Translated from Philip Schaff's History of The Christian Church
第八章 教会纪律
目录
§85. 悔罪书
§86. 教会的惩罚:逐出教会、咒诅、禁令
§87. 补赎与大赦
参见第II卷§57及第III卷§68。
§85. 悔罪书
I. 各次会议的议决录、查理大帝 (Charlemagne) 及其继承者的敕令集,以及各部悔罪书,尤其是坎特伯雷的狄奥多尔 (Theodore of Canterbury) 的悔罪书和罗马悔罪书。见米涅 (Migne)《教父集》(Patrol.),第99卷,第901–983页。
- 弗里德里希·昆斯特曼 (Friedr. Kunstmann,罗马天主教徒):《盎格鲁-撒克逊人的拉丁文悔罪书》(Die latein. Pönitentialbücher der Angelsachsen)。美因茨 (Mainz),1844年。F. W. H. 瓦瑟施莱本 (F. W. H. Wasserschleben):《西方教会的悔罪规章》(Bussordnungen der abendländ. Kirche)。哈雷 (Halle),1851年。施泰茨 (Steitz):《罗马的告解圣礼》(Das röm. Buss-Sacrament)。法兰克福 (Frankf.),1854年。弗兰克 (Frank,罗马天主教徒):《教会的悔罪纪律》(Die Bussdisciplin der Kirche)。美因茨,1867年。普罗布斯特 (Probst,罗马天主教徒):《圣礼与圣仪》(Sacramente und Sacramentalien)。图宾根 (Tübingen),1872年。哈丹与斯塔布斯 (Haddan and Stubbs):《大不列颠与爱尔兰的会议及教会文献》(Councils and Ecclesiastical Documents relating to Great Britain and Ireland),第III卷。牛津 (Oxf.),1871年。H. 约斯·施米茨 (H. Jos. Schmitz,罗马天主教徒):《教会的悔罪书与悔罪纪律:依据手稿史料》(Die Bussbücher und die Bussdisciplin der Kirche. Nach handschriftl. Quellen)。美因茨,1883年(XVI及864页)。参见瓦瑟施莱本发表于《神学文献报》(Theol. Literaturzeitung),1883年,第614页及后,对此书的评论。
宾厄姆 (Bingham),第XIV编。史密斯与奇瑟姆 (Smith and Cheetham),第II卷,第608页及后(悔罪书)。赫尔措格 (Herzog),第2版2,第III卷,第20页及后(Bussbücher,悔罪书)。韦策尔与韦尔特 (Wetzer and Welte),第2版2,第II卷,第209–222页(Beichtbücher,告解书);第II卷,第1561–1590页(Bussdisciplin,悔罪纪律)。
参见§87所列文献。
大公教会的纪律以授予使徒及其继承者的钥匙权为基础,包括将犯罪的成员逐出教会及使其复归。它起初纯属属灵的管辖权;但在基督教确立为国教以后,也开始影响受惩罚者在世俗社会中的处境。中世纪普遍相信,以罗马教皇制为中心的有形教会,乃是上帝所设立、施予永恒救恩的机构;被逐出她的团契,若不继之以悔改和复归,就意味着永远沉沦。这种信念使教会纪律牢牢支配了公众的心灵。从来没有任何异端或宗派声称拥有这种权力。
纪律为蛮族各族那种狂野而独立的精神所深恶痛绝。主教通过宗教会议法庭执行纪律;在查理大帝的领土内,这种法庭每年开庭,以促进良好的道德。查理大帝命令主教每年巡视所属各堂区一次,查究乱伦、弑父、杀害兄弟、奸淫,以及其他违反上帝律法的恶行。1西班牙和英格兰的宗教会议也颁布了类似的指示。较大的主教区划分为若干会吏长辖区。会吏长代表主教,由于这种密切关系,他们拥有高于司祭的权力和管辖权。会众中有七名成员受托负责监督,必须向审讯法庭报告宗教和道德的状况。无论违反教会法规还是民事法律的行为,都立即受到罚金、禁食、朝圣、鞭打或监禁的惩罚。世俗当局协助主教执行纪律。公开的过犯须受公开的补赎;私下的过犯则向司祭告解,司祭随即在一定条件下给予赦免。
中世纪拉丁教会的纪律载于所谓“悔罪书”中。2这些书规定悔罪的程序,并为某些罪行,如醉酒、淫乱、贪婪、伪誓、杀人、异端、拜偶像,订立具体的惩罚。其材料大多取自教父著作,以及安居拉 (Ancyra,314年)、新凯撒利亚 (Neocaesarea,314年)、尼西亚 (Nicaea,325年)、冈格拉 (Gangra,362年) 各次会议的教规,并取自直至七世纪的北非、法兰克和西班牙各次会议的教规。这些悔罪书的共同宗旨,是使人履行实际的义务,根除异教的凶暴和淫荡情欲。它们描绘了一幅极其阴暗的肉体罪恶图景。它们使人始终意识到上帝的道德治理:凡违背他律法的行为,他都要惩罚;但它们又助长了一种有害的观念,以为罪可以借机械的操练和缴纳一笔钱款来赎除,因而削弱了人的罪责感。
这类书为数甚多,有不列颠的、爱尔兰的、法兰克的、西班牙的和罗马的。其中最著名的是七、八世纪盎格鲁-撒克逊人的悔罪书,尤以坎特伯雷大主教狄奥多尔(669–690年)的为著。他生于基利家 (Cilicia) 的大数 (Tarsus),是希腊人,将东西方的纪律规则整理成体系。以他的名字命名的那部书,并非由他亲自执笔,而是在他的指导下编成,在他生前经他授权出版;其中收录了他答复一位名叫埃奥达 (Eoda) 的司祭和其他人,就补赎及整个教会纪律领域所提各种问题而作的裁决。近来,德国和英国学者共同努力,已从早期手稿中发现了这部书的真本文本。3其序言和正文均以粗陋的拉丁文写成。从书中对圣巴西尔 (St. Basil) 及希腊习俗的援引,可以看出狄奥多尔所受希腊教育的痕迹。继狄奥多尔的汇编之后,还有以尊者比德 (Bede,卒于735年) 和约克大主教埃格伯特 (Egbert,卒于767年) 之名流传的悔罪书。4
最早的法兰克悔罪书出自爱尔兰传教士哥伦巴努 (Columban,卒于615年) 之手。他严厉执行修道院纪律,在惩罚过犯时特别重视体罚。《库米安悔罪书》(Poenit. Cummeani) 源于苏格兰—爱尔兰传统,或被归于爱奥那的哥伦巴 (Columba of Iona,约597年),或归于他的门徒之一库明 (Cumin),或归于死在博比奥 (Bobbio) 哥伦巴努修道院的库米安 (Cummean,711年以后)。康布雷主教哈尔蒂加尔 (Haltigar, bishop of Cambray) 于九世纪(约829年)出版了一部《罗马悔罪书》,声称取材于罗马档案,实际上却有很大部分来自哥伦巴努及法兰克的资料。另有一部较早的著作,也称为《罗马悔罪书》(Poenitentiale Romanum),成于八世纪前期,性质较为一般,但其确切来源尚不清楚。“罗马”一词,是用来标明某一类悔罪书的性质,表示其权威超出了地方范围。5拉巴努斯·毛鲁斯 (Rabanus Maurus,卒于855年) 应美因茨大主教奥特加尔 (Otgar of Mayence) 之请,于841年编成一部《悔罪书》(Liber Poenitentitae)。几乎每个主教区都有自己的一部此类书籍,但其精神和材料大致相同。
附注
作为这些悔罪书的范例,我们摘录《狄奥多尔悔罪书》(Poenitentiale Theodori,作者为坎特伯雷大主教) 第一卷的头两章,依据哈丹与斯塔布斯《大不列颠与爱尔兰的会议及教会文献》(Councils and Eccles. Doc. relating to Great Britain and Ireland),第III卷,第177页及后所刊文本。我们也采用了瓦瑟施莱本所用其他手稿中的几处较佳异读。
I. 论饕餮与醉酒 (De Crapula et Ebrietate)
- Si quis Episco pus aut aliquis ordinatus in consuetudine vitium habuerit ebrietatis, aut desinat aut deponatur.
若有主教或任何受按立者染有惯常醉酒的恶习,或须戒除,或须革职。
- Si monachus pro ebrietate vomitum facit, XXX. dies peniteat.
若修士因醉酒而呕吐,须补赎三十日。
- Si presbiter aut diaconus pro ebrietate, XL. dies peniteat.
若司祭或执事因醉酒而如此,须补赎四十日。
- Si vero pro infirmitate aut quia longo tempore se abstinuerit, et in consuetudine non erit ei multum bibere vel manducare, aut pro gaudio in Natale Domini aut in Pascha aut pro alicujus Sanctorum commemoratione faciebat, et tunc plus non accipit quam decretum est a senioribus, nihil nocet. Si Episcopus juberit, non nocet illi, nisi ipse similiterfaciat.
但若是由于身体软弱,或由于长久节制,而素无多饮多食的习惯;或是在主降生节、复活节,或纪念某位圣徒时因欢喜而如此,且所进饮食并未超过长老规定的分量,则不算过犯。若是主教吩咐的,对那人不算过犯,除非他自己也照样行。
- Si laicus fidelis pro ebrietate vomitum facit, XV. dies peniteat.
若平信徒因醉酒而呕吐,须补赎十五日。
- *Qui vero inebriatur contra Domini interdictum, si votum sanctitatis habuerit VII. dies in pane et aqua, LXX. sine pinguedine peniteat; laici sine cervisa [cervisia*].
