;据这一传统,他曾写过一部反对尼西亚会议的书。见瓦尔希,第XI卷,第65页及后;赫费勒,第III卷,第697页。↩︎
他称之为 posterior tempore, non tamen posterior crimine, eloquentia, sensuque carens, synodus ineptissima,即“时间在后,罪恶却不在后,既无雄辩,也无见识,是极其荒谬的会议”,等等。他不信任一个没有自己领土内教会代表参加的会议。他也反对妇女在教会中担任教师的职分,认为这违背了 lex divina(神的律法)和 lex naturae(自然律)(第III卷,第13章,米涅版,第1136栏)。伊琳娜解除了她儿子与他女儿的婚约,他有理由为此愤怒。↩︎
这次会议常被称为 universalis(普世会议),并谴责了嗣子论(见赫费勒,第III卷,第678页及后)。反对圣像的决议见曼西,第XIII卷,第909页。主要段落是:“Sanctissimi Patres nostri omnimodis et adorationem et servitutem eis [sc. imaginibus Sanctorum] renuentes contemserunt atque, consentientes condemnaverunt.” 意即:“我们至圣的教父们全然拒绝、鄙弃向它们〔即圣徒的像〕施行敬拜和事奉,并一致予以谴责。”艾因哈德 (Einhard) 在其《编年史》794年条下作了如下记载(载佩尔茨 (Pertz),《文献集》〔Monum.〕,第I卷,第181页;另见吉泽勒,第II卷,第67页):“Synodus etiam, quae ante paucos annos in Constantinopoli〔尼西亚会议在此闭幕〕sub Herena〔Irene,伊琳娜〕et Constantino filio ejus congregata, et ab ipsis non solum septima, verum etiam universalis est appellata, ut nec septima nec universalis haberetur dicereturve, quasi supervacua in totum ab omnibus〔聚集在法兰克福的主教们〕abdicata est.” 意即:“几年前在伊琳娜及其子君士坦丁治下,于君士坦丁堡召开的那次会议,被他们称为第七次会议,甚至称为普世会议;这次会议也被所有人当作多余之举而全然摒弃,不得视为或称为第七次会议或普世会议。”巴罗尼乌斯、贝拉明,甚至赫费勒(第III卷,第689页),都指责这次会议歪曲了尼西亚会议;后者认可对圣像的敬拜(广义而言),却不认可对圣像的崇拜。然而,教皇送给查理曼的拉丁文译本,一律将 προσκύνησις* 译作 adoratio;教皇的图书馆长阿纳斯塔修斯在其改进的译本中也如此处理,因而使这种混淆获得了双重认可。↩︎
这一说法,一部分依据是盎格鲁—撒克逊人阿尔昆很可能参与了《加洛林书》的撰写,一部分依据则是达勒姆的西缅 (Simeon of Durham,约1100年) 的见证。见特威斯登 (Twysden) 的《英国史十家著作》(Hist. Angl. Scriptores decem),I、III;《不列颠历史文献集》(Mon. Hist. Brit.),第667页;威尔金 (Wilkin) 的《大不列颠会议集》(Conc. Magn. Brit.),第I卷,第73页;吉泽勒,第II卷,第67页,注6;哈德威克 (Hardwick) 的《中世纪教会史》(Church Hist. of the Middle Age),第78页,注3。↩︎
查理曼送给教皇的究竟是全书还是仅为节本,以及他究竟是在法兰克福会议之前还是之后派安吉尔贝特前往罗马,意见各不相同。赫费勒(第III卷,第713页)断定,《条目》(Capitula,85条) 是《查理书》(Libri Carolini,121章) 的摘录,安吉尔贝特曾于公元792年及794年两次到罗马。无论如何,哈德良的答复必定写于795年12月25日之前。此答复刊于曼西,第XIII卷,第759—810页;以及米涅,《查理曼著作集》(Opera Car. M.),第II卷,第1247—1292栏。其中满是显而易见的错误。赫费勒主教(第716页)将责任分摊给了(可能犯错的)教皇、皇帝和抄写者。↩︎