凡违背主的禁令而醉酒者,若曾立圣洁生活之愿,须以七日仅食面包、饮水,七十日不食油脂作为补赎;平信徒则须戒饮啤酒。
- Qui per nequitiam inebriat alium, XL. dies peniteat.
凡存恶意使他人醉酒者,须补赎四十日。
- Qui pro satietate vomitum facit, III. diebus [dies] peniteat.
凡因饱食而呕吐者,须补赎三日。
- Si cum sacrificio communionis, VII. dies peniteat; si infirmitatis causa, sine culpa.
若连同所领圣餐祭物一并吐出,须补赎七日;若因疾病所致,则无罪。
II. 论淫乱 (De Fornicatione)
- Si quis fornicaverit cum virgine, I. anno peniteat. Si cum marita, IIII. annos, II. integros, II alios in XL. mis. III. bus., et III dies in ebdomada peniteat.
若有人与处女行淫,须补赎一年。若与有夫之妇行淫,须补赎四年:两整年,另两年则在每年三个四十日禁食期及每周三日行补赎。
- Qui sepe cum masculo aut cum pecude fornicat, X. annos ut peniteret judicavit.
对于屡次与男子或牲畜行淫者,他裁定须补赎十年。
- Rem aliud. Qui cum pecoribus coierit, XV. annos peniteat.
另有一项规定:凡与牲畜交合者,须补赎十五年。
- Qui coierit cum masculo post XX. annum, XV. annos peniteat.
凡二十岁以后与男子交合者,须补赎十五年。
- Si masculus cum masculo fornicaverit, X. annos peniteat.
若男子与男子行淫,须补赎十年。
- Sodomitae VII. annos peniteat [peniteant]; molles [et mollis] sicut adultera.
犯所多玛罪者须补赎七年;其中居被动地位者,按淫妇处置。
- Item hoc; virile scelus semel faciens IIII annos peniteat; si in consuetudine fuerit, ut Basilius dicit, XV. Si sine, sustinens unum annum ut mulier. Si puer sit, primo II. bus annis; si iterat IIII.
又有此条:犯男子间的恶行一次者,须补赎四年;若已成习惯,则如巴西尔所说,须十五年。若非惯犯,居被动地位者须补赎一年,与妇人相同。若是男孩,初犯须两年;再犯须四年。
- Si in femoribus, annum I. vel. III. XL. mas.
若在两股之间行此事,须补赎一年,或三个四十日禁食期。
- *Si se ipsum coinguinat, XL. dies [peniteat*.]
若玷污自己,须补赎四十日。
- Qui concupiscit fornicari [fornicare] sed non potest, XL. dies vel XX. peniteat. Si frequentaverit, si puer sit, XX. dies, vel vapuletur.
凡欲行淫而未能行者,须补赎四十日或二十日。若屡次如此,且是男孩,须补赎二十日,或受鞭打。
- Pueri qui fornicantur inter se ipsos judicavit ut vapulentur.
对于彼此行淫的男孩,他裁定须受鞭打。
- Mulier cum muliere fornicando [si ... fornicaverit], III. annos peniteat.
若妇人与妇人行淫,须补赎三年。
- Si sola cum se ipsa coitum habet, sic peniteat.
若她独自与自身交合,也须照此补赎。
14. Una penitentia est viduae et puellae. Majorem meruit quae virum habet, si fornicaverit.
寡妇与少女所受补赎相同。有夫之妇若行淫,应受更重的补赎。
- Qui semen in os miserit, VII annos peniteat: hoc pessimum malum. Alias ab eo judicatum est ut ambo usque in finem vitae peniteant; vel XXII. annos, vel ut superius VII.
凡将精液射入口中者,须补赎七年:这是极恶之事。他在别处裁定,双方均须终身补赎;或二十二年,或如上述七年。
- Si cum matre quis fornicaverit, XV. annos peniteat, et nunquam, mutat [mutet] nisi Dominicis diebus: et hoc tam profanum incertum [incestum] ab eo similiter alio modo dicitur ut cum peregrinatione perenni VII. annos peniteat.
若有人与母亲行淫,须补赎十五年,除主日外,绝不可变更补赎的规制。对于这等亵渎的乱伦,他也曾另作规定:须终身离乡漂泊,并补赎七年。
- Qui cum sorore fornicatur, XV. annos peniteat, eo modo quo superius de matre dicitur, sed et istud XV. alias in canone confirmavit; unde non absorde XV. anni ad matrem transeunt qui scribuntur.
凡与姊妹行淫者,须补赎十五年,方式如上文论母亲时所述。他在别处的教规中也确认了这十五年;因此,将所记载的十五年同样应用于与母亲行淫的情形,并非没有道理。
- Qui sepe fornicaverit, primus canon judicavit X. annos penitere; secundus canon VII.; sed pro infirmitate hominis, per consilium dixerunt III. annos penitere.
对于屡次行淫者,第一条教规裁定须补赎十年,第二条教规规定七年;但顾念人的软弱,经过商议,他们说须补赎三年。
- Si frater cum fratre naturali fornicaverit per commixtionem carnis, XV. annos ab omni carne abstineat.
若兄弟与亲兄弟发生肉体交合而行淫,须十五年禁食一切肉类。
- Si mater cum filio suo parvulo fornicationem imitatur, III. annos se abstineat a carne, et diem unum jejunet in ebdomada, id est, usque ad vesperum.
若母亲与自己的幼子模拟行淫,须禁食肉类三年,并每周禁食一日,即直到傍晚不进食。
- Qui inludetur fornicaria cogitatione, peniteat usque dum cogitatio superetur.
凡受淫念戏弄者,须行补赎,直到胜过这念头。
- Qui diligit feminam mente, veniam petat ab eo [a Deo] id est, de amore et amicitia si dixerit si non est susceptus ab ea, VII. dies peniteat."
凡心中爱恋妇人者,当向他[向上帝]求赦免;也就是说,若他表露爱情和亲昵之意,却未蒙她接纳,须补赎七日。
第一卷其余各章论述以下题目:De Avaritia Furtiva(论偷窃的贪欲);De Occisione Hominum [De Homicidio](论杀人);De his qui per Heresim decipiuntur(论受异端迷惑者);De Perjurio(论伪誓);De multis et diversis Malis(论诸多不同的恶行);De diverso Lapso servorum Dei(论上帝仆人各样的失足);De his qui degraduntur vel ordinari non possunt(论被革职或不得受按立者);De Baptizatis his, qualiter peniteant(论受洗者应如何补赎);De his qui damnant Dominicam et indicta jejunia ecclesiae Dei(论藐弃主日及上帝教会所定禁食者);De communione Eucharistiae, vel Sacrificio(论领圣餐或献祭);De Reconciliatione(论复和);De Penitentia Nubentium specialiter(专论结婚者的补赎);De Cultura Idolorum(论偶像崇拜)。末章表明,当时有许多异教迷信盛行,并与粗鄙的淫行相连,而教会则竭力用机械的律法主义加以抵制。第二卷论述:De Ecclesiae Ministerio(论教会职事);De tribus gradibus*(论三个等级);De Ordinatione(论按立);De Baptismo et Confirmatione(论洗礼与坚振礼);De Missa Defunctorum(论亡者弥撒)等。
§86. 教会的惩罚:逐出教会、咒诅、禁令
弗里德里希·科伯 (Friedrich Kober,罗马天主教徒):《依教会法原则阐述的教会绝罚》(Der Kirchenbann nach den Grundsätzen des canonischen Rechts dargestellt)。图宾根,1857年(560页)。同一作者:《教会教职人员的停职》(Die Suspension der Kirchendiener)。图宾根 (Tüb.),1862年。
亨利·C. 利 (Henry C. Lea):《逐出教会》(Excommunication),载其《教会史研究》(Studies in Church History)(费城,1869年),第223–475页。
教会最严厉的惩罚是逐出教会、咒诅和禁令。在中世纪,人们相信教会掌管救恩,世俗权力又以法律的强力执行教会的谕令,这些便成了教阶制度手中可怕的武器。受罚者悔改,惩罚即告终止,随后便予以赦免。赦免的判决必须由宣布逐出教会的主教作出;但在临终之际(articulo mortis),任何司铎都可以施行赦免,条件是受赦者若康复,便须服从。
- 逐出教会,就是禁止领受圣礼,尤其是圣餐。在查理曼 (Charlemagne) 的领土内,这种惩罚还伴随着公民权利的剥夺,如不得诉诸世俗法庭,甚至遭受监禁和财产没收。主教可以将任何拒绝按教会法规服从的人逐出教会。但主教只能由教皇逐出教会,而地上没有任何权力能够将教皇逐出教会。6 这种判决往往伴随着对犯过者身体与灵魂的可怕咒诅。教皇既高居普通主教之上,在咒诅的技巧上也胜过他们,并且以骇人的亵渎施展这种技巧。例如,曾为皇帝亨利二世 (Henry II) 加冕(公元1014年)的本笃八世 (Benedict VIII),将普罗旺斯伯爵威廉二世 (William II, Count of Provence) 手下几个肆无忌惮的封臣逐出教会;这些人企图以不敬的手侵占圣吉尔修道院 (monastery of St. Giles) 的财产。7 他以可怕的诅咒将他们交给撒但,虽然他大概认为,自己不过是在效法圣彼得定亚拿尼亚、撒非喇和行邪术的西门之罪的榜样。8
“顽梗的罪人,”利 (Lea) 说,“也许会藐视这样的诅咒,但其对信徒所起的作用必然难以言喻:在华丽而庄严的礼拜仪式中,主教由十二位手持燃烛的司铎环绕,郑重诵读可怕的言辞,以如此骇人的繁复咒诅,反复宣告作恶者及其所有后代都要受永远的痛苦;当这灭亡的判词达到高潮时,侍立的司铎同时将蜡烛掷在地上踏灭,象征一个人的灵魂在地狱永恒的黑夜中熄灭。此外,人们还怀着一种几乎确信无疑的期待,认为上天不会等待事态自然发展才证实这样宣布的判决,咒诅在今世也会与在来世一样有效。因此,即便有人不为属灵的恐怖所屈服,也会被那些可怕的故事吓倒;这些故事讲述审判如何临到胆敢藐视可畏咒诅的顽梗罪人。”
咒诅 (Anathema) 通常与逐出教会同义,即断绝教会的团契,剥夺教会的权利。但在较狭义的用法中,它指“大”绝罚,9 即禁止一切基督徒之间的交往,使犯过者成为不受法律保护的人;而“小”绝罚则只禁止领受圣礼。格拉提安 (Gratian) 和英诺森三世 (Innocent III) 作过这样的区分。咒诅的宣告伴随着更为庄严的仪式。335年的尼西亚会议 (Council of Nicaea) 咒诅了阿里乌派 (Arians),1563年的特伦托会议 (Council of Trent) 则以对所有异端者的三次咒诅闭幕。