曼西,第XIV卷,第415页及后;瓦尔希,第XI卷,第95页及后;吉泽勒,第II卷,第68页;赫费勒,第IV卷,第41页及后(1879年第二版)。瓦尔希说(第98页),罗马教会在这次会议的会议录问题上演了一出喜剧。曼西最先将其出版,却为此作了辩解,并认为必须附上贝拉明在其《论圣像崇拜》(De Cultu Imaginum) 附录中的驳论。赫费勒和赫尔根勒特认为,这次会议与法兰克福会议一样,对尼西亚会议作出了不公正的评判;但这并不能改变事实。↩︎
见§ 79。↩︎
罗伊特(第I卷,第24页)称他为“九世纪头脑最清晰的人”,又称他为“Aufklärung(启蒙思想)的系统化者”(即中世纪理性主义的系统化者)。↩︎
《论圣徒的像》(De Imaginibus Sanctorum),载米涅,第104卷,第199—228栏。↩︎
第35章(载米涅,第227栏):“Flectamus genu in nomine solius Jesu, quod est super omne nomen; ne si alteri hunc honorem tribuimus, alieni judicemur a Deo, et dimittamur secundum cordis nostri ire in adinventionibus nostris.” 意即:“我们只当奉耶稣的名屈膝,这名超乎万名之上;免得我们将这尊荣归给别人,就被判为与上帝隔绝,并被任凭随从自己的心,行自己所谋之事。”吉泽勒提醒人注意,阿戈巴尔德与克劳狄乌斯有好几句话在措辞上完全一致。↩︎
见《圣徒行传》(Acta SS.),六月部分,第II卷,第748页;以及米涅第13—16栏所载《圣阿戈巴尔德赞词》(Elogia de S. Agobardo)。博兰派学者将他收入自己的著作,以示尊崇,因为首位编者马松允许他使用圣徒称号,而且里昂教会通常称他为圣阿格巴图德 (St. Aguebatud),地方殉道者名录也收录了他。《里昂日课经》(Breviarium Lugdunense) 为他指定了九课式礼仪。↩︎
他在《保罗书信注释》中(载米涅,第104卷,第927栏及下栏)赞颂奥古斯丁说:“amantissimus Domini sanctissimus Augustinus. calamus Trinitatis lingua Spiritus Sancti, terrenus homo, sed coelestis angelus, in quaestionibus solvendis acutus, in revincendis haereticis circumspectus, in explicandis Scripturis canonicis cautus.” 意即:“至爱主的、至圣的奥古斯丁,三位一体的笔,圣灵的舌,在地上是人,却是天上的天使;解决问题敏锐,驳斥异端周详,解释正典圣经审慎。”在同一处,他论到保罗说,保罗的书信全然致力于破除人的功德,并高举上帝的恩典(“ut merita hominum tollat, unde maxime nunc monachi gloriantur, et gratiam Dei commendet”,即“为要除去人的功德——这正是如今修士最为夸耀的——并彰显上帝的恩典”)。关于他的奥古斯丁主义,见尼安德精审的评论。罗伊特(第I卷,第20页)称他既是合乎圣经的改革者,又是批判的理性主义者。↩︎
C. 施密特 (C. Schmidt) 在赫尔措格第二版(Herzog2),第III卷,第245页,论到这一观点说:“这一很晚才出于教义上的目的而被采纳的观点,见于莱热 (Léger) 及其他人的著作,甚至哈恩 (Hahn) 仍持此说,却没有任何历史根据;凡深入了解瓦勒度派历史的人,早已放弃了它。但这并不是要否认,克劳狄乌斯的倾向曾在意大利继续存在过一段时期;刚才已经提到,据奥尔良的约纳斯 (Jonas von Orléans) 作证,约在840年,有人试图重新传播这些主张。然而,说这些主张一直传承到彼得·瓦勒度 (Peter Waldus) 出现之时,尤其是在皮埃蒙特诸山谷中传承下来,则连丝毫的痕迹也没有。”↩︎