禁令 (Interdict)10 的范围遍及整个城镇、教区、地区或国家,使无辜者与有罪者一同受罚。它停止一切公开的宗教活动,甚至包括婚礼和葬礼;只有洗礼和临终傅油礼仍可施行,而且也只能闭门举行。它使整个国家笼罩在葬礼般的阴郁中,使人们战栗,等候最后的审判。这种非常的惩罚在第五世纪开始小规模实行。奥古斯丁曾公正地责备同任主教的奥克西利乌斯 (Auxilius),因为他滥用权柄,因一家之主的过犯而将全家逐出教会;教皇大利奥 (Leo the Great) 也禁止对任何未参与犯罪的人施行这一惩罚。11 然而,十一至十三世纪的中世纪主教和教皇却不作此想,屡次诉诸这种迫使人服从的极端手段。蛮族习惯使家族或部落为个别成员所犯的罪负责,这为他们的做法提供了某种根据。
施行禁令最初的显著实例出现在法国。鲁昂主教普雷泰克斯塔图斯 (Pretextatus, Bishop of Rouen) 在祭坛前被残暴的王后弗蕾德贡达 (Fredegunda) 雇用的凶手杀害之后,巴约主教勒乌多瓦尔德 (Leudovald of Bayeux) 与其他主教商议,于586年关闭了鲁昂所有的教堂,剥夺民众从宗教所得的安慰,直到凶手被查明为止。12 拉昂的欣克马尔 (Hincmar of Laon) 曾对自己的教区施行禁令(869年),但兰斯的欣克马尔 (Hincmar of Rheims) 不赞同此举,并将禁令撤销。1031年利摩日(利穆赞)会议 (synod of Limoges [Limoisin]) 以禁令推行“上帝的和平” (Peace of God),下列宣告曾在教堂中宣读:“我们将利摩日主教区内一切不听从主教劝告、不守和平的贵族(milites)逐出教会。愿他们和帮助他们的人都受咒诅,愿他们的武器和马匹也受咒诅!愿他们与该隐、大坍、亚比兰同得一分!正如现在灯火熄灭,他们在天使面前的喜乐也必毁灭,除非他们在死前悔改并作出补赎。”会议下令停止公开礼拜,撤去祭坛上的遮盖,移走十字架和饰物,禁止婚礼;只有教士、乞丐、异乡人及两岁以下的儿童可以获准安葬,只有临终者可以领圣餐;在贵族屈服以前,任何教士或平信徒都不得剃须。每日第三时辰,教堂应发出信号,召唤众人屈膝祈祷。人人都应穿丧服。整个禁令期间,都应作为连续禁食和自卑的时期来遵守。13
教皇用这种可怕的武器对付不服从的国王,为了自己的教阶野心,牺牲整个民族的属灵安慰。格列高利七世 (Gregory VII) 对格涅兹诺省 (Gnesen) 施行禁令,因为国王博莱斯瓦夫二世 (Bolislaw II) 亲手杀害了克拉科夫主教斯坦尼斯劳斯 (Stanislaus of Cracow)。亚历山大二世 (Alexander II) 对苏格兰施行禁令(1180年),因为国王拒绝接受教皇所派的主教,并将他逐出国境。英诺森三世于1200年将禁令悬在法国头上,因为国王腓力·奥古斯都 (Philip Augustus) 抛弃了合法妻子,与一个妾同居。14 同一位教皇又将此惩罚加于英国(1208年3月23日),希望迫使无地王约翰 (John [Lackland]) 就范。英国的禁令持续了六年多,其间除洗礼、告解和临终圣餐外,一切宗教仪式都被禁止。
禁令只有在教会拥有无限权力的中世纪才有可能实行。它们被频繁使用,又无法完全执行,威力便随之减弱;直到欧洲各国不再受制于祭司权术的管教,觉醒而意识到自己已经成人,禁令也就遭人蔑视,被一扫而空。
§87. 补赎与大赦
纳撒尼尔·马歇尔 (Nath. Marshall,温莎法政牧师、居普良著作的译者,卒于1729年):《基督以后最初四百年原始教会的补赎纪律,及其自第五世纪衰落至现状的历程》(The Penitential Discipline of the Primitive Church for the first 400 years after Christ, together with its declension from the fifth century downward to its present state)。伦敦,1714年。新版收入《英国大公派神学文库》(Lib. of Anglo-Cath. Theol.),牛津,1844年。
欧塞比乌斯·阿莫特 (Eus. Amort):《论大赦的起源、发展、效力与果效》(De Origine, Progressu, Valore ac Fructu Indulgentiarum)。奥格斯堡 (Aug. Vindel.),1735年,对开本。
穆拉托里 (Muratori):《论罪的赎免与大赦的起源》(De Redemtione Peccatorum et de Indulgentiarum Origine),载其《意大利中世纪古事考》(Antiquitates Italicae Medii Aevi),第V卷。米兰 (Mediol.),1741年。
约翰·B. 希尔舍尔 (Joh. B. Hirscher,罗马天主教徒):《大赦教义》(Die Lehre vom Ablass)。图宾根,第5版,1844年。
G. E. 施泰茨 (G. E. Steitz):《罗马的补赎圣礼:其圣经根据与历史发展》(Das römische Buss-Sacrament, nach seinem bibl. Grunde und seiner gesch. Entwicklung)。美因河畔法兰克福 (Frankf a. M.),1854年(210页)。
瓦伦丁·格勒内 (Val. Gröne,罗马天主教徒):《大赦:其历史及其在救恩安排中的意义》(Der Ablass, seine Geschichte und Bedeutung in der Heilsökonomie)。雷根斯堡 (Regensb.),1863年。
多米尼克·帕尔米耶里 (Domin. Palmieri,罗马天主教徒):《论补赎》(Tractat. de Poenit.)。罗马 (Romae),1879年。
乔治·米德 (George Mead):“补赎”条(Penitence),载史密斯与奇瑟姆 (Smith and Cheetham),II,1586–1608页。维尔特 (Wildt,罗马天主教徒):“大赦”条(Ablass),载韦策尔与韦尔特 (Wetzer and Welte)2,I,94–111页;“告解”(Beichte)及“告解保密”条(Beichtsiegel),II,221–261页。迈耶 (Mejer),载赫尔措格 (Herzog)2,I,90–92页。原始文献节录,参见吉泽勒 (Gieseler),II,105页及下页;193页及下页;515页及下页(美国版)。
关于罗马教会对补赎圣礼(Sacramentum Poenitentiae)的权威教导,见1551年举行的特伦托会议第XIV次会议(Conc. Trident. Sess. XIV.)。
“悔改”或“悔罪”一词,不足以译出相应的希腊文 metanoia;后者意指心意的根本改变,或从罪恶生活转向敬虔生活的归信。其中,消极的一面是在依着上帝意思的忧愁中离弃罪(狭义的悔改),积极的一面则是凭信心转向基督,立志跟从他。15 施洗约翰和耶稣基督的传道,都是从呼召人作这种意义上的悔改开始的。16
在拉丁教会中,悔改的观念被外在化,等同于某些为赎罪而自卑或自罚的外在行为。除极其严重的过犯外,在教会面前所作的公开补赎,在第七或第八世纪逐渐废止,由私下的补赎和告解取代。17 1215年,教皇英诺森三世主持的拉特兰会议 (Lateran Council) 规定,每个天主教基督徒都必须每年至少一次向本堂司铎告解。18
补赎,包括附耳告解和司铎赦罪,被提升为处理受洗后所犯罪行的圣礼。其理论基础由教父(德尔图良和居普良)奠定,由经院学者完成,并获罗马教会认可。这一理论认为,洗礼使过去的罪完全得赦,却不赦免此后的罪;它使人免于永远的定罪,却不免除暂时的刑罚,而这种刑罚最终体现于死亡或炼狱。补赎被描述为一种“艰苦的洗礼”;特伦托会议宣告,对于受洗后跌倒的人,补赎是得救所必需的,正如对于尚未重生的人,洗礼是必需的一样。19
补赎圣礼与司铎赦罪包含三个要素:心中的痛悔、口中的告白、以善行作出补赎。20 在这些条件下,司铎赐予赦免,这不只是宣告性的行为,更是司法性的行为。所要求的善行尤其是禁食和施舍。前往耶路撒冷、罗马、图尔 (Tours)、孔波斯特拉 (Compostella) 及其他圣地朝圣,也是人们喜爱的补赎方式。彼得·达米安 (Peter Damiani) 提倡自愿鞭笞自己,以为平息上帝忿怒的手段。在民众心目中,这些虔敬操练涵盖了补赎的全部意义。衡量敬虔的标准,是善行的数量,而非品格的优劣。
这里还须提到另一种与补赎密切相关的中世纪制度。西方教会热心防止暴力和流血,因而赞成蛮族以金钱赔偿代替对过犯施加惩罚的习惯,这原是对的;但将这一习惯应用于宗教领域,却是错的。于是,金钱可以代替禁食和其他补赎行为,并被赋予赎罪的效力。这一习惯似乎源于英国教会,不久便传遍欧洲大陆。21 它蜕变成一种常规交易,成为增加教会和修道院财产的丰厚来源。
这就是所谓赎罪券 (indulgences) 的起源,即以缴纳金钱,并以痛悔和祈祷为条件,获得小罪的赦免。经院学说为这种做法辩护,认为圣徒超出本分的善功构成了一座额外功德与额外赏报的宝库,由教皇掌管。因此,赎罪券便具有一种特殊含义:教皇从圣徒满溢的功德宝库中施予特赦或赦罪;这种权力甚至被扩展到使炼狱中的亡者受益。22
主教和大主教可以在各自的教区内颁发赎罪券,教皇则可以向所有天主教徒颁发。前者从事零售,后者从事批发。教皇颁发赎罪券的最早事例出现于第九世纪,帕斯卡尔一世 (Paschalis I.) 和约翰八世 (John VIII.) 将其赐给那些为保卫教会而战死的人。1046年,格列高利六世 (Gregory VI.) 应许将其赐给所有捐款修缮罗马各教堂的人。乌尔班二世 (Urban II.) 在克莱蒙会议 (Clermont,1095年) 上,“凭使徒之首彼得和保罗的权柄”,向十字军战士提供全大赦,作为前往圣地的赏报。此后,每一次讨伐穆罕默德教徒和异端的十字军远征,都重申了同样的应许。教皇们发现,这是扩张权势和充实府库的便利手段。于是,颁发赎罪券成为一种定期实行的制度。在利奥十世 (Leo X.) 任内,台彻尔 (Tetzel) 为圣彼得教堂筹款所进行的亵渎而可耻的交易,使其流弊登峰造极;然而,上帝的护理却使这一切转而促成宗教改革,使人重新回到圣经所教导的悔改观念。
附注
人们常指控中世纪的教皇宫廷为赎罪券制定了统一的价目表,其依据是罗马教廷文书署不时出版的收费表。罗马天主教作家(如林加德 (Lingard)、怀斯曼 (Wiseman))说,这些收费不过是办理事务和支付官员薪酬的费用,但他们也无法否认某些教皇可耻的贪婪。T. L. 格林博士 (T. L. Green,罗马天主教徒) 在《论赎罪券、圣礼赦罪及罗马教廷文书署与圣赦院的收费表:答复贪财之指控》(Indulgences, Sacramental Absolutions, and the Tax-Tables of the Roman Chancery and Penitentiary, considered, in reply to the Charge of Venality),伦敦 (London):Longmans,1872年,以及新教方面的理查德·吉宾斯博士 (Richard Gibbings,都柏林大学教会史教授) 在《宗座圣赦院的收费;或罗马教会中罪的价目》(The Taxes of the Apostolic Penitentiary; or, the Prices of Sins in the Church of Rome),都柏林 (Dublin),1872年,均详尽讨论了这一问题。吉宾斯依据1510年罗马版和1520年巴黎版,重印了《罗马圣赦院收费表》(Taxae Sacrae Poenitentiariae Romanae),拉丁文共21页;但全书的大部分(164页)是历史导论和论辩。
Original Text
CHAPTER VIII. CHURCH DISCIPLINE.
Comp. vol. II. § 57, and vol. III. § 68.
§ 85. The Penitential Books.
I. The Acts of Councils, the Capitularies of Charlemagne and his successors, and the Penitential Books, especially that of Theodore of Canterbury, and that of Rome. See Migne’s Patrol. Tom. 99, fol. 901–983.
- Friedr. Kunstmann (R.C.): Die latein. Pönitentialbücher der Angelsachsen. Mainz 1844. F. W. H. Wasserschleben: Bussordnungen der abendländ. Kirche. Halle 1851. Steitz: Das röm. Buss-Sacrament. Frankf. 1854. Frank (R.C.): Die Bussdisciplin der Kirche. Mainz 1867. Probst (R.C.): Sacramente und Sacramentalien. Tübingen 1872. Haddan and Stubbs: Councils and Ecclesiastical Documents relating to Great Britain and Ireland, vol. III. Oxf. 1871. H. Jos. Schmitz (R.C.): Die Bussbücher und die Bussdisciplin der Kirche. Nach handschriftl. Quellen. Mainz 1883 (XVI. and 864 p.). Comp. the review of this book by Wasserschleben in the "Theol. Literaturzeitung," 1883, fol. 614 sqq.
Bingham, Bk XIV. Smith and Cheetham, II. 608 sqq. (Penitential Books). Herzog,2 III. 20 sqq. (Bussbücher). Wetzer and Welte2 II. 209–222 (Beichtbücher); II. 1561–1590 (Bussdisciplin).
Comp. Lit. in § 87.
The discipline of the Catholic church is based on the power of the keys intrusted to the apostles and their successors, and includes the excommunication and restoration of delinquent members. It was originally a purely spiritual jurisdiction, but after the establishment of Christianity as the national religion, it began to affect also the civil and temporal condition of the subjects of punishment. It obtained a powerful hold upon the public mind from the universal belief of the middle ages that the visible church, centering in the Roman papacy, was by divine appointment the dispenser of eternal salvation, and that expulsion from her communion, unless followed by repentance and restoration, meant eternal damnation. No heresy or sect ever claimed this power.
Discipline was very obnoxious to the wild and independent spirit of the barbaric races. It was exercised by the bishop through synodical courts, which were held annually in the dominions of Charlemagne for the promotion of good morals. Charlemagne ordered the bishops to visit their parishes once a year, and to inquire into cases of incest, patricide, fratricide, adultery, and other vices contrary to the laws of God.(1) Similar directions were given by Synods in Spain and England. The more extensive dioceses were divided into several archdeaconries. The archdeacons represented the bishops, and, owing to this close connection, they possessed a power and jurisdiction superior to that of the priests. Seven members of the congregation were entrusted with a supervision, and had to report to the inquisitorial court on the state of religion and morals. Offences both ecclesiastical and civil were punished at once with fines, fasting, pilgrimages, scourging, imprisonment. The civil authorities aided the bishops in the exercise of discipline. Public offences were visited with public penance; private offences were confessed to the priest, who immediately granted absolution on certain conditions.
The discipline of the Latin church in the middle ages is laid down in the so-called "Penitential Books."(2) They regulate the order of penitence, and prescribe specific punishments for certain sins, as drunkenness, fornication, avarice, perjury, homicide, heresy, idolatry. The material is mostly derived from the writings of the fathers, and from the synodical canons of Ancyra (314), Neocaesarea (314), Nicaea (325), Gangra (362), and of the North African, Frankish, and Spanish councils down to the seventh century. The common object of these Penitentials is to enforce practical duties and to extirpate the ferocious and licentious passions of heathenism. They present a very dark picture of the sins of the flesh. They kept alive the sense of a moral government of God, who punishes every violation of his law, but they lowered the sense of guilt by fostering the pernicious notion that sin may be expiated by mechanical exercises and by the payment of a sum of money.
There were many such books, British, Irish, Frankish, Spanish, and Roman. The best known are the Anglo-Saxon penitentials of the seventh and eighth centuries, especially that of Theodore, archbishop of Canterbury (669–690). He was a Greek by birth, of Tarsus in Cilicia, and reduced the disciplinary rules of the East and West to a system. He was not the direct author of the book which bears his name, but it was drawn up under his direction, published during his life-time and by his authority, and contains his decisions in answer to various questions of a priest named Eoda and other persons on the subject of penance and the whole range of ecclesiastical discipline. The genuine text has recently been brought to light from early MSS. by the combined labors of German and English scholarship.(3) The introduction and the book itself are written in barbarous Latin. Traces of the Greek training of Theodore may be seen in the references to St. Basil and to Greek practices. Next to Theodore’s collection there are Penitentials under the name of the venerable Bede (d. 735), and of Egbert, archbishop of York (d. 767).(4)
The earliest Frankish penitential is the work of Columban, the Irish missionary (d. 615). He was a severe monastic disciplinarian and gave prominence to corporal punishment among the penalties for offences. The Cummean Penitential (Poenit. Cummeani) is of Scotch-Irish origin, and variously assigned to Columba of Iona (about 597), to Cumin, one of his disciples, or to Cummean, who died in Columban’s monastery at Bobbio (after 711). Haltigar, bishop of Cambray, in the ninth century (about 829) published a "Roman Penitential," professedly derived from Roman archives, but in great part from Columban, and Frankish sources. An earlier work which bears the name "Poenitentiale Romanum," from the first part of the eighth century, has a more general character, but its precise origin is uncertain. The term "Roman" was used to designate the quality of a class of Penitentials which enjoyed a more than local authority.(5) Rabanus Maurus (d. 855) prepared a "Liber Poenitentitae" at the request of the archbishop Otgar of Mayence (841). Almost every diocese had its own book of the kind, but the spirit and the material were substantially the same.
Notes.
As specimens of these Penitential Books, we give the first two chapters from the first book of the Poenitentiale Theodori (Archbishop of Canterbury), as printed in Haddan and Stubbs, Councils and Eccles. Doc. relating to Great Britain and Ireland, vol. IIIrd. p. 177 sqq. We insert a few better readings from other MSS. used by Wasserschleben.
I. De Crapula et Ebrietate.
Si quis Episco pus aut aliquis ordinatus in consuetudine vitium habuerit ebrietatis, aut desinat aut deponatur.
Si monachus pro ebrietate vomitum facit, XXX. dies peniteat.
Si presbiter aut diaconus pro ebrietate, XL. dies peniteat.
Si vero pro infirmitate aut quia longo tempore se abstinuerit, et in consuetudine non erit ei multum bibere vel manducare, aut pro gaudio in Natale Domini aut in Pascha aut pro alicujus Sanctorum commemoratione faciebat, et tunc plus non accipit quam decretum est a senioribus, nihil nocet. Si Episcopus juberit, non nocet illi, nisi ipse similiterfaciat.
Si laicus fidelis pro ebrietate vomitum facit, XV. dies peniteat.
*Qui vero inebriatur contra Domini interdictum, si votum sanctitatis habuerit VII. dies in pane et aqua, LXX. sine pinguedine peniteat; laici sine cervisa [cervisia*].
Qui per nequitiam inebriat alium, XL. dies peniteat.
Qui pro satietate vomitum facit, III. diebus [dies] peniteat.
Si cum sacrificio communionis, VII. dies peniteat; si infirmitatis causa, sine culpa.
II. De Fornicatione.
Si quis fornicaverit cum virgine, I. anno peniteat. Si cum marita, IIII. annos, II. integros, II alios in XL. mis. III. bus., et III dies in ebdomada peniteat.
Qui sepe cum masculo aut cum pecude fornicat, X. annos ut peniteret judicavit.
Rem aliud. Qui cum pecoribus coierit, XV. annos peniteat.
Qui coierit cum masculo post XX. annum, XV. annos peniteat.
Si masculus cum masculo fornicaverit, X. annos peniteat.
Sodomitae VII. annos peniteat [peniteant]; molles [et mollis] sicut adultera.
Item hoc; virile scelus semel faciens IIII annos peniteat; si in consuetudine fuerit, ut Basilius dicit, XV. Si sine, sustinens unum annum ut mulier. Si puer sit, primo II. bus annis; si iterat IIII.
Si in femoribus, annum I. vel. III. XL. mas.
*Si se ipsum coinguinat, XL. dies [peniteat*.]
Qui concupiscit fornicari [fornicare] sed non potest, XL. dies vel XX. peniteat. Si frequentaverit, si puer sit, XX. dies, vel vapuletur.
Pueri qui fornicantur inter se ipsos judicavit ut vapulentur.
Mulier cum muliere fornicando [si ... fornicaverit], III. annos peniteat.
Si sola cum se ipsa coitum habet, sic peniteat.
14. Una penitentia est viduae et puellae. Majorem meruit quae virum habet, si fornicaverit.
Qui semen in os miserit, VII annos peniteat: hoc pessimum malum. Alias ab eo judicatum est ut ambo usque in finem vitae peniteant; vel XXII. annos, vel ut superius VII.
Si cum matre quis fornicaverit, XV. annos peniteat, et nunquam, mutat [mutet] nisi Dominicis diebus: et hoc tam profanum incertum [incestum] ab eo similiter alio modo dicitur ut cum peregrinatione perenni VII. annos peniteat.
Qui cum sorore fornicatur, XV. annos peniteat, eo modo quo superius de matre dicitur, sed et istud XV. alias in canone confirmavit; unde non absorde XV. anni ad matrem transeunt qui scribuntur.
Qui sepe fornicaverit, primus canon judicavit X. annos penitere; secundus canon VII.; sed pro infirmitate hominis, per consilium dixerunt III. annos penitere.
Si frater cum fratre naturali fornicaverit per commixtionem carnis, XV. annos ab omni carne abstineat.
Si mater cum filio suo parvulo fornicationem imitatur, III. annos se abstineat a carne, et diem unum jejunet in ebdomada, id est, usque ad vesperum.
Qui inludetur fornicaria cogitatione, peniteat usque dum cogitatio superetur.
Qui diligit feminam mente, veniam petat ab eo [a Deo] id est, de amore et amicitia si dixerit si non est susceptus ab ea, VII. dies peniteat."
The remaining chapters of the first book treat De Avaritia Furtiva; De Occisione Hominum [De Homicidio]; De his qui per Heresim decipiuntur; De Perjurio; De multis et diversis Malis; De diverso Lapso servorum Dei; De his qui degraduntur vel ordinari non possunt; De Baptizatis his, qualiter peniteant; De his qui damnant Dominicam et indicta jejunia ecclesiae Dei; De communione Eucharistiae, vel Sacrificio; De Reconciliatione; De Penitentia Nubentium specialiter; De Cultura Idolorum. The last chapter shows how many heathen superstitions prevailed in connection with gross immorality, which the church endeavored to counteract by a mechanical legalism. The second book treats De Ecclesiae Ministerio; De tribus gratlibus; De Ordinatione; De Baptismo et Confirmatione; De Missa Defunctorum, etc.
§ 86. Ecclesiastical Punishments. Excommunication, Anathema, Interdict.
Friedrich Kober (R.C.): Der Kirchenbann nach den Grundsätzen des canonischen Rechts dargestellt. Tübingen 1857 (560 pages). By the same author: Die Suspension der Kirchendiener. Tüb. 1862.
Henry C. Lea: Excommunication, in his Studies in Church History (Philadelphia 1869), p. 223–475.
The severest penalties of the church were excommunication, anathema, and interdict. They were fearful weapons in the hands of the hierarchy during the middle ages, when the church was believed to control salvation, and when the civil power enforced her decrees by the strong arm of the law. The punishment ceases with repentance, which is followed by absolution. The sentence of absolution must proceed from the bishop who pronounced the sentence of excommunication; but in articulo mortis every priest can absolve on condition of obedience in case of recovery.
- Excommunication was the exclusion from the sacraments, especially the communion. In the dominions of Charlemagne it was accompanied with civil disabilities, as exclusion from secular tribunals, and even with imprisonment and seizure of property. A bishop could excommunicate any one who refused canonical obedience. But a bishop could only be excommunicated by the pope, and the pope by no power on earth.(6) The sentence was often accompanied with awful curses upon the bodies and souls of the offender. The popes, as they towered above ordinary bishops, surpassed them also in the art of cursing, and exercised it with shocking profanity. Thus Benedict VIII., who crowned Emperor Henry II. (a.d. 1014), excommunicated some reckless vassals of William II., Count of Provence, who sought to lay unhallowed hands upon the property of the monastery of St. Giles,(7) and consigned them to Satan with terrible imprecations, although be probably thought he was only following St. Peter’s example in condemning Ananias and Sapphira, and Simon Magus.(8)
"Hardened sinners" (says Lea) "might despise such imprecations, but their effect on believers was necessarily unutterable, when, amid the gorgeous and impressive ceremonial of worship, the bishop, surrounded by twelve priests bearing flaming candles, solemnly recited the awful words which consigned the evil-doer and all his generation to eternal torment with such fearful amplitude and reduplication of malediction, and as the sentence of perdition came to its climax, the attending priests simultaneously cast their candles to the ground and trod them out, as a symbol of the quenching of a human soul in the eternal night of hell. To this was added the expectation, amounting almost to a certainty, that Heaven would not wait for the natural course of events to confirm the judgment thus pronounced, but that the maledictions would be as effective in this world as in the next. Those whom spiritual terrors could not subdue thus were daunted by the fearful stories of the judgment overtaking the hardened sinner who dared to despise the dread anathema."
The Anathema is generally used in the same sense as excommunication or separation from church communion and church privileges. But in a narrower sense, it means the "greater" excommunication,(9) which excludes from all Christian intercourse and makes the offender an outlaw; while the "minor" excommunication excludes only from the sacrament. Such a distinction was made by Gratian and Innocent III. The anathema was pronounced with more solemn ceremonies. The Council of Nicaea, 335, anathematized the Arians, and the Council of Trent, 1563, closed with three anathemas on all heretics.
The Interdict(10) extended over a whole town or diocese or district or country, and involved the innocent with the guilty. It was a suspension of religion in public exercise, including even the rites of marriage and burial; only baptism and extreme unction could be performed, and they only with closed doors. It cast the gloom of a funeral over a country, and made people tremble in expectation of the last judgment. This exceptional punishment began in a small way in the fifth century. St. Augustin justly reproved Auxilius, a brother bishop, who abused his power by excommunicating a whole family for the offence of the head, and Pope Leo the Great forbade to enforce the penalty on any who was not a partner in the crime.(11) But the bishops and popes of the middle ages, from the eleventh to the thirteenth century, thought otherwise, and resorted repeatedly to this extreme remedy of enforcing obedience. They had some basis for it in the custom of the barbarians to hold the family or tribe responsible for crimes committed by individual members.
The first conspicuous examples of inflicting the Interdict occurred in France. Bishop Leudovald of Bayeux, after consulting with his brother bishops, closed in 586 all the churches of Rouen and deprived the people of the consolations of religion until the murderer of Pretextatus, Bishop of Rouen, who was slain at the altar by a hireling of the savage queen Fredegunda, should be discovered.(12) Hincmar of Laon inflicted the interdict on his diocese (869), but Hincmar of Rheims disapproved of it and removed it. The synod of Limoges (Limoisin), in 1031, enforced the Peace of God by the interdict in these words which were read in the church: "We excommunicate all those noblemen (milites) in the bishopric of Limoges who disobey the exhortations of their bishop to hold the Peace. Let them and their helpers be accursed, and let their weapons and horses be accursed! Let their lot be with Cain, Dathan, and Abiram! And as now the lights are extinguished, so their joy in the presence of angels shall be destroyed, unless they repent and make satisfaction before dying." The Synod ordered that public worship be closed, the altars laid bare, crosses and ornaments removed, marriages forbidden; only clergymen, beggars, strangers and children under two years could be buried, and only the dying receive the communion; no clergyman or layman should be shaved till the nobles submit. A signal in the church on the third hour of the day should call all to fall on their knees to pray. All should be dressed in mourning. The whole period of the interdict should be observed as a continued fast and humiliation.(13)
The popes employed this fearful weapon against disobedient kings, and sacrificed the spiritual comforts of whole nations to their hierarchical ambition. Gregory VII. laid the province of Gnesen under the interdict, because King Bolislaw II. had murdered bishop Stanislaus of Cracow with his own hand. Alexander II. applied it to Scotland (1180), because the king refused a papal bishop and expelled him from the country. Innocent III. suspended it over France (1200), because king Philip Augustus had cast off his lawful wife and lived with a concubine.(14) The same pope inflicted this punishment upon England (March 23, 1208), hoping to bring King John (Lackland) to terms. The English interdict lasted over six years during which all religious rites were forbidden except baptism, confession, and the viaticum.
Interdicts were only possible in the middle ages when the church had unlimited power. Their frequency and the impossibility of full execution diminished their power until they fell into contempt and were swept out of existence as the nations of Europe outgrew the discipline of priestcraft and awoke to a sense of manhood.
§ 87. Penance and Indulgence.
Nath. Marshall (Canon of Windsor and translator of Cyprian, d. 1729): The Penitential Discipline of the Primitive Church for the first 400 years after Christ, together with its declension from the fifth century downward to its present state. London 1714. A new ed. in the "Lib. of Anglo-Cath. Theol." Oxford 1844.
Eus. Amort: De Origine, Progressu, Valore ac Fructu Indulgentiarum. Aug. Vindel. 1735 fol.
Muratori: De Redemtione Peccatorum et de Indulgentiarum Origine, in Tom. V. of his Antiquitates Italicae Medii Aevi. Mediol. 1741.
Joh. B. Hirscher (R.C.): Die Lehre vom Ablass. Tübingen, 5th ed. 1844.
G. E. Steitz: Das römische Buss-Sacrament, nach seinem bibl. Grunde und seiner gesch. Entwicklung. Frankf a. M. 1854 (210 pages).
Val. Gröne (R.C.): Der Ablass, seine Geschichte und Bedeutung in der Heilsökonomie. Regensb. 1863.
Domin. Palmieri (R.C.): Tractat. de Poenit. Romae 1879.
George Mead: Art. Penitence, in Smith and Cheetham II. 1586–1608. Wildt, (R.C.): Ablass, in Wetzer and Welte2 I. 94–111; Beichte and Beichtsiegel, II. 221–261. Mejer in Herzog2 I. 90–92. For extracts from sources comp. Gieseler II. 105 sqq.; 193 sqq.; 515 sqq. (Am. ed.)
For the authoritative teaching of the Roman church on the Sacramentum Poenitentiae see Conc. Trident. Sess. XIV. held 1551.
The word repentance or penitence is an insufficient rendering for the corresponding Greek metanoia, which means a radical change of mind or conversion from a sinful to a godly life, and includes, negatively, a turning away from sin in godly sorrow (repentance in the narrower sense) and, positively, a turning to Christ by faith with a determination to follow him.(15) The call to repent in this sense was the beginning of the preaching both of John the Baptist, and of Jesus Christ.(16)
In the Latin church the idea of repentance was externalized and identified with certain outward acts of self-abasement or self-punishment for the expiation of sin. The public penance before the church went out of use during the seventh or eighth century, except for very gross offences, and was replaced by private penance and confession.(17) The Lateran Council of 1215 under Pope Innocent III. made it obligatory upon every Catholic Christian to confess to his parish priest at least once a year.(18)
Penance, including auricular confession and priestly absolution, was raised to the dignity of a sacrament for sins committed after baptism. The theory on which it rests was prepared by the fathers (Tertullian and Cyprian), completed by the schoolmen, and sanctioned by the Roman church. It is supposed that baptism secures perfect remission of past sins, but not of subsequent sins, and frees from eternal damnation, but not from temporal punishment, which culminates in death or in purgatory. Penance is described as a "laborious kind of baptism," and is declared by the Council of Trent to be necessary to salvation for those who have fallen after baptism, as baptism is necessary for those who have not yet been regenerated.(19)
The sacrament of penance and priestly, absolution includes three elements: contrition of the heart, confession by the mouth, satisfaction by good works.(20) On these conditions the priest grants absolution, not simply by a declaratory but by a judicial act. The good works required are especially fasting and almsgiving. Pilgrimages to Jerusalem, Rome, Tours, Compostella, and other sacred places were likewise favorite satisfactions. Peter Damiani recommended voluntary self-flagellation as a means to propitiate God. These pious exercises covered in the popular mind the whole idea of penance. Piety was measured by the quantity of good works rather than by quality of character.
Another mediaeval institution must here be mentioned which is closely connected with penance. The church in the West, in her zeal to prevent violence and bloodshed, rightly favored the custom of the barbarians to substitute pecuniary compensation for punishment of an offence, but wrongly applied this custom to the sphere of religion. Thus money, might be substituted for fasting and other satisfactions, and was clothed with an atoning efficacy. This custom seems to have proceeded from the church of England, and soon spread over the continent.(21) It degenerated into a regular traffic, and became a rich source for the increase of ecclesiastical and monastic property.
Here is the origin of the indulgences so called, that is the remission of venial sins by the payment of money and on condition of contrition and prayer. The practice was justified by the scholastic theory that the works of supererogation of the saints constitute a treasury of extra-merit and extra-reward which is under the control of the pope. Hence indulgence assumed the special meaning of papal dispensation or remission of sin from the treasury of the overflowing merits of saints, and this power was extended even to the benefit of the dead in purgatory.(22)
Indulgences may be granted by bishops and archbishops in their dioceses, and by the pope to all Catholics. The former dealt with it in retail, the latter in wholesale. The first instances of papal indulgence occur in the ninth century under Paschalis I. and John VIII. who granted it to those who had fallen in war for the defence of the church. Gregory VI. in 1046 promised it to all who sent contributions for the repair of the churches in Rome. Urban II., at the council of Clermont (1095), offered to the crusaders "by the authority of the princes of the Apostles, Peter and Paul," plenary indulgence as a reward for a journey to the Holy Land. The same offer was repeated in every crusade against the Mohammedans and heretics. The popes found it a convenient means for promoting their power and filling their treasury. Thus the granting of indulgences became a periodical institution. Its abuses culminated in the profane and shameful traffic of Tetzel under Leo X. for the benefit of St. Peter’s church, but were overruled in the Providence of God for the Reformation and a return to the biblical idea of repentance.
Note.
The charge is frequently made against the papal court in the middle ages that it had a regulated scale of prices for indulgences, and this is based on the Tax Tables of the Roman Chancery published from time to time. Roman Catholic writers (as Lingard, Wiseman) say that the taxes are merely fees for the expedition of business and the payment of officials, but cannot deny the shameful avarice of some popes. The subject is fully discussed by Dr. T. L. Green (R.C.), Indulgences, Sacramental Absolutions, and the Tax-Tables of the Roman Chancery and Penitentiary, considered, in reply to the Charge of Venality, London (Longmans) 1872, and, on the Protestant side, by Dr. Richard Gibbings (Prof. of Ch. Hist. in the University of Dublin), The Taxes of the Apostolic Penitentiary; or, the Prices of Sins in the Church of Rome, Dublin 1872. Gibbings reprints the Taxae Sacrae Poenitentiariae Romanae from the Roman ed. of 1510 and the Parisian ed. of 1520, which cover 21 pages in Latin, but the greater part of the book (164 pages) is an historical introduction and polemical discussion.
Original Footnotes
(1; original 389): See the passages in Gieseler IL 55 (Harpers’ ed.) The Synodical courts were called Sendgerichte (a corruption from Synod).
(2; original 390): Liber Poenitentialis, Poenitential, Confessionale, Leges Poenitentium, Judicia Peccantium.
(3; original 391): By Prof. Wasserschleben of Halle, 1851 (from several Continental MSS.), and Canon Haddan and Prof. Stubbs, Oxford, 1871, (III. 173-203) from a Cambridge MS. of the 8th century. The texts of the earlier editions of Theodori Poenitentiale by Spelman (1639), D’Achery (1669), Jaques Petit (1677, reprinted in Migne’s Patrol. 1851, Tom. 99), Thorpe (1840), and Kunstmann (1844) are imperfect or spurious. The question of authorship and of the MS. sources is learnedly discussed in a note by Haddan and Stubbs, III. 173 sq. See extracts in the Notes.
(4; original 392): Both are given in Haddan and Stubbs, Councils, etc. III. 326 sqq. and 413 sqq.
(5; original 393): This is the view of Wasserschleben, while Schmitz thinks that the Poenitentiale Romanum was originally intended for the Roman church, and that the Westem Penitentials are derived from it.
(6; original 394): But during the papal schism, the rival popes excommunicated each other, and the Council of Constance deposed them.
(7; original 395): Aegidius (Aijgivdio"); Italian: Sant Egidio; French: S. Gilles. He was an abbot and confessor in France during the reign of Charles Martel or earlier, and much more celebrated than reliably known. He is the special patron of cripples, and his tomb was much visited by pilgrims from all parts of France, England and Scotland. Almost every county in England has churches named in his honor, amounting in all to 146. See Smith and Wace I. 47 sqq.
(8; original 396): Bened. Papae VIII. Epist. 32 (ad Guillelmum Comitem). In Migne’s Patrol. T. 139, fol. 1630-32. Lea translates it in part, l.c. p. 337. "Benedict Bishop, Servant of the servants of God, to Count William and his mother, the Countess Adelaide, perpetual grace and apostolic benediction .... Let them [who a tempted to rob the monastery] be accursed in their bodies, and let their souls be delivered to destruction and perdition and torture. Let them be damned with the damned: let them be scourged with the ungrateful; let them perish with the proud. Let them be accursed with the Jews who, seeing the incarnate Christ, did not believe but sought to crucify Him. Let them be accursed with the heretics who labored to destroy the church. Let them be accursed with those who blaspheme the name of God. Let them be accursed with those who despair of the mercy of God. Let them be accursed with those who he damned in Hell. Let them be accursed with the impious and sinners unless they amend their ways, and confess themselves in fault towards St. Giles. Let them be accursed in the four quarters of the earth. In the East be they accursed, and in the West disinherited; in the North interdicted, and in the South excommunicate. Be they accursed in the day-time and excommunicate in the night-time. Accursed be they at home and excommunicate abroad; accursed in standing and excommunicate in sitting; accursed in eating, accursed in drinking, accursed in sleeping, and excommunicate in waking; accursed when they work and excommunicate when they rest. Let them be accursed in the spring time and excommunicate in the summer; accursed in the autumn and excommunicate in the winter. Let them be accursed in this world and excommunicate in the next. Let their lands pass into the hands of the stranger, their wives be given over to perdition, and their children fall before the edge of the sword. Let what they eat be accursed, and accursed be what they leave, so that he who eats it shall be accursed. Accursed and excommunicate be the priest who shall give them the body and blood of the Lord, or who shall visit them in sickness. Accursed and excommunicate be he who shall carry them to the grave and shall dare to bury them. Let them be excommunicate, and accursed with all curses if they do not make amends and render due satisfaction. And know this for truth, that after our death no bishop nor count, nor any secular power shall usurp the seigniory of the blessed St. Giles. And if any presume to attempt it, borne down by, all the foregoing curses, they never shall enter the kingdom of Heaven, for the blessed St. Giles committed his monastery to the lordship of the blessed Peter."
(9; original 397): Corresponding to the Cherem, as distinct from Niddui (i.e. separation), in the Jewish Synagogue. See J. Lightfoot, De Anathemate Maranatha, and the commentators on Gal. 1:8, 9 (especially Wieseler).
(10; original 398): Interdictum orprohibitio officiorum divinorum, prohibition of public worship. A distinction is made between interd. personale for particular persons; locale for place or district; and generale for whole countries and kingdoms.
(11; original 399): Aug. Ep. 250, § 1; Leo, Ep. X. cap, 8—quoted by Gieseler, and Lea, p. 301. St. Basil of Caesarea is sometimes quoted as the inventor of the interdict, but not justly. See Lea, p. 302 note.
(12; original 400): Gregory of Tours, Hist. Franc. VIII. 31.
(13; original 401): Conc. Lemovicense II. See Mansi XIX. 541; Harduin VI. p. 1, 885; Hefele IV. 693-695; Gieseler II. 199 note 12.
(14; original 402): See the graphic description of the effects of this interdict upon the state of society, in Hurter’s Innocenz III., vol. I. 372-386.
(15; original 403): Penitence is from the Latin poenitentia, and this is derived from poena, poivnh (compensation, satisfaction, punishment). Jerome introduced the word, or rather retained it, in the Latin Bible, for metavnoia, and poenitentiam agere for metanoei'n Hence the Douay version: to do penance. Augustin, Isidor, Rabanus Maurus, Peter Lombard, and the R. Catholic theologians connect the term with the penal idea (poena, punitio) and make it cover the whole penitential discipline. The English repentance, to repent, and the German Busse, Bussethun follow the Vulgate, but have changed the meaning in evangelical theology in conformity to the Greek metavnoia.
(16; original 404): Matt. 3:2; 4:17; Mark 1:15. Luther renewed the call in his 95 Theses which begin with the same idea, in opposition to the traffic in indulgences.
(17; original 405): Pope Leo the Great (440-461) was the first prelate in the West who sanctioned the substitution of the system of secret humiliation by auricular confession for the public exomologesis. Ep. 136. Opera I. 355.
(18; original 406): Can. 21: "Omnis utriusque sexus fidelis, postquam ad annos discretionis pervenerit, omnia sua solus peccata confiteatur fideliter, saltem semel in anno, proprio sacerdoti."Violation of this law of auricular confession was threatened with excommunication and refusal of Christian burial. See Hefele V. 793.
(19; original 407): Conc. Trid. Sess. XIV. cap.2 (Schaff’s Creeds I. 143). The Council went so far in Canon VI. (II. 165) as to anathematize any one "who denies that sacramental confession was instituted or is necessary to salvation, of divine right; or who says that the manner of confessing secretly to a priest alone, which the church has ever observed from the beginning (?), and doth observe, is alien from the institution and command of Christ, and is a human invention."
(20; original 408): Contritio cordis, confessio oris, satisfactio operis. See Conc. Trid. Sess. XIV. cap. 3-6 (Creeds, II. 143-153). The usual Roman Catholic definition of this sacrament is: "Sacramentum poenitentiae est sacramentum a Christo institutum, quo homini contrito, confesso et satisfacturo (satisfacere volenti) per juridicam sacerdotis absolutionem peccata post baptismum commissa remittuntur." Oswald, Die dogmat. Lehre von den heil. Sacramenten der katholischen Kirche, II. 17 (3rd ed. Münster 1870).
(21; original 409): Archbishop Theodore of Canterbury is the reputed author of this commutation of penance for a money-payment. See his Penitential I. 3 and 4, and the seventh penitential canon ascribed to him, in Haddan and Stubbs III. 179, 180, 211. "Si quis"says Theodore, "pro ultione propinqui hominem occiderit, peniteat sicut homicida, VII. vel X. annos. Si tamen reddere vult propinquis petuniam aestimationis, levior erit penitentia, id est, dimidio spatii."The Synod of Clove-ho (probably Abingdon), held under his successor, Cuthbert, for the reformation of abuses, in September 747, decreed in the 26th canon that alms were no longer to be given for diminishing or commuting the fastings and other works of satisfaction. See Haddan and Stubbs, III. 371 sq.
(22; original 410): This theory was fully developed by Thomas Aquinas and other schoolmen (see Gieseler II. 521 sq.), and sanctioned by the Council of Trent in the 25th Session, held Dec. 4, 1563 (Creeds II. 205 sq.), although the Council forbids "all evil gains" and other abuses which have caused "the honorable name of indulgences to be blasphemed by heretics." The popes still exercise from time to time the right of granting plenary indulgences, though with greater caution than their mediaeval predecessors.
脚注
Best guess 对照表
正文及中文脚注中带上标 * 的外文为 best guess,尚未逐项核实;原始字串保留如下。
| 原字串 | Best guess | 语言 | 出现位置 | 说明 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| gratlibus | gradibus | Latin | 正文第 48 段 | 结合 De tribus 及三个等级的语境,疑为 gradibus 的字形误识。 |
| Aijgivdio" | Αἰγίδιος | Greek | 脚注 7 | 按旧字体编码还原,与拉丁名 Aegidius 对应。 |
| metavnoia | μετάνοια | Greek | 脚注 15 | 旧编码 v 表示前一元音的锐音,推测还原为 μετάνοια。 |
| metavnoia | μετάνοια | Greek | 脚注 15 | 与同注前一处编码相同,推测还原为 μετάνοια。 |
| poivnh | ποίνη | Greek | 脚注 15 | 按原编码还原,保留其在 ι 上的锐音;通常词形为 ποινή,此处不擅改重音。 |
| metanoei'n | μετανοεῖν | Greek | 脚注 15 | 旧编码撇号表示前一元音的曲音,与悔改一词的不定式相符。 |
参见吉泽勒 (Gieseler),IL. 55(Harpers版)所引各段。宗教会议法庭称为 Sendgerichte(由 Synod 一词讹变而来)。↩︎
Liber Poenitentialis, Poenitential, Confessionale, Leges Poenitentium, Judicia Peccantium. 即《补赎书》《补赎手册》《告解手册》《补赎者法规》《犯罪者裁断》。↩︎
由哈雷的瓦瑟施莱本教授 (Wasserschleben) 于1851年出版(依据欧洲大陆的几种抄本),又由哈丹法政牧师 (Haddan) 和斯塔布斯教授 (Stubbs) 于1871年在牛津出版(III. 173–203),后者依据剑桥所藏的一份第八世纪抄本。斯佩尔曼 (Spelman,1639年)、达舍里 (D’Achery,1669年)、雅克·珀蒂 (Jaques Petit,1677年,重印于米涅 (Migne) 的《教父集》Patrol.,1851年,第99卷)、索普 (Thorpe,1840年) 和昆斯特曼 (Kunstmann,1844年) 较早刊行的《狄奥多尔补赎书》(Theodori Poenitentiale),其文本或有残缺,或属伪托。哈丹和斯塔布斯在III. 173及下页的一则注释中,对作者归属和抄本来源问题作了博学的讨论。节录见附注。↩︎
两者均载于哈丹和斯塔布斯 (Haddan and Stubbs) 的《会议录》等 (Councils, etc.),III. 326及后、413及后。↩︎
这是瓦瑟施莱本 (Wasserschleben) 的看法;施米茨 (Schmitz) 则认为,《罗马补赎书》(Poenitentiale Romanum) 最初是为罗马教会编写的,西方各补赎书都由此衍生。↩︎
但在教皇分裂期间,彼此对立的教皇相互革除教籍,康斯坦茨会议 (Council of Constance) 则将他们废黜。↩︎
埃吉迪乌斯 (Aegidius,Αἰγίδιος*);意大利语:Sant Egidio;法语:S. Gilles。他是查理·马特 (Charles Martel) 统治时期或更早时法国的一位修道院院长和宣信者;他的声名远远超过人们对他的可靠了解。他是残疾者的特殊主保;来自法国各地、英格兰和苏格兰的朝圣者,经常前往他的墓地。英格兰几乎每个郡都有以他命名的教堂,总计146座。参见史密斯和韦斯 (Smith and Wace),I. 47及后。↩︎
教皇本笃八世 (Benedict VIII.),《书信》第32封 (Bened. Papae VIII. Epist. 32)(《致威廉伯爵》,ad Guillelmum Comitem)。载于米涅 (Migne)《教父集》(Patrol.),第139卷,栏1630–32。利 (Lea) 在前引书 (l.c.) 第337页译出其中一部分。“本笃主教,上帝众仆人的仆人,致威廉伯爵 (Count William) 及其母阿德莱德伯爵夫人 (Countess Adelaide),愿永远的恩典与使徒的祝福归于你们……愿他们[那些企图劫掠修道院的人]的身体受咒诅,愿他们的灵魂被交付毁灭、沉沦和折磨。愿他们与被定罪者一同被定罪;愿他们与忘恩负义者一同受鞭打;愿他们与骄傲者一同灭亡。愿他们与那些看见道成肉身的基督,却不信而设法将他钉十字架的犹太人一同受咒诅。愿他们与那些竭力摧毁教会的异端一同受咒诅。愿他们与亵渎上帝之名的人一同受咒诅。愿他们与对上帝的怜悯绝望的人一同受咒诅。愿他们与那些在地狱中被定罪的人一同受咒诅。除非他们改正自己的行径,承认自己得罪了圣吉尔 (St. Giles),否则愿他们与不敬虔者和罪人一同受咒诅。愿他们在大地的四方受咒诅。在东方,愿他们受咒诅;在西方,愿他们丧失产业;在北方,愿他们受禁令处分;在南方,愿他们被革除教籍。愿他们白昼受咒诅,黑夜被革除教籍。在家受咒诅,在外被革除教籍;站立时受咒诅,坐下时被革除教籍;吃时受咒诅,喝时受咒诅,睡时受咒诅,醒时被革除教籍;劳作时受咒诅,休息时被革除教籍。愿他们春季受咒诅,夏季被革除教籍;秋季受咒诅,冬季被革除教籍。愿他们今世受咒诅,来世被革除教籍。愿他们的土地落入外人手中,妻子被交付沉沦,儿女倒在刀刃之下。愿他们所吃的受咒诅,所剩的也受咒诅,以致吃剩物的人也受咒诅。凡将主的身体和血给予他们,或在他们患病时探望他们的司铎,愿他受咒诅并被革除教籍。凡将他们送入坟墓、胆敢埋葬他们的人,愿他受咒诅并被革除教籍。他们若不悔改并作出应有的补偿,愿他们被革除教籍,并受一切咒诅。你们务要确知,在我们死后,任何主教、伯爵或世俗权势,都不得篡夺蒙福的圣吉尔的领主权。若有人胆敢尝试,愿上述一切咒诅都压在他们身上,使他们永不得进天国,因为蒙福的圣吉尔已将他的修道院交归蒙福的彼得管辖。”↩︎
相当于犹太会堂中的 Cherem(咒诅),有别于 Niddui(即隔离)。参见J. 莱特福特 (J. Lightfoot)《论“主必要来”的咒诅》(De Anathemate Maranatha),以及《加拉太书》1:8、9的各家注释(尤其是维泽勒 (Wieseler))。↩︎
Interdictum 或 prohibitio officiorum divinorum,即禁止公共礼拜。其中又区分为:针对特定个人的 interd. personale;针对某地或地区的 locale;以及针对整个国家和王国的 generale。↩︎
奥古斯丁 (Aug.)《书信》(Ep.) 250,§ 1;利奥 (Leo)《书信》(Ep.) X,第8章——引自吉泽勒 (Gieseler) 及利 (Lea),第301页。有时有人称凯撒利亚的圣巴西尔 (Basil of Caesarea) 为禁令制度的创始人,但并不确当。参见利,第302页注。↩︎
图尔的格列高利 (Gregory of Tours),《法兰克人史》(Hist. Franc.),VIII. 31。↩︎
第二次利摩日会议 (Conc. Lemovicense II.)。参见曼西 (Mansi),XIX. 541;阿尔杜安 (Harduin),VI. 第1部分,885;赫费勒 (Hefele),IV. 693–695;吉泽勒 (Gieseler),II. 199,注12。↩︎
关于这项禁令对社会状况所造成的影响,参见胡尔特 (Hurter)《英诺森三世》(Innocenz III.),第I卷,372–386页,其中有生动的描述。↩︎
Penitence(悔罪)一词来自拉丁文 poenitentia,后者又源于 poena、ποίνη*(补偿、补赎、惩罚)。哲罗姆在拉丁文圣经中引入了这个词——更确切地说,是保留了这个词——来译 μετάνοια*,并以 poenitentiam agere 来译 μετανοεῖν*。因此,杜埃译本 (Douay version) 译作“行补赎”。奥古斯丁、伊西多尔 (Isidor)、拉巴努斯·毛鲁斯 (Rabanus Maurus)、彼得·伦巴德 (Peter Lombard) 以及罗马天主教神学家,都将这个词与刑罚的观念(poena、punitio)联系起来,使其涵盖整套补赎纪律。英语的 repentance、to repent 和德语的 Busse、Bussethun 沿袭了武加大译本,但在福音派神学中,其含义已依照希腊文 μετάνοια* 而改变。↩︎
《马太福音》3:2;4:17;《马可福音》1:15。路德 (Luther) 在反对赎罪券交易的《九十五条论纲》中,重新发出了这一呼召;论纲开篇所表达的正是同一观念。↩︎
教皇大利奥 (Leo the Great,440–461年) 是西方第一位批准以附耳告解的私下自卑制度,取代公开认罪 (exomologesis) 的高级教士。《书信》(Ep.) 136;《全集》(Opera),I. 355。↩︎
第21条:“Omnis utriusque sexus fidelis, postquam ad annos discretionis pervenerit, omnia sua solus peccata confiteatur fideliter, saltem semel in anno, proprio sacerdoti.”(每一信徒,无论男女,到了能辨别是非的年龄,就应至少每年一次,独自向本堂司铎如实告明自己的一切罪。)凡违反这项附耳告解法规的人,将受到革除教籍和拒绝给予基督教葬礼的惩罚。参见赫费勒 (Hefele),V. 793。↩︎
《特伦托会议决议》(Conc. Trid.),第XIV次会议,第2章(沙弗《信经集》,I. 143)。会议在第VI条教规(II. 165)中甚至宣告,凡“否认圣礼告解是按神圣权利设立的,或否认它为得救所必需的;或声称教会从起初便一直遵守(?)、且现今仍遵守的单独向司铎秘密告解的方式,与基督的设立和命令无关,而是人的发明”的人,都当受咒诅。↩︎
Contritio cordis, confessio oris, satisfactio operis(心中的痛悔、口中的告白、以行为作出补赎)。参见《特伦托会议决议》(Conc. Trid.),第XIV次会议,第3–6章(《信经集》,II. 143–153)。罗马天主教对这项圣礼的通常定义是:“Sacramentum poenitentiae est sacramentum a Christo institutum, quo homini contrito, confesso et satisfacturo (satisfacere volenti) per juridicam sacerdotis absolutionem peccata post baptismum commissa remittuntur.”(补赎圣礼是基督所设立的圣礼;借此,凡痛悔、告解并将作出补赎〔愿意作出补赎〕的人,通过司铎司法性的赦罪,得蒙赦免受洗以后所犯的罪。)奥斯瓦尔德 (Oswald),《天主教会神圣圣礼的教义学教导》(Die dogmat. Lehre von den heil. Sacramenten der katholischen Kirche),II. 17(第3版,明斯特 (Münster),1870年)。↩︎
据称,以金钱缴纳折抵补赎的做法,始创于坎特伯雷大主教狄奥多尔 (Theodore of Canterbury)。参见他的《补赎书》I. 3、4,以及归于他名下的第七条补赎教规,载于哈丹和斯塔布斯 (Haddan and Stubbs),III. 179、180、211。狄奥多尔说:“Si quis pro ultione propinqui hominem occiderit, peniteat sicut homicida, VII. vel X. annos. Si tamen reddere vult propinquis petuniam aestimationis, levior erit penitentia, id est, dimidio spatii.”(若有人为亲属复仇而杀人,就当按杀人者之例补赎七年或十年。但他若愿意向死者亲属缴纳所估定的赔偿金,补赎便可减轻,即期限减半。)747年9月,在他的继任者卡斯伯特 (Cuthbert) 任内,为革除流弊而召开的克洛夫霍会议 (Synod of Clove-ho,可能即阿宾登 (Abingdon)),在第26条教规中规定,不得再以施舍来减免或折抵禁食及其他补赎善功。参见哈丹和斯塔布斯,III. 371及下页。↩︎
这一理论由托马斯·阿奎那 (Thomas Aquinas) 和其他经院学者充分发展(参见吉泽勒 (Gieseler),II. 521及下页),并于1563年12月4日举行的特伦托会议第25次会议上获得认可(《信经集》(Creeds),II. 205及下页);不过,会议禁止“一切不义之财”,以及其他使“赎罪券的尊贵名声遭异端亵渎”的流弊。教皇们至今仍不时行使颁发全大赦的权利,只是比中世纪的前任们更为谨慎。↩︎
